Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I know, according to what I was taught, that to become a catholic one must be baptized, go to church, obey the clergy, and appease God through the eucharist so God wont beaver dam you to hell, shed blood for the remission of sins, have hate of self and do good works, yet how does one leave the church? Is there a formula? an application? an un-baptism?
I no longer consider myself a catholic as I don't think its right to be a hypocrite and say I am something when I don't believe in it.
where does someone like me stand according to the Church? Am I saved? damned? double-damned? going to purgatory? - I don't think I ever was part of the "body" of Christ to begin with and I know I was never saved (special and important to God). Thanks

Posted (edited)

GodChild, I'm not sure you and Catholicism have ever met.

You've posted before about experiencing God as sadistic, about the Christ of Catholicism "bleeding [you] dry with all the demands, all the rebukes, all the crosses." I want to first reiterate what has come up before... that these things you are attributing to Catholicism are not Catholicism. They are in fact ways of thinking that the Church has fought against for 2000 years. Gnosticism, including a belief that being human is evil. Pelagianism, the belief that you must earn salvation by your works. I know that's how you feel, but don't blame the Church... the Church is the one telling you it's not so.

Is it possible - I don't know you, I'm just asking - is it possible that you've dumped all your pain and psychological baggage onto the idea of "Catholicism", giving yourself a convenient scapegoat to blame for all your suffering and confusion? The Church says that humanity is good and salvation is all grace. The Catechism says so, the Pope says so, the Church fathers say so, the Bible says so, everybody here says so, every Catholic who knows the first thing about their faith says so. I don't want to sound harsh, but what gives you the right to define Catholicism as something completely different, against all of that?

Why do you feel a need to redefine Catholicism as something you can hate? Does it take your mind off hating yourself? From your previous posts, it sounds like you really do hate yourself a lot. These horrible things you are attributing to Catholicism are what you have said you feel...strongly... that God hates you, that God might be kind to others but couldn't care less about you except maybe to beat you up. I'm sorry that I and others have failed to help you see otherwise. I'm sorry for all the ways that Catholics and other Christians have hurt you in the past, whatever they might be. No, I'm not arrogant enough to think that will make you feel any different, but still, I'm sorry.

Please don't be afraid of God because of these feelings. He can handle your fury. Have you read Lamentations?

As far as where you stand according to the Church...well, no human being can tell you the state of your soul. No one but God can judge the heart, and he is love right through. He is mercy itself. Next to the Divine Mercy of Christ, your sins - whatever they might be - are as nothing. You can't earn it. You can't deserve it. Trying to earn it or deserve it will just drag you farther down.

I hope someday you can believe this, that someday you can trust His mercy and love for you.

Edited by beatty07
Posted

I just saw your post in the "do suicides go to hell" thread about what you were taught, and replied there... but that sheds some light on this as well. It sounds as though you've been the victim of the worst Catechist EVER. So...please be open to relearning everything you think you know about the Catholic faith. And may God have mercy on whoever worked so hard to lead you astray. It is not God who is sadistic, but a "teacher" who tells you lies about Him.

Posted

Dear GodChild,

That's a nice username you have. Perhaps it shows that, deep down, you know that you are God's child, and He really loves you a lot.

Well, in the past two years, I went through something. I don't really know what it was. It had all the symptoms of what is medically known as Depression. I hated everything in life, disconnected from most of my friends, and felt that I was totally useless. I wondered why I was alive.

There were even extended periods of time when I thought, (God forgive me!) that perhaps God was punishing me severely for my sins, so that He could hold me up as an example to others, of what happens to those who disobey Him.

I'm not sure if I came to hate God, but I did have fear of Him, and was confused about not being able to perceive His love, which all Christians claim is infinite.

Perhaps there is some area of your life - religious/social/personal/academic/professional in which things are not going as you would like them to. Is it possible that this could be causing you to be depressed? If this is so, (I'm not an expert on Depression. I haven't studied it. I only went through it, or something like it, but it was the worst torture. ) you might want to go to counseling with someone who has experience with helping those who are feeling depressed, like a psychotherapist, or a spiritual counselor, or a doctor.

