Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, its pretty sad down here in Chile how many liturgical abuses I've seen... I realize now after reading up on some of these that I also see quite a few at home, but I think here its a little more serious. First of all, generally speaking, what is the proper action to be taken? Talk to the priest? A letter to the Bishop??

And speaking more specifically, I'm going to tell you about the sad sad Mass I went to on Thursday and ask what you recommend in this situation. Keep in mind that my Spanish is not perfect so if confrontation is needed I would be more comfortable writing something.

First, just found out that this is a no-no: the priest only wore the alb and stole.
Mainly, the abuse is this, and I think its an abuse in like 10 different ways and I wanted to cry and I definitely did NOT go up for communion:
The priest, after taking communion himself, gave instructions on what to do. Then he LEFT the Body and the chalice of the Precious Blood on the altar and SAT DOWN. Everyone formed a line, went up BEHIND the altar, took the Body THEMSELVES, dipped it in the Blood, and self-communicated.
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!

OK. So I've found some documents that clearly state that this is wrong. What should I do? Other details: this is the priest at a Catholic university of 16,000 students, the vast majority of which are Catholic (but probably the vast majority don't attend Mass ever). This was a special evening Mass on a weekday, but the same priest also says Mass every weekday morning (and I'm not sure if there is a Sunday Mass there). Also, I think the diocese and maybe the country as a whole is fairly on the "liberal Catholic" side.

:annoyed: :weep: I can't wait to get back to Pittsburgh. :sadder: :unsure:

Thanks in advance for the help.

Posted

Sounds very similar to the Mass I have to deal with on a weekly basis. :(

The first level should always be the priest performing the Mass. Talk to him about it first. This can be a rather unsettling position, I know as I have no desire to tell a PRIEST on how to say Mass, but if this problem can be corrected by you simply stating that you're offended by it will correct itself much quicker than if you got the higher authorities involved. If that doesn't work, however, I believe most dioceses to have some way of reporting liturgical abuses. I would advise to search the internet for whatever diocese you're currently visiting.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted
:sadder:

The practices you describe are universally reprobated (as you know from looking at the documents), if this fact does not matter to these people than I don't know what you can do apart from praying for them and maybe sending off a letter of concern to the bishop. I heard of a bishop in this country (US) who recently cracked down on a parish such as this so you never know. I read the letter that this bishop sent to the pastor and was amazed by how this bishop was able to essentially command the priest to shape up without coming off as though he was being authoritarian. The main attribute of this letter that contributed to this was that the bishop clearly and brilliantly explained why what they were doing was wrong.
It is sad that obedience is apparently too much to ask from many clergy but one would have to be a real creep to set aside this bishop's letter. And I must say that I am convinced that a lot of this is caused by ignorance and misunderstanding rather than malice or arrogrance. Many places have been doing their own thing liturgically for decades and in a sense they deserve an explanation as to why this is problematic.
farglefeezlebut
Posted

Without wishing to state the obvious, you need to pray.

Posted

Your post reminded me of a Paul Simon song:

She said it’s really not my habit
To intrude
Furthermore, I hope my meaning
Won’t be lost or misconstrued
But I’ll repeat myself
At the risk of being crude...

Posted

I have found a good way to begin is to ask the priest why he does what he does. That way, you are not condemning his actions, but you can use this as a way to begin, saying you were always taught that the priest or extraordinary minister was in charge of distributing the Eucharist. Of course, it is much more difficult when you're in a foreign country and don't speak the language very well.

For me personally, when I see such liturgical abuses at a place where I do not attend Mass regularly, I don't say anything, as the opinion of one outsider will probably have no positive effect on the situation. It may indeed make the priest more disgruntled towards those who are knowledgeable enough to know what liturgical abuses are if the situation is not handled very delicately.

