Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Consecration, Epiklesis Or Both?


  

15 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412938' date='Nov 1 2007, 07:42 PM']886 Can. 4. If anyone says that after the completion of the consecration that the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ is not in the marvelous sacrament of the Eucharist, but only in use, while it is taken, not however before or after, and that in the hosts or consecrated particles, which are reserved or remain after communion, the true body of the Lord does not remain: let him be anathema [cf. n. 876 ].[/quote]
I believe that the body and blood of Christ are present on the altar after the prayer of consecration, i.e., the epiklesis.

Posted

Do you honestly think the Fathers of the Council of Trent meant the Epilkesis when they decreed that canon?

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412947' date='Nov 1 2007, 07:52 PM']Do you honestly think the Fathers of the Council of Trent meant the Epilkesis when they decreed that canon?[/quote]
I do not believe that the Council of Trent is ecumenical; instead, I hold that it is a particular synod of the Latin Church.

Posted (edited)

So the fact that the Council itself called itself "the holy, ecumenical, and general Synod of Trent lawfully assembled in the Holy Spirit" countless times and the fact that in the profession of faith for the Maronites (D 1459 - 1473) Trent is numbered among the Ecumenical Councils means nothing?

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412969' date='Nov 1 2007, 08:05 PM']So the fact that the Council itself called itself "the holy, ecumenical, and general Synod of Trent lawfully assembled in the Holy Spirit" countless times and the fact that in the profession of faith for the Maronites (D 1459 - 1473) Trent is numbered among the Ecumenical Councils means nothing?[/quote]
The Roman Catholic Church and thirteen Orthodox Churches just issued the "Ravenna Document" (13 Oct. 2007), which explicitly states that ". . . an ecumenical council is not an 'institution' whose frequency can be regulated by canons; it is rather an 'event', a [i]kairos[/i] inspired by the Holy Spirit who guides the Church so as to engender within it the institutions which it needs and which respond to its nature. This harmony between the Church and the councils is so profound that, [b]even after the break between East and West which rendered impossible the holding of ecumenical councils in the strict sense of the term[/b], both Churches continued to hold councils whenever serious crises arose. These councils gathered together the bishops of local Churches in communion with the See of Rome or, although understood in a different way, with the See of Constantinople, respectively" [[i]Ravenna Document[/i], no. 39]. The Western synods are not binding upon Eastern Christians, and never will be binding upon them, praise God.

Posted

Do you have any prove that this "Ravenna Document" was a magisterial document of the Church or that it was signed and/or explicitly approved by the Supreme Pontiff?

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412938' date='Nov 1 2007, 08:42 PM']886 Can. 4. If anyone says that [b]after the completion of the consecration[/b] that the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ is not in the marvelous sacrament of the Eucharist, but only in use, while it is taken, not however before or after, and that in the hosts or consecrated particles, which are reserved or remain after communion, the true body of the Lord does not remain: let him be anathema [cf. n. 876 ].[/quote]
This would seem to me to include a need for the whole prayer of Consecration.
In your quote, they do not seem to be referencing the words of Institution.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1412989' date='Nov 1 2007, 10:14 PM']The Roman Catholic Church and thirteen Orthodox Churches just issued the "Ravenna Document" (13 Oct. 2007), which explicitly states that ". . . an ecumenical council is not an 'institution' whose frequency can be regulated by canons; it is rather an 'event', a [i]kairos[/i] inspired by the Holy Spirit who guides the Church so as to engender within it the institutions which it needs and which respond to its nature. This harmony between the Church and the councils is so profound that, [b]even after the break between East and West which rendered impossible the holding of ecumenical councils in the strict sense of the term[/b], both Churches continued to hold councils whenever serious crises arose. These councils gathered together the bishops of local Churches in communion with the See of Rome or, although understood in a different way, with the See of Constantinople, respectively" [[i]Ravenna Document[/i], no. 39]. The Western synods are not binding upon Eastern Christians, and never will be binding upon them, praise God.[/quote]

I'm tredding in uncertain waters here, but isn't this talking about the Eastern Churches who are not in communion currently? That currently those councils are not binding on them, but if a Church were to come into full communion with the Roman Catholic Church, wouldn't the councils 'become' binding on them?
Basically where do you find the backing for your last claim "never will be binding"?

Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1413040' date='Nov 1 2007, 10:05 PM']This would seem to me to include a need for the whole prayer of Consecration.
In your quote, they do not seem to be referencing the words of Institution.[/quote]

Yes they do...

Let's look at who, where and when the Fathers of the Council of Trent were writing. They were mostly Roman Rite Bishops at an Ecumenical Council held in northern Italy in the sixteenth century. Almost all of them had said the Ancient Form of the Roman Rite since their ordinations. In the Ancient Use one of the most oblivious things is the fact that the Words of Institution consecrate. It is only during the Words of Institution that the lids of the ciboria are taken off that the hosts therein may be consecrated. It is only during the Words of Institution that the pall is taken off the chalice. Immediately after the Words of Institution the the priest genuflects and adores the Host (the rubrics themselves say that the priest adores the Host when he genuflects immediately after the Words of Institution), he then elevates It for adoration of the people, then genuflects again in adoration Christ's Body. The selfsame thing is done for the Words of Institution spoken over the Chalice. In altar missals and on altar cards the Words of Institution are written in all capital letters to signify the great solemnity with which they must be spoken because those words themselves consecrate.

