kenrockthefirst Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 If I understand correctly, the Catholic Church interprets the woman spoken of in Revelation 12 as Mary. Is that correct? If so, here's my question: the text speaks of the woman giving birth with "pangs" and "anguish:" [i]And a great portent appeared in heaven, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars; she was with child and she cried out in her pangs of birth, in anguish for delivery.[/i] Rev. 12:1-2 (RSV) My understanding of Church teaching is that Mary did not deliver Jesus vaginally, and hence did not experience "pangs" and "anguish," which accompany childbirth as one of the consequences of the Fall. How do we square that with the scripture cited above?
thessalonian Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 The woman in Rev 12 is not only Mary and not completely Mary. Mary is a type of the Church, of which the passage can be viewed as as well, and it can be seen as Israel. Types do not have to have all of the elements of what they represent. Where did you get that Mary did not deliver Jesus vaginally however. It is a speculation as to why she might not have had pain but it is not even doctrinal as far as I know? Jesus experienced pain and suffereing and death and so we cannot say that those who are perfect do not experience pain and suffereing.
kenrockthefirst Posted September 7, 2007 Author Posted September 7, 2007 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1380334' date='Sep 7 2007, 11:11 AM']The woman in Rev 12 is not only Mary and not completely Mary. Mary is a type of the Church, of which the passage can be viewed as as well, and it can be seen as Israel. Types do not have to have all of the elements of what they represent. Where did you get that Mary did not deliver Jesus vaginally however. It is a speculation as to why she might not have had pain but it is not even doctrinal as far as I know? Jesus experienced pain and suffereing and death and so we cannot say that those who are perfect do not experience pain and suffereing.[/quote] Thanks for your explanation. Re Jesus' physical birth, from the Catechism: 499 [i]The deepening of faith in the virginal motherhood led the Church to confess Mary's real and perpetual virginity even in the act of giving birth to the Son of God made man. In fact, Christ's birth "did not diminish his mother's virginal integrity but sanctified it." And so the liturgy of the Church celebrates Mary as Aeiparthenos, the "Ever-virgin." [/i] We've had other discussions on this board re how Mary's virginity remained intact despite Jesus' birth. I'd be interested in hearing whether there is official Church teaching on the physical nature of Jesus' birth.
Noel's angel Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 Surely you're diminishing the idea of virginity to a purely physical state if you believe it must have been necessary for a non-vaginal birth if Mary was to remain a virgin.
Resurrexi Posted September 7, 2007 Posted September 7, 2007 [quote][b]Fr. George Haydock's Catholic Bible Commentary for Apoc Ch. 12, Vs. 1:[/b] Ver. 1. A woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet. By this woman, interpreters commonly understand the Church of Christ, shining with the light of faith, under the protection of the sun of justice, Jesus Christ. The moon, the Church, hath all changeable things of this world under her feet, the affections of the faithful being raised above them all. --- A woman: the Church of God. It may also, by allusion, be applied to our blessed Lady [the Virgin Mary]. The Church is clothed with the sun, that is, with Christ: she hath the moon, that is, the changeable things of the world, under her feet; and the twelve stars with which she is crowned, are the twelve apostles: she is in labour and pain, whilst she brings forth her children, and Christ in them, in the midst of afflictions and persecutions. (Challoner) --- On her head....twelve stars, her doctrine being delivered by the twelve apostles and their successors. (Witham) [url="http://haydock1859.tripod.com/id298.html"]http://haydock1859.tripod.com/id298.html[/url][/quote] [quote][b]The Catechism of the Council of Trent:[/b] THE NATIVITY OF CHRIST TRANSCENDS THE ORDER OF NATURE But as the Conception itself transcends the order of nature, so the birth of our Lord presents to our contemplation nothing but what is divine. Besides, what is admirable beyond the power of thoughts or words to express, He is born of His Mother without any diminution of her maternal virginity, just as He afterwards went forth from the sepulchre while it was closed and sealed, and entered the room in which His disciples were assembled, the doors being shut;13 or not to depart from every-day examples, just as the rays of the sun penetrate without breaking or injuring in the least the solid substance of glass, so after a like but more exalted manner did Jesus Christ come forth from His mother's womb without injury to her maternal virginity. This immaculate and perpetual virginity forms, therefore, the just theme of our eulogy. Such was the work of the Holy Spirit, who at the Conception and birth of the Son so favored the Virgin Mother as to impart to her fecundity while preserving inviolate her perpetual virginity.