XIX Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 Maybe it's just me, but it seems like there is a lot of criticism, anger, side-taking, and division going on at the phorum. People can't take three steps around here without having someone correct them, and sometimes it's a rather angry discussion that follows. Chuck Norris, sigs, politics, relationships, the lame board, the Charismatic movement, and prayer requests. These seven things have the following in common: 1) Someone brings it up, and two or more people disagree with each other over it 2) People takes sides 3) Serious debate breaks out 4) Sometime during steps 1-3, someone gets angry at someone else and starts tossing inordinately angry comments at others 5) These "debates" are essentially exclusive to practicing, devoted Catholics. 6) They also may cause a person to announce that they will leave Phatmass. 7) XIX involved with each of these, and probably contributing to the carnage to a certain extent. I mention that last part not because I am trying to convince you that I am humble or that I am not judging anyone--though truth be told, I have no intention to cast stones. However, I very easily slip into the temptations that I am attempting to discuss. Ergo, I imagine it is similar for other people. I think the problem is that the internet gives us a wall of false security that you don't find in person or even over the phone. It somehow leads to incredible blowups. You can pretty much say whatever you want to and you never really have to confront the consequences like you would if you if you had to see that person at school or work the next day, or next month, or right now for that matter. On the internet, you scarcely have to worry about the consequences. You don't even have to pay attention to the people you may be confronting, if you really don't want to. You can completely disconnect yourself at will. I'm not say it's that bad on phatmass, but it does seem to be symptomatic of the internet in general. Case in point: there was a discussion on Yahoo answers in the hockey section. Person A mentions wikipedia.com and another Person B mentions that it's wikipedia.org, not wikipedia.com. This promts Person A to go on a tirade for a whole paragraph. Insults, name calling, baseless accusations, you name it. It was a little funny, and a little sad. This guy was going off over a simple correction. Could you imagine that ever happening in real life--anywhere? I don't think I have ever seen someone just sit there and go nuts, or even care that much over anything that silly. Okay, I'm sure it happens once in a while, but not nearly as often as it does online. If someone ever flipped out that badly on me, I would walk away significantly disturbed. I'd either laugh hilariously at the person after it was over, or I'd burst into a fit of tears. He was able to do his monologue un-interrupted, and he had no problem with it because he will never have to confront the damage he caused--not in this world anyway. I see these incredible temper tantrums regularly over the internet, and almost never in the real world. Fortunatly, I don't see anything that bad happening on Phatmass; however, I do see a lot of tension on this phorum that goes considerably above and beyond anything I ever see at an Adoration group or a Bible study. Of course, a lot of this may or may not be explainable just by my own perception. It is true that it's easy to get signals mixed up over the internet. Ergo, there maybe be no tension at all where I think I see it. So maybe it really is just me. But what I perceive is people getting upset over things that should never divide Catholics. People getting way too emotional over a Chuck Norris debate, for example. I mean, most people have handled themselves well over the Chuck Norris thing. But it's becoming rather difficult to even mention a topic like that without wondering if someone will bite your head off over it. Same with sigs, speaking in tongues, etc. Some of the other issues I mentioned at the beginning are obviously more important than Chuck Norris jokes. And yes, some of the backlash against others is warranted--particularly when fellow Catholics or separated bretheren defy Catholic teaching. But most of the backlash is not warranted--even when people defy Catholic teaching, we are called to exercise prudence and Christian charity. One thing I do know is that most of the innward and outward whining on my end has not been warranted. It would be nice if I was the only one, but I bet I'm not. All I am saying is, we should be mindful of what we say. As a general rule of thumb, don't write anything you wouldn't say to another's face, and you should be okay. That said, people may get upset with you anyway. So it is worth mentioning that it's wise to give people the benefit of the doubt. [color="#0000FF"][b]This is not directed at any one person. If it sounds like I am only talking about you, I am not. I promise.[/b][/color] Unity is vitally important, especially within the Church. St. Paul wanted the Church to be united--he complained about all of the different factions that were forming within the Church. Jesus said that a house divided against itself can never stand. Popes have echoed this sentiment. So did the Council of Nicea: We believe in one holy catholic apostolic church. Hence, some things are just not worth getting upset over. Why? Because you risk tearing down the unity among Catholics for the sake of merely proving a point. If it's a vitally important point, like wearing modest clothes or going to Sunday Mass, then you'll probably have to risk getting someone mad at you. If not, then at some point you have to drop it. But hey, this is just the internet and it's quite possible that I have just misinterpreted the goings on at Phatmass. So really, maybe it is just me.
