Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Priests And The Sacraments


Recommended Posts

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

A Repost, because the other forum doesn't seem to get much traffic.

A friend of mine for whom I hold immense respect and love, both as a Christian and as a dear friend, asked me a question I have not been able to answer. This was nearly a month ago, and I've been wrestling with it internally, although, to be honest, no, I haven't really pursued it in research, mostly because "because the Church says so" isn't really cutting it for me right now. This isn't to be belligerent or anything; I'm simply in something of a weird place right now, and I'm a little iffy on simply accepting the episcopal sayso.

The question is this: why is it that only through priests does God bring about the Eucharist?

This arose in a long and painful discussion. Two friends, really, are very hurt at the notion that they are excluded from the Eucharistic feast. Both of them believe in the Real Presence, but do not understand why it is that only priests can officiate, so to speak, why only priests can tell the story and why only through priests the symbol becomes the reality. They both believe very profoundly in the Eucharist, and consider it central to Christianity and their own understanding of it. But I couldn't argue, I couldn't make the point, because I don't know the answer, and I'll be honest, I hadn't even considered the question, which shames me.

Because when I do, the whole thing kind of stops making sense for me. Is apostolic succession the only thing I can fall back on? Is that tradition all I have to respond? Because it doesn't satisfy them, and it doesn't satisfy me, either.

Posted

I am so "not" the right person to try to answer this question . . . but perhaps by putting some concepts forward, those more knowledgeable than I can correct and redirect


1. Your friends realize it is not just the laity which can't confect the Eucharist? Even those who have been ordained in the lesser holy orders (deacons) are also prohibited. Not being able to confect is not the same as being excluded from the sacrament, so if I'm misunderstanding the question, I apologize. The laity can self-exclude themselves from the sacrament if they are aware of mortal sin which has not been absolved through sacramental confession.

. . . There can be no substitute whatsoever for
the ministerial Priesthood. For if a Priest is
lacking in the community, then the community
lacks the exercise and sacramental function of
Christ the Head and Shepherd, which belongs to
the essence of its very life. For “the only
minister who can confect the sacrament of the
Eucharist in persona Christi is a validly ordained
Priest. Redemptionis Sacramentum 146

2. The purpose of the liturgical norms is to direct the faithful toward Christ. The ordained priest, ordained as you mentioned through other priests in an unbroken line back to the Apostles, stands before the faithful as a symbol of Christ.

. . . The office “that belongs to Priests in
particular in the celebration of the Eucharist” is a
great one, “for it is their responsibility to preside
at the Eucharist in persona Christi and to provide
a witness to and a service of communion not
only for the community directly taking part in
the celebration, but also for the universal Church,
which is always brought into play within the
context of the Eucharist. Redemptionis Sacramentum 30

3. The Church doesn't have the power to change the form of the sacraments established by its founder and head, Jesus Christ. No individual member of the Church has that power either (be it ordained or lay). Where there is improved or enhanced understanding of the mysteries, the texts of the liturgy may be revised - e.g. the current ordinary and extraordinary forms of the Mass - but the form remains.


That's probably enough to bring out the scholars.
Suggested readings:

Two fairly recent letters
Redemptionis Sacramentum (which I have quoted)
Ecclesia de Eucharistia

and
[url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19641121_lumen-gentium_en.html"]Lumen Gentium[/url]
[url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19631204_sacrosanctum-concilium_en.html"]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/url]

the sources cited in those texts should help verbalize the reasons ordained priests are essential to the celebration of the sacrament of Eucharist

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Because God isn't an anarchist :)

But seriously... read through the Creation narrative of Genesis 1, the story of Noah, Moses and the Ten Commandments, and the system of sacrifices and laws established for the Israelites under their covenant. There is always some sort of order to things, from the purpose of each day of Creation to the specific instructions Noah received for building the ark and filling it, from how Moses was told to approach Pharoah and bring about the plagues to the sacrificial system of making atonement to God at the Temple in Jerusalem.

Can you imagine if Jesus told the apostles, "Any Christian is allowed to preside over the Eucharist and forgive sins under my authority." If you think abuses might be bad now, it would be far, far worse in that situation! Instead, as Scripture says, Jesus specifically gave the twelve apostles this authority, but it is for the benefit of all Christians because our confidence is in the work God does through priests.

After all, any organization needs a hierarchy to maintain structure and communication among all people within it. Go to any church, no matter how small and non-hierarchical it may be, and who will preside over their Lord's Supper or Communion? Some dude who just joined the church two months ago? A 15-year-old high school kid? No, with rare exception, it'll be a pastor or elder. It's the same in Catholic/Orthodox Churches... what can you say, God's a smart guy :)

Does that make more sense?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...