Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey everyone - thanks so much for all of your advice. We attended the Mass this morning and it was absolutely beautiful. It was so "sensual" - I witnessed the mass, I smelled the incense, I heard the words, and I tasted the body of Christ. It was awesome. My guys thought it was very cool too. We had some really good discussions leading up to the mass, and of course it lead into great discussion afterward. We tried to not get caught up in the missal and to immerse ourselves in the Mass. That is easier said than done - I think some of my guys did a better job than I did, I like to know exactly what is going on. I don't know if any of us are going to become regulars, but it was a wonderful experience and we all agreed that we must go back soon. We do have an amazing home parish with an exceptional priest. I have pictures of my group outside the church that I will get off the camera sometime this week (I hope) and I will post them.

My group and I will continue to lurk around the forum, and hopefully participate a bit more. This is such an amazing place. Thank you all.

Frisbee

Posted (edited)

Now that we have had some time to digest the Mass, we have some questions that maybe you all can help answer.

1. Should the congregation join in the common prayers such as the Creed, the Our Father, and the Lamb of God? Some people did, others didn't.

2. Should the congregation also cross themselves when the priest does?

3. Should the congregation sing when the choir sings - if the words are in the missal? Again, some people did, some did not.

4. We noticed that it was the 11th Sunday from Pentecost at the TLM, and it is "actually" the 19th Sunday in ordinary time according to the "new St. Joseph Missal in accordance with Vatican II". Since the TLM is using the 1962 missal, do the readings keep repeating for 1962 over and over again each year, or is there a cycle A, B, and C?

5. As I mentioned in a previous text, we have a beautiful n.o. mass and a very dynamic priest in our home parish and do not want to leave. Is it acceptable to every once in a while visit the TLM in a nearby parish? What about visiting a Byzantine Catholic church to experience the liturgy there? It is all Catholic, and I am interested - as our my guys - in experiencing everything that is Catholic.

I am probably leaving out some questions. I am meeting again with my guys on Wednesday and will share the answers as well as get any other questions.

Ya'll are awesome.

Peace.

Frisbee

Edited by Frisbee
Posted

1. Only the priest says the Our Father, the server/people say "sed libera nos a malo." At Low Mass (non-dialogue, but where do you find a dialogue mass anymore?) only the priest says the Creed. At high/sung Mass, the people can chant the creed or alternate with choir/schola according the local custom. Only the priest says the Lamb of God. At some places, especially in Europe, the people say the Lord I am not worthy along with or instead of the priest right before their own communion (when the priest turns around and shows the host).

2. The congregation crosses themselves at the beginning, the absolution after the people's confiteor, at the end of the Gloria, Credo, and Benedictus with the priest, at the absolution before the confiteor before their communion (if applicable), and at the final blessing.

3. The people can sing/chant, sometimes alternating verses with the choir, if that's the practice at the church. The people usually do join in at the ordinary parts of the mass.

4. Yes, the readings are the same - keep repeating. There is no cycle at the Tridentine Mass.

5. Yes, as has been decreed lately, the Novus Ordo is the ordinary form and the Tridentine the extraordinary according to Benedict XVI. So yes you can go to any Catholic rite whenever you wish.

Hope this helps!


[quote name='Frisbee' post='1358403' date='Aug 13 2007, 06:25 PM']Now that we have had some time to digest the Mass, we have some questions that maybe you all can help answer.

1. Should the congregation join in the common prayers such as the Creed, the Our Father, and the Lamb of God? Some people did, others didn't.

2. Should the congregation also cross themselves when the priest does?

3. Should the congregation sing when the choir sings - if the words are in the missal? Again, some people did, some did not.

4. We noticed that it was the 11th Sunday from Pentecost at the TLM, and it is "actually" the 19th Sunday in ordinary time according to the "new St. Joseph Missal in accordance with Vatican II". Since the TLM is using the 1962 missal, do the readings keep repeating for 1962 over and over again each year, or is there a cycle A, B, and C?

5. As I mentioned in a previous text, we have a beautiful n.o. mass and a very dynamic priest in our home parish and do not want to leave. Is it acceptable to every once in a while visit the TLM in a nearby parish? What about visiting a Byzantine Catholic church to experience the liturgy there? It is all Catholic, and I am interested - as our my guys - in experiencing everything that is Catholic.

I am probably leaving out some questions. I am meeting again with my guys on Wednesday and will share the answers as well as get any other questions.

Ya'll are awesome.

Peace.

Frisbee[/quote]

Ora et Labora
Posted

[quote name='Frisbee' post='1358403' date='Aug 13 2007, 08:25 PM']Now that we have had some time to digest the Mass, we have some questions that maybe you all can help answer.

