genxcathedra Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Our priest told us about how someone was convicted by the FBI based on his sacramental confession! It was meant for mobsters and maybe he was, but it's still usable if they can hear you and have the green light to use it. Apparently, some cell phones have the devices in them that work even if the phone is turned off! If someone else is listening, it might affect the validity of your Confession if you are aware of the possibility. I don't know though. The priest told other priests about the devices in cell phones after he saw the article in a regular paper. This priest is level-headed. This is not Coast to Coast AM stuff.
dUSt Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 There's nothing wrong with the coast to coast AM stuff. Long live Art Bell!
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 My cell phone has gone off during confession. How embarassing! :
RobeofJustice Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='genxcathedra' post='1401079' date='Oct 11 2007, 10:01 PM']Our priest told us about how someone was convicted by the FBI based on his sacramental confession! It was meant for mobsters and maybe he was, but it's still usable if they can hear you and have the green light to use it. Apparently, some cell phones have the devices in them that work even if the phone is turned off! If someone else is listening, it might affect the validity of your Confession if you are aware of the possibility. I don't know though. The priest told other priests about the devices in cell phones after he saw the article in a regular paper. This priest is level-headed. This is not Coast to Coast AM stuff.[/quote] Freaky stuff dude!
Aloysius Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I'll have to remember next time I'm confessing a felony!
Carolyn Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1401166' date='Oct 12 2007, 08:40 AM']I'll have to remember next time I'm confessing a felony! [/quote]
LouisvilleFan Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='genxcathedra' post='1401079' date='Oct 12 2007, 01:01 AM']If someone else is listening, it might affect the validity of your Confession if you are aware of the possibility.[/quote] It wouldn't affect the validity of your Confession, whether you're aware or not. I don't have a source for it, but I remember reading that Fr. Damien, the priest who ministered to lepers on one of the Hawaiian islands, would row out to a passing ship and yell his Confession to a priest on board. Obviously, he was more concerned about receiving the sacrament than whether anyone overheard You're free to tell anyone what you want to tell them. After all, Confession used to be given in front of the whole congregation before private confessionals became standard practice.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 The penitent can tell about his confession, the priest cannot. Only the priest is bound by secrecy.
Justin86 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 It also should be noted that anyone who happens to overhear a Confession is bound by the Seal as well.
Lounge Daddy Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 That was part of the Patriot Act, was it not?
genxcathedra Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 Although noone said it was baloney, here are some articles that hint that there are those trying to overturn the secrecy or get around it. I reported; you decide. I hope posting these without the source's ok isn't stealing or otherwise immoral or illegal. [url="http://www.catholicleague.org/catalyst.php?year=1996&month=July-August&read=101"]http://www.catholicleague.org/catalyst.php...st&read=101[/url] [url="http://frontpagemag.com/Articles/Printable.aspx?GUID={112C46BB-EA83-4B57-AC4D-F67A85B0BB18}"]http://frontpagemag.com/Articles/Printable...D-F67A85B0BB18}[/url] read the part...so if you were close to the.. [url="http://www.alamo-girl.com/110.htm"]http://www.alamo-girl.com/110.htm[/url] .CNSNews.com 8/10/99 Lawrence Morahan "...The ages-old legal right of Catholic priests to keep to themselves what they hear in the confessional is under attack by a preparatory commission of the International Criminal Court (ICC), a United Nations' body established last year to investigate genocide and crimes against humanity. In ongoing meetings this week to determine rules of evidence and procedure, the commission is considering revoking the so-called priest-penitent privilege, a sacred authority bestowed on ordained priests to hear the confessions of Catholics and grant them absolution for sins...." [url="http://www.textfiles.com/conspiracy/CN/cn07-83.txt"]http://www.textfiles.com/conspiracy/CN/cn07-83.txt[/url] [url="http://media.www.thetriangle.org/media/storage/paper689/news/2006/03/03/EdOp/The-Catholic.Church.Was.The.Bigger.Threat-1654626.shtml"]http://media.www.thetriangle.org/media/sto...t-1654626.shtml[/url] These aren't about cell phone bugging. Does it really matter if it's not admissable? These are: but not about confessionals [url="http://news.zdnet.com/2100-1035-6165067.html"]http://news.zdnet.com/2100-1035-6165067.html[/url] [url="http://news.zdnet.com/2100-1035-6140191.html"]http://news.zdnet.com/2100-1035-6140191.html[/url] It's a brave new world.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I once called my boyfriend while he was in Confession...I did not know he was there, and he generally has it on vibrate?
jeffpugh Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) if i ever get a call, i'll just push the little button on the side of the phone that hangs up on the person. Edited October 14, 2007 by Sacred Music Man
jenna311 Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 i usually just leave my phone (and pretty much anything i have with me) outside of the confessional. i usually feel safe leaving any thing outside...and besides, it would be really sad if someone stole stuff while waiting in line for confession...
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 If a microphone could record when the device was turned off, I hardly think removing a battery could make a difference. Now if someone else recorded you on a cellular phone that'd be quite a big difference. HOWEVER, this is a complete scam. I'm studying criminal justice (along with other things). You mentioned FBI and so I'm assuming this is in the United states. The law goes as such. A recoding made without the knowledge of any of the parties being recorded cannot be used in court. Atleast one person must know they are being recoded. For in one case there were cameras installed in urinals where a drug deal was made, the evidence was not allowed in court becuase neither the dealer or the receiver knew they were there.
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 ^ Exception to the above is prisons or mental health facility where the person is considered under care of the state. Then the state can act "as" the person in certain cases, eg, if a prisoner's phone call is recorded by an officer the officer is acting as the prisoner even though the prisoner dosn't know.
Justin86 Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1402140' date='Oct 14 2007, 03:13 PM']If a microphone could record when the device was turned off, I hardly think removing a battery could make a difference. Now if someone else recorded you on a cellular phone that'd be quite a big difference. HOWEVER, this is a complete scam. I'm studying criminal justice (along with other things). You mentioned FBI and so I'm assuming this is in the United states. The law goes as such. A recoding made without the knowledge of any of the parties being recorded cannot be used in court. Atleast one person must know they are being recoded. For in one case there were cameras installed in urinals where a drug deal was made, the evidence was not allowed in court becuase neither the dealer or the receiver knew they were there.[/quote] So how come the cops can bug my house without me knowing and that's valid in court? Edited October 14, 2007 by Justin86
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 a) they need a warrant, which means they *should* have enough to convict you but want evidence for some other reason. Eg. they want to overhear who you're talking to so they can also convict that person b) you a known or highly suspected part of a group that falls under such a warrant c) you or someone in the bug's domain pose a threat to national security during a time of war d) you are in a public place, or place of high traffic (an apt building) where someone could naturally overhear by any means, (eg, a lipreader) e) They can also convict anyone of a crime discovered while investigating another crime. EG, if they are listening for people tapping phone-lines and while they listen one of the innocent customers in the neighborhood reveals a crime that person can be charged with a crime pending further evidence. However, things fall on both side of these rules. For example, some states will not allow infrared pictures as evidence for a warrant, nor allow infrared technology to prove someone is home. On the other hand massive bugging is allowed in some states becuase of a poorly designed warrant and lax judges. This is why convictions can be appealed successfully. On a lighter note, do you know why the "war on drugs" was very successful back in late 2002? Not because people decided to be good or becuase we found out better crime stopping methods but becuase we secured our boarders in significant ways and this created a net which caught much drug traffic even though its intention was to catch terrorists.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now