Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question About God's Oneness And His Exsistence.


Is there a 100% totally irrefutable argument that God exsist?  

15 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote][b]Baltimore Catechism[/b]
22. Q. Why can there be but one God?
A. There can be but one God because God, being supreme and infinite, cannot have an equal.
[url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/ebooks/mast...re/bcreed01.htm"]http://www.cin.org/users/james/ebooks/mast...re/bcreed01.htm[/url][/quote]

Why can't there be two or three supreme and infinite beings.


[quote]Yes, it's actually a Dogma that the existence of God can be proven from nature (defined at the [b]First Oecumenical Council of the Vatican and can be found at Denzinger No. 1806[/b])[/quote]

Can anyone give a 100% totally irrefutable argument that God exsist?

Edited by matthew1618
Posted

[quote name='matthew1618' post='1368376' date='Aug 22 2007, 07:59 PM']Why can't there be two or three supreme and infinite beings.[/quote]

Think about it for a minute. If you have two things, then there must be some difference between them in order to distinguish them. (Otherwise they would really be one thing.) Now if both "gods" are truly infinite and supreme, what could there be to distinguish them from each other? If one "god" had an extra quality then the other isn't truly infinite or supreme because it lacks something. Namely, it lacks what makes the first "god" different from the second.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='matthew1618' post='1368376' date='Aug 22 2007, 07:59 PM']Why can't there be two or three supreme and infinite beings.[/quote]

The answer to that question has already been stated: "There can be but one God because God, being supreme and infinite, cannot have an equal." [cf. Baltimore Catechism No. 4, Q 21]

For a more detailed answer to that question read S.T. I, Q. 11:
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1011.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1011.htm[/url]

[quote name='matthew1618' post='1368376' date='Aug 22 2007, 07:59 PM']Can anyone give a 100% totally irrefutable argument that God exsist?[/quote]

Yes. If you accept the authority of the Catholic Church the argument would be that it was defined as a dogma.

If you do not accept the authority of the Catholic Church or want an argument based from nature go read S.T. I, Q. 2:
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1002.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1002.htm[/url]

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

The answers to these questions depend on definition of terms. For instance, if by "gods" you mean "non-physical beings with power and knowledge far beyond us" like the Greeks had in mind... then, yes, one can logically believe in many. But if you mean the God of Jesus Christ, the God of Israel, then it is contradictory to believe in more than one. The question "why can't there be two or three infinite beings" means you aren't thinking of "infinite" the way we are. The Summa Theologica citation already posted is a great explanation.

Thomas also treats about the possibility of arguing for God's existence. He concludes that God's existence is self-evident in itself. That is, pure and perfect reason cannot believe other than that God exists. However, no human being reasons purely and perfectly. So God is not self-evident to every person.

If by "irrefutable argument" you mean an argument such that every person who hears it will be unable to disbelieve in God, then there is certainly no such argument. But that's the limitation of our reason at work. We human beings excel at refuting the irrefutable.. at least in our own minds.

I love Anselms "ontological argument" - which is usually completely misunderstood - because it gets behind the question "does God exist." Anselm says to the atheist, "look, whatever you are thinking God is, if you can possibly believe he doesn't exist, then you're not talking about the God I'm talking about. If you were thinking of what I'm thinking of, you could never say 'it doesn't exist.'" That's why we can tell the atheists, "we also do not believe in the 'god' in whom you do not believe."

Call him pure act, call him the ground of being, or Being Itself, whatever... if they were thinking of God as God really is, then they couldn't even think of him not existing. It is, quite literally, unthinkable. Can't be thought. If you can think "it doesn't exist," then it isn't God you're thinking about.

ThyWillBeDone
Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1368816' date='Aug 23 2007, 10:48 AM']That is, pure and perfect reason cannot believe other than that God exists. However, no human being reasons purely and perfectly. So God is not self-evident to every person.

If by "irrefutable argument" you mean an argument such that every person who hears it will be unable to disbelieve in God, then there is certainly no such argument. But that's the limitation of our reason at work. We human beings excel at refuting the irrefutable.. at least in our own minds.[/quote]

I believe Beatty07 explained it perfectly. I just wanted to add that arguments for God's existence often fail because, someone cannot be "reasoned into" faith. If someone is for some reason not open to the gift of faith, all the reasonable arguments you present to them will mean nothing. We must first get the person to desire faith, the pray for faith, then reason can help them reach the point where they can accept the gift of faith offered to them by God.

Unfortunately this is often harder then presenting arguments, because it involve presenting to them a good Christian model, showing them the deep inner joy that flows from union with God, it involves "giving a reason for the joy that is in you" to paraphrase scripture. And this task is much more difficult but it is one every Christian has a duty to undertake.
God Bless

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...