S][N Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 @ Knight [mod]Not funny. There are ways to get your point across without being uncharitable. Something more like, "I think your line of thought is the same type of faulty reasoning that keeps civilization from advancing" would be acceptable because it attacks the argument, not the person. -Raph[/mod] ----- There ya go raph. All nice
Ash Wednesday Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1406342' date='Oct 21 2007, 12:45 AM']i christopher walken![/quote] Me too (obviously) [quote name='rachael' post='1406217' date='Oct 20 2007, 07:28 PM']Like, totally. [/quote] I was doing my best Regina George impression (Mean Girls)... you know that part where someone told her that her house was awesome and she said "I know, right?" I don't think any less of you for liking Potter, because you have Walken appreciation.
abercius24 Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Justin86' post='1405964' date='Oct 20 2007, 03:17 AM']Hey look another Harry Potter topic! Just when I thought the debate was over... Prediction: Supporters of the series will claim that since the books never explicity dealt with Dumbledore's homosexuality it's irrelevent to the morality of the books. Critics will in turn say that this is only confirmation that the J.K Rowling is promoting witchcraft. People will keep the same opinions as before and no one will change their minds.[/quote] Yes and no. I personally have debated whether to let my kids read the books when they were old enough to discerned between the true, satanic nature of "magic" versus the playful, reckless, fictionalized version Rowling has wrote of in her books. Given the immoral context and culture the book exists in now, and how Rowling's words have further solidified her books within that culture, I am definitely not letting my kids read these books at any time whatsoever. How can I have my 12-year-old discussing these books with other kids and have him get into a debate on Dumbeldore's "sexual orientation"? No way am I going to support that kind of exposure! My kids will have to learn about the evils of the world in a much more controlled way, one that I can help them work their thoughts and emotions through and still maintain their innocence. [quote name='Raphael' post='1406042' date='Oct 20 2007, 12:15 PM']This is just stupid. It's not even implicit in the books, lol...oh, and by the way folks, we have no reason to believe he acted on homosexual tendencies either. For all we know, J.K. Rowling could have kept him celibate for a reason. PS-as Adam just reminded me in a private message, you can't write a whole series and then go back and add a new detail about one character that wasn't even implicit in the text, just because you decide it would be an interesting character trait. I mean, there's a certain point at which new added details simply should not be attributed to the characters...what if JRR Tolkien had come out after he'd published LOTR and added, "oh, by the way, Frodo and Sam were a couple." It just doesn't work that way. Sorry.[/quote] I wish Tolkien had explicityly stated that Sam and Frodo were far from gay, frankly. Having done a lot of research on LOTR, I have found a disturbing number of websites that discuss Frodo and Sam as being homosexual. I know he couldn't have predicted where our society would be today, but I'm sure if he had known, he would have wanted to make his faith clear on that point.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 (edited) This is getting ridiculous. English literature is my subject at university. If some of the people posting in this thread had their way, it would be a subject at all, as the tools of analysis would be taken away from us. It is just not possible to say definitively, "Emily Bronte's [i]Wuthering Heights[/i] is about X and Y" and then treat that decision as a kind of literary dogma that mustn't go unchallenged. I wrote my dissertation last year on autism in the work of Emily Bronte. Does this mean that the pro-cure crowd who are forever demonising autism should slam Bronte's work as a glorification of what they see as 'disease'? No, because my interpretation is just that - interpretation. Not the law. There are all kinds of different theories and analyses about all kinds of different books, which are never based on what an author happens to say about his or her work. Once the text is out there in the hands of the readership, it ceases to be the author's property. Your analysis is based on the text and what you can make of it, using your understanding of the language and the culture in which it was written and its relationship with present-day culture and many other things. It's not the place of the reader or the literary critic to try and judge the author's intention, a practice that is known as 'psychoanalysing the author' and is frowned upon heavily - for good reason. The author can't step in and say, "When I wrote that, I meant this" and expect the readers to take his or her word as the truth in concrete. My analysis of Aeschlyus's [i]Prometheus Bound[/i] almost certainly doesn't tally with what Aeschlyus 'meant' when he wrote it, but that doesn't