Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ok, So I've Always Wondered..


Recommended Posts

Posted

It is the one I tried last week. The St. John's that was supposed to be considered traditional. I have been complaining to phatty about this for 20min or so. I fear my hunger and pain will end up making me eastern or trad someday.I fear that. I sense it coming. Kill me before I crave the blood of the innocent. Except, I cant stand most trad's either. My dr/prof said I could never stand being catholic. I would become a free-church catholic and lose my right to teach. maybe he was right. I could never be protestant again I fear. So I am kinda stuck. I just try and learn and learn and learn. My leaning has me wondering if I will end up in an eastern/trad situation. The american latin rite lacks something to me. It feels weird. The focus on sin and canon law rather than theosis. The modern church rather than incense and icons. I dunno. It just makes me sad I guess.
I actually like the Novus mass. If it is done with reverence.
The churches in roch dont even have crosses. They have the ressurected Jesus either standing like a greek statue or in front of an artist-messed with cross
I see the pictures Your posts (as an example) and I know that is what I long for.
I feel like I go to mass on sunday because I have to. Not because I want to. Because I leave mass hungry for something. I see all the luke-warm bench warmers and the false warm-fuzzy country club carp that made me leave protestantism
look at those pictures. it breaks my heart\

I want a church that people will come in and truely feel the meaning of this quote..

[quote]When you are before the altar where Christ reposes, you ought no longer to think that you are amongst men; but believe that there are troops of angels and archangels standing by you, and trembling with respect before the sovereign Master of Heaven and earth. Therefore, when you are in church, be there in silence, fear, and veneration.
– St. John Chrysostom[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1391089' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:30 PM']I agree that there were similar styles in early Roman art, but I think there is something distinctly "Roman" about it that distinguishes it from Byzantine art. I'm no art expert either, so I don't know what technical differences there would be, but I believe Byzantine icons are supposed to be flat and somewhat unrealistic, whereas Roman art seems to me more realistic and often has more dimension. Even in the examples you posted, they look clearly "Roman" to me and very different from Byzantine icons. The art around the Rutler sanctuary strikes me as Byzantine and not Roman.

I think maybe Fra Angelico is a good general example of Roman art.[/quote]
The Roman tradition of sacred art is pretty rich and varied and I was not trying to equate Byzantine and Roman sacred images at all, but the style of icon present in Fr. Rutler's church is a part of our tradition as well, as are the statues that adorn the place, the stained glass work, etc.
When I look at the pictures it is pretty obvious to me that I am looking at a Roman Catholic Church and in fact the iconography calls to mind certain ancient Roman churches. The Pantocrator icon on the apse is obviously a reproduction of the famous sixth century icon from Saint Catherine's Monastery. I find this interesting because in the middle ages that monastery is the center of the Mount Sinai school of iconography which is a mixture of 12th century Western and Eastern traditions. This monastery contains many of the most ancient icons in existence and some of them are in fact Western in origin. Although we think of the icon as something particular to the East this is not so and the strictly Byzantine style of iconography was copied by Latins for centuries and has an important place in our traditions of sacred art.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1391106' date='Sep 22 2007, 10:45 PM']When I look at the pictures it is pretty obvious to me that I am looking at a Roman Catholic Church and in fact the iconography calls to mind certain ancient Roman churches.[/quote]
The altar area definitely looks Roman (no iconostasis), but I find the Byzantine art around the sanctuary artistically distracting (but still beautiful). If I had to worship there I wouldn't be complaining, though!

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1391095' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:33 PM']It is the one I tried last week. The St. John's that was supposed to be considered traditional. I have been complaining to phatty about this for 20min or so. I fear my hunger and pain will end up making me eastern or trad someday.I fear that. I sense it coming. Kill me before I crave the blood of the innocent. Except, I cant stand most trad's either. My dr/prof said I could never stand being catholic. I would become a free-church catholic and lose my right to teach. maybe he was right. I could never be protestant again I fear. So I am kinda stuck. I just try and learn and learn and learn. My leaning has me wondering if I will end up in an eastern/trad situation. The american latin rite lacks something to me. It feels weird. The focus on sin and canon law rather than theosis. The modern church rather than incense and icons. I dunno. It just makes me sad I guess.[/quote]
Dude, I feel your pain on all of these points. I have become more and more devoted to studying the theology and history of the liturgy and while it has been a rewarding and illuminating experience, it has brought me to the point where the mainstream liturgical life of the Roman Catholic Church in America is often a source of pain and sadness.
If someone like Cardinal Mahony had become Pope instead of Cardinal Ratzinger I don't know where I would be right now. Maybe I would even be Orthodox right now. There is no way that I could become SSPX or something like that because I do not believe in their principles. Perhaps I would have become Orthodox in union with Rome if that is at all possible.
The "lex orandi" of the Church that I experience is more often than not foreign or even hostile to the "lex credendi" that I believe in. Some people who I have talked to about this have suggested that I find a parish that I can call home and just stick to that, which I have done to some extent although this parish is not even in my own diocese and I don't feel entirely at home there. And of course I have lived in places where this is impossible because there are no such parishes within driving distance. Besides, I cannot ignore or forget about these crises in the Church.
The writings and deeds of our Pope give me a lot of hope for the future and liturgical scholarship seems to be opening up to some new directions which are inspiring to me. I think the worst of the post-conciliar debacle is past and there will be a gradual improvement in the future. I would rather try to keep things in perspective and stay loyal to the Holy Father and to this Church and perhaps even work toward the building up of the Church in some way. There will always be parishes and priests who are doing things that aren't right. I can't think of a time in history that was without its heretics and false shepherds. I dunno...