* Christ Compared to Adam, Mary to Eve The Apostle sometimes calls Jesus Christ the second Adam, and compares Him to the first Adam; for as in the first all men die, so in the second all are made alive:14 and as in the natural order Adam was the father of the human race, so in the supernatural order Christ is the author of grace and of glory.15 The Virgin Mother we may also compare to Eve, making the second Eve, that is, Mary, correspond to the first, as we have already shown that the second Adam, that is, Christ, corresponds to the first Adam. By believing the serpent, Eve brought malediction and death on mankind, and Mary, by believing the Angel became the instrument of the divine goodness in bringing life and benediction to the human race. From Eve we are born children of wrath;16 from Mary we have received Jesus Christ, and through Him are regenerated children of grace. To Eve it was said: In sorrow shalt thou bring forth children.17 Mary was exempt from this law, for preserving her virginal integrity inviolate she brought forth Jesus the Son of God without experiencing, as we have already said, any sense of pain. Types and Prophecies of the Conception and Nativity The mysteries of this admirable Conception and Nativity being, therefore, so great and so numerous, it accorded with the plan of divine Providence to signify them by many types and prophecies. Hence the holy Fathers understood many things which we meet in the Sacred Scriptures to refer to these mysteries, particularly that gate of the sanctuary which Ezechiel saw closed;18 the stone cut out of the mountain without hands, which became a great mountain and filled the universe, of which we read in Daniel;19 the rod of Aaron, which alone budded of all the rods of the princes of Israel;20 and the bush which Moses saw burning without being consumed.21 The holy Evangelist describes in detail the history of the birth of Christ;22 but, as the pastor can easily recur to the Sacred Volume, it is unnecessary for us to say more on the subject. [url="http://catecheticsonline.com/Trent.php"]http://catecheticsonline.com/Trent.php[/url][/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1380250' date='Sep 7 2007, 08:47 AM']If I understand correctly, the Catholic Church interprets the woman spoken of in Revelation 12 as Mary.[/quote] In the Fathers of the Church the woman is variously interpreted (the Church, Our Lady, or both). Magisterial teaching has proposed the Marian interpretation of Revelation 12 (for example the dogmatic decree concerning the assumption of Mary) but this does not in any way exclude the ecclesiological interpretation of the same pericope. Polyvalent symbolism is perfectly common to the apocalyptic-prophetic genre. In light of other biblical texts I am of the view that Rev 12 can be understood according to the concept of corporate personality. I wrote up a series of posts on Rev. 12 a couple years ago from which I shall now glean quotes. "[i]The commingling of the collective and the individual is proper to the Hebrew mentality, in particular with regard to visions of the future... One can readily grant that modern thought would not have devised such a mode of expression... It is a rich and fruitful concept which the Old Testament provides us with, and its proper milieu is the Hebrew mentality itself[/i]." - J. Coppens, Le Protevangile "[i]Corporate personality allows that the whole group, including its past, present and future members might function as a single individual through any one of those members conceived as representative of it[/i]." - W. Robinson, The Hebrew Conception of Corporate Personality Some aspects of corporate personality: [i]a. The unity of its extension both into the past and into the future. b. Characteristic "realism", which distinguishes it from "personification", and makes the group a real entity actualized in its members. It is neither a literary personification nor merely an ideal. c. Fluidity of reference, facilitating rapid and unmarked transitions from the one to the many and from the many to the one. Thus... it is easy to understand how the nation can be represented by some outstanding figure belonging to it.[/i] - From The Hebrew Conception of Corporate Personality Connected with this concept are the concepts of totality conception and the law of participation. The law of participation means [i]"that things, beings and phenomena can be at once themselves and something other than themselves. This identification permits the primitive mind to think at the same time of the individual in the collective and the collective in the individual[/i]." - "The Hebrew Conception of Corporate Personality" "[i]It is a fact that the primitive thinks in a concrete, synthetic way and not in an abstract, analytical manner as we are accustomed to. He is not a friend of many distinctions. He does identify himself with his tribe, not in a materialistic way, but in a way that reminds us of the corporate personality of the Hebrews[/i]." - W. Koppers, Primitive Man and his World Picture I wrote a crude essay specifically on this topic a while back but I can't find it at the moment.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 For more details you can scope out this very old thread in which I made a number of related points. [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=8581"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=8581[/url] Please excuse the atrocious grammar and butt-ugly sentences. I was apparently a very sloppy writer at that time (not that I'm much better now).
