Mateo el Feo Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 Happy Fiji Day, everyone! I love Oct. 10th. So what's everyone planning to do in November to celebrate National White Guilt Month?
Era Might Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 It's not so much a matter of race as nationality. America is for Native Americans what the Hagia Sophia is for Christians. I don't know enough about Columbus to say whether we should honor him with a holiday, but there are different sides to history. European history views 1492 in terms of "discovery," but that history looks very different for the Natives (who had been here for millenia). From a Christian perspective, the discovery of the Americas brought the great good of the Gospel (which was God's providence), but that doesn't necessarily mean the discovery itself has to be celebrated, for its own sake. The history of the Native peoples after 1492 is horrific, and it was perpetrated to make way for the new arrivals and their temporal rule. I'm not saying anyone should feel personally guilty about the past, but I can understand if some people choose not to celebrate that event (and again, this is not a judgment on Columbus personally, who I don't know much about, but about the historical significance of his arrival and what came afterward).
Lena Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1400430' date='Oct 10 2007, 02:09 PM']It's not so much a matter of race as nationality. America is for Native Americans what the Hagia Sophia is for Christians. I don't know enough about Columbus to say whether we should honor him with a holiday, but there are different sides to history. European history views 1492 in terms of "discovery," but that history looks very different for the Natives (who had been here for millenia). From a Christian perspective, the discovery of the Americas brought the great good of the Gospel (which was God's providence), but that doesn't necessarily mean the discovery itself has to be celebrated, for its own sake. The history of the Native peoples after 1492 is horrific, and it was perpetrated to make way for the new arrivals and their temporal rule. I'm not saying anyone should feel personally guilty about the past, but I can understand if some people choose not to celebrate that event (and again, this is not a judgment on Columbus personally, who I don't know much about, but about the historical significance of his arrival and what came afterward).[/quote] I agree...we share a collective history with the Native populations, it's not "guilt" but [i]awareness[/i] in the atrocities committed, in the history of our country... I just took a mid-term essay exam today on the Columbian Exchange, the point is that all the bad and all the good that occurred, shaped the US for what it is today.
Mateo el Feo Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 [quote name='Lena' post='1400490' date='Oct 10 2007, 06:03 PM']I agree...we share a collective history with the Native populations, it's not "guilt" but [i]awareness[/i] in the atrocities committed, in the history of our country... I just took a mid-term essay exam today on the Columbian Exchange, the point is that all the bad and all the good that occurred, shaped the US for what it is today.[/quote]To a large part, it shaped what the entire Western Hemisphere is today, and probably had a pretty big impact on what the Eastern Hemisphere is today (e.g. the impact on European monarchies, African slavery, Asian immigration). The fact that Columbus' ocean-crossing adventures impacted almost the entirety human civilization might be why we celebrate Columbus Day and not "Native American Day" or some other made-up PC holiday.
MissScripture Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 [quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1400414' date='Oct 10 2007, 01:11 PM']Aw man! I still feel guilty because my Norman ancestors kept the Saxon man down! Also for the crimes my Aztec forerunners perpetrated on my Mayan foreunners. Heck...for that matter, I still cannot sleep at night because of the Sumerian persecution of the Phoenecians......drives me teal with guilt.....[/quote]
Dreamweaver Posted October 10, 2007 Posted October 10, 2007 (edited) What? No one celebrates Leif Erikson Day? I didn't either, but the Vikings discovered North America before Columbus! Edited October 10, 2007 by Dreamweaver
Socrates Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 Christopher Columbus, for whatever his flaws, brought the light of Christ and Western Civilization to a New World, and made possible the eventual founding of this great nation, and for this he should be celebrated. I can't stand all this p.c. self-loathing revisionist carp. I'm not going to wallow in guilt about what my white European ancestors did. One of them married a Cherokee Indian ancestor - it's not about genocide; it's about love, baby!
catholicinsd Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='Dreamweaver' post='1400543' date='Oct 10 2007, 07:37 PM']What? No one celebrates Leif Erikson Day? I didn't either, but the Vikings discovered North America before Columbus![/quote] St. Brandon came before him
catholicinsd Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 Also for those you who haven't, I would strongly encourage you all in the Americas to research the indegeous people of your particular area. I garentee you will be amazed at the story of the fore-bearers of this land.
Groo the Wanderer Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 ...and I strongly encourage YOU to research who was here before that. NOBODY was truly indigenous to North or South America. Even the Indians (feathers, not dots) migrated here...just like the Europeans. They just took a different mode of transpo... South Dakota? They have internet up there?
homeschoolmom Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1400720' date='Oct 11 2007, 08:13 AM'](feathers, not dots)[/quote]
catholicinsd Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1400720' date='Oct 11 2007, 08:13 AM'] ...and I strongly encourage YOU to research who was here before that. NOBODY was truly indigenous to North or South America. Even the Indians (feathers, not dots) migrated here...just like the Europeans. They just took a different mode of transpo...[/quote] I would strongly encourage you to cut the ignorant, racist carp.
Groo the Wanderer Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 Do praytell, point out to me what is racist about anything in my post, dear child? I bashed no group, not Indians, not Europeans, not carp, not even South Dakotans. Methinks you are a little too tightly wound....try decaf mebbe?
catholicinsd Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 The 'feathers, not dots' crack. And the little cartoon you choose to use.
ardillacid Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='catholicinsd' post='1400767' date='Oct 11 2007, 11:46 AM']I would strongly encourage you to cut the ignorant, racist carp.[/quote] ...which leads me to my next point: Don't smoke crack!
CatholicCid Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 (edited) On behalf of Carp, I demand a bashing. Edited October 11, 2007 by CatholicCid
Aloysius Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 the statements are no more racist than Carlos Mencia is racist. calm down. there's a girl in anthropology club that's got amerian indian ancestry. we make fun of how us good anthropologists like to crack stupid native american jokes with her. on a more serious note: the natural ethnocentric impulse doesn't go away by supressing the urge to make jokes at other cultures' expenses; it is curbed by accepting that you have it, understanding that you'll always have an ethnocentric bias on the level of emotions, and being light-hearted about it all. it's like the difference between moderation and puritanism. apply the rule of St. Benedict to all things: ne quid nimis; nothing to excess.
Maggyie Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 Useless fact: Christopher Columbus was considered for canonization, which I think means he has the same status as Pope John Paul II, that of a "Servant of God."
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now