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1391095' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:33 PM']I actually like the Novus mass. If it is done with reverence.[/quote]
I am quite sure that if the forma ordinaria was done properly there would be far less rad trads. I know of many people who have become Byzantine because of the way the forma ordinaria is typically celebrated. I'm sure you know that I prefer the forma extraordinaria for a long list of reasons, but I certainly respect those who simply prefer a properly celebrated forma ordinaria and I am nothing but supportive of this.

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1391095' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:33 PM']The churches in roch dont even have crosses. They have the ressurected Jesus either standing like a greek statue or in front of an artist-messed with cross[/quote]
You shouldn't have to deal with parishes that could care less about how the liturgy is actually supposed to be. If I was in a position where I could not find an orthodox parish (at least a tolerable parish) I would start looking into Byzantine Catholic parishes. Even a Byzantine parish with latinizations is better than a Roman Catholic parish that has the do-it-yourself Mass mentality or Protestant tendencies. In my opinion anyway.

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1391095' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:33 PM']I see the pictures Your posts (as an example) and I know that is what I long for.
I feel like I go to mass on sunday because I have to. Not because I want to. Because I leave mass hungry for something. I see all the luke-warm bench warmers and the false warm-fuzzy country club carp that made me leave protestantism
look at those pictures. it breaks my heart.

I want a church that people will come in and truely feel the meaning of this quote..[/quote]
I know what you mean bro. Fortunately I have participated in many worthy liturgies in the past and have those experiences to fall back on when I am feeling particularly distressed over this. I often try to keep in mind such things as Liturgiam Authenticam and other such signs that Rome is working on things and that there are signs that the liturgical crisis is being addressed on different levels. It can be a "bitter trial", to use the words of Evelyn Waugh, but there is only so much we can expect from a cultural situation that is so impoverished and perverse. I see it as primarily an occassion to contribute something positive and cling to prayer. There will be moments of transfiguration along the way I am sure.

That quote is awesome Rev.. *sigh* That's what I'm all about too man.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1391114' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:50 PM']The altar area definitely looks Roman (no iconostasis), but I find the Byzantine art around the sanctuary artistically distracting (but still beautiful). If I had to worship there I wouldn't be complaining, though![/quote]
Yeah, most Roman Catholic churches these days are relatively sterile and inexpressive. I suppose our modern sensibilities might be overwhelmed to some extent by such robust and expressive adornment.
Personally I find it to be a vivid and elavating reminder of what the liturgy is: the concelebration of heaven and earth; a participation in the heavenly liturgy; a procession to the heavenly realm.

Posted

[quote]The "lex orandi" of the Church that I experience is more often than not foreign or even hostile to the "lex credendi" that I believe in. Some people who I have talked to about this have [b]suggested that I find a parish that I can call home and just stick to that[/b], which I have done to some extent although this parish is not even in my own diocese and I don't feel entirely at home there. And of course I have lived in places where this is impossible because there are no such parishes within driving distance. Besides, I cannot ignore or forget about these crises in the Church.[/quote]

I tried, it made me not want to go anymore. I left hungry.


[quote]I am quite sure that if the forma ordinaria was done properly there would be far less rad trads. I know of many people who have become Byzantine because of the way the forma ordinaria is typically celebrated. I'm sure you know that I prefer the forma extraordinaria for a long list of reasons, but I certainly respect those who simply prefer a properly celebrated forma ordinaria and I am nothing but supportive of this.[/quote]

actually I have no idea what you are talking about. I have never talked liturgy with you much. Remember sir, I converted theologically far before I converted in practice. I might be a neophyte in catholic theology, but Im a rube with practice.


