Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Baptism Of Babies And Salvation


Recommended Posts

King's Rook's Pawn
Posted

I have a weird question that's been bugging me. We believe that when baptized babies or very young children die they go directly to Heaven, correct? Meanwhile, baptized individuals who grow up have a chance to commit a mortal sin and go into eternal damnation when they die. Then, hypothetically speaking, why isn't it logical, under Catholic dogma, for parents to kill their babies after they've been baptized, thereby sending them directly to eternal bliss in Heaven rather than letting them live and risk eternal suffering in hell? Of course, it would be a sin itself, being murder, but what if the parent decided that they would rather go to hell rather than risk their children going there. Technically, wouldn't that be the selfless thing to do and to do otherwise would actually be selfish? You could possibly argue that the child would grow up to be a saint and save others, but he could also grow up to be a great heretic and beaver dam others. Concievably, according to this logic, it would be the most selfless act to simply baptize and kill all young children, risking damnation for oneself to dave the souls of others? I hope the Church has some kind of answer to this, because it's really troubling me, and if there is no answer then these all doctrines seem illogical to me.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

First, very good and thought provoking question. It's crossed my mind before, but I hadn't found a suitable answer until I began typing this out. Just like the Holy Spirit to reserve wisdom from me when it is for myself, but to grant it when it is for others. :P

[quote name='King's Rook's Pawn' post='1398064' date='Oct 5 2007, 05:02 PM']I have a weird question that's been bugging me. We believe that when baptized babies or very young children die they go directly to Heaven, correct? Meanwhile, baptized individuals who grow up have a chance to commit a mortal sin and go into eternal damnation when they die. Then, hypothetically speaking, why isn't it logical, under Catholic dogma, for parents to kill their babies after they've been baptized, thereby sending them directly to eternal bliss in Heaven rather than letting them live and risk eternal suffering in hell? Of course, it would be a sin itself, being murder, but what if the parent decided that they would rather go to hell rather than risk their children going there. Technically, wouldn't that be the selfless thing to do and to do otherwise would actually be selfish?[/quote]

Let me ask you this: Jesus desired to go through the greatest suffering imaginable to show us how much He loved us...did He undergo eternal damnation for us?

Despite the fact that it might seem selfless, we can never offer to go to hell for another. Jesus Himself only descended to the netherworld, the place of the dead where they rested in waiting, not hell, per se.

The reason is this: to whom do we owe more...our fellow human persons (including our children) or God? It is better to give God His due than to give to another human person what they will not even accept (since your concern is that they would fall away if they were to live on). So, since you are the steward of your own life, and your job in life is to "make interest" on your life (i.e. grow in holiness so that, when your Master returns, you will have something greater to give Him back when you give Him yourself in heaven--Matthew 25:14-30 is a great demonstration of this). You owe God yourself...your eternal self. To give that away to or for another would be to choose against giving God what He deserves (even marriage, which is giving yourself to another, ends at death...it is not eternal). It is therefore not selfish to preserve your own salvation, even while another may fall into damnation (although we should certainly try to stop this from happening as much as we are able without sinning ourselves), because you do not owe your eternity to another human, but to God. It is selfless because you are holding on to yourself to give yourself back to God.

[quote]You could possibly argue that the child would grow up to be a saint and save others, but he could also grow up to be a great heretic and beaver dam others. Concievably, according to this logic, it would be the most selfless act to simply baptize and kill all young children, risking damnation for oneself to dave the souls of others? I hope the Church has some kind of answer to this, because it's really troubling me, and if there is no answer then these all doctrines seem illogical to me.[/quote]

You mentioned the possibility of sainthood. Ultimately, if we fail to hope for this for every single person, then we fail to hope. We cannot judge who will be saved and who will be damned, and so we must give these stewards a chance to "gain interest" on themselves, that is, to grow in holiness and become saints. Yes, it is a risky venture, but to take that chance away from them would be to bury their talent in the ground for them, and as we see, that is punished.

We need to practice hope and allow these sorts of questions to drive us to preach the Gospel at all times; if we don't, others may pay for it for eternity, and we also will be held accountable.

Again, though...great question.

God bless,

Raphael

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...