1. Should the congregation join in the common prayers such as the Creed, the Our Father, and the Lamb of God? Some people did, others didn't.

2. Should the congregation also cross themselves when the priest does?

3. Should the congregation sing when the choir sings - if the words are in the missal? Again, some people did, some did not.

4. We noticed that it was the 11th Sunday from Pentecost at the TLM, and it is "actually" the 19th Sunday in ordinary time according to the "new St. Joseph Missal in accordance with Vatican II". Since the TLM is using the 1962 missal, do the readings keep repeating for 1962 over and over again each year, or is there a cycle A, B, and C?

5. As I mentioned in a previous text, we have a beautiful n.o. mass and a very dynamic priest in our home parish and do not want to leave. Is it acceptable to every once in a while visit the TLM in a nearby parish? What about visiting a Byzantine Catholic church to experience the liturgy there? It is all Catholic, and I am interested - as our my guys - in experiencing everything that is Catholic.

I am probably leaving out some questions. I am meeting again with my guys on Wednesday and will share the answers as well as get any other questions.

Ya'll are awesome.

Peace.

Frisbee[/quote]

1. Except for the Our Father, yes, you participate. :)
2. I'm not sure about this one...I mean, I cross myself when my missal tells me too. I'm not looking at the priest the whole time...
3. I'm IN the choir... :lol: And let me say, the choir LIKES it when people join in. ;) If you want to, go ahead!
4. Yes, they repeat.
5. I think it's a great thing to experience different Masses!! My church is in the middle of downtown Houston, right NEXT to the Minute Maid ball park (home of the Astros) which means we have visitors all the time! Our priest doesn't mind. :)

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1355518' date='Aug 10 2007, 08:19 PM']you're right. me failing to see that uncovered shoulders are a modesty issue is a complete failure to appreciate the beauty of the whole female body because i'm completely desensitized :rolleyes:

oh please!

i've known people with beautiful hands, should they have to wear gloves? what about dainty ankles? the point is, modesty has to do with keeping ourselves covered to the extent that sexual provocation is not an issue, not covering any part of our body considered to be objectively beautiful.[/quote]

It would seem like pope Pius XII would agree with me:

[quote]"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
--The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII[/quote]

Also, a picture that is found outside St. Peter's in Vatican City:

[img]http://www.azcanada.com/photoblog/photos/DSC00991.jpg[/img]

I'm sorry, but modern fashion is not typically modest. It matters not whether it is commonplace -- I'd assume you would agree that much in our world that is commonplace is sinful. I don't blame you for this, you, like virtually everyone else, has never heard this preached by the Church as she had done in ages past. You only have seen the world. I pray that all holy men and women come to this understanding, for the sake of salvation of souls.

My [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showuser=542"]betrothed[/url] dresses very modestly, and in a very feminine way. She actually informed me of the church's standards of dress.

And if sexual provocation is the only issue, why did women wear veils to mass for 1900+ years? Modesty goes beyond sexual provocation. You also don't know what might sexually provoke someone, and it's always best to err on the side of caution.

There's a convent in NYC that's run by a group of very prayerful nuns, and has a perpetual adoration shrine open to the public. They don't allow women to enter if they have any slits in their skirts, skirts above the knee, shorts, sleeveless shirts, low-cut necklines, etc. This is the way the church was for time immemorial.

Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1358543' date='Aug 14 2007, 01:15 AM']Only the priest says the Lamb of God.[/quote]

Actually, at the high mass, the people may chant the [i]Agnus Dei[/i] along with the choir.

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1358543' date='Aug 14 2007, 01:15 AM']At some places, especially in Europe, the people say the Lord I am not worthy along with or instead of the priest right before their own communion (when the priest turns around and shows the host).[/quote]
To clarify, in a mass where people other than the priest are receiving the Eucharist, the [i]Domine non sum dignus[/i] is said thrice by the priest while facing the altar, and then thrice again wile facing the congregation after he receives communion. The people may say it along with him the second set, but not the first.

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1358543' date='Aug 14 2007, 01:15 AM']3. The people can sing/chant, sometimes alternating verses with the choir, if that's the practice at the church. The people usually do join in at the ordinary parts of the mass.[/quote]

The people are encouraged to sing the ordinary ([i]Kyrie, Credo, Gloria, Agnus Dei, Sanctus[/i]), but are forbidden to sing the propers (Introit, gradual, etc.) In fact, only the men in the choir may chant the propers, as they are prayers "owned" by the priest.

Feel free to ask if you have any further questions.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...