Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is This A True Representation Of Church Teaching?


Recommended Posts

hyperdulia again
Posted

Sex Changes & Catholicism


Published on Tue Nov 28, 2006 8:30 pm

Sexual Morality: A Catholic Perspective, by Philip S. Keane, S.S.

NIHIL OBSTAT: Peter F. Chirico, S.S., S.T.D. Censor Librorum

IMPRIMATUR: Raymond G. Hunthausen, Archbishop of Seattle.

Citation: Keane, P. S. (1977). Sexual Morality: A Catholic Perspective. New York, NY: Paulist Press, pp. 178 - 180.

"Sex-Changing Surgeries and Related Processes There are two major types of cases in which sex-changing surgery is an issue. The first type of case concerns persons born with both testicular and ovarian tissue (hermaphrodites), and person who are of one sex but in whom hormonal imbalances have produced characteristics of the opposite sex (pseudohermaphrodites). Related to this category would be the situation of persons whose sexual organs are in some way defective (e.g., men whose semen is discharged at the base of the penis instead of the tip). In all such cases, the best moral judgment has held for some time that if medical science can find a means of correcting these problems (through surgery, hormone therapy, mechanical aids, etc.), all well and good. 15 The question, of course, is whether medical science has at its disposal techniques that are really suitable (from the medical viewpoint) to correct the kind of difficulties just described. Some of the problems, such as female pseudohermaphroditism, can be quite successfully treated through hormone therapy and surgery, whereas in other cases the prognosis is not as good. 16 Fortunately, true hermaphroditism is very rare. Ongoing medical research into hermaphroditism and other physical defects in the sexual organs certainly seems to be called for.

The second major type of case involving sex-changing surgery is the case of the person which physically normal sex organs who wishes to be or sincerely believes that he or she is a member of the opposite sex. As we mentioned earlier, persons who fit into this case are usually called transsexuals. Traditional moral theology used to categorize all sex-changing surgery for transsexuals as immoral. Today, using the principle of proportionate reason, it might be argued that, if all other means of dealing with transsexualism (counseling, etc.) have been exhausted, sex-changing surgery might be used as a last resort. Not a great deal has been said in print on this subject by Catholic moralists, but the number of Catholic moralists who would at least privately accept transsexual surgery in certain circumstances seems to be growing. 17

A moral perspective that must enter into our assessment of sex-changing surgery for transsexuals is the perspective of how successfully such surgery can be accomplished. Obviously no perfect means of sex-changing surgery (e.g., enabling reproduction) is now available, but it does not seem that a totally perfect change of sex would be necessary to justify sex-changing surgery for transsexuals. What can be said is that, as of now, the sex-changing process form male to female is much more satisfactorily accomplished than the change from female to male. Hence , as of now, it seems best to apply the last resort justification of transsexual surgery to the case of males who wish to be or believe they are females. If more effective female-to-male surgeries become available through additional medical advances, these surgeries might also be used.

The notion that seems to underlie the argument for the morality of last-resort sex-change operations for transsexuals is the notion that the human mind is an even more complex and mysterious reality than the human body. The implication is that when there is a major dissonance between the human mind and the human body, it may be easier (and perhaps more moral) to change the human body than to change the human mind. Obviously there are limits as to how far we can go in our efforts to change either the human mind or the human body, but some changes (operations, psychotherapies) are clearly agreed to be moral and ours is a position of continuing reflection on what humans may morally do to themselves with modern science. 18

Notes:

15. Thomas O'Donnell, MM, pp. 259-261. (MM : Morals in Medicine. By Thomas O'Donnell. 2nd Ed. Westminster, Md.: The Newman Press, 1959.)

16. Cf. K&L, pp. 41-42, 106-109, 334. (K & L : Herant A. Katchadourian and Donald T. Lunde. Fundamentals of Human Sexuality. 2nd ed. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1975.)

17. One Roman Catholic moralist who has expressed an openness to such surgeries is John F. Dedek, CME, pp. 77-80. (CME : Contemporary Medical Ethics. By John F. Dedek. New York: Sheed and Ward, 1975.)

