iheartjp2 Posted September 28, 2007 Posted September 28, 2007 (edited) I've been having a convo on the board of an online group in an online community. The group is called "Jesus Loves Homosexuals", and its spirit is to send the message that Jesus, as well as his followers don't dislike, condemn, or hate homosexuals, although (for a very large part), Christians don't condone homosexual behavior, which is definitely something that I don't do. The convo goes a little something like this: [color="#0000FF"]Them[/color]:"From the 5th to 14th century, the Roman Catholic church conducted special ceremonies to bless same sex unions...." [color="#FF0000"]Me[/color]:"??? Intriguing, never heard anything like that before. Source, please?" [color="#FF0000"]Me[/color]:" Allright, I did find the quote in the file that stated that the Church did this thing (on page 8). Basically, what I want to say is that there's no reason to believe that, and as far as I'm concerned it's as good as a pretty convincing lie to someone who would want to believe it. Why? There's not one citation of any source of ANY KIND found in the document. I could understand them leaving out citations for facts or figures that are pretty common knowledge, but in the paragraph that contains the "fact" that you're referring to, they actually say 'Many people are unaware that . . .' , making it virtually unknown to any common person. Why would they not want to back this up with a citation from an actual document, historical or theological? Why should anyone believe it since they didn't? It seems to me that whoever took the time to write this did a shotty job of making it presentable to a scrutinizing reader." [color="#0000FF"]Them[/color]:"In Contemporary Sociology, Vol. 24, No. 3. (May, 1995), pp. 367-368. Indiana University professor Lutz Kaelber calls Boswell's book a "dazzling study". The Indiana professor says, "In twelve years of study and travel to archives all over Europe and Near East, from the Vatican to St. Petersburg to monastaries on Mount Athos and Mount Sinai, Boswell found more than 60 manuscripts containing ceremonies that ostensibly pertain to same-sex unions"... In Speculum, Vol. 71, No. 3. (Jul., 1996), pp. 693-696. Joan Cadden of Kenyon College writes that the Boswell shows , “…Christianity has not always been hostile to homosexual feelings and relationships-that, on the contrary, Christian society and ceremonial practice once actively accepted both”. Cadden calls the book, “…a monument to John Boswell’s prodigious accomplishments…'. If you are looking for a scholarly citation of the fact I posted, it came from a book written by Yale Professor/Historian John Boswell. The title of the book is "Same Sex Unions in Premodern Europe". In order for a work to be considered "scholarly" it has to be reviewed in several scholarly journals." Okay, so here's the thing: I'm pretty sure that neither I nor any of you can say that you've ever heard anything of this sort happening in the Church, ever. The Church, herself, from her heart, Rome, has never said anything like this about homosexual unions. They've always said that they're not allowed. What I want to know is who this author guy is and where he gets his info, because I've never heard anything like it, and this guy sounds like he's a Dan Brown type figure who's trying to build some faulty case for why the Church should let up on her position. I mean, I'm not denying that individual priests or even bishops may have blessed same-sex unions in the medieval period; there are lewd and obsene things that they were guilty of back then, prostitution for example, but does anyone have any info on what this guy is talking about? Edited September 28, 2007 by iheartjp2
Era Might Posted September 29, 2007 Posted September 29, 2007 Anthony Dragani, who used to answer questions at EWTN, mentioned something about this a few years back: [quote]In the Byzantine tradition a specific ritual can be used for achieving very different purposes. For example, infants and adult converts are sealed with the Holy Spirit through the Mystery of Chrismation - what Latin Catholics call Confirmation. An identical ritual was also used to reconcile apostates to the Church. These apostates had already been Chrismated previously, and the performance of this second ritual of Chrismation was not intended to re-seal them with the Holy Spirit. It was actually an exercise of the Mystery of Reconciliation. Another example: in the Byzantine tradition a ritual was sometimes used in monasteries to join two monks in "spiritual brotherhood." These monks would be joined for life, and were to watch over one another's spiritual well-being. This ritual was in form almost identical to the ritual for Marriage. Thus, some modern commentators have tried to claim that this was a Byzantine "homosexual wedding ceremony." It was nothing of the sort, and intended something completely different from marriage. But the fact was that virtually the same ritual was used for two very different purposes.[/quote]