Noel's angel Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 (edited) It is easy for things to get blown out of proportion on the internet. I think a lot has to do with the fact that often it's not what we say but how we say it that determines what we really mean. For example, I could say the same thing, once in a serious tone and the second time I would say it in a more light-hearted way. But on the internet, you can't really tell these things sometimes. So it's easy to misinterpret and have a go at someone, unjustly. Secondly, humans will be humans. People disagree every minute of the day and it's forgotten about. But here, everything is in black and white, and it's easy to get caught up in the heat of the moment. For the most part, I think Phatmass has few faults. People are generally considerate and kind to each other. There is a real sense of 'phamily' here. If someone is in trouble-generally, people will pray whole-heartedly for them. There are times when people fall out, cliques are formed and other people feel very left out. But I think it goes in cycles really. People have their 'secret jokes', but they pass. I think, as long as we remember that there are people looking at what we type, and it's not just us typing to our computer, things would be better. No one is innocent of all of the things you have mentioned, so I think we can all see where you're coming from. I forgot to mention this as well. A lot of people come on to this phorum because it's the only place they feel they can speak and be heard. Everyone here is carrying their own burdens and it's easy to allow them to spill over and affect how people relate to others. In 'real life' we know when our friends are hurting, we know when something bad has happened to them, but we don't know everyone's 'story' here. There could be a reason behind anger, bitterness etc. that has nothing to do with the people it's directed at. I think... Edited August 12, 2007 by Noel's angel
Sojourner Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I think we tend to go in cycles here. There are definitely times when we are more on edge than other times, and it's always good to have a reminder to take care with what we say and how we phrase things. I think you are right that we can tend to forget there are people on the other ends of the words we post. I know sometimes we don't think enough about how what we write will be interpreted, and we don't really try too hard to be charitable. (When I say "we" I really mean "me"). I think by and large, though, we enjoy one another and are pretty good about admitting when we're wrong and moving on.
journeyman Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I read a couple of the Norris posts - couldn't figure out what it was about, obviously I was absent the day or days it was "the" topic of the day - and have resolved to ignore it as a non-issue thread topic . . . now if the header suggests that Norris announces conversion to Catholic Church and enters seminary . . . I might read that one . . .
journeyman Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I think that qualifies as side-stepping, rather than side-taking
Sojourner Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 [quote name='journeyman' post='1357511' date='Aug 12 2007, 05:14 PM']I think that qualifies as side-stepping, rather than side-taking[/quote] you ARE a lawyer! haha
journeyman Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1357516' date='Aug 12 2007, 05:16 PM']you ARE a lawyer! haha[/quote] I'd prefer a voice of moderation or a force for reconciliation . . . but alas, I am stuck with the certifications and licenses I already possess I had noticed that your lovely avatar had acquired a sidekick . . . and you stated at some point that you were one of the first . . . but figuring out the hows and whys you spearheaded an insurrection just didn't engage the synapses . . .
Ash Wednesday Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I always feel the board gets particularly cranky during Lent.
Norseman82 Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1357508' date='Aug 12 2007, 06:11 PM']I think we tend to go in cycles here.[/quote] That reminds me of the line Clemenza said in "The Godfather" (no, not the cannoli line) regarding how the gang wars are necessary every so often to "clear out the bad blood".
alicemary Posted August 12, 2007 Posted August 12, 2007 I really don't post much anymore because of the nasty comments made by certain members of the phorum. I usually post on Vocation Station, but it has become unbearable with the snide nastiness over there. I try to be a voice of moderation and people just don't like that. A few ruin it for the majority.