cathoholic_anonymous Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1380568' date='Sep 7 2007, 11:13 PM']Surely you're diminishing the idea of virginity to a purely physical state if you believe it must have been necessary for a non-vaginal birth if Mary was to remain a virgin.[/quote] A very good point. Lots of women cease to be 'intact' for a variety of non-sexual reasons - taking part in strenuous sports, using tampons, even just walking down the street. (And apologies if that was too much information for most people.) With regard to the original question: is physical pain in childbirth really what God meant during Genesis? I feel a qwerty sort of pain when I look at something very beautiful. Pain is not necessarily an entirely negative thing. My mum tells me that giving birth to me was one of the loveliest experiences of her life, even though it hurt.
kenrockthefirst Posted September 10, 2007 Author Posted September 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1380568' date='Sep 7 2007, 04:13 PM']Surely you're diminishing the idea of virginity to a purely physical state if you believe it must have been necessary for a non-vaginal birth if Mary was to remain a virgin.[/quote] [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1381162' date='Sep 8 2007, 03:56 PM']A very good point. Lots of women cease to be 'intact' for a variety of non-sexual reasons - taking part in strenuous sports, using tampons, even just walking down the street. (And apologies if that was too much information for most people.) With regard to the original question: is physical pain in childbirth really what God meant during Genesis? I feel a qwerty sort of pain when I look at something very beautiful. Pain is not necessarily an entirely negative thing. My mum tells me that giving birth to me was one of the loveliest experiences of her life, even though it hurt.[/quote] I'm echoing my understanding of what the Church teaches, to wit, that Jesus was not delivered via Mary's birth canal. The most important aspect of this is that Mary did not experience the pain associated with childbirth, a consequence of the Fall, which as far as I understand it is what is clearly meant in Genesis, i.e. that childbirth will hurt, a lot. What I was primarily interested in in my original post was not whether Mary's hymen remained intact or not - which is really neither here nor there - but whether she experienced an effect of the Fall. Some of the other posters have cleared up that point for me insofar as they've clarified that the "woman" spoken of in Revelation 12 can be variously understood as Mary, the Church, or Israel. As an aside, and FWIW, I was present at the birth of all three of my children, and I can tell you from what I observed that in the case of my wife, while childbirth may have been a deeply [i]spiritual[/i] experience, it was also a deeply [i]painful[/i] one.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 11, 2007 Posted September 11, 2007 I can offer my assistance in clarifying Catholic dogma on the pending issue. The ancient Church spoke of Our Lady as ever-virgin [[i]aeinarthenos[/i]] and in general the speculations of the fathers understood this as meaning, among other things, that Mary's hymen was not broken in bringing forth the Christ (although there is a degree of divergence in patristic speculation on this specific point). This popular understanding was coupled with the idea that the birth of Christ occurred in a miraculous fashion and undoubtedly without the pains of birth. The assertion that Mary's physical virginity was lost in bringing forth Christ was explicitly condemned by a local synod presided over by Saint Ambrose and later rejected by the Fifth Ecumenical Council at Constantinople which gave Our Lady the title "perpetual virgin" [[i]aeiparthenos[/i]]. But does not the question of how one defines physical virginity still linger? Certainly in the ancient world the integrity of the hymen was of prime importance, but in today's understanding the hymen is only circumstantially connected with virginity. Properly speaking virginity (in the formal physical sense) refers simply to the state of not having engaged in the sex act and the status of the hymen is of little concern since it can be ruptured in many non-sexual ways and some women may even be born with little hymen to speak of or a hymen that by archaic standards is already "ruptured." When the state of the hymen is not intrinsically linked to virginal integrity the rupture of the hymen in the case of the virgin birth becomes nothing more than the natural result of child birth and hardly a tainting of virginity. Within the scope of the modern understanding of virginity the dogmatic formulation which says that Mary remained a virgin, including the full physical sense, during and