Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I read in the NY post that Mel Gibson is doing a new movie, this time hes doing a film about Fatima.
I cant wait to see this, his movies are always great. I wonder what his vision of hell will be when he films that part.

Posted

[quote name='Matt1618' post='1346164' date='Aug 1 2007, 12:04 PM']I wonder what his vision of hell will be when he films that part.[/quote]
I heard the devil is gonna be played by Kevin Federline, with all his lines being in rap form.

Hell indeed.

Posted

is the project still going through? i heard about it a while back, but due to mel's meltdown last year, i heard it was canceled. i hope not though. this movie would be sicker than a hospital.

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

I don't understand how awesome this movie would be, figuring it would be produced, written and directed by someone who isn't exactly in line with the current Church.

I hope its cancelled. Heck, I'll direct a movie about Fatima.

Posted
:smokey: Yhere is a lovely movie made years ago about Fatima.I'm not sure about Mel's version even if he does make it.
I saw the Passion of Christ and while it was very moving,it almost made me laugh in one part.
It was were Jesus is scourged at the Pillar.The pillar was so low,but more than that,it seemed that the actor that was whipping Jesus was enjoying it too much and was really over the top.Hard to explain what I mean,but it seemed to go on too long.

The scence with Mary wiping up Jesus' blood bothered me because it was not in THE HOLY BIBLE!
The business with the devil in the Garden of Gethsamene bothered me too as it is not in The Holy Bible.
It was a good movie.But yet I kind of prefer Cecil B.DeMille's movie about Jesus,the King of Kings.
As I said,I'm not articulate enough to explain it to you.

Others have made comments that it seems as if Mel was the one being crucified for his beliefs rather than Jesus.
That he has taken flack for his beliefs and not following the usual Hollywood baloney.mention was also made of Braveheart in his torture scene ,etc.

from the comments I have read here,some of you don't think a Fatima movie by him would be a good thing.
Church Punk
Posted

I think Mel makes good movies, most are over the top and action backed (just what I like). I just watched Apocolypto last weekend. I was left with saying COME ON this guy is amazing! Then when the Spanish showed up at the end I was just like you have to be kidding.

I am sure the Fatima movie will be good and he will some how find a way to make it action packed. It would be cool if it was through Sr. Lucia's memories. But I fear that there may be some mocking at the Chruch heirachy regarding the secrets and such. We will have to see.

As for the scenes Holly Dolly discribed, I believe that they were taken from Blessed Anne Catherine Emmericks Dolorious Passion vision (please correct me if I am wrong). As for my self, I in no way found the scouraging funny, and I thought that was well done, especially in line of Isiah and Psalm 22.

Posted

[quote name='HollyDolly' post='1347111' date='Aug 2 2007, 09:15 AM']The scence with Mary wiping up Jesus' blood bothered me because it was not in THE HOLY BIBLE!

The business with the devil in the Garden of Gethsamene bothered me too as it is not in The Holy Bible.[/quote]


Holly, your post bothers me because it's not in the Holy Bible... :lol:

The devil was in the Garden--read in between the lines <hint: Jesus is the New Adam>.

As for wiping the Blood--it's to show that every drop of His Blood is Precious.

Posted

Holly dolly I cannot disagree with you more. You say you didnt like the scourging scene, but i think it has to be over the top to illustrate what the forgiveness of our sins cost the Son of God, and that he would be willing to go through all of that suffering because he loves us. As for the Roman that was enjoying beating Jesus, I see no problem with that, dont forget the Romans were pretty sadistic,(they watched people kill each other for entertainment for crying out loud) The Romans hated the Jews anyway so whos to say they didnt take pleasure in torturing them. And you also say you didnt like the non biblical scenes with mary, and satan etc, then I guess you have a problem with all of the stations of the cross that came up in the movie most of which are not in the Bible
( Mary sees Jesus, Women weep for Jesus, Jesus falls 3 times etc) i think mel is a great director and a good man I love all of his movies, I just pray that he fully gets back in line with the Church. I heard that hes part of SSPX, is that true?

