Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

JMJ + FC


I have two questions. I'm talking to some Protestants online (this is an extension of the conversation I was having on the early churches being the Catholic church... which we never really resolved).

My Protestant brothers in Christ believe that John 6 has nothing to do with "Communion" (their word). I was kind of baffled, as anyone who has ever looked at the chapter can see that just about every other verse is talking about Jesus' Body and Blood being food.

My question is, is there a way to argue that Jesus was being [b]literal[/b] in John 6 concerning the Eucharist with Protestants who do not have an authority besides Scripture (i.e., do not have a Magisterial authority interpreting Scripture for them)?

The second question is tied into that... is citing the early Church Fathers the best way to argue that Jesus instituted apostolic succession if they do not accept these verses I quoted:

Old Testament:

[color="blue"][b]Isaiah 22:22[/b] And I will lay the key of the house of David upon his shoulder: and he shall open, and none shall shut: and he shall shut, and none shall open.[/color]


New Testament:

[color="blue"][b]John20:22-23[/b] When he had said this, he breathed on them; and he said to them: Receive ye the Holy Ghost. Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them: and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.

[b]Matthew 16:18-19[/b] And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven. And whatsoever thou shalt bind upon earth, it shall be bound also in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose upon earth, it shall be loosed also in heaven. [/color]




Thanks to anyone who persevered through this post. I am really confused as to where to go from here.


Lauren

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted

I have found that when Jesus wanted to teach us about how to live and treat each other, he told a parable. When he wanted to teach us something about himself, he spoke very plainly and simply, and just repeated himself over and over again, and then stepped back and basically said "take it or leave it." That's what he did in John. Just do the same thing back to them, and repeat the section to them out loud, including what Jesus said to Peter and the Apostles. Tell them that Jesus lost some of his disciples because they didn't want to believe it either. and for yourself, you intend to believe Jesus' words. Anything else, Protestants want to take literally.

Posted (edited)

I'm going to refer to my favourite site: scripturecatholic.com

John 6:51-52- then Jesus says that the bread He is referring to is His flesh. The Jews take Him literally and immediately question such a teaching. How can this man give us His flesh to eat?

John 6:53 - 58 - Jesus does not correct their literal interpretation. Instead, Jesus eliminates any metaphorical interpretations by swearing an oath and being even more literal about eating His flesh. In fact, Jesus says four times we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. Catholics thus believe that Jesus makes present His body and blood in the sacrifice of the Mass. Protestants, if they are not going to become Catholic, can only argue that Jesus was somehow speaking symbolically.ro

John 6:23-53 - however, a symbolic interpretation is not plausible. Throughout these verses, the Greek text uses the word "[b]phago[/b]" nine times. [b]"Phago" literally means "to eat" or "physically consume." [/b]Like the Protestants of our day, the disciples take issue with Jesus' literal usage of "eat." So Jesus does what?

John 6:54, 56, 57, 58 - He uses an even more literal verb, translated as "[b]trogo[/b]," which means to gnaw or chew or crunch. He increases the literalness and drives his message home. Jesus will literally give us His flesh and blood to eat. The word “trogo” is only used two other times in the New Testament (in Matt. 24:38 and John 13:18) and [b]it always means to literally gnaw or chew meat[/b]. While “phago” might also have a spiritual application,[b] "trogo" is never used metaphorically in Greek.[/b] So Protestants cannot find one verse in Scripture where "trogo" is used symbolically, and yet this must be their argument if they are going to deny the Catholic understanding of Jesus' words. Moreover, the Jews already knew Jesus was speaking literally even before Jesus used the word “trogo” when they said “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?” (John 6:52).