even after the birth of Christ amounts to little more than saying that Mary did not engage in the sexual act even after the birth of Christ. In effect the teaching seems to be emptied of some of its content. One must "historicize" the teaching to some extent since the insistence on virginity "during" the birth amounts to little more than an appeasement to the culture of the time; surely we have moved beyond such things. And yet Pope Pius XII in our own time affirms that Our Lady gave birth to Our Lord in a miraculous fashion -- what are we to make of this? Given the historical-theological context of Constantinople's definitions it would seem that the implication of hymen integrity ought to follow. Theologians and saints of the past have often elucidated the miraculous birth and have seen various biblical types and symbols as referring to this. Images such as "the closed gates", "the garden enclosed", "the sealed fountain", the sealed tomb of the resurrected Christ, His passing through closed doors, etc. have been interpreted in reference to that miraculous child birth which left even the hymen of the mother intact. Many of the fathers are extremely adamant on this point and seemingly consider it to be tradition in the full sense and not mere conjecture. But what can truly be said to be dogmatically proposed? Based on dogmatic conciliar definitions and definitive papal teachings (i.e., Pope Martin I; Pope Paul IV) we can first affirm a three-fold character of this perpetual virginity. 1. Virginity of the mind which means a constant virginal disposition. 2. Virginity of the senses or of desire which means freedom from inordinate sexual desire. 3. Virginity of the body which means that physical integrity that is proper to the virginal state. But the question has still not been completely answered: does this physical integrity mean definitively that the hymen must be intact or does it suffice to say that there had never been a sexual act or insemination? The traditional view would probably be the miraculous birth interpretation, but for many this implies something negative toward maternity and alienates Our Lady from maternity and humanity. On top of this the hymen preoccupation is attributed to archaic understandings of the body and perhaps even a creeping Gnosticism (an inference that I strongly reject btw). This would no doubt be the assessment of the modernist minded; but then there are those of another stripe who would consider such an inquiry to be impious in the first place -- who are content to affirm the mysteriousness of the doctrine and leave it at that. As for myself I prefer to be in the company of many great fathers and saints in affirming the miraculous, painless birth. I believe a strong case could be made for this view based on Catholic principles, but as to the question of strict dogmatics, I must suggest that there is a good bit of room for interpretation. Saint Thomas Aquinas affirms the traditional understanding thus (although I don't want to be misleading by calling it "the" traditional understanding since tradition is not in fact univocal on the specifics): [quote]In a sermon of the Council of Ephesus (P. III, Cap. ix) it is said: "After giving birth, nature knows not a virgin: but grace enhances her fruitfulness, and effects her motherhood, while in no way does it injure her virginity." Therefore Christ's Mother was a virgin also in giving birth to Him. I answer that, Without any doubt whatever we must assert that the Mother of Christ was a virgin even in His Birth: for the prophet says not only: "Behold a virgin shall conceive," but adds: "and shall bear a son." This indeed was befitting for three reasons. First, because this was in keeping with a property of Him whose Birth is in question, for He is the Word of God. For the word is not only conceived in the mind without corruption, but also proceeds from the mind without corruption. Wherefore in order to show that body to be the body of the very Word of God, it was fitting that it should be born of a virgin incorrupt. Whence in the sermon of the Council of Ephesus (quoted above) we read: "Whosoever brings forth mere flesh, ceases to be a virgin. But since she gave birth to the Word made flesh, God safeguarded her virginity so as to manifest His Word, by which Word He thus manifested Himself: for neither does our word, when brought forth, corrupt the mind; nor does God, the substantial Word, deigning to be born, destroy virginity." Secondly, this is fitting as regards the effect of Christ's Incarnation: since He came for this purpose, that He might take away our corruption. Wherefore it is unfitting that in His Birth He should corrupt His Mother's virginity. Thus Augustine says in a sermon on the Nativity of Our Lord: "It was not right that He who came to heal corruption, should