Totus Tuus Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 (edited) JMJ + Hi Pham, Here's the list. If you have a CD that is from a band on the list, you can cut it and half and send it to the record company (whose address you'll find in the CD jacket) if you wish. It's a good way to protest. I've done it a couple times SOURCE: [url="http://rockforlife.org/music_proabortionbands.php"]http://rockforlife.org/music_proabortionbands.php[/url] "There are many reasons for a band to be on our pro-abortion bands list. Some of them donate money or play concerts to raise money for Planned Parenthood, Rock for Choice, Voters for Choice, Axis of Justice, America Coming Together, PunkVoter.com, Air Traffic Control Project, or other pro-abortion causes. Some of these bands produce songs with a pro-abortion message or they have taken a strong pro-choice stance. The bands on the following list either promote or endorse abortion." A A.K.A.'s PunkVoter.com Affirmative Action Jackson Against All Authority PunkVoter.com Against Me! PunkVoter.com Alanis Morissette March for "Women's Lives" Alice in Chains Alkaline Trio PunkVoter.com ALL PunkVoter.com Amiee Mann test Amy Joe Johnson March for "Women's Lives" Amy Maines March for "Women's Lives" Ani DiFranco March for "Women's Lives" Anti-Flag PunkVoter.com Ashley Judd March for "Women's Lives" Ataris PunkVoter.com Audio Karate PunkVoter.com Audioslave Morello, Cornell & Wilk; Axis of Justice Audrey McDonald Aus-Rotten Authority Zero PunkVoter.com Auto Pilot Off PunkVoter.com Avail PunkVoter.com Avoid One Thing PunkVoter.com B Babes in Toyland Bad Astronaut PunkVoter.com Bad Religion PunkVoter.com Barenaked Ladies Bayside PunkVoter.com Behind Enemy Lines PunkVoter.com Ben Harper America Coming Together benefit , March for "Women's Lives" Betty Big D and the Kids Table PunkVoter.com Bigwig PunkVoter.com Bikini Kill Blink 182 PunkVoter.com Blues Traveler Bobot Adrenaline PunkVoter.com Bonnie Raitt America Coming Together benefit Bouncing Souls PunkVoter.com Bracket PunkVoter.com Break the Silence PunkVoter.com Bright Eyes America Coming Together benefit Bruce Cockburn Bruce Hornsby Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band America Coming Together benefit Bush C Cabaret 4 Choice "An Independently-Produced Show & CD Recording To Benefit Freedom of Choice" Carole King March for "Women's Lives" Carrie Newcomer Donated portions of album sales and done benefit concerts for Planned Parenthood. [url="http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/living/events/s_510194.html"]http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburgh...s/s_510194.html[/url] Carrier Can you please add our pro death band Carrier to the list? Thanks! Casio Cassanova Plays VOX shows Casualites PunkVoter.com Cathie Martino Chaka Khan Cher Chin Music Choir the Bear Christina Aguilera March for "Women's Lives" Circle Jerks PunkVoter.com Citizen Fish PunkVoter.com Common Rider PunkVoter.com Corrine Cowboy Junkies Cutthroat Junction Plays VOX concerts Cyndi Lauper D Da Rat Pack Played VOX show Dag Nasty PunkVoter.com Dance Hall Crashers Dave Matthews Band David Byrne David Crosby Death Cab for Cutie America Coming Together benefit Deborah Cox Denali PunkVoter.com Descendents PunkVoter.com Destiny Plays Vox shows Destruction Made Simple PunkVoter.com Dice Raw Diesel Boy PunkVoter.com Dillinger Escape Plan PunkVoter.com Dillinger Four PunkVoter.com Dixie Chicks America Coming Together benefit, glorifying abortion supporters in tour video Dropkick Murphys PunkVoter.com E Enemy You PunkVoter.com Ensign PunkVoter.com Enzymes PunkVoter.com Ethyl Everclear Everlast Eve’s Plum F Fabulous Disaster PunkVoter.com Face to Face Father MC Fifteen PunkVoter.com Fishbone Flatbush PunkVoter.com Flipsides PunkVoter.com Flogging Molly PunkVoter.com Foo Fighters PunkVoter.com Four Non-Blondes Frenzal Rhomb PunkVoter.com Frisk PunkVoter.com