make his meaning more valid than my interpretation. To say otherwise is to value the author over the text. Personally, I don't think that Dumbledore was gay. I see him as an asexual figure. He is whimsical, comic, romantic in the poetic sense - but not a sexually charged man at all. I could draw out samples of text to back me up in this analysis. Other people might turn to the text to try and 'prove' that he is gay - just as people have tried to show that Jane Eyre was a lesbian or that Sam and Frodo had a homosexual relationship. It is silly to expect the author of a work to sit down and clarify every little point ("No, so-and-so never owned a pair of purple socks. Such-and-such is definitely heterosexual, yes.") before you read the book. There is no such thing as a [i]de facto[/i] interpretation in literary analysis. The study of literature is essentially the study of humanity. We can't sanitise literature and try to bring it in line with our own worldview. I am a Catholic because I have seen a lot of other ideas and beliefs, mostly represented through the pages of books, and felt that Catholicism makes the most sense in this world. I am [i]not[/i] a Catholic because I only read books that meet a set of stringent moral criteria and base all my thinking on those. There is no justification for banning books ever. The only kind of book I fear is one that is badly written. Edited October 21, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
rachael Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1406452' date='Oct 21 2007, 04:35 AM']I don't think any less of you for liking Potter, because you have Walken appreciation.[/quote] Aww...thanks!
Justin86 Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1406477' date='Oct 21 2007, 11:08 PM']This is getting ridiculous. English literature is my subject at university. If some of the people posting in this thread had their way, it would be a subject at all, as the tools of analysis would be taken away from us. It is just not possible to say definitively, "Emily Bronte's [i]Wuthering Heights[/i] is about X and Y" and then treat that decision as a kind of literary dogma that mustn't go unchallenged. I wrote my dissertation last year on autism in the work of Emily Bronte. Does this mean that the pro-cure crowd who are forever demonising autism should slam Bronte's work as a glorification of what they see as 'disease'? No, because my interpretation is just that - interpretation. Not the law. There are all kinds of different theories and analyses about all kinds of different books, which are never based on what an author happens to say about his or her work. Once the text is out there in the hands of the readership, it ceases to be the author's property. Your analysis is based on the text and what you can make of it, using your understanding of the language and the culture in which it was written and its relationship with present-day culture and many other things. It's not the place of the reader or the literary critic to try and judge the author's intention, a practice that is known as 'psychoanalysing the author' and is frowned upon heavily - for good reason. The author can't step in and say, "When I wrote that, I meant this" and expect the readers to take his or her word as the truth in concrete. My analysis of Aeschlyus's [i]Prometheus Bound[/i] almost certainly doesn't tally with what Aeschlyus 'meant' when he wrote it, but that doesn't make his meaning more valid than my interpretation. To say otherwise is to value the author over the text. Personally, I don't think that Dumbledore was gay. I see him as an asexual figure. He is whimsical, comic, romantic in the poetic sense - but not a sexually charged man at all. I could draw out samples of text to back me up in this analysis. Other people might turn to the text to try and 'prove' that he is gay - just as people have tried to show that Jane Eyre was a lesbian or that Sam and Frodo had a homosexual relationship. It is silly to expect the author of a work to sit down and clarify every little point ("No, so-and-so never owned a pair of purple socks. Such-and-such is definitely heterosexual, yes.") before you read the book. There is no such thing as a [i]de facto[/i] interpretation in literary analysis. The study of literature is essentially the study of humanity. We can't sanitise literature and try to bring it in line with our own worldview. I am a Catholic because I have seen a lot of other ideas and beliefs, mostly represented through the pages of books, and felt that Catholicism makes the most sense in this world. I am [i]not[/i] a Catholic because I only read books that meet a set of stringent moral criteria and base all my thinking on those. There is no justification for banning books ever. The only kind of book I fear is one that is badly written.[/quote] Using your reasoning, can I claim Da Vinci's [i]Last Supper[/i] depicts Mary Magdalene instead of St. John? After all to have Da Vinci step in and say what he meant would be valuing the author over the paint would it not? That would be some sort of artistic dogma. No one ever said anything about getting rid of Literature to study. Spare me the needless whine.
