Chaya Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 last week i announced to my family that i had taken the neccessary steps to finally fully embrace the catholic faith. i am already receiving communion though, after discussing with the priest. as soon as my hubby comes home from hospital, the priest will come to our home to discuss with us the baptism of our children.my hubby is calvinist and still somewhat reticent (he wants them to get vaptised when they can decide it he says. Naomi has been asking for two years now--) but i think he'll agree. i hope so. anyways, when i told my family, except for my mother -who fully understands me and supports me, pondering on conversion herself every now and then but having trouble with Our Mother Mary- they were all shocked. my gramma -who is lutheran but not practicing anything- even almost hung up the phone telling me that now she has to sit down and digest it. except for the very few and rare catholic and orthodox friends, just about all friends are shocked, or against it, often advancing the latest Motu proprio of Benedict XVI on the churches and the status of protestant churches. and the thing is that i agree with all he said on the Church and protestant denominations. for those of you who converted, how did your friends and family take it? i was afraid that becoming catholic would be kinda 'treason' towards my jewish ancestry, and with time i have found so many jewish things within catholicism, so much acceptance --that now it is aberrant. they are all protestants and feel 'betrayed' even if they are not practicing and never have, don't even go to church for christmas or easter or anything...
homeschoolmom Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 Been there.... To answer your question-- not well.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 I'm not a convert, but I can understand the general disgust some people have when they find out you're a practicing Catholic... It's definitely a form or martyrdom. Oh, just a side note, the motu proprio and the document on the status of non-Catholic churches were two separate documents on different topics. The first was on liturgy, the second was on ecclesiology. The thing is, though, that the second document didn't change anything...it just restated what the Church has always taught, so I don't know why people get so upset over it. As for your Jewish ancestry, I have some as well, and I am increasingly convinced that Christianity is the fulfillment of God's plan for the Jewish people and the whole world. I mean, He meant them to draw all nations to themselves and they failed (not that we were any better...while some of my ancestors were Jews, most of my ancestors were worshipping oak trees [German] and practicing human sacrifice [Irish])...and that's what the Church does. In fact, that issue with the Blessed Virgin...well...all of those doctrines make a lot more sense in light of Jewish teachings. Being a Catholic in the world is difficult, but there are many supporting friends you will find in parishes. God bless, Micah
Chaya Posted September 3, 2007 Author Posted September 3, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1377084' date='Sep 3 2007, 11:08 PM']Oh, just a side note, the motu proprio and the document on the status of non-Catholic churches were two separate documents on different topics. The first was on liturgy, the second was on ecclesiology.[/quote] ahhh... mixed them up actually people are also making quite a fuzz about the mass in latin... as to the non-catholic churches, i tell them that the catholic church has been saying that always. the answer is: well that proves they are sectarian and dangerous... i wonder why being a practising Catholic provokes such disgust? any ideas except the opposition light/darkness? my ancestors, as i have recently found out are (i am 3/4 jewish yet not jewish as my maternal grandmother is the only one who isn't jewish but swiss) jewish (from france/germany and algeria) and egyptian et nubian/ethiopian.
PapaHilarious Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 i entered the Church at the vigil of 2006. my mother cried and said she never wanted to talk about it again. my father was more supportive, though he preferred to only talk about things we had in common. (him being an evangelical.) since my father passed, though, my mother has softened considerably. she'll ask questions from time to time, which is a big step in the right direction, so i can't complain. the first step for me to appreciate Catholicism, after all, was knocking down my walls of prejudice and misinformation.