[quote]You shouldn't have to deal with parishes that could care less about how the liturgy is actually supposed to be. If I was in a position where I could not find an orthodox parish (at least a tolerable parish) I would start looking into Byzantine Catholic parishes. Even a Byzantine parish with latinizations is better than a Roman Catholic parish that has the do-it-yourself Mass mentality or Protestant tendencies. In my opinion anyway.[/quote]

area code 55901. Try to find one. I have a list right now of all the catholic churches within an hour and I am slowly going thru the list.

[quote]That quote is awesome Rev.. *sigh* That's what I'm all about too man.[/quote]

and that is why phatmass is my church community. If I spoke like that at any of the churches in my area. Im sure it would not go over well. Its not user-friendly.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

As a matter of personal opinion (which is rooted in far more than mere aesthetic taste), I believe that the icon is the richest and most appropriate form of sacred art for churches. If I was a builder of Roman Catholic churches I would see Fr. Rutler's parish as a model of good sense.

Posted

I love my icon. Just wish I knew more about it and could maybe restore it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Rev,

Supposedly St. John the Evangelist has a Latin Mass at 4:00 on Sundays. I went to their website and it didn't say anything about it but some website had them listed as a parish in MN with the Latin Mass (forma extraordinaria to be more precise). From the looks of the church on their website I find this hard to believe. Might be worth checking out though.. Maybe they don't advertise it because it represents a repressed minority and their parish just happened to be picked as the traddy ghetto for that diocese. I dunno..

Peace.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Is Minneapolis too far to drive for you?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1391089' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:30 PM']I think maybe Fra Angelico is a good general example of Roman art.[/quote]
Oh man, Fra Angelico is awesome. :)

He is a good example of the early Renaissance style, but this style is a late-comer is our Church's 2,000 year history. I agree with you that all of our authentically Catholic art deserves respect and a proper place; but if I was the Pope I would issue a motu proprio giving icons pride of place. I guess as a matter of personal preference I like the proportions of Fr. Rutler's parish. The iconography dominates but there are other forms of Catholic sacred art that are given a presence. There is just so much theological depth behind the iconographic tradition and it is particularly venerable because of its antiquity, etc., that I see it as having pride of place in a way analogous to Gregorian chant perhaps. I would never knock the best that Renaissance polyphony has to offer, but it still does not enjoy that pride of place which is proper to Gregorian chant for many reasons.
If I may further this analogy I would say that Gregorian chant is in many respects a model or at least touchstone for sacred music in our Church (as well as being normative in a certain sense); I would suggest something of this sort for the icon in terms of sacred images.
It is just an analogy used in reference to a personal opinion, but I believe in it nonetheless.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1391089' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:30 PM']I believe Byzantine icons are supposed to be flat and somewhat unrealistic, whereas Roman art seems to me more realistic and often has more dimension. Even in the examples you posted, they look clearly "Roman" to me and very different from Byzantine icons. The art around the Rutler sanctuary strikes me as Byzantine and not Roman.[/quote]
Icons are supposed to be flat and somewhat unrealistic; this is not something particular to the Byzantine style. It is true that because of the Renaissance style it is not uncommon to see Western icons that incorporate a distinctive degree of realism, but this hardly represents our iconographic tradition as a whole or in its essence.
Perhaps the biggest problem here is that a great many churches, in Europe and other places, that are often considered "traditional" in some definitive sense, are quite often simply examples of the Baroque period.
I believe that a more organic understanding of our traditions is the ideal. Again, from my perspective Fr. Rutler's church is a masterpiece. It seems to have it all -- in remarkably fitting proportions.

Please don't misunderstand me on this; I'm not suggesting that all parishes should be copies of Fr. Rutler's parish. There are a great many things to consider in the design of the Church and one would expect variation from place to place. I think anyone who was to tour the churches of Europe for example would appreciate this. I just believe that churches should manifest the meaning of what takes place within their walls. At the same time it should be possible to taste something of the organic, historical life of the Church along the way rather than just one era. This is part of why I find the tendency of "modernization" to be radically arrogant and shallow at times.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1391178' date='Sep 22 2007, 11:18 PM']Yeah, most Roman Catholic churches these days are relatively sterile and inexpressive. I suppose our modern sensibilities might be overwhelmed to some extent by such robust and expressive adornment.[/quote]
It's not the robustness of it that distracts me, but the Byzantineness. It's kind of like if I walked into a Byzantine Church and saw a Roman style painting front and center behind the altar. It might be beautiful, but I think it would be out of place. I guess it's kind of general to me what is "Roman" and "Byzantine," but when I look at sacred art there seems to be something clear that distinguishes the two, whatever it is. I think this is even true for early Roman art.

