Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So I went on a pilgrimage walk yesterday (27km! I'm quite sore lol) and there was a Mass at the end of it, starting at around 5:15 and ending around 6:30. Time-wise, that is a Sunday vigil Mass. However, they did not read the Sunday readings. Nor the Saturday readings for that matter. (Isaiah, Romans, Luke were the readings). Sooooo... should I go to Mass today? I don't want to go "twice in one day" but I don't want to not go if I should. (as I mentioned I'm pretty sore, plus it will cost a couple dollars for translation, so if there is uncertainty I most likely won't go, since after all, it was a vigil Mass...)

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I am not sure. What you describe sounds more like a special pilgrim Mass, even if it did take place at vigil time. The content of the Mass is as important as the hour - that was not the Mass for the 29th Sunday in Ordinary Time. However, if you are genuinely feeling too sore to move comfortably and need to rest I think you may excuse yourself. :)

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1406496' date='Oct 21 2007, 10:57 AM']I am not sure. What you describe sounds more like a special pilgrim Mass, even if it did take place at vigil time. The content of the Mass is as important as the hour - that was not the Mass for the 29th Sunday in Ordinary Time. However, if you are genuinely feeling too sore to move comfortably and need to rest I think you may excuse yourself. :)[/quote]

Ahhh... well, I hadn't thought about it being a "special pilgrim Mass" (which is sad, I just figured it might be another of the many liturgical abuses here in Chile). So I did some searching with that idea and found this:
[quote]A person who assists at a Mass celebrated anywhere in a Catholic rite either on the feast day itself or in the evening of the preceding day satisfies the obligation of participating in the Mass [CIC Can. 1248 §1].[/quote]
and a few different people saying that this means that if the readings are different (like this situation or a wedding for example), it still counts. So I guess that answers my question. Unless anyone thinks that is not the correct interpretation?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

If they weren't the Sunday readings, then you probably didn't go to Sunday Mass. Since there's no harm in going twice (and receiving Eucharist twice), I'd say you should go.

Posted

Take it from someone who's been there: just go. :)

Posted

Exactly. Jesus is there, don't leave Him waiting for you.

Posted

It sounds like she, according to canon law, has satisfied her obligation, so I don't see why it would be necessary for her to hear Mass again today.

Archaeology cat
Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1406517' date='Oct 21 2007, 04:15 PM']It sounds like she, according to canon law, has satisfied her obligation, so I don't see why it would be necessary for her to hear Mass again today.[/quote]

It does sound like that. I guess it's along the same lines as a nuptial Mass. I mean, had my husband and I gotten married in the evening instead of 11.00 on a Saturday, that the Nuptial Mass would have fulfilled our Sunday obligation (according to our priest). I don't see why this would be different. Of course there's never harm in going a second time, but doesn't look like it's required here.

Edited by Archaeology cat
Posted

Look at it this way: what's the harm in [i]not[/i] going?

Viewing our Catholicism as merely doing the bear minimum and live by "the rules" isn't a very good perspective on it. We should be actively living our faith in out daily lives, not just doing merely the required.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1406528' date='Oct 21 2007, 12:29 PM']Look at it this way: what's the harm in [i]not[/i] going?

Viewing our Catholicism as merely doing the bear minimum and live by "the rules" isn't a very good perspective on it. We should be actively living our faith in out daily lives, not just doing merely the required.[/quote]

Right, and if I hadn't walked 27 kilometers yesterday with a heavy bookbag, and had been able to get some of this mountain of homework done instead of going on the pilgrimage, I would definitely be going to Mass. Also, the pilgrimage was a very powerful experience, so I don't feel like I'm majorly missing out spiritually (except not getting Jesus, but I only would have gone to Mass once this weekend anyway)

Posted

When in doubt go.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1406539' date='Oct 21 2007, 10:44 AM']When in doubt go.[/quote]

But there is no doubt. She has most certainly fulfilled her obligation according to the [i]Codex Iuris Canonici[/i].

Posted

agreed. if you have to question yourself, you need to go.

Theologian in Training
Posted

Perhaps this is going sound a little blunt, but why are you asking this question when you have already clearly decided you don't want to go?

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1406543' date='Oct 21 2007, 12:53 PM']Perhaps this is going sound a little blunt, but why are you asking this question when you have already clearly decided you don't want to go?[/quote]

Well, wanting to and having an obligation to are different aren't they? I'm sure everyone here has had Sundays when they didn't want to go, but they went because it is an obligation.

As for the "having to question myself"... well, I did, until I found the canon quote, so I don't think thats an issue anymore...

If you go to a Saturday vigil Mass, do you plan to go to Sunday Mass too? No. I honestly thought this was a Saturday vigil Mass, until I went to read the readings this morning (I usually read the readings before or after Mass here because I don't always understand them in Spanish), and realized that they were not the same.

Plleeeeaaaase people, do not infer that I am trying to do the least possible. It makes me sad here that I cannot go to daily Mass more often. Do you think I'm just trying to get out of Mass??? I just wanted to know if I fulfilled my obligation or not!!!

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1406549' date='Oct 21 2007, 01:01 PM']Well, wanting to and having an obligation to are different aren't they? I'm sure everyone here has had Sundays when they didn't want to go, but they went because it is an obligation.

As for the "having to question myself"... well, I did, until I found the canon quote, so I don't think thats an issue anymore...

If you go to a Saturday vigil Mass, do you plan to go to Sunday Mass too? No. I honestly thought this was a Saturday vigil Mass, until I went to read the readings this morning (I usually read the readings before or after Mass here because I don't always understand them in Spanish), and realized that they were not the same.

Plleeeeaaaase people, do not infer that I am trying to do the least possible. It makes me sad here that I cannot go to daily Mass more often. Do you think I'm just trying to get out of Mass??? I just wanted to know if I fulfilled my obligation or not!!![/quote]

So, then what decision have you arrived at?

Posted

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1406549' date='Oct 21 2007, 11:01 AM']Well, wanting to and having an obligation to are different aren't they? I'm sure everyone here has had Sundays when they didn't want to go, but they went because it is an obligation.

As for the "having to question myself"... well, I did, until I found the canon quote, so I don't think thats an issue anymore...

If you go to a Saturday vigil Mass, do you plan to go to Sunday Mass too? No. I honestly thought this was a Saturday vigil Mass, until I went to read the readings this morning (I usually read the readings before or after Mass here because I don't always understand them in Spanish), and realized that they were not the same.

Plleeeeaaaase people, do not infer that I am trying to do the least possible. It makes me sad here that I cannot go to daily Mass more often. Do you think I'm just trying to get out of Mass??? I just wanted to know if I fulfilled my obligation or not!!![/quote]

Well, according to Canon Law you have...

Posted

Well, since we seem to have established that I went to a legitimate Saturday vigil Mass, I will not be going to Mass again today.


Do you think I am wrong, Father?

Sister Rose Therese
Posted

"It is often said that second thoughts are best. So they are in matters of judgment but not in matters of conscience." John Henry Newman

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...