marccatholic Posted October 28, 2007 Posted October 28, 2007 marc... my response to Dismas' comment the Catholic Priests are under the lineage of Milchezedec. First, DAVID WAS A KING NEVER A PRIEST!... His action around the Ark, dancing and singing in the streets do not connote the office of a priest -- to approach God and minister to God ( Exod 28:1). What he wore were not priestly robes! Moses led but left the priestly duties to the levites. David led yet he organized the levites to minister and carry the ark after it was recovered back! marc.... Dismas was right when he said " There have to have been other priests of that order, or else the whole concept falls apart." It would fall apart marc...! SECOND: CHRIST DID NOT ORDAIN PRIESTS! Christ annointed Apostles, Prophets, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers - NOT PRIESTS !!! (Eph 4:11) WHO THEN are these priests that the scriptures are talking about? PETER HIMSELF taught us: "But ye are a chosen generation, a ROYAL PRIESTHOOD, an holy nation..." 1 Pet 2:9 marc... Peter further taught us: "Ye also, as lively stones, are built up a SPIRITUAL HOUSE, an HOLY PRIESTHOOD, to offer up SPIRITUAL SACRIFICES, acceptable to God by Jesus Christ." 1 Pet 2:5 Our priesthood is a SPIRITUAL ONE as confirmed by Paul: "Know ye not that YE ARE THE TEMPLE OF GOD, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?" 1 Cor 3:16 marc... God has destroyed the temple made by hands and transferred it into our Spirit so we could be the SPIRITUAL PRIESTS! 1 Pet 2:9, Rev 1:6, Rev 5: 9-10 If Peter himself know of this spiritual priesthood, why would he sit in the Pontifex Maximus'chair as the First Pope of Rome? God was establishing the BODY OF CHRIST and He needs Apostles, Evangelists, Prophets, Pastors and Teachers - NOT PRIESTS! marc... as spiritual priests, we have SPIRITUAL SACRIFICES! 1. Spiritual sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving. Rom 12:1, Phil 2:17, 1 Thess 5:16-19, 2. Burning of the spiritual INCENSE - our PRAYERS! Rev 5:8, 8:3-4, Psalms 141:2, 1 Tim 2:8 I could go on an on including the robes of the priests, their ordination, their duties -THEY ARE ALL SPIRITUAL! That is why there is no longer a need for a PHYSICAL PRIEST NOW as God has established the Body of Christ, the Iglesia ni Cristo! marc... Let us put things in its proper perspective. As he himself taught us, I AGREE Peter was a spiritual priest according to the order of Milchezedec performing spiritual duties in the temple which is his Body one of the living stones that build the spiritual House-the Body of Christ! I disagree that Peter was a Physical Priest of the Roman Catholic Church performing quasi Levitical priesthood duties in Cathedrals ( I can prove it Marc...) marc... I could still go on and give you more scriptures to show that ALL of us the redeemed are PRIESTS AND KINGS BEFORE God to follow our Lord Jesus Christ as our High PRiest according to the Order of Milchezedec! Christ has destroyed ALL DIVISIONS AND BOUNDARIES! He hated the Doctrine ofthe Nicolaitans because it is a DIVISION OF THE CLERGY AND THE LAITY which is prevalent in the RC Church! Rev 2 marc...please take time to study the doctrine of the Iglesia ni Cristo deeper! thnks marc.... I would appreciate if your good friend Dismas could comment on what I posted here and answer us POINT BY POINT, verse by verse! I read what you posted on my account but I would classify those as unsubstatial as it is in conflict with the Words of God. See you .... marc... there's one more comment I forgot to post: The scriptures never mentioned about MINISTERIAL PRIESTHOOD! We have the spiritual priesthood and we are given a very specific ministry - The ministry of reconciliation! A PRIEST approaches God and MINISTER to him - Exod 28:1 Ministerial priesthood is, sad to say, invention of the Catholic church to justify the existence of Priests and Peter! (Hope u'll give time answering ths challenge.Thanks!)