by His advent violate integrity." Thirdly, it was fitting that He Who commanded us to honor our father and mother should not in His Birth lessen the honor due to His Mother. Reply to Objection 1. Ambrose says this in expounding the evangelist's quotation from the Law: "Every male opening the womb shall be called holy to the Lord." This, says Bede, "is said in regard to the wonted manner of birth; not that we are to believe that our Lord in coming forth violated the abode of her sacred womb, which His entrance therein had hallowed." Wherefore the opening here spoken of does not imply the unlocking of the enclosure of virginal purity; but the mere coming forth of the infant from the maternal womb. Reply to Objection 2. Christ wished so to show the reality of His body, as to manifest His Godhead at the same time. For this reason He mingled wondrous with lowly things. Wherefore, to show that His body was real, He was born of a woman. But in order to manifest His Godhead, He was born of a virgin, for "such a Birth befits a God," as Ambrose says in the Christmas hymn. Reply to Objection 3. Some have held that Christ, in His Birth, assumed the gift of "subtlety," when He came forth from the closed womb of a virgin; and that He assumed the gift of "agility" when with dry feet He walked on the sea. But this is not consistent with what has been decided above (14). For these gifts of a glorified body result from an overflow of the soul's glory on to the body, as we shall explain further on, in treating of glorified bodies (XP, 82): and it has been said above (13, 3, ad 1; 16, 1, ad 2) that before His Passion Christ "allowed His flesh to do and to suffer what was proper to it" (Damascene, De Fide Orth. iii): nor was there such an overflow of glory from His soul on to His body. We must therefore say that all these things took place miraculously by Divine power. Whence Augustine says (Sup. Joan. Tract. 121): "To the substance of a body in which was the Godhead closed doors were no obstacle. For truly He had power to enter in by doors not open, in Whose Birth His Mother's virginity remained inviolate." And Dionysius says in an epistle (Ad Caium iv) that "Christ excelled man in doing that which is proper to man: this is shown in His supernatural conception, of a virgin, and in the unstable waters bearing the weight of earthly feet."[/quote] As far as Revelation 12 is concerned I will simply note the fact that the birth pangs mentioned are often interpreted (in their Marian sense) in connection with the prophecy of Simeon in Luke’s gospel and the crucifixion account of John’s gospel. The polyvalent symbolism of this passage affords a multifaceted, synthetic interpretation such that this act of bringing forth refers both to the nativity of Christ proper, and the bringing forth of the entire body of Christ in that birth of the Church on Calvary. There is also an historical and even eschatological possibility here.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 You know, I've been thinking about this thread a bit and I don't see how the dogma of Our Lady's perpetual virginity can be understood other than clearly meaning a painless birth that resulted in no physical damage to the body of Mary – In other words, a miraculous birth of some kind. Although I have already done so, I must now even more strongly reject the speculations that litter my previous post (insofar as they undermine this conclusion).
Chiquitunga Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 [url="http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13"]http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1388493' date='Sep 19 2007, 01:54 AM'][url="http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13"]http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13[/url][/quote] Wow, this looks awesome so far.
beatty07 Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 At some point, in zeal to protect Mary's uniqueness, do we weaken the sense in which she gave birth to the Lord? I'm just asking because the thought that Jesus just sort of translocated from her womb to the outside world...well, is that really "giving birth"? Doesn't it seem to fit the whole beauty of the Incarnation better if the Lord was born in a more natural way? I've never understood why Mary's hymen was important, or even why it was considered an appropriate subject for discussion. But it's definitely there in the Fathers... and there does seem to be pretty considerable weight on one side in the tradition. So for me, this is sort of an intellectual humility thing. I just don't get it, but so what? There's no way I'm gonna say that all those Fathers and saints are wrong. At the same time, I would insist that this matter is in the realm of opinion, for reasons well explained in L_D's first post.