abercius24 Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1406477' date='Oct 21 2007, 09:08 AM']This is getting ridiculous. English literature is my subject at university. If some of the people posting in this thread had their way, it would be a subject at all, as the tools of analysis would be taken away from us. It is just not possible to say definitively, "Emily Bronte's [i]Wuthering Heights[/i] is about X and Y" and then treat that decision as a kind of literary dogma that mustn't go unchallenged. I wrote my dissertation last year on autism in the work of Emily Bronte. Does this mean that the pro-cure crowd who are forever demonising autism should slam Bronte's work as a glorification of what they see as 'disease'? No, because my interpretation is just that - interpretation. Not the law. There are all kinds of different theories and analyses about all kinds of different books, which are never based on what an author happens to say about his or her work. Once the text is out there in the hands of the readership, it ceases to be the author's property. Your analysis is based on the text and what you can make of it, using your understanding of the language and the culture in which it was written and its relationship with present-day culture and many other things. It's not the place of the reader or the literary critic to try and judge the author's intention, a practice that is known as 'psychoanalysing the author' and is frowned upon heavily - for good reason. The author can't step in and say, "When I wrote that, I meant this" and expect the readers to take his or her word as the truth in concrete. My analysis of Aeschlyus's [i]Prometheus Bound[/i] almost certainly doesn't tally with what Aeschlyus 'meant' when he wrote it, but that doesn't make his meaning more valid than my interpretation. To say otherwise is to value the author over the text. Personally, I don't think that Dumbledore was gay. I see him as an asexual figure. He is whimsical, comic, romantic in the poetic sense - but not a sexually charged man at all. I could draw out samples of text to back me up in this analysis. Other people might turn to the text to try and 'prove' that he is gay - just as people have tried to show that Jane Eyre was a lesbian or that Sam and Frodo had a homosexual relationship. It is silly to expect the author of a work to sit down and clarify every little point ("No, so-and-so never owned a pair of purple socks. Such-and-such is definitely heterosexual, yes.") before you read the book. There is no such thing as a [i]de facto[/i] interpretation in literary analysis. The study of literature is essentially the study of humanity. We can't sanitise literature and try to bring it in line with our own worldview. I am a Catholic because I have seen a lot of other ideas and beliefs, mostly represented through the pages of books, and felt that Catholicism makes the most sense in this world. I am [i]not[/i] a Catholic because I only read books that meet a set of stringent moral criteria and base all my thinking on those. There is no justification for banning books ever. The only kind of book I fear is one that is badly written.[/quote] So no books should be banned because they contribute to a legitimate study of humanity? What about erotica detailing the sexual abuse of children? What about how-to manuals for sexual predators? Should we make kiddie porn legal in the United States if its bound by a reputatable publisher? Quite frankly, your absolutist argument is very troubling in such a light. There are reasonable limits. The real question is proper balance. Ban Harry Potter? No. It's not that destructive to society in general. Me not let my kids read it. Absolutely! Edited October 21, 2007 by abercius24
Autumn Dusk Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 Ever hear of Marion Zimmer-Bradley. She wrote some amazing science fiction. It's adult si-fi, so there's some romance but less than However, her and her husband were later accused (and I think her husband was convicted) of sexual abuse of boys. I wouldn't be caught dead reading one of those books, I wouldn't walk around with a book, purchace it, or even borrow it knowing that the author commited henious crimes while writing it. That would cause me not to read a book. I find this different than an author stating after she published a book that a character was homosexual. I don't think even an author make something true about a book after its published. Even if Dumbledore is homosexual he didn't act on his desires, so I don't see what the big deal is. (and I happen to remember a romace between Dumbledore and someone else, which is confusing to me) Snape is more gay than anyone. Finally, there is no reason to reveal this after a series is completed unless its for attention. And JK Rowling has ALWAYS been about the attention. Its a wonder she had time to write the books as she went to interviews, contributed to the movie, maintained a website...she obvously sees her poplulartiy fading. I think that generating plenty of fan-fic was the reason behind this. Fan-fic in most cases can't be legally copyrited by the author, btw, as the original author holds the copyright to it. According to some laws JK owns all of that fan-fic. And what better thing is there for her than 10,000 people working on ideas for her next book.