John 6:55 - to clarify further, Jesus says "For My Flesh is food indeed, and My Blood is drink indeed." This phrase can only be understood as being responsive to those who do not believe that Jesus' flesh is food indeed, and His blood is drink indeed. Further, Jesus uses the word which is translated as "[b]sarx[/b]." [b]"Sarx" means flesh (not "soma" which means body)[/b]. See, for example, John 1:13,14; 3:6; 8:15; 17:2; Matt. 16:17; 19:5; 24:22; 26:41; Mark 10:8; 13:20; 14:38; and Luke 3:6; 24:39 which provides other examples in Scripture where "sarx" means flesh. [b]It is always literal.[/b]

John 6:55 - further, the phrases "real" food and "real" drink use the word "[b]alethes[/b]." [b]"Alethes" means "really" or "truly,"[/b] and would only be used if there were doubts concerning the reality of Jesus' flesh and blood as being food and drink. Thus, Jesus is emphasizing the miracle of His body and blood being actual food and drink.

John 6:60 - as are many anti-Catholics today, Jesus' disciples are scandalized by these words. They even ask, "Who can 'listen' to it (much less understand it)?" To the unillumined mind, it seems grotesque.

John 6:61-63 - Jesus acknowledges their disgust. Jesus' use of the phrase "the spirit gives life" means the disciples need supernatural faith, not logic, to understand His words.

John 3:6 - Jesus often used the comparison of "spirit versus flesh" to teach about the necessity of possessing supernatural faith versus a natural understanding. In Mark 14:38 Jesus also uses the "spirit/flesh" comparison. The spirit is willing but the flesh is weak. We must go beyond the natural to understand the supernatural. In 1 Cor. 2:14,3:3; Rom 8:5; and Gal. 5:17, Paul also uses the "spirit/flesh" comparison to teach that unspiritual people are not receiving the gift of faith. They are still "in the flesh."

John 6:63 - Protestants often argue that Jesus' use of the phrase "the spirit gives life" shows that Jesus was only speaking symbolically. However, Protestants must explain why there is not one place in Scripture where "spirit" means "symbolic." As we have seen, the use of "spirit" relates to supernatural faith. What words are spirit and life? The words that we must eat Jesus' flesh and drink His blood, or we have no life in us.

John 6:66-67 - many disciples leave Jesus, rejecting this literal interpretation that we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. At this point, these disciples really thought Jesus had lost His mind. If they were wrong about the literal interpretation, why wouldn't Jesus, the Great Teacher, have corrected them? Why didn't Jesus say, "Hey, come back here, I was only speaking symbolically!"? Because they understood correctly.

I hope that helps a bit.

Oh, and here's the link to the 'Apostolic Succesion' page on the same site'. It's got quotations from Church Fathers too.
[url="http://www.scripturecatholic.com/apostolic_succession.html"]http://www.scripturecatholic.com/apostolic_succession.html[/url]

Edited by Noel's angel
Archaeology cat
Posted

Really good post by Noel's Angel. The only thing I'd add is that Jesus prefaces his statements with "Amen, and amen" to show how true these statements were (as "Amen" is an affirmation of truth).

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1380132' date='Sep 6 2007, 11:57 PM']I have found that when Jesus wanted to teach us about how to live and treat each other, he told a parable. When he wanted to teach us something about himself, he spoke very plainly and simply, and just repeated himself over and over again, and then stepped back and basically said "take it or leave it." That's what he did in John. Just do the same thing back to them, and repeat the section to them out loud, including what Jesus said to Peter and the Apostles. Tell them that Jesus lost some of his disciples because they didn't want to believe it either. and for yourself, you intend to believe Jesus' words. Anything else, Protestants want to take literally.[/quote]


I tried the parable vs. non-parable approach (which, like you, was the first idea that struck me). But then they said, "then is Jesus literally a VINE", because He used that term outside of a parable. The part about Him repeating Himself, I'm sure, would bear no weight with them.

Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1380225' date='Sep 7 2007, 07:37 AM']I'm going to refer to my favourite site: scripturecatholic.com

John 6:51-52- then Jesus says that the bread He is referring to is His flesh. The Jews take Him literally and immediately question such a teaching. How can this man give us His flesh to eat?

John 6:53 - 58 - Jesus does not correct their literal interpretation. Instead, Jesus eliminates any metaphorical interpretations by swearing an oath and being even more literal about eating His flesh. In fact, Jesus says four times we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. Catholics thus believe that Jesus makes present His body and blood in the sacrifice of the Mass. Protestants, if they are not going to become Catholic, can only argue that Jesus was somehow speaking symbolically.ro

John 6:23-53 - however, a symbolic interpretation is not plausible. Throughout these verses, the Greek text uses the word "[b]phago[/b]" nine times. [b]"Phago" literally means "to eat" or "physically consume." [/b]Like the Protestants of our day, the disciples take issue with Jesus' literal usage of "eat." So Jesus does what?