Another interesting thing I would like to add is that in the Roman Rite there is no Epiklesis. There is only the prayer Quam Oblationem which does not ask God the Father send the Holy Ghost upon the bread and wine but merely beseeches God to make the oblation "blessed, approved, ratified, reasonable and acceptable that it may become for us the Body and Blood of Thy most dearly beloved Son our Lord Jesus Christ" without a mention of the Holy Ghost. The Roman Canon is not only one of the most ancient Anaphoræ of the Church, but also the only Anaphora which was used by the Successor of the Prince of the Apostles for centuries which proves that that the Epiklesis is not only not required for validity, but does most certainly not consecrate.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1413060' date='Nov 1 2007, 10:52 PM']Yes they do...[/quote]

But where in the document does it specify the Words of Institution?


On a side note that got me wondering, if a Priest did not remove the ciboria, but had the intention to consecrate the hosts, would you consider the consecration valid?

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1413088' date='Nov 1 2007, 11:43 PM']But where in the document does it specify the Words of Institution?
On a side note that got me wondering, if a Priest did not remove the ciboria, but had the intention to consecrate the hosts, would you consider the consecration valid?[/quote]

Read post #8 on the previous page for a plethora of magisterial documents and citations from Early Church Fathers on the subject in a well written summary by a renowned mid-twentieth century theologian.

And according to Father Jone's [i]Moral Theology[/i], if I recall correctly, such a consecration would be valid if the priest intended to consecrate the hosts in the ciborium.

Posted (edited)

I believe I actually stepped outside of my own beliefs on this subject a little after re-reading it, which is easy for me to do on online discussions.

Won't hurt to continue onward I suppose


[quote]As far as the consecration effected by the Church is concerned, the Fathers ascribed this either to the whole prayer of thanksgiving which is contained in the narrative of the institution, or expressly to the words of institution.[/quote]
Is this not what we are discussing?

[quote]The view of H. Schell that the Greeks consecrated by the Epiclesis alone, and the Latins by the words of institution alone, must be rejected, since the substance of the Sacraments is not within the disposition of the Church.[/quote]
To me, this seems to say that it should be looked as a whole.

I must add, I am very underread in this issue. I hope to read a book suggested by Raphael concerning similiar questions on the Eucharist, so right now I'm just drawing from the few documents provided.

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1413107' date='Nov 2 2007, 01:37 AM']Is this not what we are discussing?
To me, this seems to say that it should be looked as a whole.

I must add, I am very underread in this issue. I hope to read a book suggested by Raphael concerning similiar questions on the Eucharist, so right now I'm just drawing from the few documents provided.[/quote]
The part you are quoting is saying that the belief that there are different timings depending on what rite you are, is to be rejected. The idea that for the Eastern Church's its at Epiklesis and for the Western its at Consecration should be rejected. At least thats how I read it.

STM you keep rehashing the obvious, but you really fail to answer the key objection here. There are no words of institution in the Anaphora of Addai and Mari, yet this is a valid consecration.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412923' date='Nov 1 2007, 08:28 PM']Yes they are.

If you do a search of the words, you will find the words "This," "is," "My," "Body," and "Blood" in it.[/quote]

Don't you think that's just a little bit of a stretch for piecing together a consecration narrative?

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1413114' date='Nov 2 2007, 01:09 AM']STM you keep rehashing the obvious, but you really fail to answer the key objection here. There are no words of institution in the Anaphora of Addai and Mari, yet this is a valid consecration.[/quote]

If you'd really like to know my thoughts on the matter, I don't know if the Anaphora is valid. I doesn't seem that the document from the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity was an authoritative document of the magisterium and therefore we are not bound by it, but if I am wrong, someone please correct me.


[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1413126' date='Nov 2 2007, 02:29 AM']Don't you think that's just a little bit of a stretch for piecing together a consecration narrative?[/quote]

Looking at what the Church teaches, it seems to be the only that the Anaphora could be valid.

Posted (edited)

double post

Edited by StThomasMore
goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1413240' date='Nov 2 2007, 12:32 PM']Looking at what the Church teaches, it seems to be the only that the Anaphora could be valid.[/quote]

I agree. That does seem to be the only explanation possible. I just don't see it as being nearly sufficient to square with doctrine. Man am I glad I don't have to try and come up with such funky explanations anymore to defend the indefensible.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1413342' date='Nov 2 2007, 05:54 PM']I agree. That does seem to be the only explanation possible. I just don't see it as being nearly sufficient to square with doctrine. Man am I glad I don't have to try and come up with such funky explanations anymore to defend the indefensible.[/quote]

It's not a terribly funky explanation. When I read the document in light of Tradition (the way all documents are meant to be read) it seems to be the interpretation I get.

goldenchild17
Posted

Can't say I agree (big surprise huh :D), but I definitely respect the effort to explain things in an orthodox way. peace

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1413240' date='Nov 2 2007, 01:32 PM']Looking at what the Church teaches, it seems to be the only that the Anaphora could be valid.[/quote]

This doesn't seem right. If the only way the Anaphora could be valid is by stringing together words "This...is...my...Body..." then we would have consecrations going on throughout the mass. This idea, stringing together the words, totally kills any idea that the consecration occurs when the priest says "This is my Body" (one phrase) since you could string together the words and have a consecration at an earlier moment.

Also I should point out that the document you are quoting (btw I love that book and use it often) is not any more binding on a Catholic than the document from the Church regarding the Anaphora.

Edited by rkwright

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...