But, like I said, I'm talking from an artistic perspective, not spiritual. I'm not saying there's anything "wrong" with the Church or that it would bother me spiritually, just artistically I would have designed it differently.

And actually, about the robust aspect, I was thinking about this when watching the Mass from the EWTN shrine in Hanceville. It's somewhat plain and white, but the altar area is gold which makes for a stark contrast. I guess the white works, to focus the attention on the altar, but I was wondering how the Church might look if there were more color to it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1391369' date='Sep 23 2007, 06:34 AM']It's not the robustness of it that distracts me, but the Byzantineness. It's kind of like if I walked into a Byzantine Church and saw a Roman style painting front and center behind the altar. It might be beautiful, but I think it would be out of place. I guess it's kind of general to me what is "Roman" and "Byzantine," but when I look at sacred art there seems to be something clear that distinguishes the two, whatever it is. I think this is even true for early Roman art.[/quote]
This parish strikes me as largely Romanesque in style, not Byzantine. The three-dimensionality of the icons, the Pantokrator on the apse instead of the dome, etc. With the exception of a few minor details the church strikes me as classically Roman. I find it to be distressing that iconography is automatically called "Byzantine" and then assumed to be foreign to our traditions. Another thing that is erroneous is to assume that the Baroque style of iconography is the only validly Roman system. In my observation the common perception of what is authentically Roman Catholic, even among traditionalists, is often too restricted to the past several centuries.
I don't know enough about this parish to say for sure, but from what I can see of the church the approach taken in its interior is quite appropriate to its architectural design.

Posted

I don't understand the problem incorporating Eastern traditions into a Roman Catholic parish. I've seen many Roman Catholic parishes with Byzantine icons.

The Sisters of Bethlehem in Livingston Manor, NY (a Roman Catholic Religious Institute of Pontifical Right founded in France in the 1950's, with over 30 monasteries throughout the world) combine both Western and Eastern traditions. They have Byzantine icons in their churches as well as Romanesque statues. They have the forma ordinaria Roman Mass, and a Byzantine Divine Office.

I've been to Mass at Fr. Rulter's parish, and it is incredible! His homilies are awesome!

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

It's all beautiful, and for a while it made me regret that during term-time I worship in a grotty hall with no proper pews (just plastic chairs), a portable altar (on wheels), and walls made of unpainted brown brick. During the week the hall is rented out to traders. We've been raising the money to have a proper chapel, but that won't happen for some years.

Then I thought, "If I can pray in that hall, without any sacred art or sublime artistic beauty to inspire me, I will be able to pray anywhere." So while it makes me thank God to see such talent, especially when it's being used in worship...I'm not going to be jealous. My soul is even more beautiful because it was crafted by God, even if I can't see it. The people who surround me in that dingy old hall are beautiful too. God's creation at His best. I won't always have an inspiring church or a wonderful liturgy, but as Bl. Elizabeth of the Trinity once wrote, I will always be able to go to Him in my soul. No matter what the physical surroundings are like.

Don't get upset, Rev. The quality of the liturgy and the beauty of the sacred art are important. But not so important that it's impossible to pray without them. Perseverence in prayer is more crucial than anything else, as without prayer we die. What would happen to you if Catholics were being persecuted for our faith and we could no longer attend Mass anywhere? Then we would all give anything for the most badly decorated, liturgically incorrect parish. The basic, primitive God-hunger goes beyond beautiful art, which only exists to express God-hunger, not to satiate it. Never to satiate it. As strange as it may seem, you are blessed to be in this position. You know your own need (which, according to my priest, is the most fundamental quality in a Catholic) and you are learning to find God in the less than perfect. There are blessings in everything - especially things that may look bad at the outset.

Posted (edited)

Westerners are pragmatists as far as icons are concerned, while for Easterners the veneration of icons is an expression of dogmatic truth.

I remember when a person once said to me that, "There are too many icons in this Church," and my response to her was that, "That’s like saying that there is too much grace in this Church."

Icons manifest the presence of God and His saints, because they are a perpetual extension of the incarnation through space and time. Moreover, icons are not meant to simply look pretty or make the Church building more interesting; instead, they are meant to be given the worship of veneration, and by the acts of veneration of the worshippers within the Church they bestow grace (i.e., divine energy) upon them, and upon everyone present. In other words, icons are not just pictures of a sacred person or event; instead, they really are that sacred person or event, because an icon is a living reality, and to come into contact with an icon is to come into contact with the very thing depicted in it.

Edited by Apotheoun

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...