Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Wether Gay Is Right Or Wrong? (philosophy)


Recommended Posts

Posted

On one occasion I was putting my left foot at the door step in order to get inside in philosophy class and we have a strong discussion about morals and ethics ”Gays are born gay. and that is not their fault. It is correct to let them have their love.” said he, I however did not agree so I ask the teacher if I could be in the opposing side and talk. He allowed me I when on stepped and went in the board “this is a false theory because we as philosophers do not judge the people but their ideas
So it does not mean because the person is gay, therefore the person was born like that with different genes those genes.” Said I Sven stared at me like if I was tricking him because we where friends for all that year. Then he raised his voice
“is it really moral that we allow a couple marry but not gay people? Why do we let the love of a man and a women. But how come we do not let the love of a man let it be with another man? Is it because we fail in being fair or is it really discrimination ? Or is there any good reason?” then I said “what is right, the man that tricks the teachings of his creator or let man teach his own creator? God told us that homosexuality is an abomination and it is not in order to get us annoyed it is because they get aids, in Mexico we have biological prove, and have test it in the U.S.A. the government prove that we could test it. that even the married people get aids because either the husband or wife used to homosexual and gets his wife sick or husband.” Said I “ then how come American scientist have proven that also adulterated drugs also produce aids Explain?!” said he “ provably because a gay person must have used it before, the other person did not clean the injection and injected the same injection.” Said I he said “we can choose to hurt their feelings but I believe that we should change that. My conscience tells me that every man deserves freedom” said he “how can a man love another man in a discus ting way that should be only between a man and a women? Why can’t they love as brothers, adoptive father, and adoptive son or only as friends or best friends why?! Tell me!” said I “how come the catholic church hired Leornado Davinci in order to paint St peters cathedral?!” Said he and I told him “ 1st of all we never hide gay people 2nd of all did you know that davinci was not gay people interpreted him as gay but he loved man as brothers. back then hugging a man was not gay now at days people get freaked out, they do not understand the differences of Latin culture it is not at all like Anglo Saxon culture, and actually Davinci was accused for being with many women even married ones. 3rd if he was gay we would not pay him for being gay but for his paintings. It is not like if the pope was having a relationship with him.” Said I then “what if the bible is wrong and was written by these persons who created the idea of morals.” Said he while looking at me with anger I said it would not be possible that the pope has those letters and back then they where separated so there was no way to contact each other one they where separated from country to country.’
He closed his mouth looked at the floor trying to think what else he had in order to make it right. Finally he got another point and turned his eyes back to me and said “God also said that he wanted Us to be happy. He died for us and for our sins so we can do what ever we want. Because he saved us and because if we believe in him we are already saved so we could do what ever we want homosexuality is not wrong because you are not killing anybody” said he
“your are not killing physically you are killing a soul temporary and you are not loving him you are giving him a disease, and God died not so we can have fun but so we can repent and show us an example of life. it is not the matter of believing, it is the matter of what you do with the rest of your life, I can say I believe I God and be the worse kind of person the worse kind of criminal now how do we know what defines right from wrong if we would not have a God but I believe he exist and he tells us everything for a reason.” said I.
Then I looked at some at the teacher’s eyes and I said “if gays produce aids and they produce it to society therefore homosexuality is wrong” then the class took view points and I won for my first debate

God bless you

Posted

how far should we go into the theological realm when discussing this in a philosophy class?

congrats btw :)

Posted

[b]Thank-you for sharing this.[/b]

Matty

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

did you say that only Homosexuals get the HIV virus?

Posted

I read that too.

Gay people do not "produce" AIDS. Straight people spread it, unsanitary tatooing can spread it for Pete's sake.

I have a hard time believing ANY professor would have let you win a debate with that false logic. Sorry to be rude, but you are very misinformed about AIDS my friend.

I think your post is terribly homophobic, ill informed, and has no place on a board like this.

Posted

Aids is not merely a disease of gay people nor can it misconstured as a punishment for gay people. Ask those dying by the thousands in many parts of the world. Ask any nurse who is at risk of it everytime she goes to work. Ask any worker who might pick up a trash bag with a used syringe in it. You have much to learn and much more to experience.

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

I think there's a little confusion in the translation.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

I would like to see an explanation of this, to see what you really mean, because such ideas do not fit and have no place in Catholicism social teaching.

