Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican One And Avignon France


Recommended Posts

Posted

“We teach and define that it is a dogma divinely revealed that the[b] Roman Pontiff[/b], when he speaks ex cathedra, that is, when in discharge of the office of pastor and doctor of all Christians, by virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine regarding faith and morals to be held by the universal church, by the divine assistance promised him in blessed Peter, is possessed of that infallibility with which the divine redeemer willed that His Church should be endowed for defining doctrines regarding faith and morals, and that therefore such definitions of the Roman Pontiff of themselves—and not by virtue of the consent of the Church—are irreformable.”


I don't have a problem but a pastor I know is making an issue about the papacy being in Avignon France for 70 years. Is the doctrine really that the successor of Peter has this power and would it have been better to state this differently to avoid confusion? Peter was in Anticoch and Jersualem for a while after all. So the office is not neccessarily tied to Rome specifically? Or is it? I know there is some other language in the Vatican I document that may have bearing on this and I need to go look at it. What constitutes being a bishop of an area? Does one have to reside there?

Here is his arguement.

"Saint Peter?

If the Pope is the Bishop of Rome, then how could the popes during the French period be valid? Again, how can it possibly be maintained that the popes that resided in Avignon, France for over 70 years are to be considered the Bishops of Rome?

“It is true that popes have not always reigned from Rome. Between 1309 to 1377, the papacy directed the Church from Avignon, of which the dramatic papal palace there is a reminder. But this absence from Rome was always referred to as ‘the Babylonian Captivity’. . . It is true that some popes were never able to get to Rome . . . Urban IV (1261-4), Clement IV (1265-8), and Celestine V (1294) never actually set foot in Rome as pope.”

Some Catholics argue that it is acceptable that popes ruled from Avignon because of the precedent, according Rome’s version of history, of Peter moving from Antioch to Rome. If so, however, then the papacy should not be tied to Rome at all, but rather merely to the successor of Peter wherever he may reside. "

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I think Rome is elevated because of the presence of the successor of Peter, not the other way around.

Posted

Of course, that is a good point. But to a protestant watching the words do you see the issue he is having? The statement in Vatican I is taken as infallible. I think however the problem is he does not accept the authority that says that even while those Popes were in Avignon they were Bishops of Rome. It seems to him to be a big deal that they were not in Rome.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1392573' date='Sep 24 2007, 07:23 PM']Of course, that is a good point. But to a protestant watching the words do you see the issue he is having? The statement in Vatican I is taken as infallible. I think however the problem is he does not accept the authority that says that even while those Popes were in Avignon they were Bishops of Rome. It seems to him to be a big deal that they were not in Rome.[/quote]
Yeah. That seems to be the major issue. A glimpse at the anti-pope in Pisa is helpful. St. Bernard of Clairvaux supported the Pisan anti-pope (he didn't know better) and wrote about how the honor of having Peter had fallen from Rome and that Pisa had risen to take it up. It seems to be very much about "where is Peter?" not "is Peter at home?" That he understood it this way, even if his conclusions were wrong, does give the matter some context.

Posted

The bishops of Rome, Antioch, and Alexandria all possess an historical succession from St. Peter, because as St. Gregory the Great said:

"Wherefore though there are many apostles, yet with regard to the principality itself the See of the Prince of the apostles alone has grown strong in authority, which in three places [i.e., Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch] is the See of one. For he himself exalted the See in which he deigned even to rest and end the present life. He himself adorned the See to which he sent his disciple as evangelist. He himself established the See in which, though he was to leave it, he sat for seven years. Since then it is the See of one, and one See, over which by Divine authority three bishops now preside, whatever good I hear of you, this I impute to myself. If you believe anything good of me, impute this to your merits, since we are one in Him Who says, 'That they all may be one, as You, Father, art in me, and I in you that they also may be one in us.'" [Registrum Epistolarum, Book VII, 40]

Posted

The Roman Pontiff means the Roman Successor to Peter, the holder of the See of Rome. The Popes who lived at Avignon held the See of Rome even if they were not geographically present. They were indeed Roman Pontiffs (Pontiffs over the Roman Church, one might say), they were the Roman Successors of Peter.

Were they bishops of Rome? Absolutely, I think... there wasn't another legitimately consecrated bishop of the city of Rome itself during that time, was there? Even if there was, and they were not the bishop of the particular city of Rome, they were still the Pontiff over the Roman Church.

Yes, there are three Petrine Sees. The Roman one has pre-eminence because it is where Peter and Paul were both martyred. The See in Rome is distinctly Petrine, but it sprang from the blood of both Peter and Paul, and thus is Pauline as well, to a certain extent. That is why the Patriarch of Rome is first among equals, with the special role of promoting the unity of the Whole Church, of being the Patriarch through which the whole Church is united.

The Church is to be one in the same way the Son is one with the Father. And so, there are co-equal patriarchs of co-equal sui juris churches; and through the Patriarch of Rome, through the Pope, they are one, as the Blessed Trinity is One through the Father as the principal of the Godhead.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1392783' date='Sep 25 2007, 04:51 AM']The bishops of Rome, Antioch, and Alexandria all possess an historical succession from St. Peter, because as St. Gregory the Great said:

"Wherefore though there are many apostles, yet with regard to the principality itself the See of the Prince of the apostles alone has grown strong in authority, which in three places [i.e., Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch] is the See of one. [Registrum Epistolarum, Book VII, 40][/quote]


In 382 Pope St. Damasus issued the following decree, defending the Traditional integrity of the three Apostolic patriarchates:

[quote]"Although all the catholic churches spread abroad throughout the world comprise but one Bridal Chamber of Christ, nevertheless, the holy Roman church has been placed at the forefront, not by the councilor decisions of the churches, but has received the primacy by the evangelic voice of our Lord and Savior, Who says: "You are Peter..." In addition to this, there is also the companionship of the vessel of election, the most blessed Apostle Paul, who along with Peter in the city of Rome in the time of Caesar Nero, equally consecrated the above-mentioned holy Roman church to Christ the Lord; and by their own presence and by their venerable triumph, they set it at the forefront over the others of all the cities of the world. The first see, therefore, is that of Peter the Apostle, that of the Roman Church, which has neither stain nor blemish, nor anything like that. The second see is that of Alexandria, consecrated on behalf of the blessed Peter by Mark, his disciple and an Evangelist, who was sent to Eqypt by the Apostle Peter, where he preached the word of truth and finished his glorious martydom. The third see is that of Antioch, which belonged to the most blessed Peter, where first he dwelled before he came to Rome, and where the name 'christians' as first applied, as to a new people." (Decree of Damasus #3, 382 A.D.)[/quote]

Posted

When the Pope had is residence his Avignon, he was still Bishop of Rome for the office of the Supreme Pontiff and the office of Bishop of Rome are inseparable.

Keep in mind also that since the First Vatican Council was held after the residence in Avignon if there was a conflict between the two it would have been discussed by the Council Fathers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...