Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Any Suggestions For My Senior In Hs


Recommended Posts

Posted

And doesn't believe ANY religion is right! She was raised Catholic, attends a Catholic HS, but has always been a)really logical b)really independent c)really unable to trust


I am praying for her, trying to not 'nag' or 'lecture'. The other day we briefly got into it when I asked her to pray for her brother and she announced the above, to which I replied, ' oh, c'mon, secular humanism IS a 'religion' !!! Man is the god of that religion!!! It is the worship of self!!!"


ooops......

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Is she a very intellectual person or is this likely something she picked up from friends at school?

My thought is that she might not have made the effort to "own" this pseudo-religion yet. If she picked it up from friends, it may be a thing that, in a few years (and with many prayers), she realizes is goofy and leaves behind. If she's a very intellectual person, she may try to make it her own very quickly, but might also be open to reading opposing texts (and if she's not open to that, then she doesn't really believe in it, I'd dare to say).

Anyway, I'm not a philosopher, so I'll leave that to others.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

The Pope talked about this the other day:

[quote]“Without God, man loses his greatness; without God, there is no true humanism”.

With these words, Pope Benedict XVI today recalled the great legacy of another early Church father, Saint Gregory of Nazianze, theologian, preacher and poet from fourth-century Cappadocia.

A friend and admirer of St. Basil, whom the Holy Father remembered last week, St. Gregory was inspired to seek Baptism and to enter monastic life, devoting himself to prayer, solitude, and meditation.

The Pope recalled how St. Gregory “loved to leave behind the things of this world and enter into intimate communion with God, so that the depths of his soul became like a mirror reflecting the divine light”.

“Here was a man who sensed the primacy of God and so speaks to us today, to this world of ours”, the Pope said. “Without God, man loses his greatness; without God, there is no true humanism. That’s why we listen to this voice and also try to come to know the face of God”.

[url="http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=10068"]http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=10068[/url][/quote]

IrishSalesian
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1353726' date='Aug 9 2007, 10:01 AM']And doesn't believe ANY religion is right! She was raised Catholic, attends a Catholic HS, but has always been a)really logical b)really independent c)really unable to trust
I am praying for her, trying to not 'nag' or 'lecture'. The other day we briefly got into it when I asked her to pray for her brother and she announced the above, to which I replied, ' oh, c'mon, secular humanism IS a 'religion' !!! Man is the god of that religion!!! It is the worship of self!!!"
ooops......[/quote]
Pray for her. Try and talk to her and ask why she feels that Catholocism is the Religion of Self. Invite a priest over for dinner or something so he can talk to her. Maybe...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1353737' date='Aug 9 2007, 08:11 AM']The Pope talked about this the other day:[/quote]
I love the pope.

As St. Augustine said, "Our hearts were made for you, O Lord, and they are restless until they rest in you."

From the little philosophy I do know, I know that secular humanism doesn't disprove God, it just ignores Him. A bunch of philosophers sat around and said, "so, what if we could just cut God out of the picture and do what we want to do?" and then built a philosophy around it. The answer to secular humanism is to show the greatness, beauty, and fulfillment found in a true Christian understanding of humanity.

"The Problem of God" is a good introductory text that touches on this.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

My advice may seem strange, but my days of exploring other faiths and declaring myself a follower of this, that, and the other are still close enough for me to remember how I was thinking and feeling back then.

I always had a passion for truth. It sounds to me as if your daughter is the same. If she is labelling herself a secular humanist, it is likely that she is especially concerned about issues of social justice. My friend E (farglefeezlebut on Phatmass) often remarks that the Church's own social teaching is the world's best-kept secret - and it must be, as it was years before I even began to discover it. Being in a Catholic family and attending a Catholic high school may not be enough for your daughter to see it for what it is.

It would be a good idea to have literature on Catholic social justice about your home - pamphlets from CAFOD, for example, and more substantial books. I recently read an absolutely marvellous book called [i]Left to Tell[/i] by Immaculee Illibigaza. It is the autobiography of a young Catholic college student who survived the Rwandan genocide, in which one million Tutsis perished (including her own family). In the book she talks about how she was able to forgive the murderers even while they were tearing the house apart in search for her hiding-place, her visions of Jesus and the Holy Mother, the days she spent praying in a starving and dehydrated stupor, and her final journey to her village after the war was over to give the killers (now in prison) her forgiveness. That book has nourished my faith in ways I can't even describe. It is pure, unadulterated Catholicism. Perhaps your daughter might benefit from it.

But don't push her to read anything. Let her explore things on her own. She will come home. Apart from this, entrust her to the Immaculate Heart every day and make sure that you have a green scapular in her home. :)

Posted

I decided I was a libertarian in HS but I didn't know what it was. I just knew it was more Constitutional than the other parties... So like Raphael says, it may or may not be that ingrained into her yet :)

Posted

You all are so wonderful!