withouthavingseen Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 L_D's essay was thorough, balanced, and articulate. Thanks for that. It strikes me to be the sort of question we wouldn't ask in an unfallen world. The Church's constant teaching has been that Mary is untouched by any of the intrinsic effects of the Fall. While extrinsic effects (other people's sins) might do her harm (crucify her Son, for instance), the moral and physical effects concomitant to sin are entirely absent in Mary. Thus, while she had to grow and mature like anyone else, her maturation was unimpeded by sin; on the contrary, sin impedes our maturation, and sometimes very extensively. Genesis 3:16 lays out the primary consequences of sinful nature upon women (as women): the intensification of childbearing pain and dysfunctional, even morally enslaved, relationships with men. Mary would be unimpeded by those as much as any of the other consequences of sin, being free not only from actual sin, but the proclivity toward sin (original sin) intermingled with our nature. In an unfallen world, EVERY childbirth would be relatively painless. While children would still be conceived in the normal, beautiful sexual way, in an unfallen, chaste world, we can speculate that neither chaste marital relations nor childbirth would damage a woman's integrity in any way. Far from rupturing the integrity of a woman physically, motherhood is intended to perfect it. We would all know more or less what the Virgin's delivery was like, because it would be more or less like all the others, differing only in paternity and conception. A THEORY: Another possibility is that the hymen itself is a result of the Fall (though unmentioned in Scripture) - a sort of natural guard against disintegrity. Indeed, one of the mechanisms by which men historically (and still in traditional cultures) lord their power over women is by the hymen. Whereas his philandering might be tolerated, hers is not - and the ultimate mechanism to prove a woman has not "known" a man, is (perceived to be) by her hymen. Thus a man might take a dozen women during his youth, rendering them all unmarriageable, while yet marrying himself. In many cultures the hymen thus becomes caught up in a pattern of sexual domination and control. In which case, Mary would not have been anatomically damaged because she would not have such a post-Fall condition (of having a hymen) in the first place. The hymen is important, not because virginity is only an anatomical condition (although, in the canon law of the time, that was exactly the meaning and intent) but because of the integrity it shows. Sin causes disintegrity - duplicity in relationships, non-correspondence between knowledge of goodness and our desires, lack of self-control, and so on. Not only was Mary's soul integrated, and her body integrated, but her body and soul were better integrated than any since Adam and Eve's before the Fall. Death, the ultimate dis-integration of soul from body, had no claim upon her. The intactness, or at least inviolateness, of her body is an outward manifestation of the intactness and inviolateness of her soul. That's why the hymen is important. All that said, the dogma boils down to this: 1) Mary is untainted by any stain of original sin. (One can safely assume that any pain beyond the level of discomfort is excluded from her delivering the Messiah to the world.) 2) Mary was virginal before, during, and after her delivery of Jesus, in whatever (dogmatically undefined) manner. (Remember, a woman who delivers by caesarian still very much delivers. Mary's delivery would not be enhanced by painfulness. Sacrifice and pain are concomitant to love only in a fallen world.) 3) "Virginal" was understood very much to mean "hymen unruptured" and thus we must reason that they meant Mary's hymen was unruptured. (How that is possible is subject to discussion. I offered a theory above, but don't necessarily support or defend it. There are other conceivable theories.) Maybe the best idea is, at some point, submission of the mind to the mystery.
kenrockthefirst Posted September 19, 2007 Author Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1388493' date='Sep 19 2007, 01:54 AM'][url="http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13"]http://www.airmaria.com/?p=13[/url][/quote] Thanks, good stuff, very helpful. BTW, your avatar is the cover of the book, "Hail, Holy Queen" by Scott Hahn.