Dismas Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... my response to Dismas' comment the Catholic Priests are under the lineage of Milchezedec. First, DAVID WAS A KING NEVER A PRIEST!... His action around the Ark, dancing and singing in the streets do not connote the office of a priest -- to approach God and minister to God ( Exod 28:1). What he wore were not priestly robes! Moses led but left the priestly duties to the levites. David led yet he organized the levites to minister and carry the ark after it was recovered back! marc.... Dismas was right when he said " There have to have been other priests of that order, or else the whole concept falls apart." It would fall apart marc...![/quote] I'm afraid that my reply to this will be slow and drawn out. I am currently living in a temporary residence while my home is being repaired. Thankfully between insurance and money already put aside, I am not set back financially. Even so, my current internet connection is rather poor and my time is rather limited. It is true that Moses who led the people of Israel, and that Aaron and his sons were consecrated as priests, yet a few verses on, we see that it is Moses who performed the ritual to ordain them, this includes the sacrifice of the bulls and rams. This does defeat the argument given, though I do concede that it is written that Moses was also a Levite. Even so, it is also a fact that an Ephraimite, Samuel, ministered to God before the Ark (1 Sam 1:1-2:11) including sacrifice (1 Sam 7:9). Note, this means that Samuel's ancestor was Joseph, not Levi. While he was raised since weaning by Eli, a Levite, he was still considered a son of the Ephraimite Elkanah; so this is not a case of adoption, but rather pious consecration. As for King David. While it is noted that he did in fact dance and sing in the streets before the Ark, and that he did organize the Levites into priests, judges, scribes, and singers, the fact is that David was not solely a distant administrator. The details concerning the Temple and Temple worship were of his authorship and command. His songs and poetry were not just a one time impromptu street dance. They were used ritually from Temple sacrifice to daily prayer of the Jewish people. Even today, the singing of the Psalms throughout the day remains in the Catholic Church, a tradition that stretches back to the Apostles. While King David did not wear the robes of priest, he did act thoroughly as a direct intermediary between men and the Divine, which is universally understood in the true religion and the false as the duty and honor of a priest. I could continue into the historical and cultural understanding of "king" in the pre-Christian Middle-East, but I believe my case is already sufficiently defended. (to be continued...)
Dismas Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... my response to Dismas' comment the Catholic Priests are under the lineage of Milchezedec. First, DAVID WAS A KING NEVER A PRIEST!... His action around the Ark, dancing and singing in the streets do not connote the office of a priest -- to approach God and minister to God ( Exod 28:1). What he wore were not priestly robes! Moses led but left the priestly duties to the levites. David led yet he organized the levites to minister and carry the ark after it was recovered back![/quote] I previously stated a defense to my using David in my previous post. I stand by it. Even so, having recently re-read my post on October 15th, I notice now that I had not stated David was a priest of the order of Melchizedek, or of Aaron. I only referred to David once, and that being his role as King. I wonder if my rebuttal back in October was given much attention after all.
