Moneybags Posted August 1, 2007 Posted August 1, 2007 My protestant neighbors received several Catholic books recently. They, of course, will not read them, so they put them on my doorstep. I took them in and began to look through them. I have never read any of them, but there was two small books in bad condition that seemed to be of value. One says "Priest's Ritual" and the other "Rites, Blessings, and Prayers" on the sidebar. Both are small pocket-sized books with Latin/English Prayers. The first has the rite of Baptism of a child, Matrimony, Extreme Unction, etc. The other has prayers and blessings. I am glad to receive them However, I don't know anything about the other books. I can't read them all to evaluate them since I start seminary on August 25. Does anyone know anything about these books? Are they authentically Catholic? The Cost of Discipleship by Bonhoeffer To the Priests: Our Lady's Beloved Sons by the Marian Movement of Priests Tell the Next Generation: Homiles and Near Homilies by Walter J. Burghardt, SJ As One Who Serves: Reflections on the Pastoral Ministry of Priests in the United States Biblical Catechetical Homilies for Sundays and Holy Days (ABC) by Rev. David Q. Liptak Celibacy, Prayer, and Friendship by Christopher Kiesling, OP The Pastoral Sermons of Ronald A. Knox Cenacles of the Marian Movement of Priests: Purpose/Guide Dear Father: A Message of Love to Priests by Catherine de Hueck Doherty Grace Under Pressure: What Gives Life to American Priests
Church Punk Posted August 1, 2007 Posted August 1, 2007 the only one i know is To the Priests: Our Lady's Beloved Sons by the Marian Movement of Priests The have a copy at the back of the chapel at my Church.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 1, 2007 Posted August 1, 2007 I don't know any of them, but I would say that, as a seminarian, you should keep them all. Sounds like they could all potentially help with priestly formation.
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 1, 2007 Posted August 1, 2007 I've inserted my opinion of the texts that I know something about in bold. The Cost of Discipleship by Bonhoeffer [b]Bonhoeffer was a Lutheran and his theology is not orthodox but if you intend to study theology professionally I would hang on to it. That's actually a well known and respected book. I see nothing wrong with reading it so long as you understand that the author was not an orthodox Catholic.[/b] To the Priests: Our Lady's Beloved Sons by the Marian Movement of Priests [b]Private revelations to an Italian priest. Not sure what the status is as far as approval from Rome (you might want to look into it) but I've read some of that book and it seemed cool to me.[/b] Tell the Next Generation: Homiles and Near Homilies by Walter J. Burghardt, SJ [b]Never read it but the author is a liberal Catholic. I personally wouldn't be terribly excited about owning that book.[/b] As One Who Serves: Reflections on the Pastoral Ministry of Priests in the United States [b]1970's "pastoral" stuff, but probably interesting to read (at least for research purposes).[/b] Biblical Catechetical Homilies for Sundays and Holy Days (ABC) by Rev. David Q. Liptak [b]Don't know anything about it.. [/b] Celibacy, Prayer, and Friendship by Christopher Kiesling, OP [b]Never read it but the author (if I'm thinking of the right guy) is a "spirit of Vatican II" social justice type. Be sure you have a barf bag handy while reading, just to be on the safe side.[/b] The Pastoral Sermons of Ronald A. Knox [b]Very good stuff![/b] Cenacles of the Marian Movement of Priests: Purpose/Guide [b]If I'm correct in assuming that this is a text related to the "To The Priests" book at the top of your list then I suspect it is just a guide to running the Marian prayer meeting that is a part of that movement.[/b] Dear Father: A Message of Love to Priests by Catherine de Hueck Doherty [b]I've read several of Catherine Doherty's books and they're mostly good. They sometimes have that seventies flavor that I can't stand, but that's just me. Oh, and I believe she has been declared venerable which is always a good thing. ;-)[/b] Grace Under Pressure: What Gives Life to American Priests [b]I've never heard of it.[/b]
Pio Nono Posted August 1, 2007 Posted August 1, 2007 JMJ 8/1 - St. Alphonsus Liguori (Seven Maccabean Martyrs/St. Peter in Chains) Actually, [i]The Cost of Discipleship[/i] is a very good book. Don't discount it just because he's a Lutheran. He's got typically Lutheran attitudes about justification, but his thoughts on the Parable of the Good Samaritan, for instance, are AMAZING. And anything, ANYTHING by Msgr. Knox is worth reading. His [i]The Belief of Catholics[/i] will go in to the canon of 20th Century Catholic authors.