It might help you. I hope you are comforted and healed soon.

I shall remember you in my prayers.

With love and prayers,

Yours in Christ,
Innocent

Posted

Spiritually speaking, when you are baptized or Confirmed in the Catholic Church, it changes your soul, permanently. You are now a part of God's family, an adopted child, through Jesus Christ, of the Heavenly King. This is why even when people "leave the Church," they are only one Confession away from "returning."

God can never de-adopt you, because, whether you can accept this or not, He does not hate you. Possibly (probably) you have been taught to hate yourself. But that is not God talking.

Posted

O my :(

Well, first of all, there is no formula or application. there is no un-baptism as baptism leaves an indelible and unrepeatable mark on the soul. What you are talking about is called "apostacy" and it can be as simple as simply formally joining another faith community. It is, neverthheless serious. The extent of its seriousness depends on how well you know what it is you are leaving.

Given what yu have posted here and in other places, I would have to say "not very well". This sounds like a cross between jansenism, sadomasochism, and a 21st ccentury incarnation of the Flagellants. It isn't catholicism as it is actually taught by actual catecists. It isn't Catholicism as it is actually practiced by practicing Catholics.

As for whether you are saved or damned, the Church has no opinion. Not ieven about Judas, regardless of what that execrable teacher taught you.

Posted

One leaves the Church by simply obstinately denying any or all of the truths which God has revealed to His Church.

One can also leave the Church by doing anything which would [i]latae sententiae[/i] excommunicate him or by doing something which ecclesiastical authority excommunicates him.

Posted

There is an actus formalis defectionis ab Ecclesia catholica:

[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/intrptxt/documents/rc_pc_intrptxt_doc_20060313_actus-formalis_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontific...ormalis_en.html[/url]

Send a letter to your bishop informing him you no longer wish to be Catholic, be sure to describe yourself as qualifying for all those things listed, and say that you wish to make a formal act of defection from the Catholic Faith.

But be assured of the veracity of #7:
7. It remains clear, in any event, that the sacramental bond of belonging to the Body of Christ that is the Church, conferred by the baptismal character, is an ontological and permanent bond which is not lost by reason of any act or fact of defection.

By performing these legal steps, you do not undo the indelible change in the character of your soul which makes the angels weep over your loss.

Posted

sorry, I'm struggling alot - I'll try my best to repsond

[quote]you've posted before about experiencing God as sadistic, about the Christ of Catholicism "bleeding [you] dry with all the demands, all the rebukes, all the crosses." I want to first reiterate what has come up before... that these things you are attributing to Catholicism are not Catholicism. They are in fact ways of thinking that the Church has fought against for 2000 years. Gnosticism, including a belief that being human is evil. Pelagianism, the belief that you must earn salvation by your works. I know that's how you feel, but don't blame the Church... the Church is the one telling you it's not so.[/quote]

To the contrary, it IS the church teaching me this - my priest in the confession, religious women in a catholic community I was a part of, my former spiritual director (a nun) and a group leader at the Catholic Charismatic group - these are church leaders - the "clergy" every catholic MUST obey and never utter a peep against ... unless I must disobey the clergy and in doing so commit the hellbound sin of disobeying church clergy - so no, I find it, to be honest IMPOSSIBLE to believe these are not church teachings, as they are and have consistently been taught to me by religious (priest, nuns, religious group leaders)

[quote]is it possible - I don't know you, I'm just asking - is it possible that you've dumped all your pain and psychological baggage onto the idea of "Catholicism", giving yourself a convenient scapegoat to blame for all your suffering and confusion?[/quote]

maybe ... i don't know, but in truth I find it hard to think of the Church without feeling resentment and hatred and i hate this, because I am not a hateful person. However, to be a scapegoat, the church would need to be innocent, and from my experience the Church is hardly innocent and I think my fear and disdain for the church is well founded. I understand what your saying to me, i struggle with it alot and everything I think of I question - "am i being evil? is this my evil nature coming out? is god going to torment me for these thoughts?"

