Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Parents Want To Convert To Episcopalian


Recommended Posts

Laurentina1975
Posted

A conversation at the dinner table yielded some discussion about how my parents want to visit the Episcopalian Church. Does anyone know what core beliefs? I know they don't recognize Rome (the pope, etc) and that they still have devotions to Our Lady and the Saints.

What can I bring forth to them to make them at least consider staying in the Catholic Church?

Also, what are the pro's and con's of being Episcopalian?

I am not too keen on this religion.

Thanks

Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted (edited)

I can't think of any pros at the moment...but some pretty hefty cons would be invalid priesthood, defiance to the Supreme Pontiff, and an invaild liturgy (no Eucharist).

That's just my $.02...

Edited by Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted

yeah...though there's plenty of other points to be made, it really all comes down to the Eucharist. If they believe, wild horses won't be able to drag them away. If not... what can one say?

Posted

I would say rather than focusing on why the Episcopalians aren't as good, maybe try to see what their beef is with the Catholic Church. What is making them look for greener pastures elsewhere in the first place?

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1386614' date='Sep 16 2007, 08:46 PM']I would say rather than focusing on why the Episcopalians aren't as good, maybe try to see what their beef is with the Catholic Church. What is making them look for greener pastures elsewhere in the first place?[/quote]

:yes:

Beyond that, I suggest that you commend them to the Immaculate Heart of Mary through the simple prayer, "Immaculate heart of Mary, pray for us now and at the hour of our death." It is a prayer of healing and conversion, and it is closely associated with the green scapular. If you can get hold of such a scapular it might be very helpful.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

When it comes to advantages of the Episcopalian Church over the Catholic Church, I think Robin Williams, an Episcopalian, said it best, "All the sin, none of the guilt."

Posted

Pros-

Religious relativism
Gay bishops that abandon their wife and daughter

Posted

Episcopalianism is catholic lite: they range from disbelief in Jesus himself to fervant christians. They have no valid ordination, no eucharist, and the Communion is breaking up now do to the ordination of gay bishops. Their hierarchy has no actual power to enforce any standards. Imagine a church governed by committee [ think of the US congress to see how well THAT works]. They need prayers for tthier particular issues, just as we do for ours.

Laurentina1975
Posted

So there is no communion what so ever?? Like no breaking of the bread? Obviously they don't have the Eucharist, but is there any type of communion?

As far as praying for my parents, I believe they can make their won choices. I am not against it or for it really, I just wish them to be happy and where they are comfortable.

I gues what happened was this church here in Mesa Arizona that they belonged to (a Catholic one) wants to rebuild a new church and they are asking the parishoners for 5800 a family. They also request in their chruch bulletin $10 a mass. My dad, however, always gives $$ and is very generous. But my parents are wealthy. I guess they were taken aback by the request from the church.

I tried to explain to them that it is logical that they ask for donations because the masses are wall to wall packed and there are not enough of them here in AZ. I also explained that the Church isn't DEMANDING it.

For my father, it is the "concept".

Personally, I am tired of arguing with them. I don't think running away because of money is the answer to remaining faithful to what you believe.

I have no idea what else to say to them except, they will probably be back.

Older folks.......sheesh.

Posted

I've attended a service and visited Episcopal/Anglican churches before. And while many people can't put their finger on it, something feels "missing." (We can safely say that what is missing is the Eucharist.) I have had a friend who flirted with the Episcopal church when she was lapsing as a Catholic -- but it didn't really last.

And how is it that the concept of building a new church and asking for money is somehow exclusive to Catholicism? It's not like new Episcopal churches materialize out of thin air and are for free...

Posted

[quote name='Laurentina1975' post='1386850' date='Sep 17 2007, 12:38 AM']So there is no communion what so ever?? Like no breaking of the bread? Obviously they don't have the Eucharist, but is there any type of communion?[/quote]
The have communion, but it's invalid. They do not believe in transubstantiation, but a more Lutheran/Calvinist consubstantiation. However, they do use the words of institution, and if a Catholic priest defects to the Anglican church, he still actually retains the ability to consecrate, and may do so, however illicitly.

[quote name='Laurentina1975' post='1386850' date='Sep 17 2007, 12:38 AM']As far as praying for my parents, I believe they can make their won choices. I am not against it or for it really, I just wish them to be happy and where they are comfortable.[/quote]

Your parents are considering committing heresy and schism. You are ambivalent towards your parents' actions, and if you do not take actions to prevent it -- and at the bare minimum, that means praying for them -- you are at least partially guilty. It's not outright apostasy, as it would be if they became a Hindu or Mohammedan or something, but it's really, really bad, and could very well lead them to hell.

Posted

[quote]As far as praying for my parents, I believe they can make their won choices. I am not against it or for it really, I just wish them to be happy and where they are comfortable.[/quote]

One cannot leave the boosom of the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church and still be happy. Prayer is not about taking their choice away. It's about God giving them the grace so that they truly have choice, rather than follow after their humanly corrupt minds and passions. What they propose to do is a serious sin. The Catholic Church is the fullness of the truth and separating oneself from it is not without serious consequence. Be concerned.

