Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Just A Heads Up


Recommended Posts

Autumn Dusk
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1482202' date='Mar 23 2008, 11:48 AM']Confession means nothing if you don't mean it. And it is obvious that you don't mean it, as you've stated repeatedly that you don't actually believe in the tenets of the Church.[/quote]


I adhere to the tenants of the church and when I confess I do "make up my mind not to sin again" and I'm sorry I did whatever I did.

Posted

K, I just wanna say, quit knocking AD. I'd say she's doing better than many people who came to church today... who only go to receive "the bread" on Easter and Christmas so they can say they are Catholic. If AD can intellectually believe the bread is really Christ, and the Wine is really His Precious blood, and that she wants to sin no more, than that's a flippin big start. She'll come around, in the end. But to me, I'm seein' too much blame from many of you.

Posted (edited)

Is it blame or truth SMM? Theo quoted scripture that is pretty clear on the matter. Yes there is some blame going on, I won't deny that but AD needs to know the truth. And sometime the truth hurts.

We all need to pray for AD and others in a similar position.

Edited by Mercy me
Autumn Dusk
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1482234' date='Mar 23 2008, 12:54 PM']Is it blame or truth SMM? Theo quoted scripture that is pretty clear on the matter. Yes there is some blame going on, I won't deny that but AD needs to know the truth. And sometime the truth hurts.

We all need to pray for AD and others in a similar position.[/quote]

For the final time, atleast on this thread. I don't need or want prayers. And I'm sure other people "in a similar position" would say the same. However, if you want to waste your prayers go ahead.

And you are neither a theologian or doctor of the church. You read scriptures your own way. I can understand how you can come to those ideas but guess what, I don't agree. I do what is required of me by the rules and if thats not good enough for God than I really don't want him.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1482235' date='Mar 23 2008, 10:58 AM']For the final time, atleast on this thread. I don't need or want prayers. And I'm sure other people "in a similar position" would say the same. However, if you want to waste your prayers go ahead.

And you are neither a theologian or doctor of the church. You read scriptures your own way. I can understand how you can come to those ideas but guess what, I don't agree. I do what is required of me by the rules and if thats not good enough for God than I really don't want him.[/quote]Why do you dislike receiving prayers?






Alleluia

Edited by tgoldson
KnightofChrist
Posted

A prayer is never wasted. Prayers. :sign:

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1482235' date='Mar 23 2008, 04:58 PM']For the final time, atleast on this thread. I don't need or want prayers. And I'm sure other people "in a similar position" would say the same. However, if you want to waste your prayers go ahead.

And you are neither a theologian or doctor of the church. You read scriptures your own way. I can understand how you can come to those ideas but guess what, I don't agree. I do what is required of me by the rules and if thats not good enough for God than I really don't want him.[/quote]

All of us need prayers. :) I will pray for you, AD, and I trust that you will pray for me also.

I don't know what has happened to you in your past and I'm not going to speculate about your personal life, but I'm sure that your feelings didn't just emerge from nowhere. God is glad of our best. You give Him your best. Nobody could ask for more.

Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1482102' date='Mar 23 2008, 12:46 AM']Meh. I don't care and thats really that.



Point of practicing, as said above. Because I want to and because I feel like it. Its an excuse to get out of hell when it comes down to it, atleast in my opinion. Out of all the religions Catholicism makes the most logical sense so I follow the rules and the actions. I will defend it if asked. And I don't think anything more should be asked of me.

And as I told another above poster. Pray for someone who wants it. I don't need your or anyone else's prayer.[/quote]

You aren't really Catholic. You are an agnostic. You can follow every doctrine of the church but, if you do not believe in any of it, God sees that. He knows everything you think and feel. Going through the motions gets you nothing. It is better than nothing though but, I don't think very much. I can't imagine anything sadder than going to mass and not feeling God's presence.