Moneybags Posted August 2, 2007 Author Posted August 2, 2007 Thanks for the help. I will definitely keep and read the sermons by Msgr. Knox. I've only heard good comments about that book. I will think about the others and may decide to try and sell a few of them.
Totus Tuus Posted August 2, 2007 Posted August 2, 2007 [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1346214' date='Aug 1 2007, 02:32 PM']The Cost of Discipleship by Bonhoeffer[/quote] This is by a Lutheran. I know of Catholics (solid Catholics) who like it. But I was a little confused by his ideas of grace. So I didn't get into it (I had started it). [quote]To the Priests: Our Lady's Beloved Sons by the Marian Movement of Priests[/quote] This is private revelation so you don't have to believe it. I LOVE this book. But it is totally up to you. If it makes any difference, all the people I know who love it are very solid Catholics. [quote]Tell the Next Generation: Homiles and Near Homilies by Walter J. Burghardt, SJ As One Who Serves: Reflections on the Pastoral Ministry of Priests in the United States Biblical Catechetical Homilies for Sundays and Holy Days (ABC) by Rev. David Q. Liptak Celibacy, Prayer, and Friendship by Christopher Kiesling, OP Grace Under Pressure: What Gives Life to American Priests[/quote] Never heard of these. [quote]The Pastoral Sermons of Ronald A. Knox[/quote] I'm assuming this is pretty good. I believe he's a convert (?) So you might want to make sure these are his POST-conversion homilies [quote]Cenacles of the Marian Movement of Priests: Purpose/Guide[/quote] This goes with "To the Priests" [quote]Dear Father: A Message of Love to Priests by Catherine de Hueck Doherty[/quote] I don't know about the book but I hear great things about the author.
Moneybags Posted August 2, 2007 Author Posted August 2, 2007 Kiesling may be an advocate of women-priests too.
Moneybags Posted August 2, 2007 Author Posted August 2, 2007 I think I'm going to add the following to the list of Books that I would like to sell: Celibacy, Prayer, and Friendship by Christopher Kiesling, OP ISBN: 08189-0365-1 As One Who Serves: Reflections on the Pastoral Ministry of Priests in the United States Tell the Next Generation: Homilies and Near Homilies by Walter J. Burghardt, SJ ISBN: 0-8091-2252-9
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 3, 2007 Posted August 3, 2007 [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1347524' date='Aug 2 2007, 02:48 PM']I think I'm going to add the following to the list of Books that I would like to sell: Celibacy, Prayer, and Friendship by Christopher Kiesling, OP ISBN: 08189-0365-1 As One Who Serves: Reflections on the Pastoral Ministry of Priests in the United States Tell the Next Generation: Homilies and Near Homilies by Walter J. Burghardt, SJ ISBN: 0-8091-2252-9[/quote] I would just use them as kindling next time you have a barbecue.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted August 3, 2007 Posted August 3, 2007 Reading books by Protestant theologians will not hurt you. Being exposed to different ideas will not contaminate your time in the seminary. I always get slightly disturbed at this idea that to be "orthodox" we have to closet ourselves in some ivory tower and read nothing that doesn't bear an imprimatur. To avoid confusion, I would advise new or poorly catechised Catholics to read mainstream and solid Catholic works before looking at work by Protestant theologians. But if you're going into the seminary, you should be capable of reading and thoughtfully evaluating different ideas without getting confused and/or going green and slumping to the floor. A book may be Protestant. That doesn't make it worthless.
Totus Tuus Posted August 3, 2007 Posted August 3, 2007 I don't think it's wrong to read Protestant books either, as long as you know your [i]Catholic[/i] Faith well enough to identify the errors. Otherwise you're just going to get confused, and possibly led astray
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now