Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

Reading this thread make me realize how fortunate I am. I have never had a problem scheduling a confession. There was only one time that Fr told me he didn't have any free time, and it would be a couple days. I told him it wasn't a problem, and I was able to call another priest who's number was in my phone. He was so glad to hear from me he took me to lunch afterwards.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1373474' date='Aug 29 2007, 11:55 AM']Rev,

I wonder if you should be looking for is a spiritual director rather than trying to hammer all these issues out in confession. IT can be but does not have to be a priest. This website might help you.

[url="http://www.sdiworld.org/finding_a_spiritual_director.html"]http://www.sdiworld.org/finding_a_spiritual_director.html[/url]

also

[url="http://catholicspiritualdirection.org/"]http://catholicspiritualdirection.org/[/url][/quote]

Say what? Interesting...

[quote]Your frustration over the other participants' possible attitudes should not lead you to disregard Church Law. If it does you may want to question how justified your attitude is.[/quote]
Might just be my own interpretation. But are you challenging me here? My attitude isn’t a justifiable matter. It’s my attitude. It’s based on something and ignoring that something to conform is not "something" I'm looking to do. If I had an infection on my arm I could either choose to ignore it or do something about it. But I don’t need someone questioning the justification of my attitude. As a convert I got some beefs to work out. The fact is the church looks great on paper and in paper until I actually go on Sunday. It’s a funky buyer’s remorse.

[quote]However, Sacraments are not about 'feeling'. If the host didn't 'feel' like Christ would it make it any less the body, blood, soul and divinity of our Lord? No. It is dangerous to base the validity and importance of religious experiences on feelings.[/quote]

It isn’t a magic spell. If I don’t "feel" change it doesn’t seem valid to me. If I don’t think the priest is engaged in it I doubt it is valid. The Eucharistic analogy is poor because the essence and attributes of the host are different. Eucharistic theology is strikingly Aristotellian where as confession isn’t. You go ahead and tell me what makes a confession valid.

Feelings are not wrong if the thing that produces them is not wrong. My feelings of discomfort here are due to what I feel is a serious problem with the mass in my area. If my wife was mugged I would have strong feelings, when she comes home and says "I love you" I have strong feelings also. Feelings are only dangerous if we refuse to look to the reasoning behind them. Or if we pursue an emotional ecstasy at the expense of "meat and potatoes"(shout out thes) I don’t believe in any form I am doing that here. But to say I miss the realness, the relationships and the devotion that I saw from the protestant churches I grew up in, lead in, but do not see in the catholic churches is not a hippy emotional response. It is a genuine concern.

I like your paper bag analogy. I like that alot. And that diamond is the only reason I have not found a justification to go back to the other team.

beatty, thanks for going to Augustine. It is weird, I forgot about ex opere operantis. but you reminded me. thank you.

Im sorry for venting. its just a tough transistion from a protestant church were there are relationships and people using the limited grace to its extent and then seeing the catholic church with all the tools and grace and it doesnt seem like the people care as much.

Posted

Its almost like I would want my kids to be evangelical first so they can understand the realness and the change and priority it takes in your life even once you leave church. But then as they get older I could grow them into catholics.

Posted (edited)

[quote]It’s based on something and ignoring that something to conform is not "something" I'm looking to do[/quote]

You took my quote out of context. In your OP you were not clear if this problem was keeping you from your obligation of participating in Sunday Mass or if you were referring to non-obligatory Masses such as weekday Mass. I was expressing my concern over whether this was drawing you to commit mortal sin.

Edited by Blessed Imelda Pray for Us
Posted (edited)

All I can say is I understand. Sometimes it's all we can do to surpress contempt and judgmental-ness, much less pray. I'm a little more understanding now that I'm presiding at Mass...I've done things out of inexperience that would have really ruffled my feathers as a congregant! But it's hard to bear when there's no sense of reverence (/community/worship/devotion/insert pet liturgical peeve here) at Mass.

Some things helped me: I would take those feelings and accuse myself, remembering how inadequate my own reverence and devotion were to the glory of God and the gift of the Eucharist. I'd internally pray "Jesus, forgive us for being so lukewarm." The "us" there is pretty important - when it becomes "them" we're in trouble. Also, I used to think about how probably at least one of these old folks who quietly attend Church with me are saints! They're easy not to notice amid the chaos.

When you talk about the Church looking good on paper, are you referencing Newman? He used that language, but as an argument in favor of the Church. The Catholic Church is not a theory, or a theological abstraction. It's a thing, that exists. Which is why it's so darn messy. The perfect Church, whose members are perfectly devoted and whose hierarchy never sins, exists only on paper. Newman praised the Catholic Church precisely for not being a "paper Church."

That doesn't excuse anything, I know, but it might be helpful to think about. That, and Groucho Marx's "I refuse to join any club that would have me as a member."

Edited by beatty07
Posted

"on paper" is because Im a theologian by nature. I was in the proto community and I am trying to here as well. I own hundreds of books and read constantly. My conversion came theologically before it actually was apparent I would need to "go" to mass.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1373447' date='Aug 29 2007, 12:17 PM']Yes that is a ridiculously small time slot.