CatherineM Posted September 30, 2007 Posted September 30, 2007 When people are trying to defend something that is un-defensible, they will pull any little misquote out of the hat to use as canon, and then say that the church knew about it all along and hid it. I'm sure that homosexuals have been around a long time, and the community at large has dealt with it well in some eras, and not so good at other times. It is very hard to explain how you can love a person, while hating their sin. I ended up with a bunch of AIDS clients in the late 80's when people were afraid to be in the same room with them. Once I was willing to take one client, it got around, and I got a bunch of other ones. I received several invitations to holy union ceremonies. I didn't attend any, but made it clear to them that it was not a disapproval of them as people, that I wished them well, but that I would not be comfortable entering their church. It was like I did many divorces, even though I don't believe in divorce. I always tried to get them to go through marriage counseling first, but when it comes right down to it, everyone has the right to live their lives with freewill.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted October 8, 2007 Posted October 8, 2007 this is an interesting thread, thank-you. New knowledge for me as well.
abercius24 Posted October 8, 2007 Posted October 8, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1394959' date='Sep 28 2007, 09:15 PM']Anthony Dragani, who used to answer questions at EWTN, mentioned something about this a few years back:[/quote] Thanks for sharing, Era!
withouthavingseen Posted October 9, 2007 Posted October 9, 2007 Iheartjp2, John Boswell is not exactly a Dan Brown type. Dan Brown was a teacher at a WASPy boarding school in New Jersey, turned writer, just like his dad. His mom was a musician and also a music teacher. Dan Brown is couldn't know or care less about the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church is as meaningful to him as the CIA is to the average Joe. It's just a good "they" who can be the focal enemy in a thriller novel. He only wants to make money selling books. John Boswell (+1994) was a convert to the Catholic faith, and held a chair in medieval history at Yale. He was orthodox on pretty much all issues - except for one. He himself was a formerly-closeted homosexual and died of AIDS. He was an impeccable historian and a gifted philologist, and never seems to have evinced any animosity toward the Church. As he progressed in his career, more and more of his work focused on the history of homosexuality within the Church, and is largely an attempt to rationalize both his weakness and sin by claiming that, in a sense, he hadn't deviated from the Church, but that the Church had deviated from him. Eventually, homosexuality and the Church became the focal point of his career; this naturally provides much fodder and ammunition for the enemies of the Church. He himself is said to have gone to daily Mass with some frequency. Boswell's argument that the various manuscripts found are actually gay marriage ceremonies, etc., isn't an historical argument at all. It is a philosophical one - insisting that the evidence means something other than what it very clearly means, while offering no evidence that such is the case. Even the name of said monastic ceremony, "adelphapoiia" means something like "brother-making" and not "lover-making," and Boswell darn well knew that. Dan Brown just makes stuff up out of thin air. "Opus Dei monks" is like "carnivorous vegans." He is stupid in the truest sense of the word: he speaks about he knows not what. John Boswell was an extraordinarily intelligent man, drawn to the Catholic Faith in sincere convinction, and troubled by his own proclivity toward sin, and unable to reconcile them in favor of Christ. Back in college, my medieval studies seminar read his book on infant abandonment in Europe. A really good book. It's a pity his history became increasingly disconnected from hard facts. I won't judge him though: he lived in a time when the Church was only beginning to formulate a support system for people with same-sex attraction (is there an adequate one yet?), and when the Ivy League academia was more than happy to offer Boswell its own form of "support". Dan Brown is still alive and John Boswell died with the sacraments. We have reason to hope for both of them. That's about what they have in common. There are good articles on him and on adelphopoiia in Wikipedia. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boswell"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boswell[/url] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adelphopoiia"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adelphopoiia[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now