Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Scrupulous Or Uninformed?


Recommended Posts

Posted

am a revert to the Church for almost 13 yrs. now. I have thought all this time that I am scrupulous and have been working on this. But recently, I had questions about sexual thoughts and actions once I became engaged. I am older and have been married and annuled. However, No matter the question I have in regards to what exactly the a Commandment means or the Church teaches,most people do not really know and I have a difficult time searching for the REAL answer. Once I have the answer to my question I am not scrupulous but conscience and making sure I do my best not to fall into sin.
My confessor at my parish gets impatient with me.but when he explains to me the meaning of what I am going through such as me judging a sin as mortal but it is really venial,then I feel calm because I know what is up.
I love the Church. However, it really is very general in teachings. For example, the Commandment on Adultry. It encludes fornication and lust. And even though the Cathecism tells us this, it does not really explain further. For example, We can see someone and think they are good looking and our body can respond to their attraction in a sexual way immediately. That is ok. But if we have EVIL INTENT,then it becomes not normal and a sin. Now a step further,what is evil intent. I hope I am making myself clear. I am very intellengent and I like to know the whole truth to things,it is my nature. I have always been like this, This was one reason I left the church at a young age because no one could answer my questions and then most people turn it back on me in one way or another,such as being scrupulous or too deep or not trusting God and on and on. But what it is ...I just want to know what something means. Simple as that.
Does anyone else experience this? how do I get my confessor to understand me? And finally,where do I go for the answers?
There are many catholic sites and places to ask a priest,etc. There really would not be a need for all this if we all had a resource that taught us. Deeper then the Cathecism. Maybe a book to go along with the Cathecism??
What do you all think?
Thanks for your time.

Posted

You might find help asking some of the resident priests here at Phatmass (cappie, theologian in training, etc.). Also, Catholic Answers has an apologist line where you can actually ask these kinds of questions over the phone. The number for that is [b](619) 387-7200[/b]

Posted

Thank you very much for your info.
Someday I pray one of the 'scholars of the church" writes an in depth book that contains questions and answers such as asked on sites for Catholics. I am a very outgoing person and it is not a comfort for me to talk to so many many people that have the same experience as me. Somehow,this unsurity of morality makes Protestant religions attractive. However, I love my Church and believe strongly in the Sacrements and would not leave.






[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1399581' date='Oct 8 2007, 08:13 PM']You might find help asking some of the resident priests here at Phatmass (cappie, theologian in training, etc.). Also, Catholic Answers has an apologist line where you can actually ask these kinds of questions over the phone. The number for that is [b](619) 387-7200[/b][/quote]

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

welcome to you!

Don't feel bad asking questions...you should see some of the stuff I ask...wooooowooowooo



Here you will always find a lotta friendly ears willing to help ya out as best you can.

On the generalization, the Church leaves it that way because there are simply too many subjective and objective factors to consider in every circumstance. Only God could keep up with it all! and He does! lol

You have to properly form your conscience so that you will know when something is right or wrong, or if a sinful act is mortal or venial Like anything else, worth doing, it takes time and practice.

Pray daily, read the scriptures daily, read the catechism nightly (helps ya fall asleep too :shock: ) and receive the sacraments (esp. confession and the Eucharist) regularly.


Oh yeah - hang out at Phatmass slinging tacos, so very tasty and good for you, as much as ya can too!

Posted

Groo the Wanderer'
Thanks for the supportive and funny post. One of my problems is my confessor. I really like him and think highly of him being a priest, however,he is super impatient with me and often judgemental of me. When he does give me advise he is good. But usually i feel put down and judged. He just told me that most of what I confess is venial and not mortal. I am a very emotional person and I tend to get teary eyed in confession and he seems to take that as something is wrong with me. I don't think that. AndI know confession ...the sacrement of it helps me greatly....whether this priest sees it or not.
I am just not sure where to go and talk to someone. I can't seem to find anyone here in Jax.










Don't feel bad asking questions...you should see some of the stuff I ask...wooooowooowooo
Here you will always find a lotta friendly ears willing to help ya out as best you can.

On the generalization, the Church leaves it that way because there are simply too many subjective and objective factors to consider in every circumstance. Only God could keep up with it all! and He does! lol

You have to properly form your conscience so that you will know when something is right or wrong, or if a sinful act is mortal or venial Like anything else, worth doing, it takes time and practice.