But if someone is going to the scheduled time for confession and can't get it done in under 15 minutes, (s)he hasn't been properly catechized on confession. A lot of folks confuse confession with spiritual direction, which is too bad. Now if someone schedules a private confession time and wants to go into greater depth of their struggles, no problem. You don't have a line of folks behind you.

I'm not advocating an "express line" mentality when going to confession. But during scheduled public times, I wish more folks spent time prior to confession thinking through the whole process and getting a list done. While I'm not privy to what's going on there, I know there's a few folks who are starting off with "Bless me father for I have sinned. Let's see......"[/quote]

Well, sometimes the most catechized have a lot to confess or have something really big to confess and it takes time. Besides, people come there literally bearing their souls, and for everyone, despite their education, it is not easy for them. So, to rush them in and out seems almost irreverent, because they thought it important enough to go to confession, sometimes for the most venial of sins, yet to them, it hurts, and they are looking for consolation, they are looking for hope. For them to come in, me to say, ok, good, do this, "I absolve you," in my opinion, makes light of something weighing upon their soul. Some people you can deal with quickly, mostly because they are silent the whole time, but most really need something, if even that extra 3 or 5 minutes.

Like you said, you are not privy to what goes on, and you see things a lot differently as the priest than the one waiting in line, and if you really want to be the instrument of mercy, most of the time, for the best to the worst, the most catechized and those who have no idea why they are there, they all need that moment, because it is moment of grace, of transformation, and you don't nor should you rush that. Even when they come 5 minutes before Mass, as I am literally trying to get out of the confessional, I will tell them that I have to say Mass, however, I will spend the time they need, and if it goes too long, I ask them or encourage them to see me after Mass or privately, but, you have to remember, more often than not, they need that time and far be it from me to deprive that of them, even if it makes me late or has others who need to come back. I don't think it is rude, because I give everyone that same moment of grace, and time is irrelevant where the sacraments are concerned.

Just my .02 from one who spend a lot of time in the confessional :)

Noel's angel
Posted

You're my hero.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1374055' date='Aug 30 2007, 03:24 PM']If I don’t "feel" change it doesn’t seem valid to me. If I don’t think the priest is engaged in it I doubt it is valid.[/quote]

During the summer term I often get up before dawn and go out into the college gardens to pray. It's not light when I go out. I am usually there for about forty minutes.

Once I sat down on my bench in the darkness and began my silent prayer. My eyes were open. I was awake. After fifteen minutes of this I moved onto rosary...and midway through the fourth decade I realised that the sun had risen.

The whole garden was bathed in early light. The sun was glowing on the brickwork of the chapel. I could see all the way across the gardens and the central courtyard. I hadn't noticed the sunrise coming. It didn't happen in a moment, with a single and astonishing blaze of light. It crept up on me very gradually. It occurred to me then that this is what my prayer is like: I may not notice anything different at the time, I may think I'm struggling against the same old sins and falling into the same old traps, I may not 'feel' anything worth speaking of.

But the change is happening. Even if I don't notice it at the time.

The same goes for Confession. I have come out of the confessional feeling frustrated and disgruntled because the 'experience' wasn't right or the priest gave bad advice. Looking back, I can see that those times were lessons in patience - and in blessed ordinariness. "God, thank you that you ignore my standards when you come to me. If you tried to live up to them, I'd never see you."

Posted

I love the morning pray story sir.

Maybe it is buyers remorse. maybe I just have bad luck finding a parish? Its just a tough thing right now. I see the pictures of the traditional masses that L_D posts, or I hear the details of the byzantine mass from Todd and I crave that.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1379517' date='Sep 6 2007, 09:29 AM']I love the morning pray story sir.

Maybe it is buyers remorse. maybe I just have bad luck finding a parish? Its just a tough thing right now. I see the pictures of the traditional masses that L_D posts, or I hear the details of the byzantine mass from Todd and I crave that.[/quote]
i totally feel your pain! :ohno: as you know, i've had some bad experiences lately, and nothing seems to be getting better and we're currently without a bishop, so everything is static. i'll keep you in my prayers, and offer my suffering at these Masses up for you and your situation :)

Posted

thanks red. My wife works every other sunday (i know she should not, but she works for an altezmers (sp) place and the old people need lovin on sundays too. ANyway, it makes it so we cant drive out of state as we have been doing for every other sunday.

I just want a place to go and pray. Watch a movie like constantine or any video game and that is the catholic church they have. Why cant we?

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1379566' date='Sep 6 2007, 10:40 AM']I just want a place to go and pray. Watch a movie like constantine or any video game and that is the catholic church they have. Why cant we?[/quote]
:idontknow: :ohno: i don't know. it is sad. most of the parishes in my diocese have not even implemented [i]Redemptionis Sacramentum[/i], because our bishop (before he retired) said he would wait a year - then he retired and now nobody is being held accountable.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...