Didacus Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 Ok, so recently I made a deal with one of my friends; I read one of his recommended books, and I'll read one of his. I selected for his reading; "Confessions" by Saint Augustine his selection: "Camp of the Saints" by Jean Raspail, written in 1973 (original language: french, but I read it in english) I don't know how many people around here would have this type of reading. If anyone has read it let me know, I'd love to hear your thoughts. The book itself is pretty hard-core, and thoroughly racist and hateful in just about every paragraph. I would not recommend this reading myself unless I know the person is mature, stable and well balanced in his/her views and ideas. *NOT MADE FOR TEENAGE READING IMHO*. So now that I'm done with the disclaimer, my questions: If one million person, bent on your destruction, would land at your border, would it be acceptable to use millitary power and deadly force to defend yourself even though they are not armed? I'm a little hard pressed to provide a reply myself. Lets say a group of person forced their way, uninvited into my home, took over the property, destroyed my property, raped my wife, killed my children and then burned down my house. At what point would I be justified to use deadly force to defend myself and my family's interest? What if they were unarmed? Another question; if I have a gun, but 10 men don't have any weapons but their hands. They rush me with the obvious intent of killing me. I have my back to the wall and can't run, can't hide. Even though my attackers do not have guns or other form of weapons, cna their number be considered a weapon on their own? Would I be justifed in self defense to use my gun and deadly force to defend myself? If ayone can give me a little guidance and constructive reflections on this subject matter it would be very appreciated, God bless and thank you. didace
CatherineM Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 I think everyone asks themselves at some point would they be capable of taking a life if it was necessary. I don't know if I could or not, and probably will never know unless it happens to me. I asked my dad once if he regretted what he did during the war. He said he regretted that it was necessary. I don't believe there is such a thing as an "unarmed" person, unless they are literally without arms. The first recorded murder was accomplished with just his hands. I believe that you are allowed to defend yourself and your loved ones. I don't think you should kill to protect just things. The US Constitution lists life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. There's a reason they are in that order of importance. I believe I could take a life to protect my life, or my husband's. I would be willing to use extreme force that I hope wouldn't result in death to protect our physical well being. I hope that I would never use extreme force to protect my material processions. If 10 men rush you with intent to do you in, I hope you have that many bullets in your gun, and can shoot fast. I wouldn't have time to say a whole prayer, but I could start one, and finish it on the other side.
Didacus Posted September 3, 2007 Author Posted September 3, 2007 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1376931' date='Sep 3 2007, 10:59 AM']I think everyone asks themselves at some point would they be capable of taking a life if it was necessary. I don't know if I could or not, and probably will never know unless it happens to me. I asked my dad once if he regretted what he did during the war. He said he regretted that it was necessary.[/quote] Your father seems very wise; separating the act from its necessity. His intent was not to cause harm, but to defend (or other). I think that is a big part of the equation; intent. [quote name='CatherineM' post='1376931' date='Sep 3 2007, 10:59 AM']I don't believe there is such a thing as an "unarmed" person, unless they are literally without arms. The first recorded murder was accomplished with just his hands. I believe that you are allowed to defend yourself and your loved ones. I don't think you should kill to protect just things. The US Constitution lists life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. There's a reason they are in that order of importance. I believe I could take a life to protect my life, or my husband's. I would be willing to use extreme force that I hope wouldn't result in death to protect our physical well being. I hope that I would never use extreme force to protect my material processions.[/quote] I agree; a life is never worth material possessions, ever. This becomes a deeper question if the material possession is required to maintain life. If someone would steel the air I breathe, thogh he indirectly attacks my life, he attacks my life none the less since without air I cannot live. [quote name='CatherineM' post='1376931' date='Sep 3 2007, 10:59 AM']If 10 men rush you with intent to do you in, I hope you have that many bullets in your gun, and can shoot fast. I wouldn't have time to say a whole prayer, but I could start one, and finish it on the other side.[/quote] Ammunition is like gum in school. If you don't bring enough for everyone, you're in trouble. The instinctive side of me says to shoot to kill as many possible prior to dying myself. I would not want to go silently in such a case. But I do have my doubts. The reflective side of me says not to cause harm, even though harm is intended. If only for myself, I think I actualy would let myself be killed rather than kill. However, put one of my children in back of me, and I most definately will shoot, relfective side or not. I can willingly choose to die (or let myself be killed), but I cannot escape my duty of protecting my son. However, this seems contradictory. I would not use lethal force to defend my life, yet I would to defend the life of my son. Why would the duty towards my own life be smaller than the duty towards my son's life? I can't explain it, but I believe that is how I would choose.