Posted

[quote name='Seven77' post='1347178' date='Aug 2 2007, 11:32 AM']Holly, your post bothers me because it's not in the Holy Bible... :lol:

The devil was in the Garden--read in between the lines <hint: Jesus is the New Adam>.

As for wiping the Blood--it's to show that every drop of His Blood is Precious.[/quote]

ditto

Posted

i wanna Mel make a Machabees movie!!!

Posted
:shock: No I have no problem with the scene where Jesus is scourged,but it seemed to go on a little too long.I am aware the romans despised the jews and anyone basically who wasn't a roman.
Will have to go back and read each of the four gospel accounts of the passion of Jesus.however,i donot recall St,John,St.Mark,St.Luke or St.Matthew saying anything about Our Lady wipeing up the Holy Blood of her son.
By the way,the gospels tell of Jesus falling, the weeping of the women of Jerusalem for him,etc.That is where the stations of the cross come from.,will re-read them again.
The bible tells of the devil tempting Jesus while i believe he was in the desert or some place.Do not
recall it saying anything about the devil hanging around Jesus in his last moments before he was taken away by the soldiers when Judas betrayed him.

I know that Mel used as a source the writings of Anne Catherine Emmerich,a german mystic for some things.As a Catholic we are not bound to believe in anyone's private revelations.
The gospels tell of Our Beloved Lord's suffering and death for our sins,so vividly that one can almost see it.
That is what I was looking for when going to see the film. The true story of Our Lord and done by a Catholic.Who better than one of us to put this on film for the world to see,about our Beloved Saviour and founder Jesus Christ.

i just wish he had stuck to the gospels and not used any of the stuff from Anne Catherine Emmerich.

I too hope he comes back to the Church and I do like Mel. I do not know if he is associated with SSPX.
You might google your question on that.I may try to myself,later on and see what I find.
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1347215' date='Aug 2 2007, 01:23 PM']i wanna Mel make a Machabees movie!!![/quote]

Mel was going to make a Macabees movie, but it got shelved after the drunk driving scandal i believe.

Church Punk
Posted

[quote name='HollyDolly' post='1347271' date='Aug 2 2007, 02:15 PM']however,i donot recall St,John,St.Mark,St.Luke or St.Matthew saying anything about Our Lady wipeing up the Holy Blood of her son.[/quote]

See post above...

[quote]By the way,the gospels tell of Jesus falling, the weeping of the women of Jerusalem for him,etc.That is where the stations of the cross come from.,will re-read them again.
The bible tells of the devil tempting Jesus while i believe he was in the desert or some place.Do not
recall it saying anything about the devil hanging around Jesus in his last moments before he was taken away by the soldiers when Judas betrayed him.[/quote]

If he wasnt being tempted, why did he say, Father if you will, allow this cup to pass from me, then after gaining his composure, But not my will, but yours be done.

Posted

[quote name='HollyDolly' post='1347271' date='Aug 2 2007, 01:15 PM']That is what I was looking for when going to see the film. The true story of Our Lord and done by a Catholic.Who better than one of us to put this on film for the world to see,about our Beloved Saviour and founder Jesus Christ.

i just wish he had stuck to the gospels and not used any of the stuff from Anne Catherine Emmerich.[/quote]

i saw an interview with him were he was being critized for certain scenes not having a biblical backing and he simply said that "this is piece of art, and its my own redition of the passion."

i agree that not every scene in the movie was in scripture, however "its a movie" mel never said this is exactly what happen. And i think the scenes where he used his artist freedom were done with reverence. i mean they were trying to save all the blood cause it was precious, its not like they were playing slip and slide on it.

all in all i think it acheived what it was set out to do. truly inpire people to see how much pain Christ went through, because of his love for us.

no beef... just love
the jUiCER

Posted

Holly,

What do you think of Michaelangelo as an artist? What do you think of the Sistine Chapel?

