Guest thalameguy Posted September 3, 2007 Posted September 3, 2007 A friend of mine recommended reading Wild At Heart by John Eldredge, which is about how to be a man in today's society. The author is not Catholic, and I'm looking for advice and opinions on the book from people who have read it.
friarMatt Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 it is wonderful! I have recommended it to students, young men from ministry and my family members. He isn't Catholic, but he doesn't have an ax to grind
N/A Gone Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 I read it as a proto and loved it. Did not feel theological at all. Just a really good devotion that uses images that make the point easier to follow. He has wrote other books as well that are very good. As for his theology, he is an open theist. They dont bite and it does not effect his writings. He doesnt pull a John Piper and try to put his theology into every devotional. I like the books.
scardella Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 I don't like some of the off-hand remarks he makes towards the beginning regarding priests and Mother Theresa, but otherwise it's quite good as a devotional.
beatty07 Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 Yeah there's a notorious bit that sounds rather condescending or dismissive toward Mother Teresa, but I don't think it should be a deal-breaker for an outstanding book. I don't even know how many times I've bought it because I gave my copy away. Interestingly, some of the ravest reviews among my friends have come from women (not to mention the most penetrating critiques). So anyway, I'm a big fan of Wild at Heart. I've only read one other, Waking the Dead, and found it absolutely horrendous. The only good parts were basically a rehash of Wild at Heart themes. The other parts, which made up the bulk of the text, were just wierd and wrong. I was really confused for a few chapters until I realized that when he wrote "the religious spirit" he was talking about a demonic, destructive force. Maybe I'm not reading him right, but it seemed pretty clear. It sounds like he's jumped on that wagon where you redefine "religion" as "hollow and worthless repitition of ritual" and then run it down. But I digress. Wild at Heart is awesome, without disclaimer!
N/A Gone Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 Weird thing is I agree that women seem to love it, but his wife writes also and is a different style and I have heard bad reviews for it. My wife couldnt stand it. She seemed guilt trippy and really down on women.
XIX Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 Wild at Heart didn't do a lot for me to be honest. I honestly believe that he think I'm less of a man because I don't like guns or outdoorsy stuff. And I not quite sure he cut to the heart of what it means to be a Christian male. There's more to being a man than being "dangerous." Don't let that stop you though. There are a lot of good themes in the book, and the majority of readers seemed to love his book.
adt6247 Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 [quote name='thalameguy' post='1377172' date='Sep 3 2007, 06:48 PM']A friend of mine recommended reading Wild At Heart by John Eldredge, which is about how to be a man in today's society. The author is not Catholic, and I'm looking for advice and opinions on the book from people who have read it.[/quote] It's OK. It gets very repetitive. There's not a whole lot of meat in the book. And the thing I kept thinking over and over again that what the book really needed was Mary.
jeffpugh Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='scardella' post='1377644' date='Sep 4 2007, 09:41 AM']I don't like some of the off-hand remarks he makes towards the beginning regarding priests and Mother Theresa, but otherwise it's quite good as a devotional.[/quote] If he actually knew about the life of a priest, and how Mother Theresa did things, he'd find that they fit the description of real men and women in "Wild at Heart" (and on the other perspective, "Captivating"). I know priests are really manly! Seriously, they're warriors in the truest sense. [quote name='XIX' post='1377735' date='Sep 4 2007, 11:55 AM']Wild at Heart didn't do a lot for me to be honest. I honestly believe that he think I'm less of a man because I don't like guns or outdoorsy stuff. And I not quite sure he cut to the heart of what it means to be a Christian male. There's more to being a man than being "dangerous." Don't let that stop you though. There are a lot of good themes in the book, and the majority of readers seemed to love his book.[/quote] Well, his point is that guys don't take risks anymore. They just wanna be the mediocre "nice guy" and such. I'm not into the macho thing either. actually, i think he put that just to make a point. the thing that really hooked me when he mentioned "writing that symphony" in passing. Every man has his shazam that he must pursue and develop. Mine is not doing stunts and stuff like some really good friends of mine, but it's music. They respect that, and they think it is a masculine thing. They read the book, and encourage my thing. Just gotta find it and take hold of it. But, if this still doesn't satisfy, maybe you just don't need the book. Any major problems in that sense has already been dealt with between you and God. Everyone is different.
jeffpugh Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1379718' date='Sep 6 2007, 03:39 PM']It's OK. It gets very repetitive. There's not a whole lot of meat in the book. And the thing I kept thinking over and over again that what the book really needed was Mary.[/quote] That's what I was thinking too. I thought the guy was pretty much Catholic in the sense of this book, except he has yet to meet his perfect Mother who is in Heaven. She will help him come to the perfect Man, Christ, to "initiate" him . There was more than that thought though.. just one example...
LouisvilleFan Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1380047' date='Sep 6 2007, 11:43 PM']Well, his point is that guys don't take risks anymore. They just wanna be the mediocre "nice guy" and such. I'm not into the macho thing either. actually, i think he put that just to make a point. the thing that really hooked me when he mentioned "writing that symphony" in passing. Every man has his shazam that he must pursue and develop. Mine is not doing stunts and stuff like some really good friends of mine, but it's music. They respect that, and they think it is a masculine thing. They read the book, and encourage my thing. Just gotta find it and take hold of it. But, if this still doesn't satisfy, maybe you just don't need the book. Any major problems in that sense has already been dealt with between you and God. Everyone is different.[/quote] Good point... "Wild at Heart" is one of the few Christian devotional books that I can stand. Most are, well, boring. (However, I haven't read much Catholic devotional stuff, but I have heard some cool excerpts from people like St. Faustina.) What hooked me on the book was addressing the problem of boredom. There are times when I feel overwhelmingly bored with life (this past week, for example) and Eldredge seems to hit the nail on the head for what I need to hear during those times. I'm sure it helps that I grew up in Scouts and have always enjoyed outdoorsy stuff, running, sports, and other "manly" things, but I agree that part of Eldredge's message is that men need to look into their hearts, find their passion, pursue that, and be confident in knowing that you are doing what you were made for.. and things like writing symphonies, nursing, and being stay-at-home dad are just as manly as hunting wild boar on spooky "Lost" island, pitching a 98-mph fastball to strike out Barry Bonds, or being a priest. And if you don't think he's Catholic, just read page 185... ain't no room for contraception there ;-)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now