Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Was The World Really Created In Six Days?


Recommended Posts

Lioness For Christ
Posted

Hey I know the bible says the world was created in six days (God rested on the seventh). and I personally believe that. But why oh why do so many people, priests and religous included, say that maybe it wasn't? I'd really like to hear what the Church says on this.. Thanks!

Posted (edited)

You have the literali[i]ist[/i] interpretation that says it MUST have been created in six days because [b]that's what the Bible says[/b]. Then you have the [i]literal[/i] interpretation that says it may or may not have been created in six days because [b]we don't know how time was being measured.[/b] "Days' might not have meant "24 hour periods of time". The Church's stance is the literal interpretation.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted

God is outside of time. The Church recognized this and supports this, and believes that, as Totus Tuus said, the world was formed in six days, which may or may not have been earthly days.

Posted

[quote name='Denzinger No. 2121 - No. 2128']The Historical Character of the Earlier Chapters of Genesis *



[Response of the Biblical Commission, June 30th, 1909]







2121 Question I: Whether the various exegetical systems which have been proposed to exclude the literal historical sense of the three first chapters of the Book of Genesis, and have been defended by the pretense of science, are sustained by a solid foundation?--Reply: In the negative.



2122 Question II: Whether, when the nature and historical form of the Book of Genesis does not oppose, because of the peculiar connections of the three first chapters with each other and with the following chapters, because of the manifold testimony of the Old and of the New Testaments; because of the almost unanimous opinion of the Holy Fathers, and because of the traditional sense which, transmitted from the Israelite people, the Church always held, it can be taught that the three aforesaid chapters of Genesis do not contain the stories of events which really happened, that is, which correspond with objective reality and historical truth; but are either accounts celebrated in fable drawn from the mythologies and cosmogonies of ancient peoples and adapted by a holy writer to monotheistic doctrine, after expurgating any error of polytheism; or allegories and symbols, devoid of a basis of objective reality, set forth under the guise of history to inculcate religious and philosophical truths; or, finally, legends, historical in part and fictitious in part, composed freely for the instruction and edification of souls?--Reply: In the negative to both parts.



2123 Question 111: Whether in particular the literal and historical sense can be called into question, where it is a matter of facts related in the same chapters, which pertain to the foundations of the Christian religion; for example, among others, the creation of all things wrought by God in the beginning of time; the special creation of man; the formation of the first woman from the first man; the oneness of the human race; the original happiness of our first parents in the state of justice, integrity, and immortality; the command given to man by God to prove his obedience; the transgression of the divine command through the devil's persuasion under the guise of a serpent; the casting of our first parents out of that first state of innocence; and also the promise of a future restorer?--Reply: In the negative.



2124 Question IV: Whether in interpreting those passages of these chapters, which the Fathers and Doctors have understood differently, but concerning which they have not taught anything certain and definite, it is permitted, while preserving the judgment of the Church and keeping the analogy of faith, to follow and defend that opinion which everyone has wisely approved?--Reply: In the affirmative.



2125 Question V: Whether all and everything, namely, words and phrases which occur in the aforementioned chapters, are always and necessarily to be accepted in a special sense, so that there may be no deviation from this, even when the expressions themselves manifestly appear to have been taken improperly, or metaphorically or anthropomorphically, and either reason prohibits holding the proper sense, or necessity forces its abandonment?--Reply: In the negative.



2126 Question VI: Whether, presupposing the literal and historical sense, the allegorical and prophetical interpretation of some passages of the same chapters, with the example of the Holy Fathers and the Church herself showing the way, can be wisely and profitably applied?--Reply: In the affirmative.



2127 Question VII: Whether, since in writing the first chapter of Genesis it was not the mind of the sacred author to teach in a scientific manner the detailed constitution of visible things and the complete order of creation, but rather to give to his people a popular notion, according as the common speech of the times went, accommodated to the understanding and capacity of men, the propriety of scientific language is to be investigated exactly and always in the interpretation of these?--Reply: In the negative.



2128 Question VIII: Whether in that designation and distinction of six days, with which the account of the first chapter of Genesis deals, the word (dies) can be assumed either in its proper sense as a natural day, or in the improper sense of a certain space of time; and whether with regard to such a question there can be free disagreement among exegetes?--Reply: In the affirmative.[/quote]

Posted

I thought i answered this? :sadder:

Posted

The text itself seems to infer that it is not intending to portray a "factual" account of creation as apposed to a "truthful" one. For example, the two different accounts of creation place the creation of man in relation to the creation of the animals in opposing orders. On a factual level, the two cannot be reconciled. However, they both support each other in relation to truth by illustrating God's love for mankind above all creation. Also, the Hebrew word used for "day" (יום/yowm) in Genesis is inherently undefined in relation to space and time. It is dependent on an associated term (Strong's Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible). So even the word used for day does not denote a twenty-four hour time period.

