Moneybags Posted August 17, 2007 Posted August 17, 2007 [quote name='Dave' post='1361120' date='Aug 17 2007, 11:34 AM']The SSPX rejects some of Vatican II's teachings. That's not very faithful to Catholic teaching or tradition.[/quote] Quote the parts of Vatican II documents to which they are not faithful.
Era Might Posted August 17, 2007 Posted August 17, 2007 Bernard Fellay stated recently in an interview: [b]"And we insist by saying that Vatican II is in disharmony—is in contradiction—is even teaching error opposed to the traditional teaching, especially on ecumenism."[/b] For those who don't know, he is one of the four men who were illicitly consecrated as Bishops by Marcel Lefebvre and excommunicated under Pope John Paul II: [quote]In itself, this act was one of disobedience to the Roman Pontiff in a very grave matter and of supreme importance for the unity of the church, such as is the ordination of bishops whereby the apostolic succession is sacramentally perpetuated. Hence such disobedience - which implies in practice the rejection of the Roman primacy - constitutes a schismatic act. In performing such an act, notwithstanding the formal canonical warning sent to them by the Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops on 17 June last, Mons. Lefebvre and the priests Bernard Fellay, Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, Richard Williamson and Alfonso de Galarreta, have incurred the grave penalty of excommunication envisaged by ecclesiastical law. --Pope John Paul II, Apostolic Letter "Ecclesia Dei"[/quote]
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 (edited) Okay! The mods have given me approval to post my response. Here it is: [quote name='brendan1104' post='1351677' date='Aug 6 2007, 10:46 PM']You can go, receive Communion and even contribute at the collection. This is allowed by the Vatican. Abercius, I'm not SSPX but back your statgement up. Please show me a quote from any society materials which say that - 1) we're going to hell 2) because we follow the pope, and 3) that he's in heresy.[/quote] May I ask that you be a little more polite in asking for additional references? I believe I deserve a little more respect than your demand conveys. It is difficult to find materials directly from the SSPX blatantly expressing what I have stated, but they do have auxilliary organizations (made up of SSPX members) that produce such materials with the unofficial blessing of SSPX. The organization is highly propogandized. But I shall do my best to satisfy your request. Here is an article (more on the milder side) found on the SSPX website that clearly shows their belief that Pope John Paul II was a heretic (note the red-text statement about our current pope's heresy, too): [url="http://www.sspx.org/SSPX_FAQs/q7_pope.htm"]http://www.sspx.org/SSPX_FAQs/q7_pope.htm[/url] For an example of their tendancy toward propoganda, compare the previous article (which I only found deep within their website using Google) with their more congenial statement regarding Benedict XVI found on their home page: [url="http://www.sspx.org"]http://www.sspx.org[/url] With regards to the validity of the Novus Ordo mass, here is a quote from the SSPX website: "The dissimulation of Catholic elements and the pandering to Protestants which are evident in the Novus Ordo Missae render it a danger to our faith, and, as such, evil, given that it lacks the good which the sacred rite of Mass ought to have. "This does not necessarily follow from the above defects, as serious as they might be, for only three things are required for validity (presupposing a validly ordained priest), proper: matter, form, and intention. "However, the celebrant must intend to do what the Church does. The Novus Ordo Missae will no longer in and of itself guarantee that the celebrant has this intention. That will depend on his personal faith (generally unknown to those assisting, but more and more doubtful as the crisis in the Church is prolonged). "Therefore, these Masses can be of doubtful validity, and more so with time." (http://www.sspx.org/SSPX_FAQs/q5_novusordo.htm) Notice the "double-talk" where they say the Novus Ordo may not be invalid, ... but ... IS EVIL and probably IS INVALID. Now if the official position of the SSPX so blatantly doubts the validity of the Novus Ordo Mass, you can imagine where some of their auxilliary organizations take that line of thinking. Without a valid mass, there is no sanctifying grace to be conferred as part of the Eucharistic Celebration, therefore, Catholics are more LIKELY to go to hell (notice in my previous post I did not say they WOULD go to hell). This mentality is what you will find very common among the members attending an SSPX mass. My point is that such people are not going to be very comfortable with a Catholic who is in-line with Rome. Here is another quote from an official letter issued by the SSPX demonstrating great fear for the continuation of the Church (because of the Novus