John 6:54, 56, 57, 58 - He uses an even more literal verb, translated as "[b]trogo[/b]," which means to gnaw or chew or crunch. He increases the literalness and drives his message home. Jesus will literally give us His flesh and blood to eat. The word “trogo” is only used two other times in the New Testament (in Matt. 24:38 and John 13:18) and [b]it always means to literally gnaw or chew meat[/b]. While “phago” might also have a spiritual application,[b] "trogo" is never used metaphorically in Greek.[/b] So Protestants cannot find one verse in Scripture where "trogo" is used symbolically, and yet this must be their argument if they are going to deny the Catholic understanding of Jesus' words. Moreover, the Jews already knew Jesus was speaking literally even before Jesus used the word “trogo” when they said “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?” (John 6:52).

John 6:55 - to clarify further, Jesus says "For My Flesh is food indeed, and My Blood is drink indeed." This phrase can only be understood as being responsive to those who do not believe that Jesus' flesh is food indeed, and His blood is drink indeed. Further, Jesus uses the word which is translated as "[b]sarx[/b]." [b]"Sarx" means flesh (not "soma" which means body)[/b]. See, for example, John 1:13,14; 3:6; 8:15; 17:2; Matt. 16:17; 19:5; 24:22; 26:41; Mark 10:8; 13:20; 14:38; and Luke 3:6; 24:39 which provides other examples in Scripture where "sarx" means flesh. [b]It is always literal.[/b]

John 6:55 - further, the phrases "real" food and "real" drink use the word "[b]alethes[/b]." [b]"Alethes" means "really" or "truly,"[/b] and would only be used if there were doubts concerning the reality of Jesus' flesh and blood as being food and drink. Thus, Jesus is emphasizing the miracle of His body and blood being actual food and drink.

John 6:60 - as are many anti-Catholics today, Jesus' disciples are scandalized by these words. They even ask, "Who can 'listen' to it (much less understand it)?" To the unillumined mind, it seems grotesque.

John 6:61-63 - Jesus acknowledges their disgust. Jesus' use of the phrase "the spirit gives life" means the disciples need supernatural faith, not logic, to understand His words.

John 3:6 - Jesus often used the comparison of "spirit versus flesh" to teach about the necessity of possessing supernatural faith versus a natural understanding. In Mark 14:38 Jesus also uses the "spirit/flesh" comparison. The spirit is willing but the flesh is weak. We must go beyond the natural to understand the supernatural. In 1 Cor. 2:14,3:3; Rom 8:5; and Gal. 5:17, Paul also uses the "spirit/flesh" comparison to teach that unspiritual people are not receiving the gift of faith. They are still "in the flesh."

John 6:63 - Protestants often argue that Jesus' use of the phrase "the spirit gives life" shows that Jesus was only speaking symbolically. However, Protestants must explain why there is not one place in Scripture where "spirit" means "symbolic." As we have seen, the use of "spirit" relates to supernatural faith. What words are spirit and life? The words that we must eat Jesus' flesh and drink His blood, or we have no life in us.

John 6:66-67 - many disciples leave Jesus, rejecting this literal interpretation that we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. At this point, these disciples really thought Jesus had lost His mind. If they were wrong about the literal interpretation, why wouldn't Jesus, the Great Teacher, have corrected them? Why didn't Jesus say, "Hey, come back here, I was only speaking symbolically!"? Because they understood correctly.

I hope that helps a bit.

Oh, and here's the link to the 'Apostolic Succesion' page on the same site'. It's got quotations from Church Fathers too.
[url="http://www.scripturecatholic.com/apostolic_succession.html"]http://www.scripturecatholic.com/apostolic_succession.html[/url][/quote]


This is very helpful and I will definitely use that site as a source... I was looking for a site just like that!