AlterDominicus Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 Um....well, I dont realy remember at first it seemed like God was calling me to be a nun as oppose to my actual conversion and I told my now Godparents about it, and they were happy and its funny because when I was at their house on the day I told them we were watching the Sound of Music and I hoped me mom wouldnt call and she did for whatever reason and mom seemed to be okie doke. Okie, sorry what I just said doesnt make any sense does it? Basically in a nut shell the rule in the family is when you turn 14 you can choose whatever faith or religion your heart so desires, thats why I'm the only Catholic in the family and everyone else is different to.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 [quote name='Chaya' post='1377123' date='Sep 3 2007, 04:43 PM'] ahhh... mixed them up actually people are also making quite a fuzz about the mass in latin... as to the non-catholic churches, i tell them that the catholic church has been saying that always. the answer is: well that proves they are sectarian and dangerous... i wonder why being a practising Catholic provokes such disgust? any ideas except the opposition light/darkness? my ancestors, as i have recently found out are (i am 3/4 jewish yet not jewish as my maternal grandmother is the only one who isn't jewish but swiss) jewish (from france/germany and algeria) and egyptian et nubian/ethiopian.[/quote] As to the Latin liturgy thing, most of the people who knock it simply haven't tried it. It's beautiful and well worth attending, if for nothing but to see the way things used to be ordinarily. As for the "sectarian and dangerous" thing, I think that's silly. On the contrary, Jesus prayed that we would all be one. That prayer, in an imperfect way, is already true, but as with so many things in theology (the Kingdom of God, for instance), it is "already here, but not yet completely here." That unity already exists, fully in the Church in heaven, largely in the Catholic Church on earth, and in an imperfect way, in the general Christian body of the faithful. The Catholic Church teaches that there is only one Church...something that must be true if we believe Christ's prayer had any effect...but that some are not perfectly bound to it. In any case, to call them "Churches" would give the illusion that there are more than one Church, and that is simply false. So we are only acknowledging what is true from Scripture (there is only one universal Church) and what is clear from logic (those who do not believe the same as that Church are not perfectly connected to that Church, but are connected to the degree that they follow the Christian faith). I really don't think it's sectarian or dangerous, on the contrary, it's unitive, because only by acknowledging this truth first can we open the door to authentic dialogue, and it's careful because it doesn't make empty claims, such as that we are already perfectly one. As such, it is not at all sectarian or dangerous.\ The rest of this turned into a bit of a rant, but I think it's worth saying anyway...keep in mind that I do not mean to condemn anyone...in a way, we are all victims of the way we were raised, temptations, etc., and so we should treat everyone with compassion...at the same time, we all cooperate with those evils...that's what sin is, of course...so it is something that seriously needs to be addressed... As for the reasons that practicing Catholics are viewed with disgust...there are several reasons. First, practicing Christians in general are viewed with disgust by the secular world. Second, many practicing Christians are not practicing as much as they should be and are trying to...well, to serve two masters (and this goes for Catholics as well as anyone else). Such people often view those who are committed to Christ (albeit imperfectly carrying out that commitment) with contempt. If a committed Christian believes in a "hard teaching," others don't care much for him because he's "a wacko" or because he "takes it a little too far." Then you have the saints, who are thoroughly Catholic, and I highly suspect that most non-Catholics, at least the hostile ones, view the saints as Catholic radicals, "wackos" to the extreme, except, of course, for the saints it is politically correct to love (St. Francis of Assisi, Bl. Mother Theresa, etc.), because no one wants to speak against those saints, but any saint such as St. Thomas Aquinas, virtually any of the papal saints, and others who were very identifiably Catholic, are all to be seen as completely out of their minds. The reason: they serve only one Master. They show us what we should be doing, but, too often, we try to dismiss them so that we don't have to live up to that standard. Likewise, anyone still alive who is committed to becoming holy is dismissed as a wacko for similar reasons by those who serve two masters. Notice, however, that as soon as a person desires to be committed to Christ, they begin to admire the saints, and they grow more and more in love with them the more committed they are to Christ. It is because the saints are images of Christ. This only goes to show that if Christ came today, He would still have been crucified by those who were supposed to follow Him, abandoned by those who wanted to serve Him and also serve another master, and followed only by those closest to Him: those who were considered radicals. To the secular world, to be a committed, practicing Catholic is radical...and radical is the only thing unacceptable in our age, because it means not being able to be swayed by everything around you...it means being a master of yourself and being your own person, so that you do not go with the flow. G.K. Chesterton said, "only something truly alive can swim against the tide." St. Irenaeus said, "the glory of God is man fully alive." Practicing Catholics are hated because the radical life we have and celebrate makes others uncomfortable around us...but we can catch them on fire, so we shouldn't lose hope. With prayer, we can be examples to those who otherwise would not make that commitment. They need to see the joy we have as committed Catholics, something they don't often see because the media and others have convinced them that being radical means giving up fun. It's not true: it means giving up the second master, but the first Master is the source of all joy; He alone can give us true and lasting joy. So those who hate us...we should willingly suffer martyrdom for them in life, offering their jeers, looks, and insults, and showing them that we have enough joy even to continue being radical after that. Those are the secular people who are disgusted by Catholics. Others are disgusted because they were raised to be disgusted...they follow their own faith and are even radical in following it, but their faith has been completely turned against Catholics...and that is a matter that seriously concerns me. If the faith with which a person is raised is almost entirely anti-Catholic jargon, that person is being led away from Catholicism, but is that person being led toward anything? As for the Jewish ancestry, did you know we have some Jewish saints...one of whom died in a concentration camp? St. Edith Stein...she was a philosopher and a nun...interesting story. God bless, Micah PS-I didn't mean to give the impression that I am a radically committed Catholic...but I mean to be.