Posted

Nor on a Catholic forum.

Posted (edited)

"I read that too.

Gay people do not "produce" AIDS. Straight people spread it, unsanitary tatooing can spread it for Pete's sake.

I have a hard time believing ANY professor would have let you win a debate with that false logic. Sorry to be rude, but you are very misinformed about AIDS my friend.

I think your post is terribly homophobic, ill informed, and has no place on a board like this"

do you have any facts of prove. or is it liberalism that people transormed it to right's.

sorry but i know defentetly about this because my uncles is a doctor and he did his doctorate degree.
and he explained it very detailed wich i will not be very specific but they are the ones who cause us problems.

now not all gay have it because some of them did not have sexual relationships.

now you think i do not know about unsenitary people that they also could have yes but
not all of them. actually most of them do not have
if you question is how do i know this well i am from mexico and i lived among these people. and doctors come and make tests to see if they have AIDS. none so far i have seen.

now the catholic teachings will not allow gay marriage because God would not allow it. it is adultery even the bible says so. and also says God pukes to them.

now explain how can catholic teachings change it to a liberal view whan God never whantted this view normal

how come soddom was destroyed
because there was no innocence in that place so God decided to punnish them there was lots of homosexuality. and that is one of many reasons that God decided to punnish sodom and gommora

Edited by eperez874
Posted (edited)

[quote name='prose' post='1370957' date='Aug 26 2007, 10:26 AM']I think your post is terribly homophobic, ill informed, and has no place on a board like this.[/quote]

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1371325' date='Aug 26 2007, 09:26 PM']I would like to see an explanation of this, to see what you really mean, because such ideas do not fit and have no place in Catholicism social teaching.[/quote]

[quote name='prose' post='1371644' date='Aug 27 2007, 12:35 PM']Nor on a Catholic forum.[/quote]
Oh no!!

Somebody just committed the Unforgivable P.C. Sin of "Homophobia"! Notify the P.C. thought police immediately!
File charges of "Hate Crime"!

Personally, I think this lad ought to be congratulated for having the cajones to stand up and say that homosexuality is wrong and immoral in today's politically correct culture when any and all criticism of homosexual behavior is taboo and often censored. And kudos to his teacher too.

So maybe he made a few factual errors, and maybe English isn't his first language.
Cut the guy a little slack! Maybe you can explain where you disagree, rather than screaming how his opinions "have no place on a Catholic forum" and other nonsense.

And while homosexuality is not the only means of spreading AIDS, it certainly is a significant factor, and does drastically increase one's risk.

It's disgusting how homosexuality has become such a sacred cow in our sick liberal culture, and these p.c. attitudes have even managed to creep into Phatmass to a certain extent.

Let's face it, we tolerate all kinds of nonsense on Phatmass without immediate calls for censorship.
Would we get this same kind of reaction if someone attacked a more politically-correct target, say Republicans, or religious conservatives?
Sure, people would disagree and argue, but you wouldn't get any of this hysterical "This has no place on a Catholic forum!" nonsense.

It's a sad double standard when on a self-proclaimed "Catholic forum," attacks on the Pope and the saints are debated against, while attacks on homosexual activity are responded to immediately with calls for censure.

Edited by Socrates
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted (edited)

is has nothing to do with political correctness (which i abhor), but factual correctness. This notion that AIDS is the plague of homosexuals is incorrect. Actually, because there are more heterosexuals than homosexuals, heterosexuals spread the HIV virus more. i agree Homosexuality increases the risk of getting HIV, but HIV does not come from Homosexuals, and is spread more by Heterosexuals.


also not all Homosexuals will get AIDS, even if they are in a sexual relationship. almost everything eperez874 says is incorrect.


eperez874: No one is arguing that Homosexuality is moral. We are just saying that they did not create AIDS. and that not all of them have aids. please do some research.

Edited by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1371644' date='Aug 27 2007, 12:35 PM']Nor on a Catholic forum.[/quote]


Now now be nice.

I think this is the perfect place to show error, since this is a perfect place to have those errors corrected. I also see some mistakes in the initial post, but lets not attack the person, let us correct the argument.