Jaime Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote]Sam and Frodo had a homosexual relationship[/quote] I totally missed that one.
Azriel Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1406452' date='Oct 21 2007, 03:35 AM']I don't think any less of you for liking Potter, because you have Walken appreciation.[/quote] Total Hijack: "Gotta have more Cowbell"
rachael Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Azriel' post='1406599' date='Oct 21 2007, 03:05 PM']Total Hijack: "Gotta have more Cowbell"[/quote] [url="http://youtube.com/watch?v=IRTDaNch0eE"]http://youtube.com/watch?v=IRTDaNch0eE[/url]
cathoholic_anonymous Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Justin86' post='1406498' date='Oct 21 2007, 04:11 PM']Using your reasoning, can I claim Da Vinci's [i]Last Supper[/i] depicts Mary Magdalene instead of St. John? After all to have Da Vinci step in and say what he meant would be valuing the author over the paint would it not? That would be some sort of artistic dogma. No one ever said anything about getting rid of Literature to study. Spare me the needless whine.[/quote] Theoretically, you [i]could[/i] claim that Da Vinci's [i]Last Supper[/i] depicts Mary Magdalene - if you had the evidence to back that up, taken from the painting alone. As it happens, several art critics stepped in after the publication of Dan Brown's novel to point out, using their skills as Renaissance art specialists, that it is a man leaning on Jesus and not a woman. The evidence provided by the painting itself is stronger than Dan Brown's argument. No one can just make a totally unfounded claim about a work of literature and expect it to be treated as valid or valuable. As I pointed out very clearly, it needs to have a firm basis. You must support your argument with what you find in the novel or the poem or the script or whatever. But here we have people saying that Rowling's oral statement about Dumbledore's sexuality alters the way we should perceive the books and/or that this is an extra reason for people not to read them - all of which completely invalidates the way literature is approached and studied.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='abercius24' post='1406569' date='Oct 21 2007, 07:18 PM']So no books should be banned because they contribute to a legitimate study of humanity? What about erotica detailing the sexual abuse of children? What about how-to manuals for sexual predators? Should we make kiddie porn legal in the United States if its bound by a reputatable publisher?[/quote] I am using the word 'book' in a literary sense. Child pornography does not meet literary criteria. Nor does a how-to manual for bomb construction, poison-brewing, or even cake-baking. I had hoped that was clear from the context I wrote it in, but I should have been more explicit. There are some works of literature that do contain worrying material. I have read novels that deal with issues such as incest and rape - novels that are extremely valuable to our literary canon - and that are far more disturbing in their content than Harry Potter could ever be. All this means is that people must be sensitive and thoughtful when choosing their reading material (a skill that you acquire as you read). To give an example, I wish that I hadn't read Maya Angelou's [i]I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings[/i] as a nine-year-old, because the sexual assault described in that book terrified me. I was too young to handle such ideas then. But this need for good judgment doesn't mean that all books dealing with uncomfortable or downright painful truths of life should be labelled 'Bad' with a capital B. People are trying to make definitive moral judgments about such novels, which just isn't possible. Edited October 21, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
aalpha1989 Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1406210' date='Oct 20 2007, 07:14 PM']I think Harry Potter is [b]overrated.[/b] Across the boards, no matter what side of the debate you're on.