Fugazi G Gamits PunkVoter.com Get Up Kids PunkVoter.com God Awfuls PunkVoter.com Good Charlotte PunkVoter.com Good Riddance PunkVoter.com Graham Nash Green Day PunkVoter.com H H2O PunkVoter.com Helen Reddy Helmet Henry Rollins Hole Holy Mary Mother of Bert Hot Snakes PunkVoter.com Hot Water Music PunkVoter.com I Iggy Pop Indigo Girls J Jackson Browne America Coming Together benefit Jackson Browne James Taylor America Coming Together benefit Janice Ian Jawbreaker PunkVoter.com Jewel Performed "Zero Population Growth" fundraiser at Madison Square Garden, Jan. 25, 1999 Joan Jett Joan Osborne Joe Henry John Fogerty America Coming Together benefit John Mellencamp America Coming Together benefit Josh Perlman Juliana Hatfield Juliette and the Licks PunkVoter.com Jurassic 5 Axis of Justice benefit CD, America Coming Together benefit K Keb ‘Mo’ America Coming Together benefit Kenny "Babyface" Edmonds America Coming Together benefit Korn L L7 Lagwagon PunkVoter.com Laurie Anderson Lawrence Arms PunkVoter.com Le Tigre often seen giving Gloria Steinem the mic Less Than Jake PunkVoter.com Limp PunkVoter.com Lisa Loeb March for "Women's Lives" Living Colour Liz Phair Lot Six PunkVoter.com Lunachicks PunkVoter.com Luscious Jackson Lyle Lovett M Mad Caddies PunkVoter.com Madcap Madonna Margie Adam March for "Women's Lives" Mary Chapin Carpenter Mary J Blige Mary Prankster Mary’s Danish Matthew Sweet Maxeen PunkVoter.com MC5 Wayne Kramer, Axis of Justice benefit Me First and the Gimme Gimmes PunkVoter.com Meatplow Melissa Etheridge March for "Women's Lives" Melissa Ferrick Mighty Mighty Bosstones PunkVoter.com Mike Watt PunkVoter.com Miles of Clear June Plays VOX shows Ministry PunkVoter.com Mishap Oct. 6, 2004 email from Rick Waldron Moby March for "Women's Lives" Morphine Mudhoney PunkVoter.com My Morning Jacket America Coming Together N Naked Aggression PunkVoter.com Nanci Griffith Natalie Merchant Neil Young New Found Glory PunkVoter.com New Mexican Disaster Squad PunkVoter.com Nirvana No Doubt PunkVoter.com No Use For A Name PunkVoter.com NOFX PunkVoter.com None More Black PunkVoter.com O Odetta Offspring PunkVoter.com Only Crime PunkVoter.com Operation Ivy PunkVoter.com P Page 80 Plays VOX shows Paint It Black PunkVoter.com Paula Cole Performed "Zero Population Growth" fundraiser at Madison Square Garden, Jan. 25, 1999 Paula Cole Pavement Pearl Jam endorses ChoiceUSA, Rock for Choice, Feminist Majority Foundation, Planned Parenthood Federations of America, National Organization for Women & National Abortion Rights Action League. America Coming Together benefit Pennywise PunkVoter.com Pete Yorn Axis of Justice benefit CD Phish Phoebe Snow Phosgene Hi, we are a German death metal band and since our website www.phosgene.de went online our link list has featured your very informative homepage including a very explicit call to visit it. So we think it would just be fair to kinda exchange links, particularly because we deserve more than to be added by your standards. Sincerely Michael Marquardt (Voc/Bass) PINK March for "Women's Lives" Possum Dixon Presidents of the United States of America Primus Q Q And Not U PunkVoter.com R R.E.M. America Coming Together benefit Rage Against The Machine Ramones Rancid PunkVoter.com Red Hot Chili Peppers Flea, Axis of Justice Reputation PunkVoter.com Rickie Lee Jones Rise Against PunkVoter.com Rocket From the Crypt PunkVoter.com Rosanne Cash Rum Diary PunkVoter.com Rusted Root Planned Parenthood Rx Bandits PunkVoter.com S S.T.U.N. PunkVoter.com Salt ‘N Pepa Santana Sarah McLachlan March for "Women's Lives" Screaming Trees Seth Timbs Plays VOX shows Seven Year B*&ch Shawn Colvin Sheryl Crow March for "Women's Lives," Planned Parenthood supporter, plays "Rock for Choice" concerts, lobbyed for SF 192 - the "Iowa Stem Cell Research and Cure Initiative" which would legalize cloning and killing human embryos for their stem