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1407475' date='Oct 22 2007, 08:46 PM']For me personally, when I see such liturgical abuses at a place where I do not attend Mass regularly, I don't say anything, as the opinion of one outsider will probably have no positive effect on the situation.[/quote]
Yeah, thats sort of what I was thinking. But this seems soooo disrespectful.

Farglefeezlebut, yes, its obvious, but how often we forget that, no? I think for now at least I need to just pray about it. I need to figure out if I can do something to actually change the situation or not.

Posted

You can't do anything really ... much like most abuses in the Church clerical order. Their important, your not - their the boss, your not - question them, your questioning god :incense: its crude and not nice but that's the way it is :huh: .

Posted

[quote name='GodChild' post='1407780' date='Oct 23 2007, 10:28 PM']You can't do anything really ... much like most abuses in the Church clerical order. Their important, your not - their the boss, your not - question them, your questioning god :incense: its crude and not nice but that's the way it is :huh: .[/quote]
Uh, not really.

That would be something like saying the local manger of a McDonalds doesn't have to follow the guidelines set by the corporation. It's rather preposterous.

Posted

i was skimming through the book [u]Mass Confusion[/u] yesterday and i came across this quote. keep it mind:

If one is talking to a priest, it is especially important to be respectful, polite and friendly. Not only for the reasons stated above, but also because priests deserve special honor by virtue of their ordination and station in the Church. One should speak to a priest as kindly as one would when correcting one's own father. (cf. 1 Tim. 5:1)

Posted (edited)

Proper protocol in such abuse (what you describe is serious) is to address the priest respectfully. Show him your documentation. He may well not agree and so you go up the ladder to his bishop with a letter. If that is not successful write the vatican. You may not get action as it's a big world out there and they have alot of this to deal with. But they need to know it is going on and it will influence there decisions regarding future bishops for that diocese.

I have had success in doing this (general absolution services). The Bishop should take action.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

I would have a heart attack.

Posted

it ought to be noted that while it is proper etiquette to first approach the priest, then approach the ordinary, and only in the last resort appeal to Rome, Redemptionis Sacramentum makes it clear that the laity have the right to take it to Rome and you may do so without the first two steps if you wish; it is less likely to be listened to if those steps are skipped, but there is nothing prohibiting you from going directly to Rome.

Posted

I know that this is a little off topic, but my friend showed me a Catholic church that has Jesus in the Tabernacle in a little chapel-like room, in the back of the church (the alter is in the front). When it is time for the liturgy of the Eucharist, the priest has to travel to the back of the church and get Jesus. Is this a liturgical abuse? I was sad to go there b/c Jesus was by Himself, in the room and he isn't exactly front and center at Mass. My friend also told me that ppl are very irrevrent at that particular Mass there (i.e. Chewing gum, talking, just being generally disruptive).

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

All this talk about liturgical abuse inspired me to look through my collection of pictures of messed up Masses (a few hundred of them are Mahony Masses so you know what I'm talking about. And of course the ever classic clown masses, barney mass, halloween mass, etc.). Usually when I look at these pictures they make me upset (sad, mad, etc.) but this time I was cracking up. I can't believe people are that asinine. haha And they think they're cool. lol.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1407787' date='Oct 23 2007, 11:49 PM']Uh, not really.

That would be something like saying the local manger of a McDonalds doesn't have to follow the guidelines set by the corporation. It's rather preposterous.[/quote]

Not really AND Macdonalds managers aren't revered half as much as priests and bishops. If you want something to change, you need to go to the priest - the priest gets offended. You may then go to the Bishop (another priest) ... no matter what way you look at it you must go through a priest. They hold the whole joint in their hands thats why they get away with everything .... liturgical abuses, preaching wishwash, unsuitable relations with young children <_< Yes indeed, the whole idea that clergy don't follow the rules is just preposterous :rolleyes: come on ... that's a lala land view of the clergy.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='GodChild' post='1409309' date='Oct 25 2007, 07:13 PM']Not really AND Macdonalds managers aren't revered half as much as priests and bishops. If you want something to change, you need to go to the priest - the priest gets offended. You may then go to the Bishop (another priest) ... no matter what way you look at it you must go through a priest. They hold the whole joint in their hands thats why they get away with everything .... liturgical abuses, preaching wishwash, unsuitable relations with young children <_< Yes indeed, the whole idea that clergy don't follow the rules is just preposterous :rolleyes: come on ... that's a lala land view of the clergy.[/quote]