[/quote] YAY! I'VE ALWAYS SAID THAT BUT NO ONE BELIEVED ME! [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1406477' date='Oct 21 2007, 09:08 AM']This is getting ridiculous. English literature is my subject at university. If some of the people posting in this thread had their way, it would be a subject at all, as the tools of analysis would be taken away from us. It is just not possible to say definitively, "Emily Bronte's [i]Wuthering Heights[/i] is about X and Y" and then treat that decision as a kind of literary dogma that mustn't go unchallenged. I wrote my dissertation last year on autism in the work of Emily Bronte. Does this mean that the pro-cure crowd who are forever demonising autism should slam Bronte's work as a glorification of what they see as 'disease'? No, because my interpretation is just that - interpretation. Not the law. There are all kinds of different theories and analyses about all kinds of different books, which are never based on what an author happens to say about his or her work. Once the text is out there in the hands of the readership, it ceases to be the author's property. Your analysis is based on the text and what you can make of it, using your understanding of the language and the culture in which it was written and its relationship with present-day culture and many other things. It's not the place of the reader or the literary critic to try and judge the author's intention, a practice that is known as 'psychoanalysing the author' and is frowned upon heavily - for good reason. The author can't step in and say, "When I wrote that, I meant this" and expect the readers to take his or her word as the truth in concrete. My analysis of Aeschlyus's [i]Prometheus Bound[/i] almost certainly doesn't tally with what Aeschlyus 'meant' when he wrote it, but that doesn't make his meaning more valid than my interpretation. To say otherwise is to value the author over the text. Personally, I don't think that Dumbledore was gay. I see him as an asexual figure. He is whimsical, comic, romantic in the poetic sense - but not a sexually charged man at all. I could draw out samples of text to back me up in this analysis. Other people might turn to the text to try and 'prove' that he is gay - just as people have tried to show that Jane Eyre was a lesbian or that Sam and Frodo had a homosexual relationship. It is silly to expect the author of a work to sit down and clarify every little point ("No, so-and-so never owned a pair of purple socks. Such-and-such is definitely heterosexual, yes.") before you read the book. There is no such thing as a [i]de facto[/i] interpretation in literary analysis. The study of literature is essentially the study of humanity. We can't sanitise literature and try to bring it in line with our own worldview. I am a Catholic because I have seen a lot of other ideas and beliefs, mostly represented through the pages of books, and felt that Catholicism makes the most sense in this world. I am [i]not[/i] a Catholic because I only read books that meet a set of stringent moral criteria and base all my thinking on those. There is no justification for banning books ever. The only kind of book I fear is one that is badly written.[/quote] speaking of ridiculous... I don't care how many literature classes you teach, if you teach that your opinion about a work of literature is as valid as the author's then you are teaching the classes wrongly. How can you say that an author isn't the ultimate authority about a book? That's like saying that God isn't the supreme authority about what creation means and is. When man writes he does so only through talent, the gift (grace) of God. This grace is poured through a man whether he knows it or not and influences his work. It does not control what he writes, but it enables him to write well. Man learning to write is simply man learning how to use this grace. Because the grace is used by the author he alone has the ultimate authority to interpret a work. An author intends something when he writes; it is an ABUSE OF ART AND LITERATURE to claim that a reader can know just as well as an author. it is missing the entire point and is akin to claiming than an individual's interpretation of scripture is just as good as the Church's official interpretation. Everyone has a different view and will use their agenda to interpret any work they want. that is wrong and destroys the whole point of writing. A writer writes to convey an idea or a story, not to give the world something to tear apart and make meaningless. Something without an absolute meaning is just that; meaningless. To say that there is no 'right' answer when interpreting literature is hogwash. I sincerely hope you don't teach college students that they can interpret literature however they want.
rachael Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1406730' date='Oct 21 2007, 06:18 PM']YAY! I'VE ALWAYS SAID THAT BUT NO ONE BELIEVED ME![/quote] That's because there's so many people who [i]do[/i] like it...