[quote]The Church says that humanity is good and salvation is all grace.[/quote] - where? do you have any writings etc to this effect i can read - my teaching has ALWAYS been that humanity is evil (original sin) that's why before we even draw our first breath we are foul and sin and this is why Jesus had to die for us - as for salvation I was taught it is "free" but you must earn it with penance, fasting, avoiding fun, movies, dances, seperating yourself from the world, being happy in misery and trying to duffer as much as possible to offer your misery to God as a pleasing sacrifice

[quote]I don't want to sound harsh, but what gives you the right to define Catholicism as something completely different, against all of that?[/quote] - :mellow: define? I did not define catholicism, it was taught to me and defined in this way to me -

[quote]Why do you feel a need to redefine Catholicism as something you can hate? Does it take your mind off hating yourself?[/quote] - again i didn't define catholicism - I don't feel a need to define catholicism .... though as of late I DO feel a need to break free from it or I will either go crazy or commit suicide - do i hate myself? of course I do, that's all I was taught to do by God ... have hate of self in order to love God more purely, "despise yourself" to be more perfect for God, "hate your life" or you wont go to heaven

These are a few of my responses ... please don't just denounce me as evil and lost, I'm struggling and need things clarified - some of you say I should not listen to my teachers in the faith, yet at the same time you will be the first to tell me of obeying the clergy?

sorry about the long response, i dont mean to cause trouble

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1370040' date='Aug 25 2007, 06:26 AM']There is an actus formalis defectionis ab Ecclesia catholica:

[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/intrptxt/documents/rc_pc_intrptxt_doc_20060313_actus-formalis_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontific...ormalis_en.html[/url]

Send a letter to your bishop informing him you no longer wish to be Catholic, be sure to describe yourself as qualifying for all those things listed, and say that you wish to make a formal act of defection from the Catholic Faith.

But be assured of the veracity of #7:
7. It remains clear, in any event, that the sacramental bond of belonging to the Body of Christ that is the Church, conferred by the baptismal character, is an ontological and permanent bond which is not lost by reason of any act or fact of defection.

By performing these legal steps, you do not undo the indelible change in the character of your soul which makes the angels weep over your loss.[/quote]

thankyou, that's what I was looking for

Posted

[quote name='GodChild' post='1370238' date='Aug 24 2007, 09:22 PM']thankyou, that's what I was looking for[/quote]

Very sad you've given up on us.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='GodChild' post='1369825' date='Aug 24 2007, 08:48 AM']I know, according to what I was taught, that to become a catholic one must be baptized, go to church, obey the clergy, and appease God through the eucharist so God wont beaver dam you to hell, shed blood for the remission of sins, have hate of self and do good works, yet how does one leave the church? Is there a formula? an application? an un-baptism?
I no longer consider myself a catholic as I don't think its right to be a hypocrite and say I am something when I don't believe in it.
where does someone like me stand according to the Church? Am I saved? damned? double-damned? going to purgatory? - I don't think I ever was part of the "body" of Christ to begin with and I know I was never saved (special and important to God). Thanks[/quote]

Godchild,

You don't want to leave. If you did, you wouldn't be here asking for someone to stop you. Underneath all the layers of anger, bitterness, and wounded hurt, is someone who is, and always will be, a Catholic.

If I remember correctly you were the one who had a group of people who treated and taught you poorly yes? If I am wrong, I apologize.

You are not at the end, but at the beginning with Jesus. You have made that first step, to get away from those people who were so negative for you--and Christ was there. Don't give up now. Our faith isn't this glorious rolling on the floor emotional experience [though we can carry a joy within us] Many times it is our faith that sustains us through harsh times, through impossible times and through lonely times. Lean on God right now--don't be afraid to seek out others who are healthy and holy in their faith. I know you can walk with Him and not away from Him.