18. A subject somewhat related to (but still clearly different from) transsexual surgery is transvestism, the psychic need to wear clothing that will cause one to be perceived as a member of the opposite sex. Older moralists used to condemn transvestism as immoral (cf. Thomas O'Donnell, MM, p. 261). While research on this phenomenon (which may or may not mean that the person wishes to belong to the opposite sex) is very limited, it would seem at present that no one really knows why the disposition to transvestism exists in some persons or how to cause this disposition to change. Hence the moral approach to transvestites would seem to parallel the moral approach to homosexuals. They should be treated with understanding and compassion. Possibly there could be some situations in which the evil of transvestism is an ontic but not a moral evil. "

Posted

I had a client 15+ years that told me they had lived their entire life without knowing really which sex they were. I assumed that I was dealing with a transsexual at first, but was introduced to the world of indeterminate sex. The first thing I did was make an appointment for them with a doctor who dealt with intersex individuals. Turns out she was female genetically. When I discussed the situation with my spiritual director, she told me that the church teaches compassion first for those individuals born with what amounts to a birth defect. It is obviously easier to have compassion for those with visible physical defects, than those who truthfully believe themselves to have a physical defect by having been born with the wrong gender.

That being said, the church is pretty clear on self-mutilation in regard to fertility. Sex reassignment surgery involves castration or hysterectomy. Both are no-no's. The church makes a lot of allowance for individuals with mental difficulties. For instance, the church allows funerals now for those who have committed suicide much more than it did 100 years ago because we now recognize that those suffering from depression or other mental illnesses are not totally in control of their actions. I just don't see the church any time in the near future being okay with sex reassignment surgery. You may have been given a heavier cross than other people have been, but the church teaches us that we have to have acceptance of what we have been given or not given, and then offer up those troubles. There isn't always an easy solution to a problem that will allow you to still remain in good standing with the church. You aren't the only person who has had to make difficult choices. I would highly recommend that you give Courage a chance. Look up couragerc.net on the web. It will answer any of these questions that you have.

hyperdulia again
Posted

well it's kind of a done deal at this point :o my question is really more about church teaching generally than about me particularly. i'd just as soon not discuss this kind of private information in detail on the boards. thank you for your thoughtful response.:)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

If by "principle of proportionate reason," the article means "proportionalism," then no, it's wrong.

Anyway, I don't think it's moral in the second case. That's trying to change, at a fundamental level, who God made you to be. However, I would tend to agree that it would be okay in the first case, since such wouldn't really be a sex change per se, but simply a removal of characteristics associated with the opposite sex of the person in question.

However, I'm not well versed in Catholic bioethics. You'd have to speak to someone who is, like The Little Way.

hyperdulia again
Posted

I think if in the second case the surgery prevented suicide, mental breakdown, etc. it is licit. Not sure. What an old Franciscan Trad told me.

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1407519' date='Oct 22 2007, 06:31 PM']I think if in the second case the surgery prevented suicide, mental breakdown, etc. it is licit. Not sure. What an old Franciscan Trad told me.[/quote]

Hmm... I would be skeptical of that advice. The ways don't justify the means, after all. So doing something that is against Church teaching to possibly (certainly not [i]guaranteed[/i] to) prevent a dramatic consequence is not morally acceptable.

For example, we can't hand out condoms to impoverished people in Africa or India to lessen the chance that they might get AIDs. Even if we save their bodies, we lose their souls.

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1407515' date='Oct 22 2007, 06:28 PM']If by "principle of proportionate reason," the article means "proportionalism," then no, it's wrong.

Anyway, I don't think it's moral in the second case. That's trying to change, at a fundamental level, who God made you to be. However, I would tend to agree that it would be okay in the first case, since such wouldn't really be a sex change per se, but simply a removal of characteristics associated with the opposite sex of the person in question.

