Dave Posted August 13, 2007 Posted August 13, 2007 Even if the SSPX isn't schismatic, as Cardinal Hoyos allegedly said, it's nevertheless true that SSPX priests are suspended. Isn't it true that in the case of priests who are suspended for ANY reason (even if not excommunicated or schismatic), their Masses are illicit and thus must be avoided? I always thought it was.
Groo the Wanderer Posted August 14, 2007 Posted August 14, 2007 IF they were properly ordained priests to begin with and IF they have not been formally laicized, then they are still priests. As such, while they should not be serving priestly functions, such as the consecration, the Mass is still valid inasmuch as the consecration is valid (all proper forms followed). Goota remember that God is not limited by the deficiencies of the priest. I guess the logical question to follow is 'why would you go to an SSPX Mass anyway to make this question come up?
Dave Posted August 14, 2007 Author Posted August 14, 2007 No no no no no ... you totally misunderstood my question! The question isn't whether or not the Mass is valid. I know it's valid! The question is whether or not a Mass celebrated by a suspended priest is ILLICIT.
Resurrexi Posted August 14, 2007 Posted August 14, 2007 [quote name='Dave' post='1358748' date='Aug 14 2007, 01:26 PM']No no no no no ... you totally misunderstood my question! The question isn't whether or not the Mass is valid. I know it's valid! The question is whether or not a Mass celebrated by a suspended priest is ILLICIT.[/quote] probably. I have a question, though. Is being suspended the same as being defrocked?
Aloysius Posted August 14, 2007 Posted August 14, 2007 no, not the same. defrocked is more severe, I believe, and I think goes with laication. suspended means they are not to exercise their priestly functions, though they are not laicized. I may be wrong now that I think about it,,, but I always thought of defrocked as going hand in hand with laization. illicit simply means contrary to the law. your question is self-explanatory; if they are suspended according to canon law, then it is illicit for them to exercise their priestly functions because the law forbids it. simple as that.
beatty07 Posted August 15, 2007 Posted August 15, 2007 Yes, the Mass is illicit if the priest is under suspension [i]of his faculties to say Mass[/i]. "Suspension" is a penalty only for clerics, treated in Canon 1333 and 1334. The term 'suspension' is too vague to answer your question, because there are different kinds of suspension. For example, a priest could be under suspension of his governing office as pastor, but not his faculties to say Mass. If someone is in danger of death, the suspension does not apply and the priest can and must provide the appropriate Sacraments. "Defrocking," so far as I can tell, is a term popular mainly in the secular media. It would seem to match Canon 290 par. 2, "a penalty of dismissal [from the clerical state] legitimately imposed." This doesn't happen often. The Church is extremely cautious about the potential for abuse, and the result is a complicated legal and appeals process. "Laicization" would seem to match C. 290 par. 3, which allows the Apostolic See (that's the Pope and his Curia) to release a cleric from the clerical state at the cleric's own request, "to deacons only for grave causes and to presbyters only for most grave causes." This was interpreted rather generously for awhile after the Council when all those priests were leaving and marrying nuns. Today it is granted more sparingly for various pastoral reasons. So "suspension," "defrocking," and "laicization" are three very distinct things. And we should be careful with those last two terms... I think a lot of people use them in a confused and misleading way.
T-Bone _ Posted August 16, 2007 Posted August 16, 2007 If a priests faculties to say Mass are "suspended", can he still have a private Masses?
adt6247 Posted August 17, 2007 Posted August 17, 2007 [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1360052' date='Aug 16 2007, 11:34 AM']If a priests faculties to say Mass are "suspended", can he still have a private Masses?[/quote] Nope -- not legally. If his faculties are suspended, any use of them is illicit. The Eucharist consecrated in such a mass would still be valid, but the mass itself is illicit.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now