I sincerely take objection to homosexuals 'creating' the virus of aids. If this was so, why did not the ancient Greeks have the virus amongst them?

No my friend, this does not fit simple logic.



However, you do touch on some very fundamental truths, such as homosexuality not 'directly' killing anyone, but progressively 'killing the soul' in a sense.

The only reason why in macro-scale of society, that homosexuality seems harmless, is because it remains for now dilluted amongst a majority or richeous. Unless artificial intervention is called upon, a homosexual society is categorically and by biological definition unsustainable and thus must be admitted as unnatural.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1372917' date='Aug 28 2007, 08:08 PM']Oh no!!

Somebody just committed the Unforgivable P.C. Sin of "Homophobia"! Notify the P.C. thought police immediately!
File charges of "Hate Crime"!

Personally, I think this lad ought to be congratulated for having the cajones to stand up and say that homosexuality is wrong and immoral in today's politically correct culture when any and all criticism of homosexual behavior is taboo and often censored. And kudos to his teacher too.

So maybe he made a few factual errors, and maybe English isn't his first language.
Cut the guy a little slack! Maybe you can explain where you disagree, rather than screaming how his opinions "have no place on a Catholic forum" and other nonsense.

[snip][/quote]

Precisely my thoughts as well. I would like to second the affirmations above.

Posted

I tried to send this to you in a PM but for some reason it didn't go through?


[quote]is has nothing to do with political correctness (which i abhor), but factual correctness. This notion that AIDS is the plague of homosexuals is incorrect. Actually, because there are more heterosexuals than homosexuals, heterosexuals spread the HIV virus more. i agree Homosexuality increases the risk of getting HIV, but HIV does not come from Homosexuals, and is spread more by Heterosexuals.


also not all Homosexuals will get AIDS, even if they are in a sexual relationship. almost everything eperez874 says is incorrect.


eperez874: No one is arguing that Homosexuality is moral. We are just saying that they did not create AIDS. and that not all of them have aids. please do some research.[/quote]

I agree with what you said, but not of how you said it.


Keep in mind the person you are addressing may be a 12 year old kid? Who knows? You take a very confrontational stance in trying to tell this person he or she is incorrect, and although what you say is indeed (as I agree) correct, I see no need for the tone you at least seem to use here.

Relax a little, join the person into his or her mistakes in order to pull them out. Short of this, you'll just be pilling stuff atop of them.


Just my two cents, no offense intended.

Peace and God bless,

Didace

Posted

"I agree with what you said, but not of how you said it.


Keep in mind the person you are addressing may be a 12 year old kid? Who knows? You take a very confrontational stance in trying to tell this person he or she is incorrect, and although what you say is indeed (as I agree) correct, I see no need for the tone you at least seem to use here."


i am actually 17 wich makes still a teenager.

and yes my primarly language is not englsh. but spanish and not only that i know what i said and i know what is AIDS. now grammer rules are different and spelling errors i might not know that very well.

but the facts are still correct.

now evidence. i will aslo search it angd give you links i need 5 months becasue i am also at school doing work. and i will defenetl;y give it to you the link becasue it is too long way too long.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1370957' date='Aug 26 2007, 12:26 PM']I read that too.

Gay people do not "produce" AIDS. Straight people spread it, unsanitary tatooing can spread it for Pete's sake.

I have a hard time believing ANY professor would have let you win a debate with that false logic. Sorry to be rude, but you are very misinformed about AIDS my friend.

I think your post is terribly homophobic, ill informed, and has no place on a board like this.[/quote]

There are certain facts about AIDS that you must be ill informed of... AIDS has it's roots in the homosexual lifestyle community. Yes, people that have normal sexual attraction also can spread it. The fact remains that in the beginning with AIDS, it was mostly practicing homosexuals that spread it.

Yes, sharing needles can too spread HIV/AIDS.... but the fact remains that the majority of people in the beginning were homosexual... and in some sense could be seen as 'producing' it.

Today, in most cases, anyone sleeping around can be spreading it. Condoms don't protect from it, etc...



As for the topic of the thread... I think this is the best analysis of the issue backed by many years of study....
Homosexuality and Hope:
[url="http://www.cathmed.org/publications/homosexuality.htm"]http://www.cathmed.org/publications/homosexuality.htm[/url]

God Bless,
ironmonk

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...