missionseeker Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 It says something like reconciliation with the Church is inseperable with reconciliation with God (I don't have my CCC with me) I was wondering what about those people whom the CHurch has excommunicated but then a couple hundred years later decided they were wrong? I asked my professor and he said "good question", it spurred a debate, and we moved on. Is there a bettter answer? How does that work? Surely they weren't sent to Hell because they dies in a state of excommunication and then taken out when the Church lifted it. But if they went to Heaven, wouldn't that mean the Church was theoliogically wrong?
withouthavingseen Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 Missionseeker, The Church, as far as I know, has never lifted an excommunication after the excommunicated's death. Did you have anyone specific in mind? If you have some specific people, I could research maybe to see whatever happened... One thing of which to beware is the usual inadequacy of reporting in the mainstream media with respect to religious events. The media is geared toward soundbites, which are pretty unnuanced. Religions, on the other hand, especially things pertaining to the Catholic religion, are often very nuanced. The unbelief common among media personnel also leaves them badly suited to report on the topic. It's like having me to report on interest rate fluctuation at the Federal Reserve, even though I cannot even balance my checkbook. Combine those two things (failure to grasp nuance, failure to appreciate religion) and you have a perfect recipe for bad reporting.
thessalonian Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 When you have the internet and google you always have the ccc. [url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p2s2c2a4.htm#IV"]http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p2s2c2a4.htm#IV[/url] 1445 The words bind and loose mean: whomever you exclude from your communion, will be excluded from communion with God; whomever you receive anew into your communion, God will welcome back into his. Reconciliation with the Church is inseparable from reconciliation with God.
N/A Gone Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 Thes, correct me. Church=manager God=owner If God wants to override the manager its all good. Its his store. We just do our job.
thessalonian Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1389022' date='Sep 20 2007, 10:19 AM']Thes, correct me. Church=manager God=owner If God wants to override the manager its all good. Its his store. We just do our job.[/quote] The paragraph does indicate that those who are excommunicated have a grave moral obligation to be reconciled with the Church. I see it in that light. If a preist retains sins in the confessional they are in fact retained and one must do what is neccessary to loose them according to the priests instructions. I am a bit cautious about your statement. Edited September 20, 2007 by thessalonian
withouthavingseen Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 Revprodeji, The metaphor that our Lord used is probably better, because it's the one He used, and He's undoubtedly better! In giving Peter "keys" to the Kingdom, he was using the sort of language that was in common use for a very long time before and since, and only meant one thing. Now we talk about giving someone the "keys to the city" as an honorary award that means only that the city is proud of the recipient. But if I gave you keys to my house, it would mean something closer to what our Lord and his contemporaries meant. For us, giving to a neighbor, friend, or lover keys to our house is essentially a statement of trust. "I trust that you will keep these in case I need them, and in the meantime, that you will only use them for legitimate business in my home based on an implicit understanding we have of what you may and may not do there." Back then, giving keys to the kingdom, or the estate was not only to trust someone to enter the kingdom, but to govern it. The keys were a symbol of authority as a stand-in for the king, or the landowner, or whoever. In fact, the authority lent was so complete that the actual owner was legally and morally bound to whatever actions were undertaken by his vicar in his name. There was no "overruling" of the "manager" by a "storekeeper" - the transference of authority by the owner, though conditional and temporary, was complete. "What you hold bound on earth is bound in heaven, and what you loosen on earth is loosed in heaven," (Mt 18:18) as our Lord said it. The trust here is so complete that the "owner" (God) commits himself [i]in advance[/i] to [i]whatever[/i] decision the "manager" (the Church) makes. No owner does this to or for his manager. But that is what God has done for the Church, particularly for Peter and his successors. In order to not make a false teacher out of God, then, the charism of infallibility is essential; otherwise God is commiting himself not to stand by His rock, but to sway in the breeze, pushed about by the changing winds of fashion.
withouthavingseen Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 We're getting far afield from the original question. My sense is that it was concerning the likes of Galileo (to whose memory the Servant of God John Paul II issued a nuanced apology), who was never excommunicated. If missionseeker will name some individuals who were supposed to have been posthumously "re-communicated", I think we will see that they were never excommunicated in the first place.
beatty07 Posted September 21, 2007 Posted September 21, 2007 distinction: Excommunication is not an infallible declaration that someone is going to Hell. Excommunication is the acknowledgment that someone has defected from the Church. So if someone dies excommunicate and goes to Heaven, there's no reason to say the excommunication was a mistake. It just means that they died outside communion with the Church, and God's mercy found some other way to them. Their salvation would of course be "through the Church" even though they died excommunicate. For example, Luther had to be excommunicated, there's no way that was a mistake, but we should still hope to see him in Heaven.
eperez874 Posted September 23, 2007 Posted September 23, 2007 the church can not make mistakes. in excomunication. they must study and ask for God's wisdom.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now