Pray daily, read the scriptures daily, read the catechism nightly (helps ya fall asleep too :shock: ) and receive the sacraments (esp. confession and the Eucharist) regularly.
Oh yeah - hang out at Phatmass slinging tacos, so very tasty and good for you, as much as ya can too!
[/quote]

Posted

cutiepie-with a few exceptions, I have never used my parish priest as my confessor. It isn't that I am afraid to tell them to someone who knows me, it's rather that I have felt in the past that it actually makes my priest uncomfortable. I had one priest that I worked with, that I really respected, but he would practically wiggle himself off his seat when he saw me come in to the confessional. Some of my best reconciliation experiences have been with older priests who are retired, or no longer in an active parish ministry. They have more time, more experience, more wisdom. Two of my best confessors in the past were a hospital chaplain, and a priest with MS who had retired to a nursing home. In the latter's case, I think he liked the idea of still being able to do some kind of active ministry. He did mass for the residents every day, did annointings, and did spiritual direction with students from the local college. That's how I met him. He said that hearing the confessions of young people reminded him of what it was like to be young, and free, and sometimes really stupid. Why don't you try to find someone else to go to. If another priest also tells you that you are confessing things that you shouldn't then you may need to look further into you soul.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Each priest is different...find one you are comfortable with. I am blessed with one right now that is very good helping me work out the issues in my life. Don't worry about getting teary...I do the same thing at adoration sometimes. As far as confessing venial sins, do what you are comfortable with right now....as you develop your conscience and faith, you will better be able to discern the difference.

Only two other things I would ask you to keep in mind about that though...
1. Always remember that attending Mass n a faithful manner 'wipes out' the venial sins...don't deny this to yourself.
2. Do not confess the same occurrence of the same sin more than once...that IS scrupulous and tends to lead you to doubt the forgiveness of Christ.


BTW - we do have a couple or more folks in the phamily that are/were scrupulous.....hang around...I am sure at least one will weigh in and/or PM you about it



:taco: :banana:

Posted

[quote name='cutiepie50' post='1399684' date='Oct 8 2007, 10:27 PM']Thank you very much for your info.
Someday I pray one of the 'scholars of the church" writes an in depth book that contains questions and answers such as asked on sites for Catholics. I am a very outgoing person and it is not a comfort for me to talk to so many many people that have the same experience as me. Somehow,this unsurity of morality makes Protestant religions attractive. However, I love my Church and believe strongly in the Sacrements and would not leave.[/quote]

John Paul II answered many of these questions in his Theology of the Body series.

[url="http://www.amazon.com/Good-News-About-Sex-Marriage/dp/0867166193/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/102-6069111-4110517?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191959118&sr=8-2"]http://www.amazon.com/Good-News-About-Sex-...9118&sr=8-2[/url]


[url="http://www.amazon.com/Man-Woman-He-Created-Them/dp/0819874213/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/102-6069111-4110517?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191959140&sr=1-1"]http://www.amazon.com/Man-Woman-He-Created...9140&sr=1-1[/url]

[url="http://www.amazon.com/Theology-Human-Divine-Parish-Resources/dp/0819873942/ref=pd_bbs_sr_3/102-6069111-4110517?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191959140&sr=1-3"]http://www.amazon.com/Theology-Human-Divin...9140&sr=1-3[/url]

hyperdulia again
Posted

The Church's moral teachings are not unclear. :)

Posted

I would just like to add a small thing on mortal and venial sins in confession:
Your priest is probably right. Most things you confess in confession are probably venial. It is not wrong to confess venial sins, as a matter of fact it is recommended. Through confessing venial sins we receive special graces to avoid those sins in the future.

I would really recommend learning the 3 necessities for a sin to be mortal as defined by the CCC. Namely:
Grave matter
Full knowledge
Full and complete consent

If any one of these three criteria are not met, than a sin is not mortal. Consent is defined by the CCC (broad definition in my opinion) as a personal deliberate choice. The Catechism also specifies that habit, psychological disorders, maturity, and other things can lessen culpability. Things like fear of death can lessen ones culpability of the sin of lying for instance. However, as to whether certain fears or habits can lessens the culpability of a sin from mortal to venial I am not sure. I've heard both that it does, and that it doesn't. Either way we should refrain from receiving communion until confession so that we are sure we are not receiving in the state of mortal sin. It is not easy to judge one's own state of his soul.