Posted

Christ is risen! Truly, He is risen!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Deb' post='1482058' date='Mar 23 2008, 01:21 AM']You should just keep going through the motions. You are right, it is better than doing nothing and some day you may just find the truth in the word of God and your motions will become moments that fill you with God's grace and Love.[/quote]
Absolutely right.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Deb' post='1482262' date='Mar 23 2008, 01:50 PM']You aren't really Catholic. You are an agnostic. You can follow every doctrine of the church but, if you do not believe in any of it, God sees that. He knows everything you think and feel. Going through the motions gets you nothing. It is better than nothing though but, I don't think very much. I can't imagine anything sadder than going to mass and not feeling God's presence.[/quote]
You are confusing feeling with belief. Many people go to Mass and have absolutely no feeling of God's presence, but still believe Catholicsm to be true, and obediently go. We don't attend for feelings pro or con, God did not ask our opinion, but He did say to keep holy the Sabbath and the Church says we attend Mass on Sunday, so we go anyway. Many other groups go to churches because it feels good, and stay home when it doesn't, but Catholics are obliged to go no matter what our emotional temperature happens to be. Feelings come and go, obedience remains.

Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1482229' date='Mar 23 2008, 11:41 AM']K, I just wanna say, quit knocking AD. I'd say she's doing better than many people who came to church today... who only go to receive "the bread" on Easter and Christmas so they can say they are Catholic. If AD can intellectually believe the bread is really Christ, and the Wine is really His Precious blood, and that she wants to sin no more, than that's a flippin big start. She'll come around, in the end. But to me, I'm seein' too much blame from many of you.[/quote]

I am not knocking AD. She can do whatever she wants. I don't care. I agree that going through the motions is better than not doing anything. I am just saying that there are people out there who love their Catholic faith more than anything else in the world. To have someone say that they are Catholic and then don't believe what they are doing is confusing to a world who tends to find fault in everything Christian. AD, like I said previously. Go to church. Go through the motions. I don't care.

I am not sure if you were referring to me as a "teen drama queen" or yourself. If you were referring to me, then you are mistaken. I am neither a "teen" or a "drama queen" thank you very much.

Legend Chaser
Posted

My prayers go with you, brother. May you find the Truth that I hope you continue to seek. God bless you and your walk.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1482351' date='Mar 23 2008, 12:54 PM']You are confusing feeling with belief. Many people go to Mass and have absolutely no feeling of God's presence, but still believe Catholicsm to be true, and obediently go. We don't attend for feelings pro or con, God did not ask our opinion, but He did say to keep holy the Sabbath and the Church says we attend Mass on Sunday, so we go anyway. Many other groups go to churches because it feels good, and stay home when it doesn't, but Catholics are obliged to go no matter what our emotional temperature happens to be. Feelings come and go, obedience remains.[/quote][i]right on. [/i] can I quote you?

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1482374' date='Mar 23 2008, 07:43 PM']I am not knocking AD. She can do whatever she wants. I don't care. I agree that going through the motions is better than not doing anything. I am just saying that there are people out there who love their Catholic faith more than anything else in the world. To have someone say that they are Catholic and then don't believe what they are doing is confusing to a world who tends to find fault in everything Christian. AD, like I said previously. Go to church. Go through the motions. I don't care.

I am not sure if you were referring to me as a "teen drama queen" or yourself. If you were referring to me, then you are mistaken. I am neither a "teen" or a "drama queen" thank you very much.[/quote]

If we do not care about a person and the way they live, how is it that we can pray for them? One of Jesus' most remarkable qualities was his ability to enter so fully into people's lives - without judging them. No one else could have wept over the death of Lazarus. It's impossible to pray unless you care.

Some people [i]do[/i] love their Catholic faith more than anything in the world - and they know it on all the different levels. Such people are rare, and perhaps they have yet to be tested. Would they survive the test? If the answer is a glib 'yes', perhaps they don't love as much as they think.

Some people don't find it so easy to give and receive love, not because of any personal defect (God created us in love, after all) but because of the turns their life has taken and the burdens that they bear. My close friend E, who posts on Phatmass as farglefeezlebut, has days when she believes that she is incapable of loving anybody, least of all God. Her Christianity isn't imperilled by that. I know that only a person with a great capacity for love would be able to persevere in the way E is persevering currently. She doesn't feel that way. I can't make her feel that way. It's not a mindset that you can choose or switch on and off. All she can do is try her best with what she's got - which is what Autumn is trying to do.

People in this kind of position may look impoverished and attract lots of censure. But it's a thousand times better to be like this than to mistake Christianity for an emotional high, and criticise anybody who doesn't experience the requisite emotions. God's love runs deeper than that, and I pray that one day we may all know it.