cathoholic_anonymous Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1406730' date='Oct 22 2007, 12:18 AM']YAY! I'VE ALWAYS SAID THAT BUT NO ONE BELIEVED ME! speaking of ridiculous... I don't care how many literature classes you teach, if you teach that your opinion about a work of literature is as valid as the author's then you are teaching the classes wrongly.[/quote] Again, that's NOT what I said. Please go back and read more carefully. I wrote that no one can just make a claim about a particular book and have it accepted automatically as valid or valuable. I wrote that a student must have [b]strong textual evidence[/b] to back up their arguments. My point is that the [b]text[/b] is the primary source, not the author's intention. Giving a disproportionate amount of attention to the author's intended 'meaning' is known in the field of literary theory as the [url="http://www.brysons.net/academic/wimsattbeardsley.html"]intentional fallacy[/url]. (It is discussed on that website in relation to poetry, but it holds good when applied to prose as well.) The concept of intentional fallacy doesn't deny the author's intention altogether - it does have its uses - but it [i]does[/i] state that authorial intention can't be used as the standard against which the worth of the text may be judged. [quote]How can you say that an author isn't the ultimate authority about a book? That's like saying that God isn't the supreme authority about what creation means and is.[/quote] Because the author isn't a God-figure. Simple. Writing a book is not like creating the universe. An author does not retain supreme control over his or her book once it is published. As soon as it is in the hands of the readers, it will be read and reviewed and studied and written about in many different ways. Once [i]The Times[/i] carried a review of my work that startled me. Although the review was positive, the journalist's reading of the book didn't match up to what I was thinking when I wrote it. But her analysis was justified, because she had based all her insights on a close reading of the text. Once somebody else wrote a short essay on the 'sense of sexual frustration' that I had supposedly captured in one of my poems. That was much harder to take, as I wasn't even thinking about sex when I wrote the poem. Sexual frustration was not what I intended to convey at all. But I read the essay through again and had to grudgingly concede that the person had made a convincing argument - based on my words, the structure, the metre, the [i]poem itself[/i]. If it had been a really bad essay, full of muddled logic and unconvincing arguments, I would have quite happily dismissed it as rubbish. As it happened, I couldn't do that. Texts have multiple layers of meaning and reading is almost like a dialogue between the reader and the text. It's an interactive process. This means that we can't assign sole interpretative authority to the writer. [quote]When man writes he does so only through talent, the gift (grace) of God. This grace is poured through a man whether he knows it or not and influences his work. It does not control what he writes, but it enables him to write well. Man learning to write is simply man learning how to use this grace. Because the grace is used by the author he alone has the ultimate authority to interpret a work.[/quote] I agree that the ability to write is God-given, just as all talents are. But this talk of 'ultimate authority' assumes that the author has an omnipotence and an omniscience that he doesn't actually possess. Furthermore, literary analysis is also a skill, and not all good writers are good literary critics. If you claim that a book can only have the meaning that the author explicitly gives to it, you are turning reading into an entirely passive process. You are also being very relativistic, ironically enough. As Wimsatt and Beardsley wrote, semi-flippantly, "Judging a poem [or any text] is like judging a pudding. [i]It has to work[/i]." [Emphasis mine.] J.K. Rowling may insist that Dumbledore is gay. Frankly, I don't think that 'works'. It doesn't fit with the way Dumbledore is presented in the text. Rather than using Rowling's statement as my yardstick, I'm looking primarily at her character development and Dumbledore's particular narrative voice - literary tools that are much more rigorous and a lot better adapted to assessing a text than comments made after publication by the author, which don't really fit the jigsaw. To give a slightly different example: Samuel Taylor Coleridge claimed that he composed his famous poem 'Kubla Khan' in the middle of an opium-induced trance, which was shattered by the arrival of a baker's boy from Porlock. After this, the fire of inspiration guttered out and Coleridge was back in the cold everyday world. This little anecdote, which entranced Coleridge's readers and made them mourn over the loss of the poem, was totally false. The lie was discovered after his death. His manuscripts for the poem have shown us that he drafted 'Kubla Khan' several times before submitting it for publication. Why did he lie? In one essay on this topic, I theorised that he wanted to simulate the sense of loss that Adam and Eve felt when they were turned away from Eden in the hearts of his readership - after all, 'Kubla Khan' deals with the theme of a paradise lost. His deception did have a creative purpose. But it was still a deception, as the text alone could show. [quote]An author intends something when he writes; it is an ABUSE OF ART AND LITERATURE to claim that a reader can know just as well as an author.