In Him

Posted

One mistake people make with regard to calling a bible story a myth is that mythology does not neccessarily mean false. The creation story is one that had been passed on for a thousand years until the time of Moses and then written down. It portrays facts about God being the creator and an original man and woman named Adam and Eve. Beyond that one may believe that the 7 days are literal and one may believe they are allegorical. The Church does not have a definitive stand beyond that.

Posted

How does the gap theory reconcile itself with Catholic teaching?

I forgot, it is another theology of mine that might not work. Not that the debate has any kind of soteriological value so I could give a flip but it helps with an overarching metaphysic.

Dont give me the "God out of time" thing either please.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1393434' date='Sep 26 2007, 01:46 PM']How does the gap theory reconcile itself with Catholic teaching?

I forgot, it is another theology of mine that might not work. Not that the debate has any kind of soteriological value so I could give a flip but it helps with an overarching metaphysic.

Dont give me the "God out of time" thing either please.[/quote]

LOL.
God is outside of time, just as the author of the book creates the story but is not present as a character in it. Time in all its facets is present to God simultaneously.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1393434' date='Sep 26 2007, 01:46 PM']How does the gap theory reconcile itself with Catholic teaching?

I forgot, it is another theology of mine that might not work. Not that the debate has any kind of soteriological value so I could give a flip but it helps with an overarching metaphysic.

Dont give me the "God out of time" thing either please.[/quote]
Gap theory? If you read the Scriptures, the Jews were not use writing until they were wandering in the desert. All teaching was oral tradition until then. Just as God guided the Apostles and Evangelists and converts to write the New Testament, God guided the oral Traditions of Israel.

Posted

Mom.

Do you really want to get into this right now?

The book analogy is flawed in that the characters have no free will, and are not faced with eternal actions based on the choices of the book.

The book analogy does not allow God to view all of time at once, rather he views whatever page he is on. All the book analogy does is predetermine a script at which we exist. If we are not writing the book how can we be judged?

The nature of time is a debate with how God relates with us, free will and the future. Patristically there was pluralism with this debate, and I believe Todd has stated that certain eastern rites do not buy into the aristotilian philosophy of Immutability in the sence of a stoic unmoving deity.

I would rather wait until November to open this issue up again.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1393447' date='Sep 26 2007, 01:04 PM']Gap theory? If you read the Scriptures, the Jews were not use writing until they were wandering in the desert. All teaching was oral tradition until then. Just as God guided the Apostles and Evangelists and converts to write the New Testament, God guided the oral Traditions of Israel.[/quote]


What? Do you know the gap theory?

Posted

not if the book is laid out before God like the page preview view in microsoft word.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1393469' date='Sep 26 2007, 02:41 PM']:'([/quote]
Gap theory in respect to a geological cataclysm between Gen 1:1 and Gen1:2 is a pain.

Posted

If by "gap theory" you mean the protestant argument that between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 all geologic time can be fitted thus preserving the other theory that the earth is only 6000 years old [ another protestant idea].

Posted

Read Ratzinger's book - he makes the point that the Genesis story and science are attempting to explain different realities. This doesn't mean they must be in direct conflict with each other, but it does mean that their ends are not the same. The story of creation in Genesis seeks to give form and substance to a God who loved all things into being. Evolution, intelligent design, etc. all seek to explain why I am here at this particular moment. Very different goals.

Posted

An early man being inspired by the Holy Spirit to record God's creation of the Universe could only put the ideas being placed in his mind and heart into the words that he knew. I can't think of any better way for an early man to put the vision of the big bang into words other than, "God said let there be light." I've always thought it presumptuous of us to put limits on how long a day is to God the Father. Perhaps it was simply that the author of Genesis was receiving his inspiration from the Holy Spirit in dreams, and each day of the creation story in Genesis represented one night's dreams.

I've always envisioned Adam as an early human living on the savanna evolving to the point where he became self aware, and God reached down and touched him giving him a soul. For a human author trying to understand and write about such complex and mysterious things, from an omnipotent source, I think the author of Genesis did a pretty good job. We just have to remember that the Bible is not a history book or a science book. It is a theology book that is supposed to teach us about ourselves, and how we are supposed to live our lives.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...