I also tried the argument you posted in the first couple of paragraphs. I asked them why, if Jesus wasn't being serious, didn't He bring back the Jews who had "misunderstood Him". The reply was that they DID understand what He was saying, which was that He was using a metaphor to tell them that He was the Son of God, and it was THAT fact which they could not understand. Thus they left.

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1380261' date='Sep 7 2007, 10:18 AM']Really good post by Noel's Angel. The only thing I'd add is that Jesus prefaces his statements with "Amen, and amen" to show how true these statements were (as "Amen" is an affirmation of truth).[/quote]


I'm afraid that would hold no weight with them, either.



I think we're at a dividing point now (these Protestants and I) because you simply cannot convince someone that Scripture means a certain thing (i.e., the thing the Church has defined it to mean) if they do not accept any authority for interpreting Scripture except their own intellects, which they believe have been individually enlightened by the Holy Spirit. And somehow that enlightenment they have also overrides logic, at times.

Posted

If one looks at John 6 and Matt 26 it is very hard to separate the two with regard to the last supper as your freinds have done. John 6 occurred at precisely the same time of year (Jn 6:4), the passover. Both have references to the bread of the passover, in both cases Peter makes an expression of faith ("to who do we have to turn" j 6, "I will never deny you" mt 26). In Jn 6 the betrayer is prophesied and in Matt 26 he is revealed. Then of course there is the direct parallel "my flesh is food indeed", "this is my body", "my blood is drink indeed", "this is my blood". There can be no doudt that the Apostles would have flashed back to the event one year before when he said these words. There is no way you can separate the two events.

Posted (edited)

Thanks thess. I'm not sure how to use that argument in this particular debate, though... I have a hard time seeing how it relates to what I'm talking about?


Am I missing something?

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted

There are some people who just don't want to be confused with the truth. It would mean to much of a shakeup in their lives.

Posted

"John 6 has nothing to do with "Communion" (their word). "

Matt 26 is the institution of communion. There word and another word for our Eucharist. I was answering that objection as to how you cannot separate John 6 from Matt 26 and therefore cannot separate it from the Lord's Supper.

Posted

Another thing that I would be careful of in this discussion is in focusing too much on the literal, so much so that it causes you to deny the figurative. Jesus words are food, i.e. scripture is food, and so that is a valid usage of the text as well. Jesus is the word made flesh and that is why we have both the liturgy of the Word, and the liturgy of the Eucharist. In both parts of the Mass we consume Jesus. Jesus does in fact mean that we believe in him when he says "unless you eat of the flesh of the son of man and drink his blood you shall not have life within you". But it is also clear that he is being literal. Protestants many times want to only allow one interpretation of a passage. In this way they end up with a finite bible. The Word made flesh is the infinite God and so we do not limit the word in this manner. Bread is figurative in the Lord's Supper. It is a figure of the grains of wheat being crushed to make the loaf, i.e. the crushing of the community to make the body of Christ. The literal understanding is first but we must be careful to counter spiritual and metaphorical understandings that the protestants have that are in fact not out of line. Where they get in to trouble is not in the figures that they speak of but in denying the literal which the Church says is the first and foremost sense of scripture. Ecumenical diaolgue will fail if we do not acknowledge what they say that is correct in some fashion. Catholics make this mistake alot in discussing the Lord's Supper with non-catholics.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1380346' date='Sep 7 2007, 12:29 PM']"John 6 has nothing to do with "Communion" (their word). "

Matt 26 is the institution of communion. There word and another word for our Eucharist. I was answering that objection as to how you cannot separate John 6 from Matt 26 and therefore cannot separate it from the Lord's Supper.[/quote]


Oh ok thanks! I appreciate the clarification and your explanation. I'm going to comb through it again today and see if I can present that to my Protestant friends.