Uhhh... I'm sure everyone knows that some priests don't follow the rules... the thread is about liturgical abuses, after all... so it's definitely not la la land? :think: The priests are supposed to follow the teaching of the Church just like the Mickey D managers are supposed to follow the franchise rules. But I'm sure across the fruited plain there are a number of restaurant tyrants who do things their way and not the Golden Arches way.

But it's not like the priesthood is the Mafia or something. There are bad ones but there are lots of good ones. Surely you can acknowledge that? The whole "the idolatrous system of sacramental priesthood keeps all the power in the hand of the wicked priests, the laymen are their helpless puppets!" thing isn't fit for good folk like yourself... more in the line of Jack Chick and other ignorant people.

Edited by Maggie
Posted

I wasn't making the claim that all priests are bad and ppl are enslaved to them. I was responding to the issue of liturgical abuse.
As for the masses being enslaved by priests?, my answer to this is yes and no ... if a priest is true to their calling then they do not enslave but serve others, thus setting others free. This is the vocation of the priest, to give and offer freedom to the people they care for .... many have been true to this call and literal heroes who have drawn God knows how many people towards heaven (St John Vianney comes to mind) ... others (and there are many of these also) do enslave ppl because they are the carpiest priests and spiritual criminals - neither entering God's love themselves and disallowing others to enter also.

Anyways this is getting off topic .......... to put my response in context of my frame of mind and thinking - If a priest is doing liturgical abuses, my opinion is that there are deeper issues at stake rather than just - oops he made a mistake. A priest committing liturgical abuses has no respect for the body and blood of Christ - do you think he'll give a carp about a parishioner? LOL - I don't think so - if the priest is abusing the Body/Blood of Christ his humility and love of God is close to zero ... he won't give a beaver dam.

By all means try to take up the matter ... but don't be disappointed if NOTHING changes and you start getting strange looks

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1407475' date='Oct 23 2007, 01:46 PM']I have found a good way to begin is to ask the priest why he does what he does. That way, you are not condemning his actions, but you can use this as a way to begin, saying you were always taught that the priest or extraordinary minister was in charge of distributing the Eucharist. Of course, it is much more difficult when you're in a foreign country and don't speak the language very well.

For me personally, when I see such liturgical abuses at a place where I do not attend Mass regularly, I don't say anything, as the opinion of one outsider will probably have no positive effect on the situation. It may indeed make the priest more disgruntled towards those who are knowledgeable enough to know what liturgical abuses are if the situation is not handled very delicately.[/quote]
Yep, same.

The best way to approach a priest is just to ask... "I was just wondering why did such-and-such... I'm used to such-and-such and I'd be interested in knowing what the Church taught in regards to it... " or whatever, but it must be phrased pretty delicately.

God bless

Posted

Hi Romans1513,

I've witnessed many liturgical abuses in the diocese of Valparaiso (I was there past winter) here in Chile. Some friends and I wrote a letter to the Bishop after one of us talked to the priest (it became quite clear that the priest didn't think very highly of liturgical norms, so it didn't make much sense to point out where he was breaking them). Maybe you could do the same. Good liturgy is, after all, our right as faithful.

It helps to read Redemptionis Sacramentum ([url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccdds/documents/rc_con_ccdds_doc_20040423_redemptionis-sacramentum_en.html"]here's the link to the document[/url]) to know exactly what qualifies as liturgical abuse.

(And, come and visit Santiago :cool: We've got more Extraordinary Form Masses! Times are changing!)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...