Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I've been nothing but honest. I'm an honest person. I broke up with him because he lied to me too much about things. But what would writing a letter to his parents do Dust? I've seen him lie to his parents before. It bothered me so friggin much. He's pretty much a compulsive liar. If I were to send a letter, or to make a phone call to his parents, he wouldn't have any problem lying to them about it all. I would be cast off as the villain once again. He's already told them that [i]I[/i] was the bad person in the relationship. How awful is that? His parents are just as bad as he is. They do and will believe anything that comes out of his mouth.

Edited by rachael
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1372148' date='Aug 28 2007, 12:01 AM']Um, I think that's a bad idea.

And totally contrary to the example we're called to set as Christians. For one, it's bearing false witness, which is a violation of a commandment.

For two, we are called to be reconciled to one another. This should always be our goal in our thoughts and actions, even if at the present moment he's not ready for a healthy relationship/friendship whatever and is evidencing it by his behaviors. That's why I recommend that she do what she can to clean her side of the street. If he's unwilling to man up and act in a mature way toward her, she can't do anything about that. But she can control her own actions and treat him in a manner that encourages him to reach for a higher level of behavior. Engaging him in his own actions is an extraordinarily poor choice.[/quote]

[edit] - I'm also thinking of the next person down the line, and I don't believe anyone is required to sacrifice their own protection and/or the protection of others in order to promote reconciliation. As a priest told me in confession when I was angry regarding my wallet being snatched, there is also the virtue of prudence in taking steps to protect one's self.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1372153' date='Aug 28 2007, 12:08 AM']Norse I've been informed I may have misread your intentions here ... that you're advocating not lying about the dude but merely making sure people know he's a liar. If that's the case I apologize for misreading you.

But, I still think it's a mistake to engage him on his turf. Fighting back using the same genre of methods that he did only creates a negative association, in my mind.[/quote]

OK, but I'm also thinking about the next person down the line. I'll go back and edit my statement.

Posted (edited)
:wacko: Edited by rachael
Posted

Who says she's not sticking up for herself? She did break up with him after all. I just don't think fighting him by telling people how awful he is is the best way to go. That is the kind of advice that backfires. Nothing good comes of descending to his level.

And frankly, if I were the next girl, I'd think that rachel had some bone to pick with him still if she made a point of warning me off of him. She should, in my view, keep quiet about him and let him self-destruct all on his own.

With regard to the reconciliation: Yes, contrition is required. But she needs to be prepared in her heart to offer forgiveness should he become truly contrite. Even if reconciliation is not possible now, it may be later.

Posted (edited)

Did I mention that he pretty much cheated on me with an ex of his while we were dating? Yes, that's the girl he's dating now. And that girl has been awful to me as well. I actually tried to forgive and befriend her back when he and I were still dating. Well, that was worthless.

Edited by rachael
Posted

[quote name='rachael' post='1372172' date='Aug 27 2007, 11:23 PM']Did I mention that he pretty much cheated on me with an ex of his while we were dating? Yes, that's the girl he's dating now. And that girl has been awful to me as well. I actually tried to forgive and befriend her. Well, that was worthless.[/quote]
That smells of elderberries. You've tried to do the right thing, and I hope you keep seeking the grace to do that. People sometimes have misplaced loyalties ... nothing you can do about that.

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1372174' date='Aug 28 2007, 12:27 AM']That smells of elderberries. You've tried to do the right thing, and I hope you keep seeking the grace to do that. People sometimes have misplaced loyalties ... nothing you can do about that.[/quote]
I know, but while I keep on trying to do the right thing, I keep on getting beat back down by a guy who just wants to harm me for some strange reason. Why does he wants to do that? I don't get it.

Posted (edited)

Rachel, in previous posts I've given my reasons for sticking up for yourself. Now, I am replying to all the stress you feel in your life as a part of it and would like you to think about the following. Please retain what you feel is worthwhile.

If this is of any comfort, know that a liar always has to come up with lies to cover their other lies, and that at some point their entire life will be devoted to keeping straight all the lies they tell, and one day it can all come crashing down - and it probably will not require you to do anything. On that day the parents will know. You will be vindicated. In the meantime you've got a loyal circle of friends, they know the truth and have your back, others know the truth (and hopefully it will reduce the number of potential victims), you're covering your base and doing the right thing, and [i]you have some vindication already[/i].