Dismas Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']SECOND: CHRIST DID NOT ORDAIN PRIESTS! Christ annointed Apostles, Prophets, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers - NOT PRIESTS !!! (Eph 4:11) WHO THEN are these priests that the scriptures are talking about? PETER HIMSELF taught us: "But ye are a chosen generation, a ROYAL PRIESTHOOD, an holy nation..." 1 Pet 2:9[/quote] I have read Ephesians 4:11, and Paul makes no effort to proclaim this as an exclusive list. It is Czarov who writes "NOT PRIESTS". If that were so, then the seven deacons in the Acts were anathema. Even so, this verse strengthens the Catholic position, rather than weaken it. [quote]11And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; 12For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: 13Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ: 14That we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive;[/quote] From reading this, we note that Paul implies the continual need for apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers. That means that Paul, as well as the other Apostles, would leave behind successors to continue "for the work of the ministry". In fact, we learn of two such successors in Scripture: Timothy and Titus. These apostolic successors are known as bishops, hence when you hear of "apostolic succession", you know that Catholics are speaking of the bishops throughout time. Aiding the bishop, who could not possibly reach out personally to every Christian in a city every week, was the "presbyteros", which literally means "elder". With few exceptions, the elders that supported the bishop were consecrated that they may administer spiritually to the Flock in the stead of the bishop. This, of course, would be the pastor. The word "presbyteros" would of course be murdered through translation several times and wind up in English as "priest". In fact, when discussing the state of priesthood in the Catholic Church, one describes it as the "presbyterate". Proof of this can be found by cross-referencing James 5:14 by Protestant and Catholic bibles. You will notice that the word is exchanged depending on perspective. Certainly, if one wishes to intentionally misinterpret what the Catholic Church teaches, he can twist the meanings of words quite easily, and perhaps even believe in it. Even so, the Church shall be judged by Christ by what she proclaims, not what others say she proclaims.
Dismas Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 (edited) [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']Peter further taught us: "Ye also, as lively stones, are built up a SPIRITUAL HOUSE, an HOLY PRIESTHOOD, to offer up SPIRITUAL SACRIFICES, acceptable to God by Jesus Christ." 1 Pet 2:5 Our priesthood is a SPIRITUAL ONE as confirmed by Paul: "Know ye not that YE ARE THE TEMPLE OF GOD, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?" 1 Cor 3:16[/quote] Czarov is correct in stating that all baptized Christians are consecrated into a Royal Priesthood. In the Catholic Rite of Baptism, the baptized are anointed as priest, prophet and king. Further, it was I who wrote preemptively, I may add, regarding the Royal Priesthood in my October posting. Further, if Czarov had a strong Catholic upbringing, he would know that such spiritual priesthood is exercised by the laity and clergy alike. For instance we are called to "offer up" our pains, frustrations and sadness in prayer to Christ crucified, that such hardships become us sharing in the Cross. In so doing, we participate spiritually in the work of Jesus by sacrificing ourselves for His sake as He sacrificed Himself for our sake. As such, this is yet no proof against the Catholic Church or her ministers. It didn't convince us when Luther said it, and it won't just because Czarov parrots him. (to be continued...) Edited November 8, 2007 by Dismas
Dismas Posted November 9, 2007 Posted November 9, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... God has destroyed the temple made by hands and transferred it into our Spirit so we could be the SPIRITUAL PRIESTS! 1 Pet 2:9, Rev 1:6, Rev 5: 9-10[/quote] Concerning 1 Peter 2:9, I have already commented, and have stated that this does not contradict the ordination of clergy. Also, Revelations 1:6 does remind us of the Royal Priesthood (sacerdos), and again I state that this is no contradiction with the priests of the Catholic Church (presbyteros). As for Revelations 5:9-10, the sense of irony overwhelms me so that I must remind you to look a little up into the chapter, say verses 5-8, and behold, the ones proclaiming it include elders. That's right, the four beasts and the twenty and four presbyteros are the ones proclaiming Revelations 5:9-10. If my feeble words cannot acquit the charge placed against the Church, that she has denied the laity their priestly honor, or that the Church somehow denies the nature of spiritual acts of priesthood, let the Church herself speak: [quote]Lumen gentium[/i], 10"] Not content with setting us free from our sins, our Lord gave us a share in his kingship and priesthood. "Christ the Lord, high priest taken from among men (cf. Heb 5:1-5), made the new people 'a kingdom of priests to his God and Father' (Rev 1:6; cf. 5:9-10) The baptized, by regeneration and the anointing of the Holy Spirit, are consecrated to be a spiritual house and a holy priesthood, that through all the works of