WillT Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1377113' date='Sep 3 2007, 03:34 PM']Ammunition is like gum in school. If you don't bring enough for everyone, you're in trouble.[/quote] I like that quote. Even if there are ten attackers and you only have 6 bullets, you have a much better chance of surviving a fight with 4 attackers trying to kill you than a fight with ten. [quote name='Didacus' post='1377113' date='Sep 3 2007, 03:34 PM']The reflective side of me says not to cause harm, even though harm is intended. If only for myself, I think I actualy would let myself be killed rather than kill. However, put one of my children in back of me, and I most definately will shoot, relfective side or not. I can willingly choose to die (or let myself be killed), but I cannot escape my duty of protecting my son. However, this seems contradictory. I would not use lethal force to defend my life, yet I would to defend the life of my son. Why would the duty towards my own life be smaller than the duty towards my son's life? I can't explain it, but I believe that is how I would choose.[/quote] The way I think of it is that my son is always behind me. I have a duty to be there for him as much as possible, even if that means killing an attacker. I guess I'm colored a little by my background as a martial artist, the whole point of which is self-defence. In a situation where I'm being attacked and the attacker has obvious intenet to kill, I'm willing to do anything I need to in order to go home that night even if it means doing whatever I have to to make the attacker unable to return home. He just picked the wrong guy to attack and I don't feel responsible for that.
Didacus Posted September 4, 2007 Author Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='WillT' post='1377882' date='Sep 4 2007, 02:25 PM']I like that quote. Even if there are ten attackers and you only have 6 bullets, you have a much better chance of surviving a fight with 4 attackers trying to kill you than a fight with ten. The way I think of it is that my son is always behind me. I have a duty to be there for him as much as possible, even if that means killing an attacker. I guess I'm colored a little by my background as a martial artist, the whole point of which is self-defence. In a situation where I'm being attacked and the attacker has obvious intenet to kill, I'm willing to do anything I need to in order to go home that night even if it means doing whatever I have to to make the attacker unable to return home. He just picked the wrong guy to attack and I don't feel responsible for that.[/quote] What if a million of them attacked a hundred of you. would you fire your gun and defend yourself as best you can even though it would kill a million?
WillT Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1377908' date='Sep 4 2007, 02:56 PM']What if a million of them attacked a hundred of you. would you fire your gun and defend yourself as best you can even though it would kill a million?[/quote] If they are the agressors I see no problem. Numbers don't matter in this situation, just intent. If my intent is to defend myself (or ourselves per the latest example) it doesn't matter if it's ten or ten million.
Didacus Posted September 6, 2007 Author Posted September 6, 2007 WillT; what do you say to those people who think violence is wrong regardless of circumstance? I see violence as a tool myself. I teach it to my kids even! Violence is not something to be ignored, it is to be understood and controlled (its part of everyone, human life in general), and used if needed. Like any tool, violence can be used for good or for evil.
WillT Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1379385' date='Sep 6 2007, 06:55 AM']WillT; what do you say to those people who think violence is wrong regardless of circumstance? I see violence as a tool myself. I teach it to my kids even! Violence is not something to be ignored, it is to be understood and controlled (its part of everyone, human life in general), and used if needed. Like any tool, violence can be used for good or for evil.[/quote] I say much the same thing that you have. The only thing I would add is the respomsibility that comes along with making yourself capable of violence. For instance, if you live in an area where carrying a gun is legal and you choose to do so, you have a huge responsibility to know how, when, and where to use it along with how, when , and where not to use it. Same thing with martial arts training, or even just training in boxing for sport. If you're a highly trained martial artist, you have a responsibility not to go pick a fight with a drunk guy in a bar because one of you is going to be injured. As a flip side of the same coin, if you're a highly trained martial artist (or gun carrier) you have a duty to use that to protect yourself and others so if you see a guy trying to steal an old lady's purse, you don't just walk by and allow it to happen.
Didacus Posted September 6, 2007 Author Posted September 6, 2007 We are in complete agreement WillT. To protect one's self is a duty. To protect others is an equal (or greater?) duty. But Jesus rejected violence all-together. How does one consolidate using violence based on Jesus' example? That is a question I have trouble with.
WillT Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1379619' date='Sep 6 2007, 12:37 PM']We are in complete agreement WillT. To protect one's self is a duty. To protect others is an equal (or greater?) duty. But Jesus rejected violence all-together. How does one consolidate using violence based on Jesus' example? That is a question I have trouble with.[/quote] I don't think Jesus rejected violence all-together. I mean driving people out of the Temple with a whip is pretty violent. Also telling the Apostles that whoever didn't own a sword should sell is clothes and buy one seems to suggest at least the apearence of being able to commit violence is ok. It seems to me that He didn't use vilence in many cases because He is God. He knew with a perfrct knowledge when and where to use violence and when and where not to. If we had that same perfect knowledge I'm sure we would use violence a lot less. He knew, for example, that His Crucifixion was God's plan and that it should happen so it wouldn't make sense for him to use violence to get out of that situation. He also knew that driving people out of the Temple with a whip was God's will too, so He used violence. Unfortunately we do not have that perfect knowlege so we just have to do the best we can to use violence with justice.