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='rachael' post='1372180' date='Aug 27 2007, 11:34 PM']I know, but while I keep on trying to do the right thing, I keep on getting beat back down by a guy who just wants to harm me for some strange reason. Why does he wants to do that? I don't get it.[/quote]
yeah ... this smells of elderberries, but you will just have to come to a point that you accept that some people are just incapable of mature behavior at the point they are at, and hope and pray they eventually come to a point they can act maturely. It could take years. In the meantime you have to focus on your own stuff. Getting angry with him because he doesn't know how to be a grownup does nothing for you. You have to let it go, even if he is not repentant and keeps acting like an @$$ (edit if need be, but I think it's appropriate here). It is not easy, because there will be things that come up that remind you of what a jerk he has been, either things he does or things others do to you. And "letting it go" happens over and over again. Dealing with it is not a quick process when the other person is totally unwilling to be mature. But you still have to deal with it in a way that doesn't leave your soul damaged.

Posted

*sigh* It's been 4 months since this began. I wish it were over by now. Too bad it just seems to be getting worse. Can I get some hugs around here?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='rachael' post='1372208' date='Aug 27 2007, 11:55 PM']*sigh* It's been 4 months since this began. I wish it were over by now. Too bad it just seems to be getting worse. Can I get some hugs around here?[/quote]
You know I'd hug ya if I could. Come to Dallas already!



:console:

Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1372212' date='Aug 28 2007, 12:59 AM']You know I'd hug ya if I could. Come to Dallas already!
:console:[/quote]
get me a ticket!

Posted

what makes the situation even more awkward is that that he's rooming with my best guy friend (who's also my best friend's boyfriend). eek!

Posted

anyways, i just wanted to say thanks to all who have responded. i just needed some insight from people outside of the situation. :)

Posted

Sorry i've come so late to the discussion :monk: :console:

Posted

rachael,
I've known you here on phatmass for awhile (I used to post as jasJis). Lot's of us go through this totally unfair 'attack' from people. Old boy(girl) friends, family, friends, co-workers, acquaintances. One of my daughters has gone through this twice when she had a falling out with two different close friends. The other person manipulates the circle of friends with lies and further harrassed my daughter. The first time my daughter tried many things to defend herself, but nothing seemed to work. After about 8 months, it petered out. The second time, she avoided engaging in the drama as best she could, was cordial when around the other person, and simply was the good person she natually is. From what I know of you, over the years on phatmass, you are definitely a nice, funny, friendly, and good person.

Give up on trying to make things right. It only adds to the drama and keeps things going. As Norseman pointed out, liars and nasty people end up showing their true colors to most people. You will never be able to convince everyone and may lose some friends, but you won't lose the people that are worth having as friends if you act and behave as rachael, the nice, friendly, kind person you really are. You aren't perfect, so you will take a few hits from this jerk. Accept that and move on. Rely on your real friends to support you and remind you what a decent person you are. Don't let this jerk drag you down.

Unfortunatley, I'm too far away to offer to blacken an eye or cause tears for you like I would do for my 4 sisters and 2 daughters when boy friends become jerks. I would tell the boy friends if you make my sister or daughter cry, be assured, I can make you cry harder. (you know I'm just kinda kidding on that, trying to lighten things up) kinda, really.

I really believe you are being treated meanly and unfairly by someone who has succumbed to evil temptations in a painful situation. Don't allow temptation for vengance, (or your version of 'justice') lead you astray and fall into the trap of engaging in wickedness yourself.

God loves you and there are plenty who know the real you that like and respect you as a great person. Cheer up.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1372280' date='Aug 28 2007, 07:23 AM']Give up on trying to make things right. It only adds to the drama and keeps things going. As Norseman pointed out, liars and nasty people end up showing their true colors to most people. You will never be able to convince everyone and may lose some friends, but you won't lose the people that are worth having as friends if you act and behave as rachael, the nice, friendly, kind person you really are. You aren't perfect, so you will take a few hits from this jerk. Accept that and move on. Rely on your real friends to support you and remind you what a decent person you are. Don't let this jerk drag you down.

I really believe you are being treated meanly and unfairly by someone who has succumbed to evil temptations in a painful situation. Don't allow temptation for vengance, (or your version of 'justice') lead you astray and fall into the trap of engaging in wickedness yourself.

God loves you and there are plenty who know the real you that like and respect you as a great person. Cheer up.[/quote]

i agree - a liar's true colors will come out in the end, and in the meantime, your true friends will rise to the surface and be there for you. sorry you have to go through this, but i also think that there may be a blessing in all of this - you are getting a taste of what Jesus had to go through (rejected by those who knew Him because of lies). this can be a great opportunity for you to grow even closer to Jesus. Peace to you!

Posted

thanks y'all. i just really wish he would grow up and start acting like the 21-year-old that he really is because it i just want to move on with my life already. <_<

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...