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1482571' date='Mar 23 2008, 08:03 PM']If we do not care about a person and the way they live, how is it that we can pray for them? One of Jesus' most remarkable qualities was his ability to enter so fully into people's lives - without judging them. No one else could have wept over the death of Lazarus. It's impossible to pray unless you care.

Some people [i]do[/i] love their Catholic faith more than anything in the world - and they know it on all the different levels. Such people are rare, and perhaps they have yet to be tested. Would they survive the test? If the answer is a glib 'yes', perhaps they don't love as much as they think.

Some people don't find it so easy to give and receive love, not because of any personal defect (God created us in love, after all) but because of the turns their life has taken and the burdens that they bear. My close friend E, who posts on Phatmass as farglefeezlebut, has days when she believes that she is incapable of loving anybody, least of all God. Her Christianity isn't imperilled by that. I know that only a person with a great capacity for love would be able to persevere in the way E is persevering currently. She doesn't feel that way. I can't make her feel that way. It's not a mindset that you can choose or switch on and off. All she can do is try her best with what she's got - which is what Autumn is trying to do.

People in this kind of position may look impoverished and attract lots of censure. But it's a thousand times better to be like this than to mistake Christianity for an emotional high, and criticise anybody who doesn't experience the requisite emotions. God's love runs deeper than that, and I pray that one day we may all know it.[/quote]

Let me clarify myself...by "I don't care" I mean I am not going to stop her from going to Church and going through the motions. That is really between her and God. I cannot read her heart. Only He can. I cannot make her do something that she does not want to do. It is not within my power. I only know what she said on this thread. That was that she goes through the motions and that is all. She does not believe in Catholicism. This is what I believe to be confusing for those who do not understand the faith and who are coming here for answers or for the truth. I am in no way accusing AD of anything. If I did, I did not mean it to be such.

I know full well that to have faith is not a feeling. I do not critize anyone who experiences that "emotional high" nor if they do not. There are days that I go into Church and wish I wasn't there but I still go because I know that it is between me and God.

I am not going to say something that does not want to be heard. Of course I am going to pray for AD and I care for her soul. However, why write that here when she has told others that she does not want prayers? I will pray for her in the privacy of my own home. I will offer my sufferings for her as I do the whole phatmass community.

I think I might have misrepresented myself as a mean, uncaring individual in this thread. This was not my intent. I guess I just got frustrated and let it carry onto this thread. Forgive me.

Meg

Posted

Faith journey is tough. Don't be too hard on yourself (or others) for not getting it right right away. Lord knows most of us have a long way to go. I certainly do.

Always challenge, never bash. If you are lacking something spiritually, pray for the grace to understand God more fully.

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1482351' date='Mar 23 2008, 06:54 PM']You are confusing feeling with belief. Many people go to Mass and have absolutely no feeling of God's presence, but still believe Catholicsm to be true, and obediently go. We don't attend for feelings pro or con, God did not ask our opinion, but He did say to keep holy the Sabbath and the Church says we attend Mass on Sunday, so we go anyway. Many other groups go to churches because it feels good, and stay home when it doesn't, but Catholics are obliged to go no matter what our emotional temperature happens to be. Feelings come and go, obedience remains.[/quote]

I agree with you wholeheartedly but there is a difference. AD has said that she doesn't need prayers, that she only goes through the motions of Catholicism because she doesn't want to go to Hell. It is a calculated thing, rather than a 'goodness, I'm finding it hard to feel like I believe, but I still want to be a good Christian, so I shall persevere.' This is more 'I don't believe in Catholicism, but it seems to be the most surefire way of avoiding Hell, so I'll do some of the things Catholics do.'

Edited by Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1482215' date='Mar 23 2008, 08:58 AM']I adhere to the tenants of the church and when I confess I do "make up my mind not to sin again" and I'm sorry I did whatever I did.[/quote]

If you don't believe in God, then you're lying when you make the Act of Contrition.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1482988' date='Mar 24 2008, 11:14 AM']If you don't believe in God, then you're lying when you make the Act of Contrition.[/quote]


"oh my God I am sorry for my sins. I will try not to sin again and make for my sins to you and other people"

How in the world do I lie?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...