CoffeeCatholic Posted August 11, 2007 Posted August 11, 2007 Hey All- As you may have heard, I'm back in the Pham full swing since I moved out to Denver. Having a few friendly faces (even if they're just internet faces) has been really helpful in my move. I'm hoping you guys can help me figure out this dilemma because I'm really at a lose. On one hand, I loved the traditionalism of the Arlington Diocese, where i converted and spent the first 3 years of my Catholic life, and censors make me feel right at home. On the other hand, I know God in His wisdom had the Bishops create Parishes for a reason, whether it's to promote neighborhood communities or in order to have an even dispersal of hard core traditionalists with new agers in order to promote the truth from both sides and weed out the irregularities associated with both, or for some other reason. I cringed at mass on Sunday at St. Vincent's when 8 Extraordinary Ministers presented themselves at the altar to help dispense the Eucharist in both species to about 200 people, and when the announcements were read BEFORE the closing prayer and blessing (including some jokes read by the Priest), and I kept having to rub my eyes to make sure i wasn't seeing things when 2 little girls were assisting at the mass alongside a boy altar server (there's nothing wrong inherently with female altar servers, i'm just not used to it, and I prefer all male for promotion of vocations, and, if necessary to have females, then 1 gender at a time, no mixed masses, because we all know that Teens have enough trouble without us adding to it in church). Also, my boyfriend, Joey, who moved out here at the same time as me (different houses) grew up in another parish nearby- Risen Christ. But when i was here at Christmas, I had a horrible experience there, although i KNOW that they are getting better (they have perpetual adoration!). also, there are a whole lot of other parishes here to "pick" from, something i'm definitely not used to coming from a small town. I could go to any number of them, even a Society of St. Peter mass in Littleton, if i wanted to keep "shopping". All in all, moving is tough- help me figure this part out.
Moneybags Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I chose the 2nd Choice. Personally, I would keep looking until I found a parish that offered the Tridentine Latin Mass.
jiyoung Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I was going to ask, since you were in Denver, if you knew about the OMV-staffed church--and then I saw "Holy Ghost." I drive a little farther in order to go to a parish they staff out here in Cali--I'm in the Orange diocese and live on the border of the LA archdiocese--I don't have so many choices if I want to have a good liturgy. I trust the OMVs--they're awesome. Also, you've gotten one of our priests, Fr. Jeremy Paulin He's awesome--he worked with the youth group and I was on core team for a year before I left for school. So yeah...I say go to Holy Ghost.
goldenchild17 Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 (edited) There's a really nice FSSP parish up there that I went to periodically before my full conversion: [url="http://www.archden.org/parishes/parish.php?p=110"]http://www.archden.org/parishes/parish.php?p=110[/url] And also an amazing parish that I go to whenever I can get someone to go with me up to Denver, but don't suspect anybody here would care for the link But your best bet would be the FSSP parish. It's good, for what it is. At least the last time I was there. Edited August 12, 2007 by goldenchild17
T-Bone _ Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 #2 Sounds the best I wish I could actually vote...
homeschoolmom Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I, personally, am in favor of #1 unless there are massive abuses going on so as to make it not Catholic anymore (and altar girls is not one of those kinds of things). Work from within to better that parish.
Totus Tuus Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 Erm... this isn't something I can vote on. I think you really need to pray about it and discern what you think God's will is for YOU. I just don't feel right submitting my vote. I hope it works out well!
kateri05 Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 you know, i voted two, but hsmom's wisdom is making me wonder... what sort of "funny" things are going on? lol, because yea, girl altar servers don't count
Deus te Amat Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 i dont want to vote either... in which parish do you think that you'd contribute the most as a Catholic? which do you think God is calling you to do the most good? my parish does announcements before the blessing, because, unfortunately, we dont want anyone slipping away beforehand....after the blessing
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1357002' date='Aug 11 2007, 11:52 PM']I, personally, am in favor of #1 unless there are massive abuses going on so as to make it not Catholic anymore (and altar girls is not one of those kinds of things). Work from within to better that parish.[/quote] I voted number 2 because when I read "funny things" I read it as "serious abuses." But if they aren't serious abuses then I totally agree with HSMom. If those things aren't detrimental to your soul and spiritual life I would go to the closer parish and work on getting rid of the "funny things" as much as I could.
CatholicCid Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 (edited) I voted #2. And I would disagree with the idea to stick around at #1 and try to help approve things if the "funny things" are not serious abuses. I suppose it depends on just what they are. "Funny things" to me would be like music that I may not like or like you said female altar servers. These items are not liturgical abuses, but basically come down to personal preference. In this case, if willing to make the drive, I would go with my own personal preference for whichever Mass I feel helps me to grow closer to God and where God might be calling me. And if you have the luxury to choose, I would go for #2 then. Edited August 12, 2007 by CatholicCid
jiyoung Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 Yeah...at the risk of sounding selfish, I decided to switch churches because the place I was wasn't really feeding me spiritually, and I had exhausted all my resources to try to effect any sort of change. It had been really draining me and I needed to be fed spiritually at this stage in my life. If it's a place where you can be fed spiritually as well as contribute, then I say go with number one as long as the "funny stuff" isn't serious abuse but stuff like bad music or little things like that. But if it's serious abuse, or it's detrimental to your spiritual life, I would say not to go there...for myself, as a young person who wasn't really taken seriously by the almighty parish council (yes, another corruption at my old church), and who needed more than what my family's parish had to offer, I chose to go to a church with frequent daily Masses and confessions as well as perpetual adoration. Maybe someday I might go back to my old church but I've become a part of the community at my church and am able to do more there than I could have at KMCC, my old church. Back at KMCC I was ridiculed for my devotion, seen as "holier-than-thou" when all I was doing was trying to find a way to become holy. I think I did try as much as I could before giving up and resigning myself to the fact that the most effective thing I could do for them would be to pray. So I agree that a poll shouldn't decide this for you. You should use your own discretion and take the good advice that people above me have given you. But I can also put in a good word for the order that runs the church you're thinking about--they're pretty much awesome, very orthodox and holy men, and I trust any church they staff.
