Guest thespoonbender Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 Dear all, A friend sent the following to me. I can't find the error in his argument. Please help! 1.) God tells us not to sin - if we sin, we may go to hell. For example, if you sin and you do not have time to repent your sin and a tree falls on you, you will go to hell with high certainty. 2.) If you throw yourself into the ocean and keep swimming until you can't swim and longer, then go underwater and try to hold your breath as long as you can, you will die. No matter what I offer you, you will not do this. You understand a basic cause-effect relationship. The same applies to hell and sin. If I tell you that hell is the worst place that you can possibly imagine why would you [i]ever[/i] sin? For instance, normal people do not commit crimes. I have never met a "normal" person who has gone to jail for murder. Even when people get very angry, they don't murder, because they know that they will go to jail. Why, then, do people do very simple things (like lie and cheat) when they know that they will go to hell? Even clergy have been known to sin. Why do Christians do this? There are two possibilities in my mind: a.) They do not understand basic cause-effect relationships. b.) The vast majority of them do not actually believe in hell. 3.) What happens if you commit a sin knowing that you will repent afterwards? For instance, if I am a catholic and I know that if I repent my sin then I can still go to heaven. Therefore, I concoct the following plan: a.) Commit sin (e.g. lie to my parents about a party I went to last weekend) b.) Repent sin Since the only thing that matters in life is whether I go to heaven or hell, this plan seems foolproof. Suppose that I implement the above plan but then I feel truly bad about it. Can I repent then? --- My friend is very convincing and I don't know how to argue about him. I know in my heart that his arguments are wrong, but I don't know what to say to him. Please help! -Gavin
Pio Nono Posted October 21, 2007 Posted October 21, 2007 JMJ 10/21 - Twenty-ninth Sunday Gavin, The famous Dominican phrase applies - "Never accept, seldom reject, always qualify." Never accept: Your friend is wrong in his assessment. Seldom reject: He does have some deep insights concerning an intellectual conception of sin. Always qualify: Here's the long part - Your friend is right. Knowing what mortal sin is, and knowing what happens should I commit it, I would never do it. The saints have always said that. The problem, though, is that I still suffer the effects of original sin. We live in a world that, though redeemed, still suffers the effects of the fall of Adam. In a perfect world, I would never get sick. In a perfect world, there would be no war. In a perfect world, no one would choose hell over Heaven. But we don't live in a perfect world. Now, our desires (passions) rule our mind (intellect) and convince us to choose (will) sin. In a perfect world, my intellect would rule my passions, but now my passions knock over my intellect like a stack of cans. If my intellect ruled my passions, I would never choose sin. But since my passions dominate my intellect, it is rather easy to do so. I know this is very convoluted, so I hope someone can clear it up further. Hope this helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now