Posted

[quote name='"Groo the Wanderer"']Only two other things I would ask you to keep in mind about that though...
1. Always remember that attending Mass n a faithful manner 'wipes out' the venial sins...don't deny this to yourself.
[b]2. Do not confess the same occurrence of the same sin more than once...that IS scrupulous and tends to lead you to doubt the forgiveness of Christ.[/b][/quote]

Groo, would you be so kind as to explain that second part for me?

I ask because I have a tendency to confess to particular sins every time I go to Confession; a more comfortable example being disrespect toward my parents. Are you saying I only have to confess to disrespect once, even if I do it again? That sounds kind of strange.

Thanks in advance. :)

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

nopers.


It means that if you confessed whacking your little brother over the head with a duck egg last Tuesday, you should not confess that again. If you whack him again next Tuesday, you do need to confess that though.

Once a particular sin is forgiven, it is gone. 're-sinning' is a new sin - confess it.




sorry bout that - I am not always clear...drives wifey nuts

Posted

"would really recommend learning the 3 necessities for a sin to be mortal as defined by the CCC. Namely:
Grave matter
Full knowledge
Full and complete consent"

So, then if you lie with full knowledge and complete consent and it caused someone harm...what is that? Mortal or venial?

I am really trying to form my conscience correctly. And I do think the Church is unclear about the DETAILS of what constitute a sin..not as above,but in a more personal daily example. If this wasn't so why are there so many Catholics on sites and asking priests and friends,etc questions about morality as pertained to Catholic teachings. Come on be real.
I really want to love God. We are all individuals and love God the best we can(us who want to love God). And for me, settling and answering morality questions will form a good and right and not scrupulous conscience in me and that is good thing and a loving thing for me,others I touch and my love of God.

Posted

[quote name='cutiepie50' post='1400053' date='Oct 9 2007, 04:50 PM']"would really recommend learning the 3 necessities for a sin to be mortal as defined by the CCC. Namely:
Grave matter
Full knowledge
Full and complete consent"

So, then if you lie with full knowledge and complete consent and it caused someone harm...what is that? Mortal or venial?

I am really trying to form my conscience correctly. And I do think the Church is unclear about the DETAILS of what constitute a sin..not as above,but in a more personal daily example. If this wasn't so why are there so many Catholics on sites and asking priests and friends,etc questions about morality as pertained to Catholic teachings. Come on be real.
I really want to love God. We are all individuals and love God the best we can(us who want to love God). And for me, settling and answering morality questions will form a good and right and not scrupulous conscience in me and that is good thing and a loving thing for me,others I touch and my love of God.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='cutiepie50' date='Oct 9 2007, 04:50 PM' post='1400053']
"would really recommend learning the 3 necessities for a sin to be mortal as defined by the CCC. Namely:
Grave matter
Full knowledge
Full and complete consent"

Posted (edited)

So, then if you lie with full knowledge and complete consent and it caused someone harm...what is that? Mortal or venial?

I am really trying to form my conscience correctly. And I do think the Church is unclear about the DETAILS of what constitute a sin..not as above,but in a more personal daily example. If this wasn't so why are there so many Catholics on sites and asking priests and friends,etc questions about morality as pertained to Catholic teachings. Come on be real.
I really want to love God. We are all individuals and love God the best we can(us who want to love God). And for me, settling and answering morality questions will form a good and right and not scrupulous conscience in me and that is good thing and a loving thing for me,others I touch and my love of God.
[/quote]

Edited by cutiepie50
Posted

I know what your confusion is. I have often been confused as to what constitutes a "grave" matter. It is difficult, but if you follow what your priest says and try your best, you should be able to be confident in your faith.

Posted

Thank you for understanding me. That is precisely it....I get confussed on what constitutes a mortal sin, I know the 3 ways to examine your sin(s) however, that still can not be enough info. I know that is sometimes scruplous and sometimes it isn't.
I want to feel more at peace with God more often.
When someone says let go and Trust in God...that is too simply for me. I want to know HOW. This issue I have prayed daily about for almosst 13 yrs. I am trying to be open and listen and learn and I have grown in my spirituality,but I seem to be at a new stage and wanted more...more depth.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...