Christian men and women they may offer spiritual sacrifices and proclaim the perfection of him who has called them out of darkness into his marvelous light (cf. 1 Pet 2:4-10)"[/quote] I cannot help but notice all those references that supposedly disprove the Church's fidelity are unflinchingly used by the Catholic Church in her own internal document, written by the clergy that Czarov so detests. [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']If Peter himself know of this spiritual priesthood, why would he sit in the Pontifex Maximus'chair as the First Pope of Rome? God was establishing the BODY OF CHRIST and He needs Apostles, Evangelists, Prophets, Pastors and Teachers - NOT PRIESTS![/quote] Actually, Peter never presided under the title of Pontifex Maximus, though he was bishop of Rome, and first of the lineage of popes. Julius Caesar, seeking to consolidate his power both popularly and militarily, purchased the title of Pontifex Maximus. It was then passed down through the emperors, starting with Augustus Caesar. In 375 AD, the Christian Emperor Gratian refused the title Pontifex Maximus. The papal title of Pontifex Maximus, however, arises by his primacy among bishops, and I know not its use until the reign of Pope Callistus I (218?-223). Yet the seat of Peter is in Rome, where he evangelized and where he was martyred and buried. And why would Peter go to Rome? Have you considered that there were more souls to be saved there than any other city in the ancient world? Rome was home to a million souls, and no city could compare in size and population until London during the Industrial Revolution. Also, Rome was a center of commerce, news, and politics. Rome simply was the best location at the time to attend to the needs of the Church and oversee the efforts of evangelization. Lastly, were do you aim your greatest weapon but at the heart of your greatest enemy? So too, Peter was thrust into the heart of the pagan Roman Empire. As for understanding the Body of Christ, I suggest to Czarov to read John 6:53-57, then reread my statement from October 15th in regards to the priesthood of the Catholic Church. Lastly, no matter how many times a false statement is repeated, it is still false, and I still haven't found "NOT PRIESTS!" in Ephesians 4:11.
Dismas Posted November 11, 2007 Posted November 11, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... as spiritual priests, we have SPIRITUAL SACRIFICES! 1. Spiritual sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving. Rom 12:1, Phil 2:17, 1 Thess 5:16-19, 2. Burning of the spiritual INCENSE - our PRAYERS! Rev 5:8, 8:3-4, Psalms 141:2, 1 Tim 2:8[/quote] These are done in the Catholic Faith, quite frequently in fact. These spiritual sacrifices and prayers are indeed powerful means to grow closer to Christ, and never has the Church denied their use. The simple fact of Christianity is that not everything is spiritual only. Even Iglesia demands water baptism. If that is the case, Czarov is no better than a Catholic priest, for though he performs less rites than the Catholic, his hypocricy for ignoring water baptism more than makes up for it. [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']I could go on an on including the robes of the priests, their ordination, their duties -THEY ARE ALL SPIRITUAL! That is why there is no longer a need for a PHYSICAL PRIEST NOW as God has established the Body of Christ, the Iglesia ni Cristo![/quote] Let us talk about the garments of the Catholic Priest. They are not named after Levite robes, but rather the garb of Roman citizens. I fail to notice this as anything more conspiratorial than keeping a classical look. Let us talk about the priestly ordination of the Catholic Church. I have the Rite of Ordination right here. Let's see, nope, I can't find any slaughtered bulls and blood sprayed on the altar and on the stoles and chasubles. I can't seem to find any part where blood is smeared on the tips of their ears. While the ranks of priests and office of Levites is mentioned, it is done so only in a historical progression and reminiscence of God's call. Furthermore, I contend that the priest of the Catholic Church offers no physical sacrifice. Indeed the Church proclaims that Jesus is the great high priest and victim; what the presbyter does in consecration is presenting the Lord's passion, and begging that Jesus be our bread of life and saving cup through the Holy Spirit. Czarov proclaims to be of the Body of Christ, yet does not eat the flesh of the Son of Man nor drink of His blood. After all, Jesus called the Twelve to the Last Supper and to "do this in memory of Me", note disciples are not mentioned as partaking in the Passover (Matt 26:20-29, Mark 14:17-24, Luke 22:14-30). Note that Eph 4:11 that Czarov is so intent on includes apostles, "those sent", and they have a specific charism to perfect the saints. These apostles continue in the True Church, the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. Simply put, Iglesia ni Cristo is a counterfeit religion founded by a fraudulent prophet who stole virtually all of his doctrines from other crackpot religions such as the Jehovah's Witness and Mormons while he was learning how to be a prophet in the United States, back in 1919. Even his charges against the Catholic Church aren't new, just stolen from other Protestants. Iglesia ni Cristo offers nothing new, and certainly not the Good News.