cells [url="http://www.fidelis.org/gw3/articles-news/articles.php?CMSArticleID=886&CMSCategoryID=10"]http://www.fidelis.org/gw3/articles-news/a...MSCategoryID=10[/url] Shudder to Think Sick of It All PunkVoter.com Sleator-Kinney PunkVoter.com Social Distortion PunkVoter.com SONiA March for "Women's Lives" Sophie B. Hawkins Soul Asylum Soundgarden Soviettas PunkVoter.com Spearhead Sponge State Control Oct. 6, 2004 email from Rick Waldron Stone Fox Stone Temple Pilots Straylight Run PunkVoter.com Strike Anywhere PunkVoter.com Strung Out PunkVoter.com Strychnine PunkVoter.com Subhumans PunkVoter.com Sugarcult PunkVoter.com Suicide Machines PunkVoter.com Sum 41 PunkVoter.com Swingin' Utters PunkVoter.com Swoosie Kurt March for "Women's Lives" System of a Down Serj Tankian, Axis of Justice T Tabula Rasa PunkVoter.com Ten Foot Pole PunkVoter.com The Bangles The Butchies PunkVoter.com The Code PunkVoter.com The Commercials PunkVoter.com The Coup Boots Riley, Axis of Justice benefit The Crisis Team Aug. 31, 2004 Brendan Susens-Jackson email The Donnas PunkVoter.com The Donots PunkVoter.com The Dwarves PunkVoter.com The Epoxies PunkVoter.com The Explosion PunkVoter.com The F-Up's PunkVoter.com The Ghost PunkVoter.com The Glitter Dragons Plays VOX shows The Gossip PunkVoter.com The Hollow Ground vocal at shows about their support of abortion The Holograms "You can be assured we would be quite proud to be listed with the many other notables on your pro-choice roster" email dated 7-16-2006 The International Noise Conspiracy PunkVoter.com The Kennedy's The Love Cats Plays VOX shows The Ques Played VOX show The Red Light The States Plays Vox shows The Unseen PunkVoter.com The Vacancy PunkVoter.com The Young Livers Plays Vox shows Thom York March for "Women's Lives" Thought Riot PunkVoter.com Tilt PunkVoter.com Toad the Wet Sprocket Tom Waits Tool Maynard, Axis of Justice benefit , PunkVoter.com Toys That Kill PunkVoter.com Tracy Bonham Trans Am Punkvoter.com U Ubre-Prima Played VOX show Useless ID PunkVoter.com V Veruca Salt W Wayne Kramer PunkVoter.com Ween Western Addiction PunkVoter.com Wilson, Winter Drive, Cassandra World/Inferno Friendship Society PunkVoter.com Wray X X Y Yellowcard PunkVoter.com Yo La Tengo Air Traffic Control Project Yo-Yo Youth Brigade PunkVoter.com Edited August 8, 2007 by Lil Red
abercius24 Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 (edited) Another good reason to support Catholic Music!!! Things will only change when people decide to invest their money into cultural networks that are righteous by design. Invest in your own so they can invest in you! Thanks for the list, Totus. Edited August 8, 2007 by abercius24
God the Father Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 So basically every good band I've ever heard.
Didymus Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 no positive side to the thread yet I see buy from these artists: [url="http://www.rockforlife.org/music_prolifebands.php"]http://www.rockforlife.org/music_prolifebands.php[/url]
saint_wannabe Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 noooo not Tom Morello ...o well i downloaded most of their songs anyway [quote name='God the Father' post='1352474' date='Aug 7 2007, 08:32 PM']So basically every good band I've ever heard.[/quote] pretty much. yea. Didymus make a thread on pro life bands
abercius24 Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 [quote name='God the Father' post='1352474' date='Aug 7 2007, 09:32 PM']So basically every good band I've ever heard.[/quote] Of course. They invest in there own, so why would we not expect them all to basically have the same beliefs. Right?
God the Father Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1352704' date='Aug 8 2007, 03:40 AM']Of course. They invest in [s]there[/s] their own, so why would we not expect them all to basically have the same beliefs. Right?[/quote] What?