goldenchild17
Posted

Preparation for the Eucharistic Discourse
In John 6 we see that Jesus first performs two miracles. John 6: 11-13 says “Then Jesus took the loaves, gave thanks, and distributed them to those who were reclining, and also as much of the fish as they wanted. When they had had their fill, he said to his disciples, ‘Gather the fragments left over, so that nothing will be wasted.’ So they collected them, and filled twelve wicker baskets with fragments from the five barley loaves that had been more than they could eat.”
Here Jesus takes a little bit of fish and a little bread, and multiplies this into enough food to feed thousands of people! And there were twelve baskets full left over! Here Christ is giving us a preview of sorts, of what is to come, when He takes just a little bread and changes it into His Body and Blood for all His followers to eat from. There will be plenty left over. Enough for all believers of all time to partake of it. An important thing to note is the format that Jesus uses. He “took the loaves, gave thanks, and distributed” the bread. This is the same format that He uses at the Last Supper. This miracle foreshadows the greatest miracle of Christ, in which He gives us to eat His own flesh and blood that was sacrificed for our sins.
The second miracle that Jesus performs occurs in John 6:19 “When they had rowed about three or four miles, they saw Jesus walking on the sea and coming near the boat, and they began to be afraid.”
He shows that even though He is indeed fully human just as we are, He is not bound by the limitations of the flesh. Through the miracles of the multiplication of the fish and bread, and of the calming of the storm Jesus is trying to build up the faith of His followers. Because He knew that what He was about to teach His disciples would be very difficult for them to accept.
What was He going to say that would be so hard to believe? Hadn’t Christ done so much already, so many miracles and impossible things? Surely nothing would shock His disciples now. Right?
The Eucharistic Discourse
Now we go to John 6:32. This event takes place during the Passover(see John 6:4). This is important considering He is the Paschal Lamb who is to be sacrificed for all. The Scripture says “So Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, it was not Moses who gave the bread from heaven; my Father gives you the true bread from heaven.” What is the true bread from heaven? Verse 33 answers this question, “For the bread of God is that which comes down from heaven and gives life to the world.” Who is that which comes down from heaven and gives life to the world? Jesus Christ, our Tree of Life, our Paschal Lamb, Himself! His audience of course, is intrigued by such bread, bread that would give them eternal life, so they ask for it, “So they said to him, ‘Sir, give us this bread always.’” (John 6:34). Jesus tells them, “I am the bread of life; whoever comes to me will never hunger, and whoever believes in me will never thirst.” (John 6:35). Jesus is claiming to be the bread of life. Christ is calling His followers to come to Him and believe. He is calling them to a greater faith than they could possibly imagine. His audience is starting to get the picture and are a little disturbed, “The Jews murmured about him because he said, ‘I am the bread that came down from heaven,’” (John 6:41).
Here is Jesus’ first opportunity to tell His audience that He wasn’t speaking literally when He said that He was “the bread of life”. This is His chance to correct them. What does He do? John 6:43, “Jesus answered and said to them, "Stop murmuring among yourselves.” He tells them to knock it off. No correction, he tells them to be quiet. Very interesting if He indeed meant something other than what they understood. Now, it needs to be said that Jesus does mean this in a symbolic way. He is telling them that by coming to Him and believing in Him, they are eating and drinking from the Bread of Life, which He is. With these words Jesus is building up to something even greater.
In verse 48 He reaffirms His earlier statements saying clearly “I am the bread of life.” Next He even insists that He is better than the manna that the Israelites received in the desert, “Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died; this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die.” (verses 49-50). We are all called to come to Jesus and believe in Him and so eat and drink of the Bread of Life. But the Jews are really struggling with this one. So, then Christ says “I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.” (John 6:51). Jesus takes it a step further this time. He again says that he is the living bread from heaven. But this time He tells them that they must EAT THIS BREAD. He tells them that this bread is HIS FLESH. The word used for ‘eat’ in Greek is ‘Phago’, which literally means, “to eat, or consume a meal”.(check definition here) How insane this must have sounded! Imagine a guy walking around telling us that we need to eat him if we want to go to heaven! Yet, Jesus is not just some guy. He is our God. Check out the response of His audience, in verse 52, “The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, ‘How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?’”