However, I'm not well versed in Catholic bioethics. You'd have to speak to someone who is, like The Little Way.[/quote]

The article seemed to be a bit convenient with how loosely it addressed the issue. It doesn't take much to make a connection between major cosmetic surgery and a rejection of the way God made us, as Raphael points out here. (To be clear, by "cosmetic" it is meant surgeries that are not correcting defects, diseases, and the like. There certainly are operations that are not required for health but can be done to correct naturally-occurring or acquired defects, such as scarring, obesity, deformity, etc.)

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1407505' date='Oct 22 2007, 06:19 PM']That being said, the church is pretty clear on self-mutilation in regard to fertility. Sex reassignment surgery involves castration or hysterectomy. Both are no-no's. The church makes a lot of allowance for individuals with mental difficulties...[/quote]

In particular, the article mentioned nothing about the Church's teachings on fertility and the forbidding of surgeries that would purposefully cease our ability to reproduce, as Catherine touches on. That seems to be the most glaring omission from the piece, but it's pretty huge.

Of course, all this being said, anything we've confessed with proper contrition that cannot feasibly be undone is beyond our control. I know some people when they come back to the Church after having a vasectomy or tubes tied will try to have the procedure reversed. (I've heard some [i]Catholic Answers[/i] episodes talk about this topic, btw...) But even with the intent to reverse, it isn't always possible.

hyperdulia again
Posted

VATICAN-TRANSSEXUALS

Jan-14-2003 (710 words) xxxi

Vatican says 'sex-change' operation

does not change person's gender

By John Norton Catholic News Service


VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- After years of study, the Vatican's doctrinal
congregation has sent church leaders a confidential document
concluding that "sex-change" procedures do not change a person's
gender in the eyes of the church.

Consequently, the document instructs bishops never to alter the sex
listed in parish baptismal records and says Catholics who have
undergone "sex-change" procedures are not eligible to marry, be
ordained to the priesthood or enter religious life, according to a
source familiar with the text.

The document was completed in 2000 and sent "sub secretum" (under
secrecy) to the papal representatives in each country to provide
guidance on a case-by-case basis to bishops. But when it became clear
that many bishops were still unaware of its existence, in 2002 the
congregation sent it to the presidents of bishops' conferences as
well.

"The key point is that the (transsexual) surgical operation is so
superficial and external that it does not change the personality. If
the person was male, he remains male. If she was female, she remains
female," said the source.

Bishop Wilton D. Gregory of Belleville, Ill., president of the U.S.
bishops' conference, sent a brief letter to U.S. bishops in October
informing them of the Vatican document and highlighting its
instruction not to alter parish baptismal records, except to make a
notation in the margin when deemed necessary.

"The altered condition of a member of the faithful under civil law
does not change one's canonical condition, which is male or female as
determined at the moment of birth," Bishop Gregory wrote.

The Vatican text defines transsexualism as a psychic disorder of
those whose genetic makeup and physical characteristics are
unambiguously of one sex but who feel that they belong to the
opposite sex. In some cases, the urge is so strong that the person
undergoes a "sex-change" operation to acquire the opposite sex's
external sexual organs. The new organs have no reproductive
function.

The document's conclusions close one area of controversial
speculation that arose in Italy in the late 1980s when a priest
publicly announced he had undergone a "sex-change" operation.

Given church teaching that only males can be validly ordained
priests, the question posed in newspapers at the time was whether a
priest who undergoes a "sex-change" operation remains a priest --
the answer is "yes" -- and whether a woman who undergoes the
procedure can be ordained -- "no."

A Vatican source said the text was prepared largely by Jesuit Father
Urbano Navarrete, now a retired canon law professor at Rome's
Gregorian University.

In 1997, Father Navarrete wrote an article on transsexualism in an
authoritative canon law journal and has been consulted by the
doctrinal congregation on specific cases involving transsexualism and
hermaphroditism.

The priest, citing confidentiality rules, declined to speak on the
record to Catholic News Service for this story.

