sarcasmguy126 Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 hey y'all! I'm fascinated with the Mayan culture a little, and I was curious to see Mel Gibson's film on the civilization, for several reasons. But, according to the many reviews (Christian and non-Christian alike), the graphic violence undermines a brilliant, fantastic story and look into another civilization. I'm not a squeamish guy, but--in my opinion--if a movie is so gory that hardly a shot passes without a severed limb or blood shooting across the screen, it's simply not worth it. I wanted some other opinions from teens. I love Braveheart, Gladiator, and the like. But is it too violent?
traichuoi Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 (edited) Apocalypto is sooooo good! I wrote about it in my blog and you can find an article in Godspy, although Godspy does give away some parts of the story. [url="http://www.godspy.com/reviews/Apocalypto-Mels-Mayan-Book-of-Revelation-by-John-Murphy.cfm"]Godspy Article[/url] [url="http://tohellwithit.vox.com/library/post/mel-gibsons-apocalypto.html"]My Blog[/url] I honestly believe the violence is necessary to depict the consequences of the Culture of Death. I'm a girl, and honestly there are parts that are difficult to watch, but very necessary. Edited September 24, 2007 by traichuoi
ardillacid Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 There was graphic violence? Did I miss that part?
St. Michael Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 This is one of my all time favorite movies.
Mateo el Feo Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 (edited) It was an awesome movie. It brought to life my visits to the Mayan ruins of [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copan"]Copan[/url]. Edited September 24, 2007 by Mateo el Feo
PapaHilarious Posted September 24, 2007 Posted September 24, 2007 I wouldn't get your hopes up. People on here seem to having nothing but glowing reviews, but to each his own... The movie suffered from a few big problems: #1. [b]Much too long.[/b] Could have easily cut 20 mins out of this and it would have flowed much better. In fact, it seems to wander a bit at times as Mel tried to connect with the culture. (A common Terrence Malik-esque problem of some of these movies.) The 2nd act dragged quite a lot. #2. [b]Surprisingly weak score.[/b] You've never have guessed this was James Horner if you didn't see his name up there. All three of Mel's other directorial features had great scores, which added so much to the film. This one was pretty soft. #3. [b]Acting and writing was sub-par.[/b] Much like other movies that have used indigenous actors with little training (see [i]End of the Spear[/i]), many of the scenes are distracting because of how unconvincing the delivery is. If they had been speaking English, one can only imagine how embarrassing it would have sounded. Also, for a story that had so much potential due to its original topic, there was really very little done with the plot or characters. As Mel said himself, this is essentially just a chase film that has a neat backdrop. However, a chase that constantly stalls and runs a total of 139mins is pretty thin. #4. [b]The violence. [/b]Despite some great visual images showing the cruelty of the culture, one has to consider why such random, graphic shots such as a [u]jaguar eating a man's face[/u] had any place in this film. Actually, the answer is simple: shock and hype. Icon knew because of the response they got from [i]The Passion[/i] that violence could sell to a non-religious crowd. (Duh.) So don't think there weren't some meetings with Mel, Bruce Davey and some other big shots to discuss how they could punch up the shock of this film to fill the seats with 18-24 yr old males. Really, they should have thought first about making the best film possible and then wonder about how to make it sell. In summary, the film is not without merits. The sets and makeup and attention to detail are all fantastic. It's just a shame they didn't try harder to craft the best story out of this as they could.
