Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

What is the significance of this phrase in the Nicene creed? Why was it included in the creed? And also, why does it say God from God, and then say again, true God from true God. Is it just emphasizing what it had previously stated?

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Bump. Good question.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1371648' date='Aug 27 2007, 11:44 AM']What is the significance of this phrase in the Nicene creed? Why was it included in the creed?[/quote]
The use of the phrase "Light of Light" is no doubt intended to emphasize the fact that the Son is [i]homoousios[/i] with the Father, because "Light" is often used in scripture as an image of Godhead (see the prologue of John's Gospel and various other chapters in that book; and also James 1:17; 1 John 1:5-7 and 1 John 2:8-11, etc.)

[quote name='Era Might' post='1371648' date='Aug 27 2007, 11:44 AM']And also, why does it say God from God, and then say again, true God from true God. Is it just emphasizing what it had previously stated?[/quote]
The Niceno-Constantinopolitan creed as it was originally written in Greek does not contain the words, "God of (or [i]from[/i]) God," but says only, "Light of Light, true God of true God."

Posted

As far as the phrase "God of (or [i]from[/i]) God" is concerned, it is found only in the Latin version of the Niceno-Constantinopolitan creed, and was probably interpolated into the text from the Creed of Nicaea I.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1372952' date='Aug 28 2007, 09:36 PM']The use of the phrase "Light of Light" is no doubt intended to emphasize the fact that the Son is [i]homoousios[/i] with the Father, because "Light" is often used in scripture as an image of Godhead (see the prologue of John's Gospel and various other chapters in that book; and also James 1:17; 1 John 1:5-7 and 1 John 2:8-11, etc.)[/quote]
Is there any particular reason why they chose light, or is it just the aspect of God that they happened to choose in describing him. For example, they could have said "Truth from Truth" or "Love from Love." The creed is a basic statement of what the Church believes, so it seems that there would be some reason why they chose "light" specifically. The phrase is describing Christ, so I wonder if maybe they chose it to highlight that he is the light that comes into the world and destroys our darkness (as you said, this is how the prologue of St. John's Gospel describes him), and so is a statement about his Incarnation.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I have always thought it a most amazing phrase, it reminds me of Creation.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

As far as the phrase "Light from Light," I wouldn't necessarily tie it to the Incarnation. I think that the three phrases (i.e. God, Light, True God) are all showing the intimate and eternal relationship between the Persons of the Trinity; in this case, the Father and the Son. Hope that makes sense.

These may (or may not) be helpful:

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3810.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3810.htm[/url]
[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/alpha/data/aud19880309en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_pau...19880309en.html[/url]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1373097' date='Aug 28 2007, 10:48 PM']Is there any particular reason why they chose light, or is it just the aspect of God that they happened to choose in describing him. For example, they could have said "Truth from Truth" or "Love from Love." The creed is a basic statement of what the Church believes, so it seems that there would be some reason why they chose "light" specifically. The phrase is describing Christ, so I wonder if maybe they chose it to highlight that he is the light that comes into the world and destroys our darkness (as you said, this is how the prologue of St. John's Gospel describes him), and so is a statement about his Incarnation.[/quote]
As already said, I wouldn't tie it to the Incarnation, although certainly the Incarnation is related to the inner-workings of the Trinity. The reason is simply that if the Son is Light from Light, then the Father is also Light, and the Father isn't incarnate, so I wouldn't find the prologue of St. John's Gospel to be particularly tied to the phrase. I mean, of course, that if the word "Light" was chosen for that reason, it wouldn't make as much sense to say that He was "from Light" in that context.

I would say this: light is more tangible than love or truth, and also more clearly defined. "Love" has multiple forms and using that term might have begged questions and required further definition, which would have gotten in the way of the purpose of the creed, which was meant to be concise. "Truth" has only one form, but is somewhat exclusive of other important attributes of God. "Light" says it best, I think. Light is what it signifies. It is in a way sacramental: it is sensible and it brings those things which one senses in it...sight (which leads to truth, ideally), warmth, joy (which to some extent conjures thoughts of love), etc. Light is more elemental than love or truth, and yet carries as much if not more meaning, and so I think it's a better term to use in human language if you want to concisely point to God.

That's just my two cents.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

In his treatise [i]De Decretis[/i] (no. 23) St. Athanasios indicates that the phrase "Light of Light" refers to the eternal origin of the Son from the Father. In other words, it is connected to the dogmatic confession made by the Nicene Fathers that the Son is [i]homoousios[/i] with the Father:

[quote]Again, the illustration of the Light and the Radiance has this meaning. For the Saints have not said that the Word was related to God as fire kindled from the heat of the sun, which is commonly put out again, for this is an external work and a creature of its author, but they all preach of Him as Radiance, thereby to signify His being from the essence, proper and indivisible, and His oneness with the Father. This also will secure His true unchangableness and immutability; for how can these be His, unless He be proper Offspring of the Father's essence? for this too must be taken to confirm His identity with His own Father. Our explanation then having so religious an aspect, Christ's enemies should not be startled at the 'One in essence,' either, since this term also has a sound sense and good reasons. Indeed, if we say that the Word is from the essence of God (for after what has been said this must be a phrase admitted by them), what does this mean but the truth and eternity of the essence from which He is begotten? for it is not different in kind, lest it be combined with the essence of God as something foreign and unlike it. Nor is He like only outwardly, lest He seem in some respect or wholly to be other in essence, as brass shines like gold and silver like tin. For these are foreign and of other nature, are separated off from each other in nature and virtues, nor is brass proper to gold, nor is the pigeon born from the dove; but though they are considered like, yet they differ in essence. If then it be thus with the Son, let Him be a creature as we are, and not One in essence; but if the Son is Word, Wisdom, Image of the Father, Radiance, He must in all reason be One in essence. For unless it be proved that He is not from God, but an instrument different in nature and different in essence, surely the Council was sound in its doctrine and correct in its decree. [St. Athanasios, [i]De Decretis[/i], no. 23; see also no. 25][/quote]

Posted (edited)

beat me to it todd.

I want to note also, off the top of my head so I cant site. That Origin and Justin Martyr (if not more, I just cant remember and im not at home) also used the image of light for the relationship of Son and Father.

I know this is a side issue, but Could you make the argument that based on what the church was facing at the time the Nicene creed is more developed in its christology than its pneumatology?

Edited by Revprodeji

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...