Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is The Catholic Priesthood A False One?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Could someone help me in this question asked by a member of the Church of Christ (Iglesie ni Kristo) founded in the Philippines. This was his statement during our debate at the youtube. (You could also visit the site just type Ang Dating Daan vs. Iglesia ni manalo).There are debates posted there about religion.However,mostly are Filipinos that's why they speak tagalog.

Here is the statement.

"marc...

I understand why you didnt see the pattern of what I was saying. We have different reference points.

Anyway, Peter according to the Catholic church
was the First Pope and a Priest!

This is another controversy because the Levitical Prieshood was already ABOLISHED after a NEW COVENANT was established by Christ!
The Catholic Priesthood can not also claim lineage from the Priesthood of Christ because this UNCHANGEABLE PRIESTHOOD is under the order of Milchezedec! "

"marc...

There are only TWO PERSONS who could claim this prieshood... One is Milchezedec and the other is Christ himself!
The reason is, for you to qualify, YOU MUST BE A KING AND A PRIEST AT THE SAME TIME! This is the Biblical requirement which nobody among us could be both!

Question now is, where do the Catholic Priests line themselves in ? There is none they can point to! "


I really need your help brothers and sisters. I need info's about this to add it up from my knowledge of Peter's ministry in Rome. Thanks.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='marccatholic' post='1402897' date='Oct 15 2007, 03:25 AM']Could someone help me in this question asked by a member of the Church of Christ (Iglesie ni Kristo) founded in the Philippines. This was his statement during our debate at the youtube. (You could also visit the site just type Ang Dating Daan vs. Iglesia ni manalo).There are debates posted there about religion.However,mostly are Filipinos that's why they speak tagalog.

Here is the statement.

"marc...

I understand why you didnt see the pattern of what I was saying. We have different reference points.

Anyway, Peter according to the Catholic church
was the First Pope and a Priest!

This is another controversy because the Levitical Prieshood was already ABOLISHED after a NEW COVENANT was established by Christ!
The Catholic Priesthood can not also claim lineage from the Priesthood of Christ because this UNCHANGEABLE PRIESTHOOD is under the order of Milchezedec! "

"marc...

There are only TWO PERSONS who could claim this prieshood... One is Milchezedec and the other is Christ himself!
The reason is, for you to qualify, YOU MUST BE A KING AND A PRIEST AT THE SAME TIME! This is the Biblical requirement which nobody among us could be both!

Question now is, where do the Catholic Priests line themselves in ? There is none they can point to! "
I really need your help brothers and sisters. I need info's about this to add it up from my knowledge of Peter's ministry in Rome. Thanks.[/quote]

I will be moving this to the Transmundane Lane so you can get a better variety of assistance. However, I will also say this...no one ever said that St. Peter was a levitical priest. What happens is that Melchizedek was a priest and a king, the king of a particular city, Salem. Salem was later changed to Jebus. Jebus was later conquered and King David changed the name of it to "Jerusalem." This is all proven by archeology. What we see is that King David was also in the Order of Melchizedek (if you look at his actions surrounding the Ark of the Covenant, it becomes clear that he took on priestly actions and duties). In fact, this is why the psalms, which refer to him and to Christ so often, refer to him as being a priest in the order of Melchizedek. An order is a line, a lineage. By its nature, this lineage had to have been upheld in the time between Melchizedek and Jesus. There have to have been other priests of that order, or else the whole concept falls apart.

What we see in the New Testament is that Jesus, the true King of Israel, is also the main priest in the order of Melchizedek. He went out and ordains other priests, who therefore share in this special lineage. Those who are Baptized are also baptized into it, although in a different way (through Baptism, we are all priest, prophet, and king). There is nothing which indicates that you must be both a priest and a king first in order to become a priest in the order of Melchizedek.

So your friend is wrong in stating that there could only be two priests. The New Testament makes that clear, because in it we find that there were many, many priests in the early years of the Church, none of whom were levitical.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

I don't have anything to add, but I figured it might be helpful to share the link the the Phatmass Defense Directory entry for Iglesia ni Cristo:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/207"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/207[/url]

Posted (edited)

Indeed, Melchizedek and Jesus are priests, prophets, and kings. It should also be mentioned that Melchizedek and his sacrifice of bread and wine prefigures Christ's passion just as Abraham's attempted sacrifice of Isaac.