Didymus Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 there's no style or influence that brings them together, aside from the fact that many want to feel as if they are doing something good, so they contribute to punk voter and others in order to get "involved" with the community and whatnot, the only problem being punk voter is pro-choice. Not all of them are adamantly anti-life, some just need a kick in the rear.
God the Father Posted August 8, 2007 Posted August 8, 2007 [quote name='Didymus' post='1352958' date='Aug 8 2007, 02:27 PM']there's no style or influence that brings them together, aside from the fact that many want to feel as if they are doing something good, so they contribute to punk voter and others in order to get "involved" with the community and whatnot, the only problem being punk voter is pro-choice. Not all of them are adamantly anti-life, some just need a kick in the rear.[/quote] I don't even know I'd go so far as to say "punk voter is pro-choice." The website administrators themselves make no mention of the issue, beyond being alarmingly liberal and therefore in latent support of pro-choicism. In the guest columns their are two references to pro-abortion, one by Tsunami Bomb (a truly awful band btw) and the other by some neo-feminazi or related trash. It's true that by hosting these columns the already morally sketchy movement is aligning itself with abortion, but it still stands that the comments are made by individuals mostly independent from the website itself, and wholly independent from the other groups associated with punk voter. PunkVoter is truly an idiotic concept in and of itself, because those who identify themselves as punks are almost 100% below voting age, and those that are not are probably too busy with their bottles, studded clothing, and mohawks to register. Also they have the wrong idea about American society, liberalism, rights, and the Democratic party. But to group in all the bands connected with PunkVoter--a lot, because it was a fad at the time of the 2004 elections--and claim that they support murder is quite a far reach, imho. It's possible that they are but it's a bold statement to make with very limited circumstantial evidence. I suppose I just rehashed what Didymus said, but hopefully you understand what I'm getting at.
littleflower+JMJ Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 [quote name='God the Father' post='1353037' date='Aug 8 2007, 03:50 PM']I don't even know I'd go so far as to say "punk voter is pro-choice." The website administrators themselves make no mention of the issue, beyond being alarmingly liberal and therefore in latent support of pro-choicism. In the guest columns their are two references to pro-abortion, one by Tsunami Bomb (a truly awful band btw) and the other by some neo-feminazi or related trash. It's true that by hosting these columns the already morally sketchy movement is aligning itself with abortion, but it still stands that the comments are made by individuals mostly independent from the website itself, and wholly independent from the other groups associated with punk voter. PunkVoter is truly an idiotic concept in and of itself, because those who identify themselves as punks are almost 100% below voting age, and those that are not are probably too busy with their bottles, studded clothing, and mohawks to register. Also they have the wrong idea about American society, liberalism, rights, and the Democratic party. But to group in all the bands connected with PunkVoter--a lot, because it was a fad at the time of the 2004 elections--and claim that they support murder is quite a far reach, imho. It's possible that they are but it's a bold statement to make with very limited circumstantial evidence. I suppose I just rehashed what Didymus said, but hopefully you understand what I'm getting at.[/quote] It makes [b]perfectly[/b] good sense with the history of many of these bands and the originator of group, Fat Mike. To say abortion is not a position these guys are making and that its not on their agenda is quite clearly be a contradiction to their name and activism. I know most of the bands on punkvoter.com and they have supported abortion through their record labels and careers before...punkvoter.com has merely helped us identify which bands exactly are by them becoming vocal and grouped together now. If any of them on punkvoter.com would be pro-life in the smallest, tinest way I am sure the originators of punkvoter.com would not allow them to be on there. Its sad really...
curtins Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 this is kinda like buying stuff from companies that are pro abort, etc. Its really impossible to not buy anything that ur dollars somehow get their way into the hands of PP or NARAL. If you like someone's music, don't not listen to it. I buy used CDs off half.com and amazon cause their cheap. but I still go to shows and buy merch.
littleflower+JMJ Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 I use to listen to alot of bands punkvoter.com but their agenda and liberalism sickens me to a point where I want nothing to do with them. My distaste for their ideals changed my taste in their music. Yeah, I still know their lyrics and songs well but now I really want nothing to do with them because their not worth my time..........and really in the end their not good. (thank GOD I got out of that stage!!) whats different with alot of the punk bands...is not all their liberal activism every second of their tour that they do (while that is pretty bad)............Their whole point is not really to entertain you and make music but to mold you. And thats what I can't stand.
