Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pest Control And Morality


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have always had a soft spot for animals. At my old apartment, we had one mouse that didn’t really bother us. When the exterminator came and set traps, we took them all down, because we felt bad killing a little animal.

In September, I moved to a worse part of town. There are so many mice in my apartment, it is ridiculous. I have found mice in my bed, my clothes, and my food. They are defecating all over my apartment. We have set traps and killed about five mice. Every time we do, I feel really sad. I just don’t know any other way of living in a sanitary home without killing them. Do you think this is immoral? We are using the snap traps, because I think they are a bit more humane than the glue traps.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1403666' date='Oct 16 2007, 01:49 PM']I have always had a soft spot for animals. At my old apartment, we had one mouse that didn’t really bother us. When the exterminator came and set traps, we took them all down, because we felt bad killing a little animal.

In September, I moved to a worse part of town. There are so many mice in my apartment, it is ridiculous. I have found mice in my bed, my clothes, and my food. They are defecating all over my apartment. We have set traps and killed about five mice. Every time we do, I feel really sad. I just don’t know any other way of living in a sanitary home without killing them. Do you think this is immoral? We are using the snap traps, because I think they are a bit more humane than the glue traps.[/quote]
We have mice from time to time as well. I too feel bad about killing them but I have three young children and don't really fancy them contracting some funky disease. Mice are furry and cute -- would / do you have any compunction about killing insects?

The bottom line is human health, coupled with being humane.

Posted

Yeah I feel bad killing insects too, but not as bad as mice. The more intelligent the animal, the worse I feel.

Posted

I think you're being scrupulous. They're health hazards and ought to be treated as such.

Posted

Look, they do not have eternal souls and so it's no big deal. Certainly we should not do it disrespecting that God has created him, but they do not reflect his image and likeness. They may be killed for valid purposes (i.e. sanatation, food (yes I saw "Never Cry Wolf" where the guy boiled them and ate them to do an experiement about how the wolves lived in Alaska). God put his creatures on the earth for our use and we may subdue them. Let the subduing commence.

Posted

I used to use the glue traps when I lived by a ravine and was being overwhelmed. I did anyway until I came home and found the glue traps stuck to my basset hounds ears. We eventually had a large snake move into our storage building, and the mouse problem went away.

Posted

[quote name='93 Phillies' post='1403666' date='Oct 16 2007, 02:49 PM']I have always had a soft spot for animals. At my old apartment, we had one mouse that didn’t really bother us. When the exterminator came and set traps, we took them all down, because we felt bad killing a little animal.

In September, I moved to a worse part of town. There are so many mice in my apartment, it is ridiculous. I have found mice in my bed, my clothes, and my food. They are defecating all over my apartment. We have set traps and killed about five mice. Every time we do, I feel really sad. I just don’t know any other way of living in a sanitary home without killing them. Do you think this is immoral? We are using the snap traps, because I think they are a bit more humane than the glue traps.[/quote]
I've always found tooth, claw and fur traps to be especially efficacious. Interestingly enough, the mouse problem went away not only my condo, but also all the adjoining ones. It seems that the smell of "cat" causes mice to flee the area.

Of course, not all mice flee, and so sometimes you might find a "present" offered to you. Sadly, these offering tend to be next to the bed. And yes, you have to praise the feline for giving you such a wonderful gift...and then toss it in the garbage.

Posted

yea, i vote cat. its very circle of life :mellow:

plus, then you have a fuzzy, purry friend to keep you company as well! ^_^

Posted

Thanks for the replies. Cat does sound like the best idea. We thought about that, but we probably won't live together next year, and we're not sure who'd take it after that. Also, wouldn't a cat be expensive with vet check ups and shots and so forth? It might be worth it though. I might liking having a feline companion around.

Posted

not with an indoor cat. upfront adoption cost and shots is pry between $150 and $200 (in LA County, there are vouchers for spaying, so it literally only costs $5), but then, if they stay inside, they don't get sick or hurt, so its not bad at all.

cats are great friends, they're good for a snuggle, but if you don't have lots of time or space to do all the doggy needs (i love dogs too, but they do require a bit more), cats work well.

PapaHilarious
Posted

gotta go with a :kitten:



i am biased, though, considering i have one sitting in my lap right now ;)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Dismas' post='1403918' date='Oct 16 2007, 11:24 PM']I've always found tooth, claw and fur traps to be especially efficacious. Interestingly enough, the mouse problem went away not only my condo, but also all the adjoining ones. It seems that the smell of "cat" causes mice to flee the area.

Of course, not all mice flee, and so sometimes you might find a "present" offered to you. Sadly, these offering tend to be next to the bed. And yes, you have to praise the feline for giving you such a wonderful gift...and then toss it in the garbage.[/quote]

It is a fallacy that the smell of cat causes a mouse to leave because I have both. Some of them take the tough guy approach and move in anyway. There are 4 cats here , 1 of which is anti-death penalty. and so far I have counted 1 live mouse in the kitchen and about 10 bodies in the yard. I don't mind them in the yard as long as I can see them before I walk outside barefoot.
I know there is a mouse because I picked up my toaster and there was a mouse clinging to the cord for dear life. I yelled, it squeaked, and both retreated.
There are dirty and carry diseases and are NOT cute little pets. Those kind you buy at the pet store and feeds to your boa.

Posted

There is nothing immoral about killing animals.

Posted

um yes there is, if its not done humanely. <_<

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1408878' date='Oct 24 2007, 11:12 PM']um yes there is, if its not done humanely. <_<[/quote]
There is a difference between killing and torturing.

Posted

exactly. killing and killing by torturing aren't equal. i was noting the difference (ie humane killing)

Posted

I'm all for killing cute and cuddly mice if they can cause disease(which they do). The Plague wiped out a third of Europe because of mice. God only knows what they could be carrying.

At the same time however why can't we make a more humane method of execution then rat poison? One time when I layed some the mouse came out of the wall and I watched it die in front of my woodstove. It looked like the poor thing was in alot of pain. I actually felt really bad for it. :sadder:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...