Posted (edited)

GodChild; I heartely reccomend you catechise yourself in the Faith, from scratch. This is not an insult, but a sincere recommendation. The Catechism of the Catholic Church; take a look at it. It's available online. [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM[/url]

It must be emphasised that feelings do not equate with one's state of soul, nor are terrible feelings a sign of God's displeasure. It is actions willed that determine one's sanctity, not how one feels. As St. Francis De Sales says [Intro to the Devout Life, p273, TAN Books], some of those who receive much spiritual consolation may in fact be much lower in holiness as compared with some who receive none at all.

Our Lord suffered in his human nature beyond what any man/woman has ever suffered. Yet He is the closest to God, His Father. It is no coincidence that the the greatest of saints have been the greatest of sufferers. Just look into Padre Pio. [i]And no, the fact that God allows people to suffer does not make Him a sadist[/i]. He allows suffering such that we can truly exercise our free will in His favour. He allows suffering such that we can be truly Christian, like Christ. It's true: God could have pardoned the sins of the whole world without His Divine Son becoming man. In fact, Christ did not have to suffer the way He did to achieve satisfaction for sin - but He chose to, to manifest His Love for us. He has willed for us to share in the sufferings of His Son, such that we may truly use our free will in opting for God, and of course, amidst all this, to understand the love of Our Lord, who suffered beyond what any human has suffered or will suffer.

Anyway, it can be shown through not only the Faith of the Church, but through sound philosophy, that God, is goodness itself; and therefore, cannot be a sadist, given how He is all-good. The only conclusion that can be drawn, when one is tempted to conceive of God as being a sadist, is that there is error on our part, or rather, that our feelings are leading us against what can rationally be known to be true.

Remember feelings = nothing. (This is not be be insensitive, as feelings can indeed be traumatic and immense). We are creatures of intellect and free will. I believe, as do so many, and as so many have come to recognise, that it is reasonable to have faith in Jesus Christ, and acknowledge the Catholic Church as the voice of God on earth - and all this implies for the way we should believe and act. This is what it comes down to.
God bless you.

Edited by Hirsap
EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='GodChild' post='1370232' date='Aug 24 2007, 09:18 PM']I understand what your saying to me, i struggle with it alot and everything I think of I question - "am i being evil? is this my evil nature coming out? is god going to torment me for these thoughts?"[/quote]
You may be suffering from scrupulosity - a condition where one's mind tries to convince them that things that they do are sinful when they are not. I suffer from it and others here do as well. It is related to obsessive compulsive disorder. If you think that you might be suffering from this, I suggest this website:
[url="http://mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupanon.htm"]http://mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupanon.htm[/url]
It is [i]very[/i] helpful.
[quote]- where? do you have any writings etc to this effect i can read - my teaching has ALWAYS been that humanity is evil (original sin) that's why before we even draw our first breath we are foul and sin and this is why Jesus had to die for us - as for salvation I was taught it is "free" but you must earn it with penance, fasting, avoiding fun, movies, dances, seperating yourself from the world, being happy in misery and trying to duffer as much as possible to offer your misery to God as a pleasing sacrifice[/quote]
"And God saw all the things that he had made, and they were very good." - Genesis 1:31 (Douay-Rheims)
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/bible/gen001.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/bible/gen001.htm[/url]
As for movies, fun, etc. I think you should seek [i]good[/i] advice on living a moral Catholic life. We don't have to stop going to movies and having fun! :)
[quote]- :mellow: define? I did not define catholicism, it was taught to me and defined in this way to me -

- again i didn't define catholicism - I don't feel a need to define catholicism .... though as of late I DO feel a need to break free from it or I will either go crazy or commit suicide - do i hate myself? of course I do, that's all I was taught to do by God ... have hate of self in order to love God more purely, "despise yourself" to be more perfect for God, "hate your life" or you wont go to heaven[/quote]
As others have pointed out, this is definately not our God. God is love. Our loving God does not ask His children to hate themselves.
[quote]These are a few of my responses ... please don't just denounce me as evil and lost, I'm struggling and need things clarified - some of you say I should not listen to my teachers in the faith, yet at the same time you will be the first to tell me of obeying the clergy?

sorry about the long response, i dont mean to cause trouble[/quote]
You have no obligation to obey teachers who are clearly incorrect. No one is lost - what you are doing is good by seeking clarification. I hope I have been of some help. God bless!