CatherineM Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 My mom is a convert. My grandmother was a seriously devout Baptist, and gave my mom all levels of hell about it. The closest she came to acceptance, was when I graduated, and she begrudgingly told my mom that the nuns gave us a pretty good education. About 20 years ago my church's womens group sponsored a seminarian who was a convert. His family completely cut him off. You have to do what you are called to do. Everyone is given crosses, some are just heavier. The most important thing as a mother is that you are not just responsible for your soul, you are responsible for your children's souls as well. You don't let your children choose to eat ice cream at every meal, or wear bathing suits outside in the snow. There are some decisions that you just can't leave up to kids to make. I've seen couples that wait and let their kids decide, and it never ends well. Most of the kids pick none of the above.
Dreamweaver Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 Hi, I come from a Lutheran background, and I joined the Church in 2002. God used my (then) boyfriend to show me His Church, and his parents were very helpful in explaining a lot of the questions I had, particularly those about Mary and the saints. I remember I first wanted to become Catholic right after attending the Good Friday service; so I basically had to wait a whole year before fully becoming Catholic and receiving the sacraments at the Easter Vigil service the next year! My parents weren't too thrilled that I was joining (we attended church services every other week or so, so they were never really very serious), and my grandfather was a bit upset. My other grandfather was happy, since is also Catholic. Eventually for a number of reasons, I broke up with my ex, but continued to be friends with him and especially his parents. His mom was my sponsor and I think of them as "adoptive Godparents" of sorts. This proved to my family that I was serious about my new faith, and it wasn't just to "win him over" or anything. My parents are cool with my decision, and they'll even attend Mass with me as visitors when we visit each other.
Archaeology cat Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 Hi, I was raised Southern Baptist, then spent a few years as a charismatic Methodist before converting. My parents were fine with it, really, since they knew that I'd prayed a lot about it. And they go to Mass with me when they're in. I lucked out, really. Now, I did have some friends who were more upset with my decision, but I generally just told them that this was not a decision I'd made lightly, that I had spent hours in prayer and study, and this is where God has led me. Usually they stopped debating at that point.
Chaya Posted September 4, 2007 Author Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1377139' date='Sep 4 2007, 12:15 AM']to be a committed, practicing Catholic is radical...and radical is the only thing unacceptable in our age, because it means not being able to be swayed by everything around you...it means being a master of yourself and being your own person, so that you do not go with the flow.[/quote] i agree wholeheartedly with what you've said. interestingly, the 'sectarian thing' mostly came from evangelicals - who wouldn't see that if anything, their church is sectarian, not the Catholic Church. when i lived for a year in CA, i was shocked by all the anti-catholic feeling and speech in free churches and such. like a woman who testified "i once was catholic but now i'm christian. please pray for my parents as they are still devout catholics" - but then here, i've heard old people from an evangelical church say that the pope is the devil. this shocks me for obvious reasons, but it also hurts a lot. do you know of any other jewish saints besides Edith Stein? *grin* i was thinking about that whilst getting ready to hospital: a jewish saint? Saint Paul!
Chaya Posted September 4, 2007 Author Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1377141' date='Sep 4 2007, 12:18 AM']The most important thing as a mother is that you are not just responsible for your soul, you are responsible for your children's souls as well. You don't let your children choose to eat ice cream at every meal, or wear bathing suits outside in the snow. There are some decisions that you just can't leave up to kids to make. I've seen couples that wait and let their kids decide, and it never ends well. Most of the kids pick none of the above.[/quote] yes, and this is why i'm grateful that i can stay at home with my kids (no offense against those mothers who are forced to go work) and see to their education and spiritual growth, not only physical needs. you can't choose between things you don't know.i see how much good the faith and the church does to them, and my daughter is so happy and excited to start catechism. she has decided a couple months ago that she wants to become a nun - and said it again: that way she can always stay in the church she's sweet
Falcon Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 I welcome you to the Catholic Church. As a Knight of Columbus, I congradulate you on your conversion. I know it was not an easy decision for you. and things are not easy for others around you. Just remain strong in your faith and pray.
MissScripture Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='Chaya' post='1377656' date='Sep 4 2007, 10:10 AM']yes, and this is why i'm grateful that i can stay at home with my kids (no offense against those mothers who are forced to go work) and see to their education and spiritual growth, not only physical needs. you can't choose between things you don't know.i see how much good the faith and the church does to them, and my daughter is so happy and excited to start catechism. she has decided a couple months ago that she wants to become a nun - and said it again: that way she can always stay in the church she's sweet [/quote] Out of curiosity, do you homeschool? I spent the summer babysitting, and the most profound things come out of the mouths of the children. The families I babysat for were Catholic homeschool families. It's so cool to see them excited about Catholic things --dancing around the room and singing songs like, "I wanna say yes, just like Mary did." We spent one afternoon playing with St. Terese paper dolls. It was a Catholic education for me! Another time, the girls started playing St. Joan of Arc and tying themselves to the trees! Oh, and welcome home to you and your family.