[/quote] But the point of reading is not to discover the author's intention or to use the text to get at the author's mind. The point of reading is to engage with the text in front of you. [quote]it is missing the entire point and is akin to claiming than an individual's interpretation of scripture is just as good as the Church's official interpretation. Everyone has a different view and will use their agenda to interpret any work they want. that is wrong and destroys the whole point of writing.[/quote] As I have already explained very clearly on two occasions now, literary analysis is rigorous. It's a skill. It takes knowledge. I'm not suggesting that people can say anything they like about literature and have it accepted as Gospel-truth. They can't. This is why some essays on English literature get As and others get Ds. But the criteria for marking those essays is not based on how close the student manages to get to the author's intention, if that intention is even known. It's based on the quality of their argument, the fluency of their writing, and the specific analytical skills that they display. The comparison with the Bible is flawed. The Bible is sacred. Literature isn't. I love my books, but I don't hold them in the same esteem as Sacred Scripture. Secondly, the Bible is our theological beacon and our guide to leading a moral life. Literature is not. For this reason it's impractical and dangerous to have 100,000+ interpretations of the Bible cluttering up the shelves. With literature, it's the opposite. The profusion of new ideas only enhances the study and enjoyment of the text. If we couldn't debate over meanings, if we couldn't look at texts in new ways, the study of literature just wouldn't exist. We would all have to sit there and say, "The author of this work wanted it to mean X, so it is absolutely impossible to say anything more. Go away, and for your assignment please design a pretty bookmark." [quote]A writer writes to convey an idea or a story, not to give the world something to tear apart and make meaningless. Something without an absolute meaning is just that; meaningless.[/quote] Literary analysis does not tear the text apart. I go into tutorials and supervisions and have lively debates over all kinds of topics related to literature, and come away with a renewed perspective and a fresh appreciation for the text under discussion. You're trying to look at literature through a moral lens and turn the author into the god of their creation. It doesn't work that way. Just as it's rarely possible to look at human beings and make absolute statements about their personalities and morals, we can hardly ever subject characters in books (or the books themselves) to that sort of definitive judgment. We have the perfect example of this in J.K. Rowling's Severus Snape. Villain? Antihero? Good Guy in Disguise? It's very difficult to tell. In fact, when an author does create a character who seems either 100% perfect or 100% evil, readers often feel a twinge of disappointment. Would Voldemort's depravity really have been so gripping if we hadn't seen the lonely Tom Riddle abandoned on an orphanage doorstep by his mother? Forget scholarly reviews. Even people with no experience of the formal study of literature are likely to dismiss that kind of didactic judgment as 'two-dimensional', which doesn't exactly make for a convincing story or a gripping plot. As for the morality of a particular text, it is equally difficult to label it 'good' or 'bad' and leave it at that. With the exception of prim little Victorian moral tales, written to instruct children who weren't permitted to read their storybooks on a Sunday, literature and its study are a lot more complex than that. Edited October 21, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Justin86 Posted October 22, 2007 Posted October 22, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1406625' date='Oct 22 2007, 06:16 AM']Theoretically, you [i]could[/i] claim that Da Vinci's [i]Last Supper[/i] depicts Mary Magdalene - if you had the evidence to back that up, taken from the painting alone. As it happens, several art critics stepped in after the publication of Dan Brown's novel to point out, using their skills as Renaissance art specialists, that it is a man leaning on Jesus and not a woman. The evidence provided by the painting itself is stronger than Dan Brown's argument. No one can just make a totally unfounded claim about a work of literature and expect it to be treated as valid or valuable. As I pointed out very clearly, it needs to have a firm basis. You must support your argument with what you find in the novel or the poem or the script or whatever. But here we have people saying that Rowling's oral statement about Dumbledore's sexuality alters the way we should perceive the books and/or that this is an extra reason for people not to read them - all of which completely invalidates the way literature is approached and studied.[/quote] But who are you to judge whether or not my basis is "firm" or not. I also found your accusation that [i]I'm[/i] advocating literary relativism laughable. Edited October 22, 2007 by Justin86
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now