Socrates Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 (edited) Those punkers are so many pierced, hair-dyed sheep, playing at being "rebels" while all marching lock-step to the same mindless leftist ideology. And urging all those kids to rise up and do something really radical . . . like vote for Hillary Clinton. Edited August 9, 2007 by Socrates
abercius24 Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 (edited) [quote name='abercius24' post='1352704' date='Aug 8 2007, 02:40 AM']Of course. They invest in their own, so why would we not expect them all to basically have the same beliefs. Right?[/quote] [quote name='God the Father' post='1352906' date='Aug 8 2007, 12:52 PM']What?[/quote] The powers that exist on the liberal political front are very united and loyal to each other. They work very closely together, even when their particular agendas have nothing to do with each other. Consider the homosexual agenda and the pro-abortion agenda. Neither of these groups really benefit from each other's work directly. Their only tie is that they have the same political opponents -- social conservatives. But because they recognize the opportunity to work together, they create a fierce synergy between their two causes. When a pro-abortion group has a protest, the homosexual activists will be there in support. Likewise, when a homosexual group has a rally, the pro-abortion group will also attend. They are a very tight-knit network who invest large amounts of time and money into each other. In the last 30 years, Hollywood has mainly found its support from the liberal front. Given that reality, why would we not see Hollywood as an extension of the liberal political arm? And its true. You cannot work in Hollywood if you're not part of the liberal network. Why should a pro-abortion producer allow a pro-life guy to direct his movie if he has a larger liberal network of directors to choose from? Even if he doesn't know if a particular director is pro-life or not, if he never sees him at a party riddled with sex and drugs, he's gonna know the guy is at least a conservative sympathizer. Its easy for liberals to recognize their own because they share the same tolerance for sin. And they do only support their own -- ask Mel Gibson. He has stated that many conservative entertainers have suffered because they would not become part of the Hollywood party culture. The majority of the bands you see ARE part of the Hollywood party culture. Whether they have strong pro-abortion opinions or not, they have proven their loyalty to the liberal front by way of their lifestyle. And because they are part of that network, they have been given generous support from their fellow Hollywood liberals. My point is that WE DON'T readily support our own. If every Catholic bought one $10 CD from a Catholic band for every 10 CDs they bought from liberal Hollywood, you would hear some really good music on the radio challenging the liberal agenda on the cultural battlefront. But you must LOOK for them. They do not have any money to build the cause of pro-life music unless you find them and invest in them. Even if you don't like their music, think of how many Hollywood Produced CDs you bought, took home, didn't like, and put away on the shelf? Sell that crummy CD on ebay and buy a $5 Catholic CD instead. Good things don't happen unless good people make them happen. So save your $10 a week by making your own coffee instead of "investing" in Starbucks, and give one of those $10 bills every month to a Catholic band and the other three $10 bills to a Church or Pro-Life organization. Give it 5 years and you'll see things change for the better! Edited August 9, 2007 by abercius24
Didymus Posted August 9, 2007 Posted August 9, 2007 too many times, even Catholics see buying the pro-life artist's cds as an act of philanthropism, since they'll probably just sit on the shelf and never be listened to. thus the tiny industry behind it doesn't feel compelled to change, since some music has been sold. I've done it too many times, buying a cd because the artist/band was Catholic/Christian/pro-life and I have quite a few of them that I don't listen to because I'd rather smash my face through the drywall in my room before I honestly find it entertaining...