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1346165' date='Aug 1 2007, 12:09 PM']I heard the devil is gonna be played by Kevin Federline, with all his lines being in rap form.

Hell indeed.[/quote]
:hehe:

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1347215' date='Aug 2 2007, 11:23 AM']i wanna Mel make a Machabees movie!!![/quote]

that'd be sweet

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='HollyDolly' post='1347271' date='Aug 2 2007, 12:15 PM']I too hope he comes back to the Church and I do like Mel. I do not know if he is associated with SSPX.[/quote]

He isn't associated with them. He, and I, is a sedevacantist. Far more "extreme" you could say. And definitely not any closer in communion with the Vatican. I can't wait for such a film on Fatima if he is actually going to do it. Though I haven't heard anything about it.

Posted (edited)

Wait a minute.

This wasn't some random fiction book he picked up at Barnes and Noble.

It was written by a Blessed (aka: almost a saint!) You really should read it before you cast an "artistic" judgment on it. Regardless of his faithfulness to the Church, The Passion was taken directly from one of the most faithful Catholics who is on her way to sainthood.

Unless your not Catholic, I can see your disagreement with it, as for opinions as a Catholic, these were given to Blessed Anne from the Blessed Mother herself.

Hope that helps some. Also, I LOVED the old Fatima movie. It would be hard to beat that!!!!

Francisco: "No, no, Let's say the rosary the shorter way and wait for the echos!"

Edited by jmjtina
Posted

[quote name='HollyDolly' post='1347271' date='Aug 2 2007, 12:15 PM']:shock: No I have no problem with the scene where Jesus is scourged,but it seemed to go on a little too long.I am aware the romans despised the jews and anyone basically who wasn't a roman.
Will have to go back and read each of the four gospel accounts of the passion of Jesus.however,i donot recall St,John,St.Mark,St.Luke or St.Matthew saying anything about Our Lady wipeing up the Holy Blood of her son.
By the way,the gospels tell of Jesus falling, the weeping of the women of Jerusalem for him,etc.That is where the stations of the cross come from.,will re-read them again.
The bible tells of the devil tempting Jesus while i believe he was in the desert or some place.Do not
recall it saying anything about the devil hanging around Jesus in his last moments before he was taken away by the soldiers when Judas betrayed him.

I know that Mel used as a source the writings of Anne Catherine Emmerich,a german mystic for some things.As a Catholic we are not bound to believe in anyone's private revelations.
The gospels tell of Our Beloved Lord's suffering and death for our sins,so vividly that one can almost see it.
That is what I was looking for when going to see the film. The true story of Our Lord and done by a Catholic.Who better than one of us to put this on film for the world to see,about our Beloved Saviour and founder Jesus Christ.

i just wish he had stuck to the gospels and not used any of the stuff from Anne Catherine Emmerich.

I too hope he comes back to the Church and I do like Mel. I do not know if he is associated with SSPX.
You might google your question on that.I may try to myself,later on and see what I find.[/quote]
The film is an artistic representation of Christ's Passion, and like almost all religious art contains material not in the Gospels themselves, however the movie contains nothing at all contrary to the Gospels. Any biblical movie is going to contain some dramatic speculation to "fill in the blanks."

A movie is never going to be exactly the same as the Gospels themselves, and is not a substitute for reading the Gospels.

I thought most of the "added material" was quite good, and contributed to, rather than distracted from, the gospel message - none of it was gratuitous, imo. These included the scene of Christ crushing the head of the Serpent, and the elements of Marian and Eucharistic theology (especially the flashbacks tying the Eucharist to the Sacrifice of Christ on the Cross).

As for the scourging, the Gospels do not say exactly how long it lasted, so that is a mute point. The point of the movie was to show the amount of suffering Christ underwent for our sins.

Imo, people, Christians included, have a tendency to go too hard on Mel Gibson and [i]The Passion of the Christ[/i]. Whatever his shortcomings, Gibson was at least making a serious reverent Christian movie against the hollywood grain, and I think we should be thankful for that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...