Posted

It sounds like you've really had a lot of influential people setting up your ideas about Catholicism...I can see where that would be really hard to undo. Still, I'll join the others in asking you to consider trying. For instance, about the goodness of humanity... God created it, it has to be good! And if that isn't enough, the Incarnation of Christ as man gives human nature a dignity we can' imagine. Sure, we are touched by the consequences of sin...but also redeemed. You don't have an evil nature that can come out or has to be battled. Like all of us, you have evil inclinations at times, but your nature is good! Your desire for truth, for love, for integrity - those are expressions of the goodness of your nature.

Here's an example of Church teaching about grace from the Catechism of the Catholic Church: "This vocation to eternal life is supernatural. It depends entirely on God's gratuitous initiative, for he alone can reveal and give himself. It surpasses the power of human intellect and will, . . " (#1998.) "The charity of Christ is the source in us of all our merits before God. Grace, by uniting us to Christ in active love, ensures the supernatural quality of our acts and consequently their merit before God and before men. The saints have always had a lively awareness that their merits were pure grace."

Those are just a few issues that have come up in the thread. I get the sense that you've really been poisoned by some awful, actually heretical, doctrine. That's why many posters are urging you to get a hold of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. And to be prepared for it to contradict much of what you've been taught about the Faith.

By the way, I'm a priest. That doesn't mean you owe me blind obedience. It doesn't mean that I can't be wrong. It doesn't even mean that I can't be a monster, as has been sadly demonstrated many times over. Everyone here will tell you that priesthood should be honored and respected, and they are right. But no one will tell you that a priest is has the right to teach you falsehood in the name of the Church, and then psychologically abuse you while demanding you obey.

I don't even know how to begin to tell you how sorry I am for the way you have experienced the Church I love so much. Where I've found solace and peace, you've only found blame and hate. I just pray that you come to know that it's not really the Catholic faith you've encountered, but a sham. That someday you can encounter Christ, the real Christ, in the real teaching of his Church... and start to heal from these awful lies you've been told about him.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1370242' date='Aug 25 2007, 12:29 PM']Very sad you've given up on us.[/quote]

I haven't given up on you - I've given up on the faith I have and the Church that goes with it

Maybe I don't know "real" catholicism as has been suggested ... but I only know what I have been taught and given. From what I have been taught and given I HAVE given up on. I have given up on the Catholic faith I have "now"

Posted

you have given up on a heretical faith, actually. the teachings you have described have been clearly and definitively condemned by the Catholic Church. read the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1372221' date='Aug 28 2007, 02:04 AM']you have given up on a heretical faith, actually. the teachings you have described have been clearly and definitively condemned by the Catholic Church. read the Catechism of the Catholic Church.[/quote]
Or, if you find the Catechism daunting, start with the [url="http://www.amazon.com/Compendium-Catechism-Catholic-Church-Ratzinger/dp/1574557203/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/105-6099317-8852419?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1188313180&sr=8-1"]Compendium of the Catechism[/url]... it's a shorter, more concise, easier read, and it references the Catechism if you want to expand on a topic.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I suspect that GodChild has used Phatmass before under a different username.

I have kept this suspicion to myself for a long time. I may be very, very wrong. I ask pardon if this is so. If I am right, it is in an insight into her psychological needs, which are much greater than people on Phatmass can meet.

Prayers for you, GodChild.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

I am so sorry about all this. I have nothing to add except that I will join in the prayers for you and that you should see a competant psychiatrist to help you get over all this.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...