Posted

[quote]As far as praying for my parents, I believe they can make their won choices. I am not against it or for it really, I just wish them to be happy and where they are comfortable.[/quote]

One cannot leave the boosom of the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church and still be happy. Prayer is not about taking their choice away. It's about God giving them the grace so that they truly have choice, rather than follow after their humanly corrupt minds and passions. What they propose to do is a serious sin. The Catholic Church is the fullness of the truth and separating oneself from it is not without serious consequence. Be concerned.

Posted

Wow. I guess I am a little more like you on this one. They are adults. You must remember they are more than that, they are your parents. You must respect them no matter what their choices are. I would suggest bringing up the areas their new choice will be lacking, and I would be gentle about it. At the end of the day, you must remember to honor your parents.

Pray for them. Gently show them the truth. Lead by example.

:)

Posted

[quote name='Laurentina1975' post='1386850' date='Sep 16 2007, 11:38 PM']So there is no communion what so ever?? Like no breaking of the bread? Obviously they don't have the Eucharist, but is there any type of communion?

As far as praying for my parents, I believe they can make their won choices. I am not against it or for it really, I just wish them to be happy and where they are comfortable.

I gues what happened was this church here in Mesa Arizona that they belonged to (a Catholic one) wants to rebuild a new church and they are asking the parishoners for 5800 a family. They also request in their chruch bulletin $10 a mass. My dad, however, always gives $$ and is very generous. But my parents are wealthy. I guess they were taken aback by the request from the church.

I tried to explain to them that it is logical that they ask for donations because the masses are wall to wall packed and there are not enough of them here in AZ. I also explained that the Church isn't DEMANDING it.

For my father, it is the "concept".

Personally, I am tired of arguing with them. I don't think running away because of money is the answer to remaining faithful to what you believe.

I have no idea what else to say to them except, they will probably be back.

Older folks.......sheesh.[/quote]
I think the communion that CMom was referring to was in the sense of unity, not in the sense of the Eucharist.

photosynthesis
Posted

Sometimes people think that Episcopalians are "Junior Varsity Catholics" or "Catholic Lite." That's because on the surface, there are a lot of similiarities between the Episcopal Church and the Catholic Church. Episcopal Churches spend lots of money on a good organist and choir. Their church buildings actually look like churches, instead of spaceships and office buildings. Episcopal pastors aren't afraid to preach a 30-minute sermon. To a certain extent, the Episcopal Church has very good at preserving Tradition and so they often seem "more Catholic" than we are. They also have bishops, they call their churches 'parishes,' and their service follows a strikingly similar format to the Mass.

Morally and theologically, the Episcopal Church and the Catholic Church are not similar at all. They allow women to be priests, they are OK with contraception and homosexuality, and in general, they are getting more lackadaisical with their morality every day. The Episcopal Church doesn't teach that Jesus Christ is fully present in the Eucharist, and they don't have confession. Instead of seeing marriage as a holy Sacrament and a vocation, they desecrate it by allowing men to marry men and women to marry women, and giving official blessings for divorces. If your parents have any respect for the sanctity of their marriage, I can't see them being happy in a church that would allow such error.

Sometimes it's easy for people to leave the Catholic Church for the Episcopal church because they're not aware of the theological differences and they don't understand how schism is a grave sin. It's up to you to tell them.

Posted (edited)

Prose,

I agree that they are adults and will make their own decision and that whatever the outcome she must love them and respect and honor them. But the "they are adults" comment came in response to someone saying she should pray for them. Further I think that one who takes a very non-chalant attitude toward this needs to read Dominus Iesus and consider whether they come under the heresy of indiffentism or not. Not trying to be confrontational or finger pointy but it is a serious matter.


[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congrega...s-iesus_en.html[/url]

22. With the coming of the Saviour Jesus Christ, God has willed that the Church founded by him be the instrument for the salvation of all humanity (cf. Acts 17:30-31).90 This truth of faith does not lessen the sincere respect which the Church has for the religions of the world, but at the same time, it [b]rules out[/b], [b]in a radical way[/b], that mentality of[b] indifferentism [/b]“characterized by a religious relativism which leads to the belief that ‘one religion is as good as another'”.91 If it is true that the followers of other religions can receive divine grace, it is also certain that objectively speaking they are in a [b]gravely deficient situation [/b]in comparison with those who, in the Church, have the fullness of the means of salvation.92

She and we all MUST pray for them. They are in my prayers.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

I don't see how anything I said was indifferent.

I was clear: gently tell them what is wrong, and pray for them.

The only thing I added was that she must still honor them as her mother and father.

When I was saying "they are adults" I was referring to them being capable of making their own decisions.

Posted

See quote in my second to last post from her. If you are a little more like her then I have to disagree and we should pray. But I don't believe you meant that.

Posted

Ah. OKay, I see what you are talking about.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...