Ordo mass), and hence our Salvation: "Let us remind the faithful of the urgency of the combat, and of what is at stake. It is not only the Holy Mass, but the Church itself in her entirety." ([url="http://www.sspx.org/superior_generals_ltrs/supgen_message_sept99.html"]http://www.sspx.org/superior_generals_ltrs...age_sept99.html[/url]) They fear the Holy Father is leading the Church into its own destruction. If the Church is the Pillar and Foundation of Truth, without the Church we would have no Truth, and without Truth, the gospel would have failed this and all following generations. I think that is pretty much a statement that hell is a likely scenario for many Catholics who follow the Holy Father. I'll try to find some more literature from some of their auxilliary organizations that demonstrate their more unfriendly side. I hope this at least shows you that the SSPX do have a hidden, malicious attitude toward those who are loyal to the Pope. By the way, you may be a little more friendly by doing some research before you ask me to justify the content of my ADVICE which I have given OUTSIDE of the debate forum. God bless! Steve S. -- Abercius24 CatholicQandA.com Edited August 18, 2007 by abercius24
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1361128' date='Aug 17 2007, 11:59 AM']Quote the parts of Vatican II documents to which they are not faithful.[/quote] How about talking smack about the Holy Father and his mission. I think that pretty much qualifies as unfaithful.
Moneybags Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1361485' date='Aug 17 2007, 09:06 PM']How about talking smack about the Holy Father and his mission. I think that pretty much qualifies as unfaithful.[/quote] You may disagree with the Holy Father when he is not speaking ex cathedra.
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 (edited) [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1361665' date='Aug 18 2007, 12:14 AM']You may disagree with the Holy Father when he is not speaking ex cathedra.[/quote] Disagreeing is a far cry from calling him a heretic and recognizing his leadership as destructive to the future of the Church. SSPX essentially teach that the Pope is no longer a participant in the Universal and Ordinary Magisterium, which would essentially mean no faithful Bishop is a participant in the Universal and Ordinary Mageisterium, since a Bishop may not participate in such without being in complete union with the Pope. Oh, and by the way, that's two doctrines the SSPX reject from Vatican I AND Vatican II: The Continuity of a Faithful Papacy (the Shepherd) and the Infallibility of the Universal and Ordinary Magisterium. The Pope and Bishops in union with him can teach errors on a one-off basis, but can never teach heresy as a whole. Furthermore the Pope can never be an outright heretic himself. Edited August 18, 2007 by abercius24
Dave Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1361665' date='Aug 18 2007, 01:14 AM']You may disagree with the Holy Father when he is not speaking ex cathedra.[/quote] Just because the Holy Father isn't speaking ex cathedra doesn't automatically mean one may disagree with him. The teachings against birth control, abortion, etc. aren't ex cathedra, but no Catholic may disagree with the Holy Father on such issues. Why? Because such teachings are infallible by virtue of the ordinary universal magisterium, which isn't nearly as solemn as an ex cathedra definition but is NO LESS INFALLIBLE. Vatican II used the ordinary universal magisterium to teach. Also, a Catholic may disagree with any given prudential decision by the pope for whatever reason. However, disagreement is one thing; insinuating he's a heretic or has done great damage to the faith is quite another. And the SSPX, as abercius' article shows, cross that line big-time.
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2007 Posted August 18, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Dave' post='1361712' date='Aug 18 2007, 01:16 AM']Just because the Holy Father isn't speaking ex cathedra doesn't automatically mean one may disagree with him. The teachings against birth control, abortion, etc. aren't ex cathedra, but no Catholic may disagree with the Holy Father on such issues. Why? Because such teachings are infallible by virtue of the ordinary universal magisterium, which isn't nearly as solemn as an ex cathedra definition but is NO LESS INFALLIBLE. Vatican II used the ordinary universal magisterium to teach. Also, a Catholic may disagree with any given prudential decision by the pope for whatever reason. However, disagreement is one thing; insinuating he's a heretic or has done great damage to the faith is quite another. And the SSPX, as abercius' article shows, cross that line big-time.[/quote] Wow, its almost like we had the same thought at the very same time. That's awesome! God bless you, my friend! Edited August 18, 2007 by abercius24
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now