Their response is nothing out of the ordinary. Who wouldn’t react strongly to such a statement? Their reaction gives Jesus a second chance to clarify to them what He means by all of this. What does He do? In verses 53-58 He responds with this, “Jesus said to them, ‘Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. For my flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him. Just as the living Father sent me and I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on me will have life because of me. This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever.’” Christ takes things one step further and uses yet a stronger word for ‘eat’. This word is ‘trogo’, which means to “to gnaw, crunch, chew”(check definition here). This word, ‘trogo’ is never used symbolically outside of this verse. The only other places that this word occurs is in Matt. 24:38 and John 13:18. Both of these verses refer to a literal eating and drinking. It is also important to see that Jesus is now referring to the bread as His ‘flesh’, not just his body, but his “flesh”. The Greek word used in these instances is ‘sarx’ which refers literally to the skin and muscle covering of a body(check definition here).
Then He says that His flesh is meat ‘indeed’ and that His blood is drink ‘indeed’. The greek word used for ‘indeed’ is ‘alethos’ which means ‘truly, of a truth, in reality, most certainly’(check definition here). Jesus really meant for them to know that His body and blood were to truly become bread and wine which they were to eat.
This is absolutely amazing. The Jewish audience of Jesus here must have been beside themselves. What could they possibly think about such an idea? John 6:60 says “Then many of his disciples who were listening said, ‘This saying is hard; who can accept it?’” They are obviously having a very difficult time with this one. Jesus asks them, “Does this shock you?” (verse 61). He says in verses 62-63, “What if you were to see the Son of Man ascending to where he was before?” Here he equates this teaching with His ascension. Something we must ask ourselves is this, is the ascension something that is literal or just symbolic? Clearly it is not symbolic, it really happened. And so to, did Christ really tell us that His flesh is the bread from heaven and that we must eat from it if we want a part in His heavenly kingdom. Many people think that Jesus is speaking symbolically in all of this because of verse 63, which says “It is the spirit that gives life, while the flesh is of no avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life.” But to this I ask one question, was Jesus’ flesh of no avail? Of course not! It was His very flesh that redeemed us from our sins and made it possible for us to enter through the gates of heaven. Jesus is once again telling his followers that they really need to accept a supernatural faith in order to believe what He is telling them. No ordinary faith, which can be understood through natural means, can bring one to accept what He is now telling them.
This is the last straw for some of Jesus’ disciples, “As a result of this, many (of) his disciples returned to their former way of life and no longer accompanied him.” (John 6:66). This is the ONLY place in Scripture that disciples are recorded leaving Jesus because of one of His teachings. Surely they must have made some sort of terrible mistake in their understanding of what Jesus was trying to tell them. Right? Well, it sure didn’t seem this way to Jesus, as verse 67 says, “Jesus then said to the Twelve, ‘Do you also want to leave?’” . Instead of trying to convince His disciples to stay, instead of trying to convince them that they are wrong in what they are taking away from this lesson, He asks His apostles if they also wish to leave. From Peter he finally receives the type of supernatural faith that he was looking for, “Simon Peter answered him, ‘Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.’" (verses 68-69).
Why Didn't He Correct Them?
Jesus is given three opportunities to clear the air about His teaching here. Three times, and each time He instead reaffirms what they had thought. If Jesus really meant something other than what they understood then He should’ve, and would’ve, corrected them. Take John 8:31-34 as an example, “Jesus then said to those Jews who believed in him, ‘If you remain in my word, you will truly be my disciples, and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.’ They answered him, ‘We are descendants of Abraham and have never been enslaved to anyone. How can you say, ‘'You will become free?’ Jesus answered them, ‘Amen, amen, I say to you, everyone who commits sin is a slave of sin.’” In this passage the Jews believed that Jesus was speaking about a literal enslavement. Jesus corrects them telling them that He is speaking about enslavement to sin. Another good example is John 4:32:34 “But he said to them, ‘I have food to eat of which you do not know.’ So the disciples said to one another, ‘Could someone have brought him something to eat?’ Jesus said to them, ‘My food is to do the will of the one who sent me and to finish his work.’” Here the disciples thought Jesus was speaking of real, physical food. Jesus corrects them saying that it is not physical food that He is talking about, but to do the will of His Father. I could share multiple examples of such misunderstandings being cleared up by Jesus. But the point is made that it is not characteristic of Jesus to let His audience go away confused about His teachings. What kind of teacher would He be if He just let his disciples leave Him because of a simple misunderstanding? Not a very good one, to say the least.