Dismas Posted November 11, 2007 Posted November 11, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... Let us put things in its proper perspective. As he himself taught us, I AGREE Peter was a spiritual priest according to the order of Milchezedec performing spiritual duties in the temple which is his Body one of the living stones that build the spiritual House-the Body of Christ! I disagree that Peter was a Physical Priest of the Roman Catholic Church performing quasi Levitical priesthood duties in Cathedrals ( I can prove it Marc...)[/quote] First, Peter was a presbyter, also known as elder, which is proven in 1 Peter 5:1, and so was and is a priest, so far as the priesthood of the Catholic Church is concerned. Second, Peter was succeeded by Linus who learned the faith from Peter, and this faith was passed down to Anacletus I and so on to this very day. Proof of Peter's life and subsequent martyrdom is first found in his tomb, which lies directly beneath the altar of St. Peter's to this very day. The visitation of tombs of popular saints, as Peter was one, was popular even in first century. The placement of altars and churches above such tombs followed shortly thereafter, as John's Apocalypse (particularly Rev 6:9) spread within the early church. We also have documents of the Early Church, as far back as 197 AD of Peter's episcopate in Rome. Third, the Catholic priesthood is not levitical, or quasi-levitical, or semi-levitical, or even pseudo-levitical. The Levitical priesthood centered upon Temple sacrifice to God, be it bulls, pigeons, doves, or grain. There is only one sacrifice, and that is Jesus; and it is Jesus who is the great high priest who offered himself as the Lamb of God. Jesus died once and for all, that our sins be forgiven, and no Catholic priest can claim to re-crucify Jesus during the Liturgy. Rather, the one sacrifice of Jesus is re-presented before God and man that all may share intimately with Jesus eternal life. Therefore, no priest, least of all Peter, could claim even partially the levitical duties of the Mosaic covenant. Fourth, as can be expected, Czarov lacks historical perspective. The Catholic Church, for the first two hundred and eighty years of her existence, was under numerous waves of persecution by the Roman Empire. As such, Peter most likely performed the Liturgy in the homes of believers in secret. As for cathedrals, well, they are named after the "cathedra", which means chair. Yes, Peter had a chair, and the one occupying that chair had Apostolic authority granted by Jesus Christ. The chair of Peter was not an impressive throne of gold and marble, but rather a common chair made of wood with wicker lacing and white leather patches, and it was likely second-hand. Those following Peter were given the same authority as Peter, and even the occasional bad pope retains that authority (Matt 23:1-3), just as bad pharisees retained the authority of Moses. Therefore, I find Czarov's representation of the Catholic priesthood to be false on all counts. (to be continued...)
