Old_Joe Posted October 1, 2007 Posted October 1, 2007 Is it better to please God or to be pleasing to God or is there even a difference?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 1, 2007 Posted October 1, 2007 This is a very good question, one I've been thinking about lately. Ultimately, if everything goes right, there is no difference. God would rather that we be pleasing to Him in our very being, but if we are, then we are pleasing Him. If, however, we strive to please Him, then we are pleasing to Him. A problem comes about when we strive to please Him even though we do not strive to be pleasing to Him. By this I mean such a situation as being dirty on the inside, but "clean" on the outside. There is a statement in theology (and philosophy): "agere sequitur esse" - "acting follows being." We act according to what (and who) we are. For instance, if we actually hate God, but try to please Him out of fear of His wrath, then we are not pleasing to Him, because we are not with Him on the inside. An attempt at pleasing God in such a case would not please Him, because He knows it is not really meaningful (and because the attempt would be imperfect in itself anyway because of the weakness of human nature). Such a person's being and interior disposition are contrary to that person's actions. The opposite is also true, however: if one truly loves God and has a true desire to please Him for His own sake, one's being is oriented in the right direction. However, such a person, in trying to carry out acts pleasing to God, will ultimately discover that our weak human nature is incapable of pleasing God perfectly. In such a case, being is more important than acting. God sees our desire to please Him and knows that our attempts are in good faith, even if they in themselves aren't completely pleasing to Him. Which person do you think would be more in God's favor - a person who hates Him but does His will imperfectly out of a desire not to be destroyed or a person who loves God and does His will, however imperfectly, out of a genuine (or at least mostly genuine) desire to please God? In the beginning, I said that they are ultimately the same thing. This is because while our actions do follow our being, they also come back to us and affect our being. Let's say that I have a bit of a desire to please God...it's not perfect, but it's there. I go out and give alms...not too much, but enough that it's a sacrifice. Now, I have a sort of mediocre love for God and a sort of mediocre action flowing from that love. However, if I'm open to God's work in my soul, that action should also affect me (sort of like Newtonian mechanics - each action has an equal but opposite reaction...if I act with love of God, that act will push back on me and affect me equally). As I get used to making mediocre sacrifices, if I am open to grace, those actions will begin to make my soul thirst for greater love of God and I will begin to love Him more in my being, acting with greater love, thus growing more in love of Him in my being, thus acting with even greater love, and the process goes on. Both in my being and my action, I will remain imperfect, but I strive for that perfection of love. As I said above, if we are pleasing to God, we should seek to please Him; if we seek to please Him, we are pleasing to Him. Things can get in the way of this correlation, but only if our love is lacking in genuineness (which it almost always is in this life, and God understands...a lack of genuineness does not mean that it's intentional). God bless, Micah
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now