Farsight one Posted September 4, 2007 Posted September 4, 2007 A very good friend of mine, who just had a daughter by the way, cannot go to church. Now, when I say "cannot, I don't mean that she's in the hospital, or the parish priest has a restraining order against her or anything like that. She just can't stand the incense. It is this incense that is creating a wall that blocks her faith from growing. I used to be able to get her to go to church with me, but she regularly has to leave after 10 minutes or so because the smell becomes unbearably strong. She's even completely passed out multiple times before! She pretty quickly gave up and stopped coming, because she couldn't possibly. So, my three questions are: 1. Is there anything I or my friend can say to the priest to get him to stop using incense? He seems to think that it is extremely important, and the church consists mostly of ultra conservatives who would most likely be shocked and offended if he stopped. 2. Is there anything like a "mass of desire"? Y'know, like baptism of desire, but for mass. It's not like she doesn't want to go. She just can't, because it's obviously quite dangerous to her health. 3. Is a non-Catholic church better than nothing? There's a few other denominations floating around town(not sure exactly what), and I highly doubt any of them use insense. And before you suggest it - there are other parishes to go to, but they ALL use insense religiously(no pun intended), so it would just be more of the same.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 6, 2007 Posted September 6, 2007 [quote name='Farsight one' post='1377583' date='Sep 4 2007, 02:55 AM']A very good friend of mine, who just had a daughter by the way, cannot go to church. Now, when I say "cannot, I don't mean that she's in the hospital, or the parish priest has a restraining order against her or anything like that. She just can't stand the incense. It is this incense that is creating a wall that blocks her faith from growing. I used to be able to get her to go to church with me, but she regularly has to leave after 10 minutes or so because the smell becomes unbearably strong. She's even completely passed out multiple times before! She pretty quickly gave up and stopped coming, because she couldn't possibly. So, my three questions are: 1. Is there anything I or my friend can say to the priest to get him to stop using incense? He seems to think that it is extremely important, and the church consists mostly of ultra conservatives who would most likely be shocked and offended if he stopped. 2. Is there anything like a "mass of desire"? Y'know, like baptism of desire, but for mass. It's not like she doesn't want to go. She just can't, because it's obviously quite dangerous to her health. 3. Is a non-Catholic church better than nothing? There's a few other denominations floating around town(not sure exactly what), and I highly doubt any of them use insense. And before you suggest it - there are other parishes to go to, but they ALL use insense religiously(no pun intended), so it would just be more of the same.[/quote] 1. I would bring up the health concerns. Perhaps one of the several weekend Masses can be celebrated without incense or at least with considerably less. I know you said not to suggest another Church, but a thought came into my mind: have you tried a hospital chapel? I would venture a guess that most hospitals would not allow incense. While it might be a bit odd or out of the way, it's a possibility. 2. No, there is no such thing as a Mass of Desire, but there is such a thing as Spiritual Communion, in which one prays to receive Christ spiritually in the heart when they are unable to receive Him sacramentally. Besides that, a person can watch a televised Mass, pray through the Liturgy of the Word for that Sunday, and also receive the Eucharist from an acolyte sent from the Church to take Jesus to the sick. I would discuss the matter with a priest and see if he has any suggestions. 3. No, it would not be better to go to a non-Catholic service. Many have spiritually dangerous teachings and they can never be considered alternatives for the Mass. The Catholic Church can and should work with those who need special help in getting to Mass and receiving Jesus. God bless, Raphael
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now