God the Father Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1357485' date='Aug 12 2007, 05:51 PM']criticism, anger, side-taking,[/quote] Criticism, anger, and side-taking on this board amounts to casual conversation at many places on the internet, and heck, in real life. I don't think you guys have anything to worry about.
Sojourner Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='journeyman' post='1357528' date='Aug 12 2007, 05:26 PM']I'd prefer a voice of moderation or a force for reconciliation . . . but alas, I am stuck with the certifications and licenses I already possess I had noticed that your lovely avatar had acquired a sidekick . . . and you stated at some point that you were one of the first . . . but figuring out the hows and whys you spearheaded an insurrection just didn't engage the synapses . . .[/quote] yeah it's a dUSt joke I and others said Chuck is a chump; dUSt warned us not to say such things, I kept it up, and got roundhouse kicked. It's kinda fun having a different group icon. There are restrictions ... can't edit, can't do searches, can't play games, can't send personal messages. No biggie.
XIX Posted August 13, 2007 Author Posted August 13, 2007 And I sold out and gave Chuck Norris respect to get the icon off.
Sojourner Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1357575' date='Aug 12 2007, 07:21 PM']And I sold out and gave Chuck Norris respect to get the icon off. [/quote] I hold no hate for you. You gotta do what you gotta do.
XIX Posted August 13, 2007 Author Posted August 13, 2007 I should diss Chuck just to make sure I don't go back into the arcade room.
Sojourner Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1357585' date='Aug 12 2007, 07:36 PM']I should diss Chuck just to make sure I don't go back into the arcade room. [/quote] Oddly, there are arcade games elsewhere on the net. Not that I've been looking. Just sayin'.
goldenchild17 Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 (edited) I really don't mind all these things going on. I'm actually waiting to be "kicked" and sort of looking forward to it too, seeing as I don't have private message abilities anyways. I don't see that being more than a temporary thing. Just a phase dUST is going through I'm sure . The only thing that has ever bothered me, and still does, about the rules is the ban on "rad-trad" discussions. Well, the sig thing is a little wierd too. Either keep them or get rid of them, I don't think more than a handful of people would ever bother to highlight an invisible sig just to see what it says. The first bothers me far more than the second, seeing as we have all manner of fundi discussions and other odd bashing discussions. It bothers me more than probably anything that's ever happened on any forum I've ever been a part of, but we need to realize that this is dUST's forum and if you don't like it, then why be here. If he wants our input he'll ask for it, and from past experience it seems that he does exactly that. Edited August 13, 2007 by goldenchild17
XIX Posted August 13, 2007 Author Posted August 13, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1357589' date='Aug 12 2007, 07:38 PM']Oddly, there are arcade games elsewhere on the net. Not that I've been looking. Just sayin'. [/quote] I think I must have overlooked all of them.
jeffpugh Posted August 14, 2007 Posted August 14, 2007 (edited) Yeah, I've totally noticed the tension around here. It seems to be escalating as of late. I admit, I've been a part of the problem in the past, but we should all work to be a voice of charity... On a less serious note, we should use emoticons more often. Helps us with interpreting words a lot better [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1357589' date='Aug 12 2007, 08:38 PM']Oddly, there are arcade games elsewhere on the net. Not that I've been looking. Just sayin'. [/quote] [spoiler]*cough*motherofallpeoplewebsite cough*[/spoiler] Edited August 14, 2007 by Sacred Music Man
Ora et Labora Posted August 14, 2007 Posted August 14, 2007 [quote name='alicemary' post='1357545' date='Aug 12 2007, 07:05 PM']I really don't post much anymore because of the nasty comments made by certain members of the phorum. I usually post on Vocation Station, but it has become unbearable with the snide nastiness over there. I try to be a voice of moderation and people just don't like that. A few ruin it for the majority.[/quote] I've always liked your advise very much.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now