cappie Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 An Italian priest has announced his engagement to a woman with a one year old child. Fr Sante Sguotti has made it clear that the relationship will remain platonic. Interfax reports that he says there is no church prohibition against loving a woman. The pastor in love has been supported by over 200 members of his parish at Monterosso near Padua. At a referendum he himself arranged, they spoke in favour of his remaining to be a priest. Only 17 people including the local bishop wanted him to leave the office. He said: "The law does not prohibit a priest to love or to be engaged to a woman if he stays celibate." He has also urged all the priests in love to "come out". The priest is not going to adopt the child. [url="http://www.interfax-religion.com/?act=news&div=3593"]http://www.interfax-religion.com/?act=news&div=3593[/url]
Hashbrowns Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 I'm really glad we have Pope Benedict as our shepherd right now, 'cause he seems like the kind of guy that doesn't budge for anyone except God. Horray for the pope!
CatholicCid Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Is he actually going for a legal canon loophole? What do the canons say in the matter?
LouisvilleFan Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Allright, I'll take the devil's advocate on this one I see a good side to this in that the priest and his "fiance" are making a public statement that true love is expressed through sharing a committed relationship. They're promoting marriage by emphasizing that sex is only appropriate within marriage and the priest is promoting life by embracing a single mother, when some Christians would steer clear to avoid getting their hands dirty. I'm glad he's remaining obedient to Church (his bishop may not like it, but that's understandable) and I'm glad he's got the guns to do what he believes is right (again, while respecting Church teaching).
Theoketos Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 One Word: Obedience. Also, his vow of celibacy is an impediment to marriage according to Canon Law.
LouisvilleFan Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Okay, I'm not such a fan of this Fr. Sante's statement here, criticizing the discipline of celibacy: “The Church is losing her best part; only the most narrow-minded and senseless remain." If there is one reason why I think it might be wise to regularly ordain married men, it would be to make the sacraments available to more of the faithful. Most Catholics live in places with thousands, if not tens of thousands, of laypeople per priest. I know that deacons and other leaders are able to help with pastoral functions, but Reconciliation and the Eucharist are essential to our faith and millions aren't receiving them on a regular basis at all. Perhaps some other accommodation could be made, like allowing bishops in countries with extreme priest shortages to ordain married men over a certain age (like the age requirement for deacons), along with a minimum length of marriage to guard against married priests putting too much stress on a young marriage. If the pope were to approve something like this, I think he should specifically disallow any such accommodations in the United States... we are spoiled enough as it is and many dioceses and religious orders are seeing the light at the end of the tunnel anyway.
LouisvilleFan Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Theoketos' post='1380026' date='Sep 6 2007, 11:26 PM']One Word: Obedience. Also, his vow of celibacy is an impediment to marriage according to Canon Law.[/quote] We can disagree with our bishops while respecting them, as long as we are faithful to Church teaching. Of course, if you're bishop is going to excommunicate you, then it's time to back up. Since he isn't getting married, there is no problem with the vow of celibacy. Edited September 7, 2007 by LouisvilleFan
Socrates Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 How can one be "engaged" if he has no plans to marry? This whole thing sounds like contradictory and pointless nonsense (and seems rather "phishy" to me). And if he simply wants to charitably help out a single mother, no "engagement" or talk of "being in love" is necessary.
LouisvilleFan Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='Socrates' post='1380091' date='Sep 7 2007, 12:20 AM']How can one be "engaged" if he has no plans to marry? This whole thing sounds like contradictory and pointless nonsense (and seems rather "phishy" to me). And if he simply wants to charitably help out a single mother, no "engagement" or talk of "being in love" is necessary.[/quote] I think he could be trying to demonstrate to a secular society that platonic love is the foundation of meaningful relationships, especially marriage. The major x factor is our lack of familiarity with modern Italian culture. We don't know where he's coming from, and even though he's critical of the Church discipline, at least he isn't going way out into left field, breaking from communion with Rome and doing his own thing. I'll leave judgment of this priest's decision to his bishop and the pope.
chelsea Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 This is silly. He's a priest. When you get engaged, your intent is to get married. Priests cant get married, because they marry the church.
prose Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Well, the thing is, (I think) that it would be more controversial if he was in love with her and rumors started flying about the time the spend together, etc. But engagement means a pre-cursor to marriage. That is the definition.
Didymus Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='chelsea' post='1380298' date='Sep 7 2007, 11:12 AM']This is silly. He's a priest. When you get engaged, your intent is to get married. Priests cant get married, because they marry the church.[/quote] yeah, u dont really have to look at canon law to see this is messed up. the purpose of engagement is for a couple to prepare for marriage, and the marriage bed. In short, this belittles marriage...
alicemary Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 We have a priest in the Richmond diocese who has been extorting more then a half a million dollars from his churches, has been living with a woman and her children for years, and kept all this from his parishoners. Neighbors thought he was married to the woman, but they merely lived together, and not platonicaly. He is on his way to jail. And the damage he has done to several rural churches has been devasting. Priests and religious certainly need our prayers.
Justin86 Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Um, if you are engaged to a woman that expresses desire to marry her. If the Catholic Church does not allow priests to marry then she can't allow priests to express desire to marry either. Seminariains aren't even allowed to date. Why on earth should an ordained priest be allowed to have an engagement? Being how aggressively Rome defends preistly celibacy I am sure this priest will be excommunicated just as if he actually married the woman. Someone said here that we don't know the culture the priest comes from. True, but that priest's Bishop sure does, and he wants this guy excomunicated. That's enough for me. [quote name='alicemary' post='1380535' date='Sep 8 2007, 06:29 AM']We have a priest in the Richmond diocese who has been extorting more then a half a million dollars from his churches, has been living with a woman and her children for years, and kept all this from his parishoners. Neighbors thought he was married to the woman, but they merely lived together, and not platonicaly. He is on his way to jail. And the damage he has done to several rural churches has been devasting. Priests and religious certainly need our prayers.[/quote] Yes I am quite familar with that case. As a matter of fact Rodis was my preist growing up. The federal indictment lists the woman he was living with as his wife by the way. Many speculated he really was married to her, and was just trying to prevent himself from being excommunicated. All we ever had was his word on the matter. It's also beleived that those kids he was living with are likely his.
Starets Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 "Double lives take half as long" -Steve Taylor
LouisvilleFan Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='Justin86' post='1380682' date='Sep 7 2007, 08:36 PM']Someone said here that we don't know the culture the priest comes from. True, but that priest's Bishop sure does, and he wants this guy excomunicated. That's enough for me.[/quote] I saw that the bishop doesn't approve, but didn't read anything about him threatening to excommunicate the priest. Are we even sure that their relationship is romantic in any fashion? The priest used the words "in love," but that's not very specific. Can that phrase mean different things in Italy than it does here?
bonoducchi Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1380955' date='Sep 8 2007, 01:03 PM']The priest used the words "in love," but that's not very specific. Can that phrase mean different things in Italy than it does here?[/quote] "I love my wife." "I love Diet Coke." "I love my dog." "I love God." "I love summer." "I love my sister." "I love the color red." Maybe "love" can have different meanings......
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now