CatholicCid Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 Hello, I was attending an apologetic's group today and we were discussing papal authority and infallibility. The first Scripture we heard was Matthew 16:13-20 [quote]13When Jesus came to the region of Caesarea Philippi, he asked his disciples, "Who do people say the Son of Man is?" 14They replied, "Some say John the Baptist; others say Elijah; and still others, Jeremiah or one of the prophets." 15"But what about you?" he asked. "Who do you say I am?" 16Simon Peter answered, "You are the Christ,[b] the Son of the living God." 17Jesus replied, "Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by man, but by my Father in heaven. 18And I tell you that you are Peter,[c] and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades[d] will not overcome it.[e] 19I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be[f] bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be[g] loosed in heaven." 20Then he warned his disciples not to tell anyone that he was the Christ.[/quote] Do you think this verse (16) would qualify as a infallible statement? Peter, the first Pope, makes a statement on Christ, which would seem to be a faith issue. Jesus Christ responds with ""Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by man, but by my Father in heaven." Jesus confirms that Peter was speaking truth through guidance of the Holy Spirit. Or, is Peter not considered Pope yet and this statement cannot be infallible? God Bless
Era Might Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 What St. Peter received was a revelation, which is different from the charism of infallibility. Like his epistles in Scripture, he was inspired by the Holy Spirit, whereas the Popes are not inspired, they are only protected from error (when speaking ex cathedra). As an Apostle, St. Peter was a giver of Christ's Revelation. The Popes cannot give Revelation, they can only preserve what has been given by the Apostles.
Resurrexi Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 Also, St. Peter did not become a bishop until the Last Supper and did not become the Supreme Pontiff until the last chapter of the Gospel of St. John.
CatholicCid Posted September 8, 2007 Author Posted September 8, 2007 (edited) Yeah, I figured it was most likely revelation, but thought it be cool if otherwise. Thanks (This can be locked if the mods want) Edited September 8, 2007 by CatholicCid
XIX Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1380749' date='Sep 7 2007, 11:29 PM']What St. Peter received was a revelation, which is different from the charism of infallibility. Like his epistles in Scripture, he was inspired by the Holy Spirit, whereas the Popes are not inspired, they are only protected from error (when speaking ex cathedra). As an Apostle, St. Peter was a giver of Christ's Revelation. The Popes cannot give Revelation, they can only preserve what has been given by the Apostles.[/quote] A key difference which you seem to be touching on is that Popes might believe heresy, but they will never teach it. Hence, even sketchy popes are protected by the charism of fallibility. In fact, I think we have a few historical cases of popes who have believed heretical beliefs but could not bring themselves to preach them.
Era Might Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1380834' date='Sep 8 2007, 08:27 AM']A key difference which you seem to be touching on is that Popes might believe heresy, but they will never teach it. Hence, even sketchy popes are protected by the charism of fallibility. In fact, I think we have a few historical cases of popes who have believed heretical beliefs but could not bring themselves to preach them.[/quote] Not necessarily. I'm not sure if the Church has formally made any distinction here, but I would be inclined to believe that the Popes cannot even be heretics personally.
Totus Tuus Posted September 8, 2007 Posted September 8, 2007 It also enters into my mind that Peter wouldn't have been making infallible statements while Christ was still alive, but that could be irrelevant.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now