CatherineM Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 I stayed at home, and homeschooled for 2 years. The oldest for 5th and 6th grade, and the youngest for 2nd and 3rd. I loved it, but there came a point where they liked the "home" part, but not the "school" part. It started to interfere in our relationship, and I decided that they needed to have mom and teacher separate. I had originally done it because I got the youngest one (they were both foster kids) when he had just finished 1st grade and couldn't read because his step mother had told him that reading was for chumps. I couldn't in good conscience send him off to 2nd grade to start off behind, maybe for the rest of his schooling. He was already the oldest one in class because of the way his birthday fell, and sending him to first again would have made him 2 years older than most of his classmates. We did without a lot of stuff because I didn't work, but they never came home to an empty house. They were both fetal alcohol, and so had different/more needs than other kids. I just always felt blessed to be able to stay home because I know most women can't.
Archaeology cat Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 (edited) [quote name='CatherineM' post='1377784' date='Sep 4 2007, 06:08 PM']I stayed at home, and homeschooled for 2 years. The oldest for 5th and 6th grade, and the youngest for 2nd and 3rd. I loved it, but there came a point where they liked the "home" part, but not the "school" part. It started to interfere in our relationship, and I decided that they needed to have mom and teacher separate. I had originally done it because I got the youngest one (they were both foster kids) when he had just finished 1st grade and couldn't read because his step mother had told him that reading was for chumps. I couldn't in good conscience send him off to 2nd grade to start off behind, maybe for the rest of his schooling. He was already the oldest one in class because of the way his birthday fell, and sending him to first again would have made him 2 years older than most of his classmates. We did without a lot of stuff because I didn't work, but they never came home to an empty house. They were both fetal alcohol, and so had different/more needs than other kids. I just always felt blessed to be able to stay home because I know most women can't.[/quote] Okay, I have to applaud you. I had two foster brothers. And I think it's great that you were able to stay at home. End of hijack. Edited September 4, 2007 by Archaeology cat
Chaya Posted September 4, 2007 Author Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1377696' date='Sep 4 2007, 06:15 PM']Out of curiosity, do you homeschool? Oh, and welcome home to you and your family.[/quote] thank you! no, i don't homeschool. it isn't permitted here. in germany, there are parents who insist on homeschooling and they are threatened with having their kids taken away, or get heavy fines/penalties. and i'm not sure i'd manage to homeschool. it intimidates me. here, we're in a small village (1,000 inhabitants) and in my daughter's class there are 14 kids. contact with the teachers is rather close, and the school is just the opposite side of the street. church is across the street 3 minutes away. i've inscribed her to the first year of catechism and she's all excited. i don't know how they do it elsewhere, but here it's quite nice - a part of the activities (reading, singing, coloring, riddles) is the be done withe parents at home,so the whole family is involved.
MissScripture Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 [quote name='Chaya' post='1377855' date='Sep 4 2007, 02:57 PM']thank you! no, i don't homeschool. it isn't permitted here. in germany, there are parents who insist on homeschooling and they are threatened with having their kids taken away, or get heavy fines/penalties. and i'm not sure i'd manage to homeschool. it intimidates me. here, we're in a small village (1,000 inhabitants) and in my daughter's class there are 14 kids. contact with the teachers is rather close, and the school is just the opposite side of the street. church is across the street 3 minutes away. i've inscribed her to the first year of catechism and she's all excited. i don't know how they do it elsewhere, but here it's quite nice - a part of the activities (reading, singing, coloring, riddles) is the be done withe parents at home,so the whole family is involved.[/quote] I just assumed that you were from 'round here...I forget sometimes that we have people from everywhere on PM. But that sounds like a great program. The catechism programs where I'm from (and from most of what I have heard from other places around here) are not nearly so comprehensive. That program sounds great!
knightec Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 I converted in 2006. I come from a very strong Baptist background. My father is an ordained minister, his brother is an ordained minister, and their dad (my grandfather) was an ordained minister with a doctorate in theology. When I decided to convert I got support from them. I had been out of the church for nearly a decade and they were happy that I was attending again. I'm sure part of them wishes I was going to a baptist church but I have a relationship with God again so that is the most important thing.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 5, 2007 Posted September 5, 2007 [quote name='Chaya' post='1377653' date='Sep 4 2007, 09:59 AM']do you know of any other jewish saints besides Edith Stein? *grin* i was thinking about that whilst getting ready to hospital: a jewish saint? Saint Paul![/quote] lol, and all the apostles, right? Let's see... St. Edith Stein St. Ignatius of Antioch (probably...according to tradition, he was the little boy Christ picked up to show to the crowds) St. Joseph St. Joseph of Arimethea ...you get the picture... I don't know of very many. That's not to say there aren't many, but I would say there aren't as many Jewish Catholic saints as Gentile Catholic saints.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now