Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Just Me Or Anyone Else Notice This?


Recommended Posts

Posted

ok, went to a really super modern, 60's, doesn't really look like a church- (catholic) church for mass. Heres a trend I notice at such churches:

-more liturgical abuses- 60's type love and peace everyone feels good about them selves type stuff. Example: additions/subtractions from the prays etc as the priest sees fit. Priest sitting in the pews, not on the alter- Eucharist and precious blood in glass vessels, alter servers not dressed for serving (no robes, cassoks albs etc)- get this one: the deacon came in at the gospel- didn't read the gospel, gave the homily, and left :unsure: .....


- such churches feel the need to put holy oils like in a place of importance and where you can see them clearly but shove the tabernacle off into some obscure corner


Maybe its just me, but I really feel the surroundings you are in for Mass, the space, has a big effect on things. On a personal level, its harder for me to focus on the mass and concentrate when I can't find the tabernacle, and when I do find it it looks like some grotesque thing.... etc etc...... and I think the surroundings reflect the attitude of the parish..... a 60s modernistic view of things and that is reflected in the liturgy

I'm not trying to be better than you, holier than the pope ..... just observations

Posted

some of the greatest heresies came out of churches that were done up all pretty

Posted

I think the tabernacle is "misplaced" in a sense of rebellion when the churches are built/"rearranged". That sense of rebellion tends to seep through in a lot of things besides the arrangement of the church, too. Liturgical abuses naturally follow. You tend to have more theological solidity when your priorities (i.e., the primacy of [i]Jesus[/i] in your surroundings) are in the right order.

Posted

absolutely. I'm absolutely not saying that the design of the church means those who worship in it are saints or are better people. I'm speaking in terms of liturgical abuses mainly, I believe they come more easily in a church that is not designed as a church should be- the layout has a reason the people are focused streight ahead on Christ in the tabernacle, on the alter. They unite with the priest to focus on the sacrifice of Christ. The church itself looks like a cross. IT clearly defines the role of the priest- at the alter, and the role of the people, in the nave (is that the word?) These 60s circular half moon designs tend to try and blur the lines between the people and the priest and where they physically are, which represents the role they each play in the mass.

Posted

Curtins, great observations. I think most people realize that our worship can be enhanced by the "visual cues" of Our Faith. There are quite a few recent books on the subject.

Posted

I think that it has everything to do with the priest of the parish. What you discribe has fortunately not been my experience.

Posted

thats certainly also a factor

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1402187' date='Oct 14 2007, 03:05 AM']I think that it has everything to do with the priest of the parish.[/quote]These two things can be related. For example, at my parish, the pastor arrived to a rather empty "worship space" and has helped enhance the sanctuary with Catholic art (e.g. statues of the saints, stained glass, etc). Our experience of the sacred is enhanced by the visual beauty as well as the reverence of the priest.

Of course, there's the flip side of the coin: priests who strip the sanctuary of our rich artistic heritage can be the same ones who "improvise" the Mass.

Posted

I would have to agree with that Mateo. My thinking had been that priest come and go from parishes but the building are constants no matter how ugly.

Posted

Sad to say my church looks like a big barn. No pews, chairs. No kneelers. No tabernacle in the church much less on the altar...it is in a side chapel. And few windows. I just don't feel like I am in church. of course, we have no resident priest either, he is scattered to 2 other parishes.

Lioness For Christ
Posted

I don't like the circular messes... And well, this past week I went to Mass in a little "chapel" all circular... The Alter is SUPPOSED to be rasied from the main floor at least a little bit, from what I learned back in gradeschool but it wasn't.. And I didnt' see the tabernacle... So it was like when I was kneeling, I felt like I was staring directly into the eyes from teh person across from my "circle".... I 'd rather stare at Jesus....

Posted

my church has a prominent tabernacle and sacred oils displayed. :mellow:


i think its cool to have the oils in visible place. (and, perhaps, the documents call for it?)


i'm just saying, is all :)

Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1402135' date='Oct 13 2007, 11:06 PM']- such churches feel the need to put holy oils like in a place of importance and where you can see them clearly but shove the tabernacle off into some obscure corner[/quote]
but how important can that 'wafer' be when the holy oils promote community? :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='Lioness For Christ' post='1402331' date='Oct 14 2007, 12:12 PM']I don't like the circular messes... And well, this past week I went to Mass in a little "chapel" all circular... The Alter is SUPPOSED to be rasied from the main floor at least a little bit, from what I learned back in gradeschool but it wasn't.. And I didnt' see the tabernacle... So it was like when I was kneeling, I felt like I was staring directly into the eyes from teh person across from my "circle".... I 'd rather stare at Jesus....[/quote]
but you've got it all wrong, doncha know?? it's not about Jesus, it's about our community! :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1402135' date='Oct 14 2007, 01:06 AM']ok, went to a really super modern, 60's, doesn't really look like a church- (catholic) church for mass. Heres a trend I notice at such churches:[/quote]

I loathe modern church architecture. It didn't start in the 1960's like most people think. There are a few examples of ultra-modernist architecture in the Milwaukee are that were built in the 50's.

One church in particular (built in 1955), was so horrible, I would beg my parents not to take me there as a small child. It did with a much smaller budget what the New Cathedral in LA could not hope to have accomplished, make a child cry at its hideousness.

Posted

Dismas, you've managed to post something that is both hilarious and heartbreaking at the same time.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...