Anomaly Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 The next logical choice is the one I made. If none of the parishes are 'funny' free, why go? If the Bishop allows it in X parish, it's only a matter of time before it's accepted in W, Y, Z and A parish. They'll just bring you down with them.
chelsea Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 As far as announcements before the final blessing, we used to do that. I think it is actually pretty common. Then one day one of our teens from lifeteen asked our priest if we could do it before mass, and he said sure. so now its always before mass. sometimes you just have to ask. I voted to number 2 because it seems like you like it. There are about 3 churches that are very close to my house, but i choose to travel farther away because i love the church that I am at. It is my home, and i love it. Dont go where you arent going to grow in holiness. that is silly.
journeyman Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I'm with HSMom and Totus Tuus on this one - a parish community (at least as the Church has traditionally [lttle t] set them up) is a geographical sub-community of the larger faith community I attend my home parish half the time, and a parish close to my parents the other half (I have a couple of choices when I'm over there, but the one with Mass offered at a time that doesn't conflict with my parents somewhat settled schedules is the one I attend) Not my will, but thine be done “speak, Lord, your servant is listening”
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 12, 2007 Author Posted August 12, 2007 Wow, mass this morning at Holy Ghost was beautiful! Full Latin Chant Choir and everything. I agree with HSmom on principality (work from within) except that it's not my job as a parishioner to change or fix the liturgy- that's how things get funny in the first place. However, I do believe in the community aspect of a parish church, and coming from a small community I see how valuable that can be. But moving to a large city, is that just a larger community, or should we strive for small and intimate communities within the larger one? As for the Fraternity of St. Peter parish in Littleton, I've thought about it, but while the Tridentine mass is beautiful (when done correctly) the Novus Ordo can be JUST as beautiful (when done correctly) because JESUS is there. And, honestly, I feel it is appropriate to attend a Novus Ordo mass as a practice, because God gave us this Mass for a reason. I have a strong desire for the Catholic church (specifically the American Church) to learn to participate in a beautiful Novus Ordo so that there is no need for a devout Catholic to feel cornered into a Tridentine when the "funny" things in parishes are all around. But what FSSP is doing is wonderful! Just not for me. (Plus, it's quite a ways away) I don't think i will go to Risen Christ- After Christmas I just feel uncomfortable there (that's a long story, including the Priest adding things to the Eucharistic prayer). But they do have Perpetual Adoration, so i think I will sign up for an hour so that i can better pray for their parish. St. Vincent's is right up the street, so I think i will try to attend daily mass there when possible, and attend Sunday mass at Holy Ghost. That way I'm able to take part in each parish, while primarily taking care for my own soul. What do you guys think about that? Oh, and the whole announcements before the final blessing thing? Yeah, that just annoys the carp out of me! Why can't you wait 10 seconds, we'll get our blessing, just keep the people standing, announce away, and then do the send off! That would be totally legit!
jiyoung Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1357239' date='Aug 12 2007, 07:52 AM']How is a parish council a corruption?[/quote] It wasn't the parish council itself but the sheer power it held--the way my old church worked was that you had to go through them in order to get anything done, and there's a lot of pomp and fanfare for people in those positions and stuff. It was like having one of those "pastoral life coordinators" who organized absolutely everything and didn't let the priest do very much, except with multiple people. It was the fact that they didn't even ask Father about certain things that got to me--I would understand if they had been given these responsibilities, since it's quite a job to manage a big parish alone, but that does mean the priest has an active role, which he didn't. I've heard though that it's been getting a little better lately, at least in the youth group, but it's still got a long way to come. The other thing is that an understanding of Korean culture is necessary to understand why my old church is how it is--power is something to show off, and while driving a BMW to church (and only to church--to show off, that's all) will do the job, that in addition to having a big important position will add to your impressiveness. Also, as a teenager at the time my opinion was completely disregarded as the folly of youth or something. And yes, I was young at the time, but that's still no excuse for brushing someone off so abruptly. I admit I'm still a little bitter about my experiences there, so it does color my perception of the place, but I'm definitely not the only person to have left--it's a really strange community and I prefer not to have to deal with the peculiarities of Korean culture combined with a church setting, which can be really distracting. [/end hijack]
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1357431' date='Aug 12 2007, 04:23 PM']I don't think i will go to Risen Christ- After Christmas I just feel uncomfortable there (that's a long story, including the Priest adding things to the Eucharistic prayer). But they do have Perpetual Adoration, so i think I will sign up for an hour so that i can better pray for their parish. St. Vincent's is right up the street, so I think i will try to attend daily mass there when possible, and attend Sunday mass at Holy Ghost. That way I'm able to take part in each parish, while primarily taking care for my own soul. What do you guys think about that?[/quote] Sounds like you've got it all figured out. lol
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 13, 2007 Author Posted August 13, 2007 I went to Holy Ghost on Sunday and it was Beautiful! I'm going to keep options open, not sending in my membership card any time soon, but I think that's where i'm going
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now