God the Father Posted August 10, 2007 Posted August 10, 2007 [quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1353177' date='Aug 8 2007, 09:46 PM']If any of them on punkvoter.com would be pro-life in the smallest, tinest way I am sure the originators of punkvoter.com would not allow them to be on there.[/quote] Punkvoter.com originated as an attempt to fuel relatively young individuals of voting age to vote(presumably against President Bush, because they'd be angsty and stupid enough to vote for John Kerry) using popular music as emotional fuel. Unless I'm mistaken about Marketing 101, name recognition is what Fat Mike was after, it wouldn't matter if a band was reactionary right wing as long as they had a fan base and were willing to attach their name to the movement. This of course wouldn't happen, because a group with those feelings wouldn't do this. But in the same vein, a group with a liberal slant caught up in the anti-Bush firestorm that is the modern entertainment industry might rush to buy into punk legend(and political idiot) Fat Mike's movement, whether they are pro or anti abortion, or more likely, don't have a public opinion on the matter at all. [quote name='abercius24' post='1353310' date='Aug 8 2007, 11:24 PM']My point is that WE DON'T readily support our own. If every Catholic bought one $10 CD from a Catholic band for every 10 CDs they bought from liberal Hollywood, you would hear some really good music on the radio challenging the liberal agenda on the cultural battlefront. But you must LOOK for them. They do not have any money to build the cause of pro-life music unless you find them and invest in them. Even if you don't like their music, think of how many Hollywood Produced CDs you bought, took home, didn't like, and put away on the shelf? Sell that crummy CD on ebay and buy a $5 Catholic CD instead. Good things don't happen unless good people make them happen. So save your $10 a week by making your own coffee instead of "investing" in Starbucks, and give one of those $10 bills every month to a Catholic band and the other three $10 bills to a Church or Pro-Life organization. Give it 5 years and you'll see things change for the better![/quote] As Didymus says, this sometimes(often) becomes an issue of quality. In most cases "Catholic" music doesn't understand me. When it comes to music I'm really not interested what your beliefs are, I'd just like to hear some nice music. Of course those beliefs are going to leak into a group's lyrics, but I don't want it to be the focus of a record. Because that's annoying. If an Alkaline Trio record made a mention of atheism, liberalism, hedonistic drug abuse, anarchy, etc. on every track it would probably put me off and I would not like the record. But there is little to no (I say little to no because I haven't heard every track) mention of these themes anywhere in their music that I have heard, and as a result I as a music listener and consumer am not affected by their politics. If a group wants mainstream success, their music and lyrics must connect to the mainstream--a broad range of political and religious beliefs. Outside of their music a group can rally around whatever cause they feel like and outside of extreme cases this will not affect their mainstream success. If a group's lyrics are expressions of beliefs a small percentage of the mainstream audience connect with then that group's audience will be a small percentage of the mainstream audience, they will not sell well. Your post was really good though. Made a lot of sense and made a lot of things clear for me.
littleflower+JMJ Posted August 10, 2007 Posted August 10, 2007 I think your looking at Punk Voter as a group that bands jump on for name, when I see it as the activist vehicle that it is that these bands accept when joining this group. And that to me is serious business. Why else would they make an organization just for that? Why would they join something if they already get what you mentioned from their record labels and cds that Fat Mike also run? One of the activist works from Punk Voter was fighting the ban on partial birth abortion. Thats not marketing, thats their production now. lol These bands are following the organization agenda to their "T" and doing work in the process and making a stance in the process. (which is why I disagree with you) Anyways, All I'm saying is to argue that abortion is NOT on their list, even when knowing the strong left-side take they have, is in the end calling them pro-life when their in an organization that is not. Either they are or they not. Obviously their not prolife...and not even in the slightest sense because for reasons like the ban.....and i didn't need Marking 101 to figure that out one. Even though I have to admit i never took it Anyways, I think you and me on the same side in the end. I guess we just see things differently.