In Jesus, we receive the one act of sacrifice that really mattered in the eyes of God and the Law. There is no need for new sacrifice for salvation, for Christ died for us once and for all.

How then, does Peter and the Apostles, their bishops and priests fall in?

All of us who are baptized into the Triune God in the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit are joined into the mystical body of Christ. In this baptism, we die with Christ, that we may rise with Him. In this baptism, we become His beloved disciples. In this baptism, we become adopted sons and daughters of God the Father. In this baptism, we become brothers and sisters of Christ Jesus. In this baptism, we share a mystical union with the Paraclete. In this baptism, yes, we like John before us, we receive even Mary, the new Eve for the New Testament and New Covenant as our adopted mother. Our Father is God, our Brother is King, our mother is Queen, and we are to share in Christ's inheritance! Indeed, is it not written that we shall be crowned in Heaven? Such is our baptism, for we share in the priesthood, and the prophesy, and the kingdom that is purchased for us in Christ.

So too, in the Eucharist, Christ draws us ever nearer. Is not the bread and wine now body and blood of Christ? By eating and drinking do we not assimilate Him into ourselves? Are we not sustained eternally by eating the flesh and drinking the blood of the Son of Man? How intimate indeed is the Eucharist, for as His Body assimilates into us, we then conform unto Him, and truly become one body, with Christ as its head.

In Confirmation, behold, for we are not denied, but rather welcomed into further intimacy! We who now are baptized in Christ, share even our bodies with His, now we are anointed with chrism in His name! When we receive this oil, and sealed therein upon our foreheads, we are so conformed to our Master as to become as Christ. We are now Christs to the world and to each other. Surely if even this is not withheld from us sinners on Earth, what glories in Heaven await us when we are perfected in Heaven!

For some of us, those who dare, those who are called, there is the sacrament of Holy Orders. We are already priests, prophets and kings within the Church. We, the baptized, share the Royal Priesthood of Christ. And yet, there are those select few men who are lead to take up a ministry in the Kingdom. Yes, as David and Solomon before Him, Christ's kingdom is attended to by ministers. These men were known as presbyters or elders in the Greek tongue, and from presbyter, we English speakers derive the word "priest". Christ enacted this ministerial priesthood, and through Christ, Peter and the Apostles appointed further ministerial priests and bishops for the growing Church. These appointed priests and bishops are succeeded generation by generation to this very day, by appointing priests and bishops to spread the Kingdom of God through all nations and all times.

The ministerial priesthood is not called to sacrifice, for there is no sacrifice that a priest can give of self or other that is pleasing to God. This is why the priesthood of the Levites was abolished. Christ has died once and for all, for the salvation of mankind.

So what does the ministerial priest do? As priest he does not sacrifice, no, but he does re-present the sacrifice to our Lord the Father, that sins may be forgiven. Indeed, in this sacred memorial feast, a priest does not bring the death of our Lord to the present, but rather, the priest brings us back to Calvary. Did not our Lord say that he would gather all things to Himself if he were to be lifted up upon the Cross? We too are gathered up to our dying Lord. We die too in His death, and we rise again in His rising. This is the first and greatest duty of the ministerial priest, to do this, the Eucharist, in memory of Him.

Second, as a minister to the Kingdom of God, a priest is called to settle accounts. Should a servant wrong his King, would not the minister respond? Should that servant beg forgiveness, is it not the minister to the King's duty to settle with the servant? So too is it in the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Our King is just and merciful. His faithful minister, knowing the desire of his King, would surely be generous with a repentant servant. The minister, recalling how his King served Him, is surely impelled to serve even the lowliest of servants, that they may rise into the good graces of their Lord and King.

This is the ministerial priesthood of Jesus Christ. This is the priesthood of Peter. This is the ministerial priesthood of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. This is the duty and the honor of the ministerial priest, that he and his children in spirit and water share in the Reign of God.

I hope this helps,
Dismas

Edited by Dismas

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...