Despite all of this, many people still believe that Jesus is only speaking figuratively when He tells us that we are to eat His flesh if we want to inherit eternal life. Besides the obvious contradiction to this, shown in all the above, there is another serious problem to deal with. In Hebrew, which is very closely related to Aramaic the language of Jesus, “eating the flesh” and “drinking the blood” already has a direct figurative meaning. Check out some of these passages and see what I’m talking about.
Psalms 27:2, “When evildoers come at me to devour my flesh, These my enemies and foes themselves stumble and fall.”
Isaiah 9:18-20, “At the wrath of the LORD of hosts the land quakes, and the people are like fuel for fire; No man spares his brother, each devours the flesh of his neighbor. Though they hack on the right, they are hungry; though they eat on the left, they are not filled. Manasseh devours Ephraim, and Ephraim Manasseh; together they turn on Judah. For all this, his wrath is not turned back, his hand is still outstretched!”
Isaiah 49:26, “will make your oppressors eat their own flesh, and they shall be drunk with their own blood as with the juice of the grape. All mankind shall know that I, the LORD, am your savior, your redeemer, the Mighty One of Jacob.”
Micah 3:3, “They eat the flesh of my people, and flay their skin from them, and break their bones. They chop them in pieces like flesh in a kettle, and like meat in a caldron.”
2 Samuel 23:15-17, “Now David had a strong craving and said, ‘Oh, that someone would give me a drink of water from the cistern that is by the gate of Bethlehem!’ So the Three warriors broke through the Philistine camp and drew water from the cistern that is by the gate of Bethlehem. But when they brought it to David he refused to drink it, and instead poured it out to the LORD, saying: ‘The LORD forbid that I do this! Can I drink the blood of these men who went at the risk of their lives?’ So he refused to drink it.”
Revelation 17:6 “I saw that the woman was drunk on the blood of the holy ones and on the blood of the witnesses to Jesus. When I saw her I was greatly amazed.”
Revelation 17:16 “The ten horns that you saw and the beast will hate the harlot; they will leave her desolate and naked; they will eat her flesh and consume her with fire.”
In each and every one of these passages we see this idea of “eating the flesh” and “drinking the blood”. In every passage it’s used figuratively, because in the context of each passage never is someone’s flesh actually being eaten or the blood actually being drunk. We see from these passages that this figurative language “eat the flesh and drink the blood” actually means to persecute, assault and destroy the person. Now, in light of this meaning, we go back to Jesus speaking about us eating His Flesh and drinking His Blood. If Jesus is really and truly speaking figuratively, then what He is really saying is “persecute me, assault me, and destroy me, and I will give you eternal life . . . Amen, amen I say to you whosoever persecutes, assaults, and destroys me will live forever”. Is it just me or does this sound a little crazy? If Jesus were truly speaking figuratively, than I think we all would have a little thinking to do about whether or not we should be following this guy. Truly anyone can see that this is ridiculous. So, I think it should be obvious that Jesus could not have been speaking figuratively.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Double post

Edited by goldenchild17
goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Triple post. Use whatever you can from the above.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

Thanks Goldenchild... did you write that? I appreciate the post(s)!!

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1380703' date='Sep 7 2007, 06:56 PM']Thanks Goldenchild... did you write that? I appreciate the post(s)!![/quote]

mhmm. It's from a somewhat longer article on the papacy from my website. It needs some updating though. hopefully there's something you can use from it.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1380733' date='Sep 7 2007, 09:08 PM']mhmm. It's from a somewhat longer article on the papacy from my website. It needs some updating though. hopefully there's something you can use from it.[/quote]


Okie doke. This argument is actually happening on CGR, no surprise ;)

Posted

These are the latest two statements I don't know what to say to:

(concerning John 6): Aside from the fact that this entire passage is about the requirements of following Jesus and not a bit about communion, I don't have anything to add to Daniels perceptive and incisive analysis.



(concerning figuring out when Jesus was being metaphorical and when He was being literal):This is about text analysis. Also, this section is not the parable but the explanation and interpretation of a parable.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...