sarcasmguy126 Posted September 25, 2007 Author Posted September 25, 2007 the very thing is, everyone seems to like it here (the teens), but even non-Christian adults (newspaper, for example) thought, "What's the point? After two hours of squirming and covering eyes, you wonder what the point is...Mel Gibson's film came so close to being great, if only he cut back on the violence
Mateo el Feo Posted September 26, 2007 Posted September 26, 2007 [quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1393059' date='Sep 25 2007, 08:58 PM']the very thing is, everyone seems to like it here (the teens), but even non-Christian adults (newspaper, for example) thought, "What's the point?[/quote]I'm far from a teen, but I'll try to answer the question. My answer is a bit of a mix between my own thoughts and the things that come out of the DVD's audio commentary (yes, I have no life). 1) The film visually presents a civilization which is killing itself. As you get closer to the city, it deliberately shows things getting worse and worse (e.g. no trees, people with poisoned water supplies, etc). 2) It shows the Mayan "big-city" folks as a decadent society, with rulers manipulating the masses. 3) In a sense, it shows an idealized depiction of living in a small village. In another sense, these villagers are just like us. They are vulnerable, they play pranks on eachother, etc. 4) Mostly (for me, at least), it's an allegory for our own "Culture of Death". [quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1393059' date='Sep 25 2007, 08:58 PM']After two hours of squirming and covering eyes, you wonder what the point is...Mel Gibson's film came so close to being great, if only he cut back on the violence[/quote]Ironically, he did cut back on the violence. Anthropologists know that the human sacrifices of the Mayans were much worse than what was depicted. A chief complaint is the jaguar scene, but I never really thought that was anything near as bad as when the village was attacked. That was the worst for me. Some other random thoughts: Regarding the music/score, I actually thought it was great. It didn't stand out; but, it wasn't supposed to. It was there to set the mood for each scene. Regarding the wardrobe and sets: top notch. They built some incredible sets for the movie. Regarding the acting, it didn't detract from the film for me. I thought that the character development was effective, particularly in trying to bridge the vast gap of culture and time. One of the other issues that is sometimes brought up is historical accuracy. Considering it's fiction, this wasn't an issue for me. I guess that for some people, all they will see is a chase movie with a "Mayan MacGyver" (think of his poison frog darts). But, for others, maybe there's more than meets the eye. Just my biased opinion, though.
traichuoi Posted September 26, 2007 Posted September 26, 2007 [quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1393059' date='Sep 25 2007, 03:58 PM']the very thing is, everyone seems to like it here (the teens), but even non-Christian adults (newspaper, for example) thought, "What's the point? After two hours of squirming and covering eyes, you wonder what the point is...Mel Gibson's film came so close to being great, if only he cut back on the violence[/quote] hey...I'm far from a teen as well. I honestly don't think he could cut back the violence. I cutting back the violence would do an injustice to what the culture of death really does to society. It's violent. Nothing less.
Church Punk Posted September 26, 2007 Posted September 26, 2007 I liked it, it had everything a Mel Gibson film does, totally over the top.
sarcasmguy126 Posted September 26, 2007 Author Posted September 26, 2007 i LOVE chase movies and looks into different cultures (history books are so biased--make Cortez and co. look cruel and greedy, and the Aztecs/Mayans look like innocent, helpless people). those are two main reasons for my desire for this movie. now that it's on DVD, one can forward through the human sacrifice. It's disgusting and disturbing... so approximately how long does the human sacrifice last (time range)? i would love to skip that, and enjoy the rest!
abercius24 Posted October 6, 2007 Posted October 6, 2007 (edited) It was a very exciting movie, but it was laced with many, many disturbing images -- including decapitations, bloody human sacrifices and the torment of a woman in front of her husband just prior to an implied gang rape. It clearly demonstrated the weight of trauma human beings can inflict upon eachother. I understand the message Mel Gibson was trying to convey, but I think he uses shock value too dangerously. Because a pure heart would find him/herself more distrubed than inspired from the movie's content, I cannot recommend it. Just a side note, though: Mel did hold back on one aspect. The Mayans performed child sacrifices much more readily than the movie showed. I am glad he didn't go there, because that kind of violence in a film is unforgivable. Given how far we've been willing to push the envelope lately, I fear that will be the next step. And how long will it take for us to become desensitized and willing to tolerate those kinds of disturbing images as a part of our entertainment culture? And you think people don't love children now? Just wait until we see them brutalized in movies! Its time to pull back before we really go too far. Edited October 6, 2007 by abercius24
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now