Noel's angel Posted September 2, 2007 Author Posted September 2, 2007 (edited) The thing is, I think it's better to sing solid hymns, not hymns where people are thinking 'well, I think it's okay to sing that'. Edited September 2, 2007 by Noel's angel
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 2, 2007 Posted September 2, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1376308' date='Sep 2 2007, 01:45 PM']The thing is, I think it's better to sing solid hymns, not hymns where people are thinking 'well, I think it's okay to sing that'.[/quote] Point taken.
Totus Tuus Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1376288' date='Sep 2 2007, 12:40 PM']the psalms, which are the quintessential hymns of the Church, very often have parts where God is speaking to His people. I think sacred music is fine in doing that, but I'd rather the choir sing such a song while the congregation hears and meditates on it...that way the congregation is still hearing the words of God to them.[/quote] That is a really good point.
uruviel Posted September 5, 2007 Posted September 5, 2007 I've seen various types of protestant hymns before in Catholic Church's. Some are completely contradictory, and some are just flat out protestant. I try to ignore them, obviously I don't sing along with them and I try to tell Jesus sorry for having that hymn in there. Most of the time I can tone the words out. But singing during Mass as a way of adoration is wonderful, I don't believe that's questionable at all. As long as you aren't too distracted with your singing.
jeffpugh Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 Well, being my parish choir, I can tell you it is work. There is a degree of concentration it takes to sing, but also keep in mind, though you must concentrate on Jesus, there must be a level of consciousness focused on singing. Besides, real sacred music counts as prayer as well. Be mindful of that.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 Augustine called singing 'praying twice'.
Noel's angel Posted September 6, 2007 Author Posted September 6, 2007 I don't think he meant tree-hugger's hymns...Praying something like 'The Lord of the Dance' twice is two times too many imo
farglefeezlebut Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 There's a difference between theologically dubious hymns and hymns that just aren't very reverent music. There are lots of "Happy clappy" hymns which I wouldn't think of as appropriate for Mass but which are good to sing at other times. I'd put "Lord of the dance" in that category. There is nothing wrong with it theologically.
Noel's angel Posted September 6, 2007 Author Posted September 6, 2007 (edited) Jesus didn't cure people by dancing though, did He? It's just a creepy song. I admit, the tune is catchy, but Jesus didn't run around dancing everywhere. I don't recall Jesus telling anyone he was the Lord of the dance. I've never heard this at Mass, thankfully. Edited September 6, 2007 by Noel's angel
missionseeker Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 I think I posted this somewhere here before but: here is really only one aesthetic requirement that music at Mass must meet: that it be beautiful. This is because, as Pope Benedict XVI says, beauty “enables us to experience the presence of God.” Here one may say "but beauty is subjective." I answer: not quite. Beauty is defined as by Webster's dictionary as "the quality or aggregate of qualities in a person or thing that gives pleasure to the senses or pleasurably exalts the mind or spirit." Yet again one might say, “what exalts individual minds or spirits is subjective.” I answer: not true. That which is the highest Good is God. The ultimate goal of every man is (or should be) to reach the greatest Good. Man cannot reach Good without goodness; man's spirit cannot be lifted to the highest Good by something that is not good. Because of the nature of “good” something cannot be good and not lift man's spirit to God, even if man does not realize that his spirit is being lifted. This is why beauty is not subjective. But, because of sin, beauty can be perverted but still seem beautiful. A prime example of this is human sexuality. I am not saying that human sexuality is beauty perverted. Human sexuality is wondrously beautiful when it is not used in a perverted fashion. It fulfills the requirement of lifting the soul to God. But when a man (or a woman) uses his sexuality in any way other than that which was intended, it no longer lifts his soul; in fact, it drags his soul away from God, yet, it still can be mistakenly perceived as good. The same is true of music. St. Augustine said, “Music, that is the science or the sense of proper modulation, is likewise given by God's generosity to mortals having rational souls in order to lead them to higher things." Beautiful music lifts the soul to God. Here I could go on for pages about how some music is not beautiful and does not lift man's soul. In fact, I have done so before (in a paper for Dr. Urbanczyk) but it is not immediately pertinent to this, so I will resist the temptation. You have been spared. Since the Mass is the highest form of worship, should an effort not be made by musicians (whether they have been trained or not) to provide the most beautiful music they can? And since beauty is not entirely subjective, should they not make an effort to train themselves (and others) to be able to determine whether music is beautiful or not? Music at Mass should not be haphazardly put together. Music at Mass should not be chosen on the basis of “I like this” but on the basis of how beautiful it is. This analysis is not based solely on the composition of the music, but also on the lyrics, the composition and the lyrics combined (a song of exultation should not sound like a dirge), and the presentation. While musicians should most certainly not think of the Mass as their performance, they should be aware of the sound of their music and able to judge whether or not it is beautiful. A choir should not present music that is not as beautiful as they can make it. Or music that they cannot make beautifully. Beautifully does not mean perfectly. But it does mean that careful attention has to be paid so that it does not sound ugly. Music that is not beautiful detracts from the grandeur of the Mass. If music is detracting from the grandeur of the Mass then it is ineffective, and sometimes, deleterious to the soul. www.ceciliaschola.org has link to sacred music objectives and documents and quotes from high up peoples.