Didacus Posted September 6, 2007 Author Posted September 6, 2007 I would be very interested in the point of view from a church scholar or two.
WillT Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='Didacus' post='1379862' date='Sep 6 2007, 04:55 PM']I would be very interested in the point of view from a church scholar or two.[/quote] Indeed. Here's what the Catechism says (I bolded the parts I thought were most important etc.): Legitimate defense 2263 The legitimate defense of persons and societies is not an exception to the prohibition against the murder of the innocent that constitutes intentional killing. [b]"The act of self-defense can have a double effect: the preservation of one's own life; and the killing of the aggressor. . . . The one is intended, the other is not."65[/b] 2264 Love toward oneself remains a fundamental principle of morality. Therefore it is legitimate to insist on respect for one's own right to life. [b]Someone who defends his life is not guilty of murder even if he is forced to deal his aggressor a lethal blow:[/b] If a man in self-defense uses more than necessary violence, it will be unlawful: whereas if he repels force with moderation, his defense will be lawful. . . . [b]Nor is it necessary for salvation that a man omit the act of moderate self-defense to avoid killing the other man, since one is bound to take more care of one's own life than of another's.66[/b] 2265 [b]Legitimate defense can be not only a right but a grave duty for one who is responsible for the lives of others.[/b] The defense of the common good requires that an unjust aggressor be rendered unable to cause harm. For this reason, those who legitimately hold authority also have the right to use arms to repel aggressors against the civil community entrusted to their responsibility. This makes it clear to me that if, as far as I can know, someone is attacking me with the intention of killing me or those under my protection I can legitimately kill them. If they are not, as far as I know, trying to kill me then I can still defend myself but without using lethal force.
Didacus Posted September 9, 2007 Author Posted September 9, 2007 Thanks for the references WillT, and I would say that those quotes do portrai very well my thinking. Have there been any saints that may have written on this matter?
CatholicCid Posted September 23, 2007 Posted September 23, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Didacus' post='1377113' date='Sep 3 2007, 03:34 PM']I would not use lethal force to defend my life, yet I would to defend the life of my son. Why would the duty towards my own life be smaller than the duty towards my son's life? I can't explain it, but I believe that is how I would choose.[/quote] On this point, I'd like to take a shot at explaining it. As Christ said, man can give no greater gift then to lay down his life for another. This is selfless love, the very love Christ exhibits for us on the Cross. When it is soley your life on the line, you would be willing to give it up if the only chance of saving it would to be lethal force on your attacker(s). Even though one would be justified in using lethal force if necessary to protect their own life, choosing to not do so I believe would be justified as well if one cannot bring themselve to do it (use lethal force that is). I would question if this might be seen as an act of charity, as you would allow the agressor(s) the chance at repentance by not using lethal force when they appear to be turned from God and have hate in their heart. However, when you are in a situation where you must protect your son or someone else, you would be willing to fight back and use lethal force if necessary. I would see this as an example of being willing to "lay down your life for another". Though, in this example you would not be losing your life, you would be fighting to protect another and in essence are willing to lay down your life if necessary to protect innocents. Just my 2 cents on that situation. On this topic overall, I believe a slightly modified version of St. Augustine's Just War theory could be applied in such situations. The first two criteria I believe could be blended together. "Just Authority" and "Just Cause" would be met as you are not the aggresor and that the ones' attacking have the intent to kill you make self defense just. "Right Intention" would be met as well as you are taking action to protect your own life against the murderous intent of others. Lethal force would be used in the "Last Resort" criteria. If the only way to protect your own life would be to use lethal force, then it would be the 'last resort'. This topic also has me wondering on a different situation I remember thinking about that is vaguely connected, so I believe it would be appropriate to toss in for discussion. A while back there was an article about a group of Christians meeting in a house for prayer. A militant group broke into the house and forced all the Christians there to, I believe, sign a sheet renouncing their prayer and possibly religion under the threat of death for all gathered. It was something along those lines. My thought on this was: Could I be willing to say "No" to the men when I know that my direct decision would also cost other people their own lives. While I hope, if the time called for it, I would be willing to give up my life for Christ, I do not believe I could willingly do so if I knew accepting my own martydom would also force other's to take up this cross whether they are willing to do so or not. Edited September 23, 2007 by CatholicCid
Didacus Posted October 7, 2007 Author Posted October 7, 2007 Thanks for your comments Cid. On account of selflessness, I think you're definately on to something. You've put into words what I was thinking but couldn't really define. Could someone offer a link to Augustine's 'just war' writtings? Is there a pdf file floating around out there I might get a hold of? The example you mention might be the one about a year ago where muslims in a muslim nation forced their way into a private home and forced those inside to sign a paper saying they would halt their praying the rosary? Like yourself, I hope if this time should ever come to me that I would havfe the strength to deny them my signature. Remember, Islam is a religion of peace.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now