Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, so here is a scenario.

Say two people live in a house, and Internet access is paid for by a third party. The third party also provides a computer for the use of the residents. One of the residents, Resident A, has installed a wireless router in order to use a laptop to access the Internet. Resident A in no way impedes Resident B's access to the computer or Internet paid for by the third party, but does not wish to give Resident B access to the wireless signal, for reasons of Resident A's own.

Does Resident B have a right to demand access to the wireless signal?

Roamin Catholic
Posted

I dont think so. I mean it's their router and since it doesn't hurt anyone so they should be able to with it as they please

Posted

I would say no because the router is attached to their computer. Some people are paranoid about anyone touching routers attached to their computers.

Posted

no, unless they were willing to pony up money for the part of the cost of the wireless router (which i know can be expensive)

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1367986' date='Aug 22 2007, 01:15 PM']no, unless they were willing to pony up money for the part of the cost of the wireless router (which i know can be expensive)[/quote]

My thoughts exactly.

Posted

Jesus would let person B share his router.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1368014' date='Aug 22 2007, 02:01 PM']Jesus would let person B share his router.[/quote]

Agreed, but there exists no obligation from person A, thus person B's demands would be groundless.

Posted

Resident B should pay for 1/2 the router is he/she wishes to use its signal. Or, resident B can get a router of his/her own, and splice the wireless that way...

Perhaps if Resident A got to the root of the issue of why he/she does not want to 'share' the wireless connection, and communicated and hopefully worked it out, this would turn into a way of using the love of Christ to reconcile one with their brother/sister, and then perhaps the 'wireless connection' issue would turn into a non-issue.

but i could be wrong.

Posted

Resident A is fully aware of reasons why he/she does not want to share the router and he/she thinks Jesus would understand.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I would say no to letting her use it especially since theres doubts of letting her use it to begin with this. You just never know if its going to hurt your ability to get on the internet yourself.....

The third party has already provided the internet. So when it comes down to it, it is up to each of you guys to find your own way to use it.

You choose the wireless router and taken care of your ability to access it. Now that other person needs to invest in their own method just like you had to in order to use it themselves.

The only way I would let them personally is if I can seriously trust them and have them help out in paying for the router. :idontknow:

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' post='1368035' date='Aug 22 2007, 03:26 PM']Resident B should pay for 1/2 the router is he/she wishes to use its signal. Or, resident B can get a router of his/her own, and splice the wireless that way...

Perhaps if Resident A got to the root of the issue of why he/she does not want to 'share' the wireless connection, and communicated and hopefully worked it out, this would turn into a way of using the love of Christ to reconcile one with their brother/sister, and then perhaps the 'wireless connection' issue would turn into a non-issue.

but i could be wrong.[/quote]
:rolling:

I think Resident A should move. :mellow:

God the Father
Posted

Resident A should slip amphetamines in Resident B's drink like on House.

Posted

Resident A does not want to go to jail.


Resident A is moving. Just not for a couple weeks.


:mellow:

Posted

there is no obligation for resident A to let RES B use the signal, however, unless there are security concerns, I don't see why resident A wouldn't let RES B use it- but if there are other underlying concerns as to why not, then its completely justified.

Posted

I think Resident B doesn't like being called RES B :getaclue:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='dUSt' post='1368014' date='Aug 22 2007, 04:01 PM']Jesus would let person B share his router.[/quote]
Not unless person B is poor and can't afford the router. Jesus did not give to the rich, as far as I can tell.

Charity does not equate to being taken advantage of.

Edited by XIX
Posted (edited)

Editied because I re-read the initial thread....
(Okay, so I'm impulsive. Sue me....)

Terra,
I'll assume that pary B is using the ISP for porn or some other immoral activity (not an illegal activity).
Since you aren't paying for ISP, it's not up to you to regulate their access to the ISP and per your post, your aren't limiting what the 3rd party is providing. Sine you bought the wireless router, you should be able to use it for your personal use and are not obligated to let anyone else use the wireless router. If the B party wants wireless access, they can add another wireless switch themselves. I don't see a problem, but I'd be happy to call them and explain the situation in 'construction language' if you so desire.

Edit again to add:
Jesus wouldn't need a router, and if He so desired, you and Res B wouldn't either...

Edited by Anomaly
homeschoolmom
Posted
:o How did you you know Terra was Person A???
Posted

i guessed she was too :mellow:


just a hunch :detective:

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1368306' date='Aug 22 2007, 09:10 PM']:o How did you you know Terra was Person A???[/quote]Easy. Applied intuitive analysis of the original post.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...