The Vatican document's specific points include:

-- An analysis of the moral licitness of "sex-change" operations. [b]It
concludes that the procedure could be morally acceptable in certain
extreme cases if a medical probability exists that it will "cure" the
patient's internal turmoil.
[/b]
-- But a source familiar with the document said recent medical evidence
suggested that in a majority of cases the procedure increases the
likelihood of depression and psychic disturbance.

-- A provision giving religious superiors administrative authority to
expel a member of the community who has undergone the procedure. In
most cases of expulsion from religious life, the superior must
conduct a trial.

-- A recommendation of psychiatric treatment and spiritual counseling
for transsexual priests. It suggests they can continue to exercise
their ministry privately if it does not cause scandal.

-- A conclusion that those who undergo sex-change operations are
unsuitable candidates for priesthood and religious life because of
mental instability.

-- A conclusion that people who have undergone a sex-change operation
cannot enter into a valid marriage, either because they would be
marrying someone of the same sex in the eyes of the church or because
their mental state casts doubt on their ability to make and uphold
their marriage vows.

-- An affirmation of the validity of marriages in which one partner
later undergoes the procedure, unless a church tribunal determines
that a transsexual disposition predated the wedding ceremony.

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote]-- An analysis of the moral licitness of "sex-change" operations. It
concludes that the procedure could be morally acceptable in certain
extreme cases if a medical probability exists that it will "cure" the
patient's internal turmoil.[/quote]

it'd be very interesting to see the actual wording of the document, regarding the moral acceptance of "sex-change" operations, as opposed to a news summation. (i'm sure that's more difficult to come by, of course.)

i say this, in particular, as the next line seems to cast considerable doubt on the idea that cosmetic procedures can actually "cure" people, which then makes the whole issue rather paradoxical.

[quote]-- But a source familiar with the document said recent medical evidence
suggested that in a majority of cases the procedure increases the
likelihood of depression and psychic disturbance.[/quote]

i can only speak from my own experience with mental illness and its effect on my family, but i find a lot of truth in the source's analysis. after all, treating psychological issues with an attitude of [i]appeasement[/i] is ultimately defeating because it doesn't address any root problems. an example i use in my book, in reference to self-deprecating mental illness, is a doctor treating a broken leg with morphine. it is never a cure. there is still brokenness, even if its effects are masked for the moment. our true cure comes from a restoration to the Community - the faith, hope, and love found in Christ's Church.

just my thoughts. take 'em or leave 'em :saint:

hyperdulia again
Posted

so is the general consensus that the first post is permissive nonsense, or is it the church's teaching?

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1407748' date='Oct 22 2007, 11:18 PM']so is the general consensus that the first post is permissive nonsense, or is it the church's teaching?[/quote]

well i'm only one man, so i can't give a consensus. nor can i say anything authoritative about the Vatican document in question because there's no direct quotes from it. i think the best we can do is read the [i]Catechism[/i] about sexual morality, seek primary sources from the Vatican, talk to priests we know and our community, and do everything in our power to inform and follow our consciences.

to me personally, the first article seemed purposefully vague -- note the wording "might be argued that" -- in its acceptance of such operations as last resorts. even its conditional acceptance relied on the idea that such surgeries were medically proven to cure psychological problems, which is a problematic notion at best.

hyperdulia again
Posted

Frankly infallibility doesn't extend to medicine (leeches anyone) so I'm not really interested in the Church's evaluation of the science. Her statements about the moral implications of the surgery are of interest, but all I can find are strange references to secret documents and totally divergent statements by theologians. oy.

Thank you though Papa. Want some bacon? I could mail it to you. We're switchin' to turkey bacon.

Posted

Leeches are still used in Western medicine. They are very helpful to reduce clotting and increase blood flow to surgically reattached appendages.

hyperdulia again
Posted

That they are, but they aren't at all useful in combatting the flu. ;)

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1407755' date='Oct 22 2007, 11:35 PM']Thank you though Papa. Want some bacon? I could mail it to you. We're switchin' to turkey bacon.[/quote]

Mmmm turkey bacon :drool:

Posted

I'd only agree w/ the first paragraph. The rest sounds like bunk.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...