Chiquitunga Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 (edited) [quote name='withouthavingseen' post='1388603' date='Sep 19 2007, 09:32 AM']A THEORY: Another possibility is that the hymen itself is a result of the Fall (though unmentioned in Scripture) - a sort of natural guard against disintegrity. Indeed, one of the mechanisms by which men historically (and still in traditional cultures) lord their power over women is by the hymen. Whereas his philandering might be tolerated, hers is not - and the ultimate mechanism to prove a woman has not "known" a man, is (perceived to be) by her hymen. Thus a man might take a dozen women during his youth, rendering them all unmarriageable, while yet marrying himself. In many cultures the hymen thus becomes caught up in a pattern of sexual domination and control. In which case, Mary would not have been anatomically damaged because she would not have such a post-Fall condition (of having a hymen) in the first place.[/quote] I don't think this theory makes sense though. Why then would the Church say in the The Catechism of the Council of Trent: [quote]... just as He afterwards went forth from the sepulchre while it was closed and sealed, and entered the room in which His disciples were assembled, the doors being shut; or not to depart from every-day examples, just as the rays of the sun penetrate without breaking or injuring in the least the solid substance of glass, so after a like but more exalted manner did Jesus Christ come forth from His mother's womb without injury to her maternal virginity.[/quote] Edited September 19, 2007 by Margaret Clare
Chiquitunga Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1381162' date='Sep 8 2007, 02:56 PM']A very good point. Lots of women cease to be 'intact' for a variety of non-sexual reasons - taking part in strenuous sports, using tampons, even just walking down the street. (And apologies if that was too much information for most people.)[/quote] CA, thanks for stating this, as it’s an important point to bring up. I think some women can (seriously not at all implying that anyone here is doing this) take this defending of this particular aspect of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary, to a personal level, and become offended by it. Also because as was stated above, this particular definition of physical virginity has been used many times to the detriment of women throughout history and in different cultures. It was good you brought this up so it can be properly understood, as L_D explained it well. [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1383287' date='Sep 10 2007, 11:53 PM']Properly speaking virginity (in the formal physical sense) refers simply to the state of not having engaged in the sex act and the status of the hymen is of little concern since it can be ruptured in many non-sexual ways and some women may even be born with little hymen to speak of or a hymen that by archaic standards is already "ruptured."[/quote] I can totally understand this, as I myself have engaged in much strenuous activity throughout my life, like cross country running and horseback riding, and am very concerned with remaining a virgin, like Mary, as I'm discerning religious life, etc. But (again seriously not at all implying that anyone is doing this - just making a general statement from my point of view) this does not at all cause me to question the Church’s traditional teaching on the Perpetual Virginity of Mary; that during the birth of her only Son, her body remained intact – that she remained a virgin even in the strict archaic definition of the word, as the Fathers and saints throughout the centuries have said. [quote name='withouthavingseen' post='1388603' date='Sep 19 2007, 09:32 AM']"Virginal" was understood very much to mean "hymen unruptured" and thus we must reason that they meant Mary's hymen was unruptured. (How that is possible is subject to discussion. I offered a theory above, but don't necessarily support or defend it. There are other conceivable theories.)[/quote] The other theory would be plain and simply as it’s described above in the CCT, that Christ passed through Mary as He passed through closed doors after the Resurrection, in a miraculous way. I’m venturing here from dogma and official Church teaching, but several approved private revelations, like St. Bridget of Sweden, Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich, or Venerable Mary of Agreda’s visions of the Nativity, portray beautifully how this miraculous birth took place – though again, this is not required for belief, as is known. I believe though, as Fr. Angelo Geiger, FI has stated, this strict definition of physical virginity and the miraculous birth of Christ, is a part of the dogma of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary. [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1388631' date='Sep 19 2007, 10:46 AM']Thanks, good stuff, very helpful. BTW, your avatar is the cover of the book, "Hail, Holy Queen" by Scott Hahn.[/quote] Yeah, we have that book, though I haven’t read it – yet. It’s Alessandro Botticelli’s, [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madonna_del_Magnificat"][i]Madonna of the Magnificat[/i][/url] More on Mary's physical virginity: [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/VIRBIR.TXT"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/SCRIPTUR/VIRBIR.TXT[/url] A thread I started a while back: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61521"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61521[/url] (I did know that the Perpetual Virginity of Mary, before, during & after is a dogma, but didn't state it well in my first post)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now