BTW, SHE does not think Catholicism a religion of self, I said Secular Humanism is actually 'a religion' where man is worshipped--a religion where self is god.

thank you all for your suggestions. She is indeed very intellectual (to a fault). I believe you hit the nail on the head when you said the bit about the social justice---she claims 'religion' has destroyed people, property and civilizations....etc etc., which is exactly what you are saying, she sees the hypocrisy, not the truth. It is, perhaps, a maturational issue.

It is so hard as a parent to see your child reject (even if only in name) the things you hold most dear. I would say this is an extension of a teenage rebellion (she also became a vegetarian years ago, and you guessed it, my hubby has a beautiful white tail hanging on the wall).


Some kids this age really look for and shoot for the Achille's heel of their parents! I think the less I make of it the better.


OK, so what is everyone's opinion of us making her attend Mass each week (mostly with us, but on her own when she crams in work schedules Sat night and Sun morning, then only has the 4pm Mass available)....

Posted

What does she like to read? Screwtape Letters is excellent, as is everything CS Lewis. The pilgrim's regress addresses this great.

If she needs a simple, straightforward read, suggest Rome Sweet Home by Scott Hahn.

The easiest way to help her on her journey is to reach her where she is with all of the basic arguments against what she believes. There is a lot of teen-based intellectual reading that you can leave on her bed for her to find and read at night.

Don't forget, mother's prayers are very efficient too! What a great way to help yourself become a saint!

Posted

thanks, prose! she is overwhelmed with reading for AP Eng and other overwhelming classes, but I do work hard at dropping little tidbits now and then. She is such a great kid, great heart, kind, loving but so sure of herself, perhaps her path in life will hold some challenges that she will have to face.

Posted

keep praying ,dont give up hope. Don't preach, but lead by example. I dont know her, but as a teenager my self, it could just be a phase.

Posted

curtins, that is probably the case, and really, I would rather have her questioning out loud than faking it and being indifferent.

See, that is why it is SO GREAT that teenagers here can give us old moms some perspective. I mean, if phatmass was a bunch of old moms chatting, we would all work ourselves up into a froth over stuff like this. I am probably NOT the typical demographic for these phorums, but it is SO AWESOME to have such cool young people to jar my memory about adolescence. Will you guys be there when my first baby goes to college next year? I am sure to wig out about that, too!! :sadder:

Posted

You guys DO know I have THREE in high school this year, right? A senior, (the one talked about above) a sophomore and my autistic-spectrum freshman.....

guess whose house looks like a dumpster this summer!!??

IrishSalesian
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1355077' date='Aug 10 2007, 11:20 AM']You guys DO know I have THREE in high school this year, right? A senior, (the one talked about above) a sophomore and my autistic-spectrum freshman.....

guess whose house looks like a dumpster this summer!!??[/quote]


2 years ago my family had 5 in high school at the same time.

Me, Senior
My Brother Tim, Junior
My Brother Ant, step sister Ellen, Sophomores
My Brother Greg, Freshman

Posted

WOW your mom must be VERY VERY clever!!! Any tips on survival???

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1354461' date='Aug 10 2007, 02:31 AM']Don't forget, mother's prayers are very efficient too! What a great way to help yourself become a saint![/quote]

I was going to mention that. I love St. Monica, personally. :)

Posted

I wear a St Monica medal !!! She is my favorite saint!!

Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1354468' date='Aug 9 2007, 08:41 PM']thanks, prose! she is overwhelmed with reading for AP Eng and other overwhelming classes, but I do work hard at dropping little tidbits now and then. She is such a great kid, great heart, kind, loving but so sure of herself, perhaps her path in life will hold some challenges that she will have to face.[/quote]


the problem with your initial riposte (not that I disagree with the conclusion) is that it is a conclusion . . . in another context I recently read something about the Eucharist and the community - with the author asking something along the lines of how can the community be both the source and the beneficiary of the graces flowing from the Eucharist . . . a secular humanist has somewhat the same issue - where does the impulse to benefit others come from if the primary human impulse is self-preservation - or going back to the very beginning, how does life spring into being from the inanimate . . .


if overwhelmed with reading for classes, etc . . . leaving books lying around to be "discovered" may be too much to ask . . . but is always a possibility . . . even when I was younger, reading was a primary form of relaxation, even from reading (reading for school - that was "work" -- reading something I picked, that was "fun")

another might be to find shorter articles on topics you know or think will grab her attention (in diocesan newsletter/magazine or in the Phatmass reference library or other websites - or even in your local newspaper) and ask her some leading questions about them . . . questions that should lead to the thought that the Church is "not" what she thought it is . . . questions to which you might already know the answers, but in answering the question for you, she will learn what you know

If she is intensely logical, you could show her Pascal's wager and ask her to explain the underlying logic (take notes, and share) . . . while I read that it doesn't fly as well in a polytheistic world, it was a solid argument when the choice was God/No God . . .

God the Father
Posted

There are people who call themselves secular humanists at my school too.

They aren't very popular :mellow:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...