jeffpugh Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 (edited) Wow! Thanks so much! [quote]Augusting called singing 'praying twice'. [/quote] Thanks. I thought that was it. Edited September 7, 2007 by Sacred Music Man
Seven77 Posted September 15, 2007 Posted September 15, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1376288' date='Sep 2 2007, 11:40 AM']I hate that hymn. It's the worst hymn ever. The theology is completely screwy and it has no real meaning. Anyway... "I am the Bread of Life" isn't so bad, in my opinion. I'm one who is generally against songs where the choir takes on God's voice, but the psalms, which are the quintessential hymns of the Church, very often have parts where God is speaking to His people. I think sacred music is fine in doing that, but I'd rather the choir sing such a song while the congregation hears and meditates on it...that way the congregation is still hearing the words of God to them. I'm not sure how that jives with the liturgical documents because I'm not a liturgist, but it seems fine to me. If anyone can show me where the documents are against it, I'll humbly bow to that. Anyway, most other such songs are filled with fluffy theology and/or shouldn't be sung by the congregation.[/quote] I agree--"I am the Bread of Life" is fine. And yes preferably the choir sings while we meditate on it. The song really moves me.
Apotheoun Posted September 15, 2007 Posted September 15, 2007 I find the song "I am the bread of life" to be aesthetically vapid.
CatherineM Posted September 15, 2007 Posted September 15, 2007 I'm also in the choir. We are a small, very poor, inner city type church. We actually have prostitutes standing in front of the church at times. We can't afford to pay organists here like my church back home used to do. We have two women who volunteer a day a month each to play piano at mass. The choir has to drag all the equipment such as mics and cords out for every mass and then lock back up when services are over so that they won't be stolen for drug money by the neighbors. I come home after mass exhausted. It is sometimes hard to remember that we are there for his glory, and not our own. Two weeks out of the month, we have no music. We have a capella leaders. I personally love contemporary Christian music, and would love to be able to introduce some of it to the service, but when the parish is having to sing without music, old traditional songs that everyone knows work best. Having a song that upsets someone in the church with a pre-Vatican II sensibility, and the resultant debate is a luxury that our parish can't afford.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 16, 2007 Posted September 16, 2007 I used to think that I understood and appreciated the Church's authentic sacred music. Only recently have I begun to realize how impoverished my appreciation has been. The pride of place that is proper to Gregorian chant and the singular fittingness of this musical treasure for our liturgy cannot be stressed enough. People who minimize this fact are in error and are, quite frankly, participating in the destruction of the Roman rite and thus the life of the Church. Anyone who disagrees will have to wait for me to finish my research and write up a systematic elucidation of this conviction.
let_go_let_God Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 First question, are we talking about the same version of "I am the Bread of Life" which goes, "I am the Bread of Life You who come to me shall not hunger And if you eat of this bread You shall live forever You shall live forever And I will raise you up And I will raise you up And I will raise you up On the last day." Also, I wrote a song once that is like Jesus speaking, but it came from me meditating on God's great mercy and how I'm not worthy of that. Should I scrap it or try to reword it so it wouldn't come from His point of view? God bless- LGLG
Noel's angel Posted September 20, 2007 Author Posted September 20, 2007 (edited) I don't think it's simply speaking from God's perspective that is wrong in itself-people have mentioned that the psalms for exmaple, do just this. It's the 'horizontal' hymns that are the problem. The ones that people sing as if they were God, to and about the congregation. It's almost as if the choir are singing as God to the people about the people. There is no lifting of the spirit to God. As for your hymn, I'm sure it's fine since you seem to be singing in awe of the mercy of God and His greatness. Edited September 20, 2007 by Noel's angel
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now