Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Morality Of Undercover Operations In This Area


Recommended Posts

Posted

Serious question.

But let me clarify a bit: I do not mean, the undercover agent would in fact engage in (what should be) the marital act; but rather, discovering whether people are willing to engage in illicit sexual activity, i.e.: engage with people with no (civil) legality to act as prostitutes.

I was watching a crimes show, in my law class at school, featuring a segment on this; in which 2-3 women (police officers) adorned themselves in clothing, and stayed alongside a particular street/s. When passerby's 'ask' for illicit services, then police move in to arrest the guy (after a signal).

Would such be moral? I mean, I can detect some moral problems in this situation : 1) dress and situation alongside the street could be an occassion of sin for passers by, 2) occassion of sin for those who ask for services (i.e.: especially when the undercover agent answers questions suggestively, so as to get a try and clearly discover whether or not the passerby is willing, so as to determine whether he should be arrested).

On the other hand, could it not be said, that such operations, will in fact cause less impurity to occur (i.e.: due to those people being arrested, they would be more sceptical - if not completely regretting - asking for such services)?

I realise in morality, the principle that one may not do evil for the purposes of good resulting. I also realise how impurity is intrinsically sinful. So what I'm getting at, perhaps, is whether or not such actions could be justified with the same reasoning as a just war is justified, i.e.: as a lesser evil. I'm not well versed in the principle of double effect, but I somehow doubt it would come into play here. I don't know.

Ideas?

Posted

Seems like you've already raised the important factors. You're right that double effect wouldn't apply. Why would be a long explanation and I'm sure there's at least one thread on that already.

Based on the problems you identified - occasion of sin, immodesty - I don't believe this to be morally admissable. I'd agree with you that it would be a case of doing evil that good may come of it, so... nope.

Just imagine if we really accepted the principle at work here. We'd all be trying to make the world more pure by doing our best to trip up potential sinners. I'm not thinking that would go very well!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...