abercius24 Posted August 11, 2007 Posted August 11, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Didymus' post='1354050' date='Aug 9 2007, 02:43 PM']too many times, even Catholics see buying the pro-life artist's cds as an act of philanthropism, since they'll probably just sit on the shelf and never be listened to. thus the tiny industry behind it doesn't feel compelled to change, since some music has been sold. I've done it too many times, buying a cd because the artist/band was Catholic/Christian/pro-life and I have quite a few of them that I don't listen to because I'd rather smash my face through the drywall in my room before I honestly find it entertaining...[/quote] Wow, that sounds painful! Yeah, I hear you there. I've heard some bands that were Catholic and/or Pro-Life by name, but were terrible as musicians. I'm not saying support terrible music against your good judgement. But, there are some excellent groups out now -- such as the ones here on phatmass! I would not consider it merely philanthropy supporting these guys. These guys have some quality stuff that deserves our attention and support. I would say that we as Catholics should look harder to support the good bands that are out there. It takes money to market your band, and if you're in an infant market, that money isn't there. If you as the consumer take the time to find these bands, you help them shorten the marketing channel and save money -- money they should be using on better instruments, recording software, travel expenses, etc. [quote name='god+the+father' post='1355431' date='Aug 10 2007, 05:40 PM']As Didymus says, this sometimes(often) becomes an issue of quality. In most cases "Catholic" music doesn't understand me. When it comes to music I'm really not interested what your beliefs are, I'd just like to hear some nice music. Of course those beliefs are going to leak into a group's lyrics, but I don't want it to be the focus of a record. Because that's annoying. If an Alkaline Trio record made a mention of atheism, liberalism, hedonistic drug abuse, anarchy, etc. on every track it would probably put me off and I would not like the record. But there is little to no (I say little to no because I haven't heard every track) mention of these themes anywhere in their music that I have heard, and as a result I as a music listener and consumer am not affected by their politics. If a group wants mainstream success, their music and lyrics must connect to the mainstream--a broad range of political and religious beliefs. Outside of their music a group can rally around whatever cause they feel like and outside of extreme cases this will not affect their mainstream success. If a group's lyrics are expressions of beliefs a small percentage of the mainstream audience connect with then that group's audience will be a small percentage of the mainstream audience, they will not sell well. Your post was really good though. Made a lot of sense and made a lot of things clear for me.[/quote] Yo also have to remember that most Catholic and Pro-Life artists make no real money at all -- its basically volunteer work. Those who are good who work in Catholic/Pro-Life music are actually making serious sacrifices to make that type of music happen. The money is with the liberal Hollywood industry, not with the Cathoilc/Pro-Life movement. See them more as public speakers who deserve a stipend for a public address about pro-life issues. Frankly, you couldn't pay me enough money to work in the mainstream media market. Mainstream fans are scary and abusive. They treat mainstream musicians like they are peices of human flesh that have no other purpose than to entertain them. Its a very usaristic, utilitarian and insensitive way to treat people. Entertainers are no more than a useful product. On the production side, you're basically a slave to someone else's vision. I'd say 98% of mainstream musicians have to play music chosen by somebody else. You have to be really rich or really lucky to realize your dreams in the mainstream. Underground music (like Catholic and Pro-Life music) is much more personal. Because you and your audience have some particular and important value in common, the relationship becomes much more respectful and genuine. There is no real money in this work. When you consider that reality while you are listening to a GOOD Catholic band, you begin to understand how thoughtful these folks are to care enough about you and the cause you share. They aren't there just to tickle your ear and walk away with your wallet. They want to help you identify more with the cause you all share and find value in the sacrifices you all make together to bring more good into this world. From the Catholic musicians point of view, the fans are so much more caring and appreciative than what one would find in the mainstream. Its not about money or utility with them; its about fellowship and filial love. When you buy a CD from a good Catholic/Pro-Life band, your not just supporting an art -- you're supporting a culture of true value. Value that this world seems to have pushed aside for cheap and shallow thrills, but is desperate for when the lights stop flashing and the noise dies down. And though this music can never compete with the mainstream in terms of number of radio stations or performances at expensive venues, we can have at least one radio station that becomes an important part of people's lives and helps keep them on the right track. That's the dream, at any rate. One many of the Fundamentalist Christian bands have realized in the last few years. I say our turn is next! Edited August 11, 2007 by abercius24
Totus Tuus Posted August 11, 2007 Author Posted August 11, 2007 [quote name='Didymus' post='1354050' date='Aug 9 2007, 02:43 PM']too many times, even Catholics see buying the pro-life artist's cds as an act of philanthropism, since they'll probably just sit on the shelf and never be listened to. thus the tiny industry behind it doesn't feel compelled to change, since some music has been sold. I've done it too many times, buying a cd because the artist/band was Catholic/Christian/pro-life and I have quite a few of them that I don't listen to because I'd rather smash my face through the drywall in my room before I honestly find it entertaining...[/quote] I'm with you on this. I don't waste my money on music I'm not going to listen to (unless it's a gift for someone I KNOW will like it). To me the bottom line is that there is SO MUCH good music out there that isn't supporting Planned Parenthood actively. I am particularly amazed with the turn-around in CCM bands in the last few years. Not only am I totally uplifted by it, but the music is just as high - if not higher- quality than the billionaire bands on secular stations. The voices are actually GOOD, the instrumentals are on par or better than secular, and I don't have to worry about being scandalized, brought down, confused, etc.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now