Dismas Posted November 11, 2007 Posted November 11, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... I could still go on and give you more scriptures to show that ALL of us the redeemed are PRIESTS AND KINGS BEFORE God to follow our Lord Jesus Christ as our High PRiest according to the Order of Milchezedec![/quote] In the sacerdotal sense, yes, all those baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are priests and kings in Christ. Not all are given apostolic or pastoral authority however, or the need for those vocations would not be mentioned in Eph 4:11. [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']Christ has destroyed ALL DIVISIONS AND BOUNDARIES! He hated the Doctrine ofthe Nicolaitans because it is a DIVISION OF THE CLERGY AND THE LAITY which is prevalent in the RC Church! Rev 2[/quote] Yes, Christ has destroyed all divisions and boundaries. The Catholic priesthood is no division within the Body of Christ, merely an articulated part within it. By the logic of Czarov, every civil servant is in sin merely for holding civil authority above that of any one else, as we are all kings. Even so, civil authority is profoundly respected by the true Christian faith, as it is scripturally demanded of us (1 Pet 2:13,14). How then is it that one named king must submit legally to another's authority and not sin, yet a spiritual priest who submits spiritually to his presbyter's authority angers God? Again Czarov mentions the Nicolaitans, yet he has no proof of what they were about, but rather he assumes out of his ignorant hatred of the Catholic Church. Let us look at "Nicolaitans" again. Since looking at the natural meaning of Nicolaitan, which means "pertaining to Nicolas" does not necessarily condemn the Catholic Church, the anti-Catholic seeks to take further effort in condemning the true Church. As Iglesia ni Cristo doesn't know who Nicolas was or his teachings, they sidestep the issue by taking a look at the Greek root words that form Nicolas. Those words are "Nike" and "Laos", which means "victory" and "people" respectively. This too does not help the purposes of anti-Catholic propaganda, as Nicolas means "Victory of the people", and that rather populist, while the anti-Catholic desires to portray the Catholic Church as elitist. Therefore, Iglesia teaches that Nicolaitan means "Victory over the people", even though adding the word "over" or "against" is plainly disingenuous on their part. Further, while there is surviving apologetic works by the True Church against the Nicolaitans, it is obvious that Iglesia ni Cristo has little use for patristic works, and blindly makes things up to suit themselves. Therefore, I will introduce what the Nicolaitans were about. They were a Gnostic cult based on the Antinomian School. They believed that there was a supreme god who had a portion break off from himself, in the form of the God of the Jews, and this accidental sub-god desired to be supreme god, and so created the material world for his own glory. Jesus is obtains knowledge according to these Gnostics of the situation, and leads those who follow him to the real god. Of course, in order for the Nicolaitans to break free from the material world, must perform grotesque acts of sin and debauchery against the God of the Jews and His law. This unrepentant evil and rebellion against the Father, all done in the name of Jesus is abhorrent to Him. As such, I cannot reconcile the Nicolaitan doctrines in truth with the silly accusations of the ignorant. Of course, if the leadership of Iglesia ni Cristo actually researched before he condemned the One True Church for something they knew nothing about, they might not look like a gibbering conspiracy theorists. [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc...please take time to study the doctrine of the Iglesia ni Cristo deeper! thnks[/quote] Thanks but no thanks. As Felix Manalo is a fraud, I shall not be taken captive by his hollow and deceptive philosophy (Colossians 2:8).
Dismas Posted November 12, 2007 Posted November 12, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc.... I would appreciate if your good friend Dismas could comment on what I posted here and answer us POINT BY POINT, verse by verse! I read what you posted on my account but I would classify those as unsubstatial as it is in conflict with the Words of God. See you ....[/quote] I have given a point by point rebuttal to the charges provided. I have argued on behalf of the Catholic faith, though I am a rank amateur in the way of apologetics. I would gladly say that there are a hundred better apologists at this forum than me, yet I have responded that the false accusations against the true Church, for the glory of God (Rev 12:10-11). I am far more secure in the scriptural soundness of the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Faith in regards to scripture than Iglesia ni Cristo. It is in the Catholic Church that we find the true vocations of Apostles in our bishops, of Prophets of which we have many in the lay and the clerical orders, Evangelists who proclaim Jesus first and foremost, Pastors in our priests, and Teachers who are our catechists. Tell me Czarov, from which of the Twelve did Manalo receive his inheritance as apostle? The answer is none (Rev 2:2). There are no apostles in Iglesia ni Cristo, as it is a fraud, and there is none in Iglesia who have inherited authority from Jesus.
Dismas Posted November 12, 2007 Posted November 12, 2007 [quote name='marccatholic' post='1410636' date='Oct 28 2007, 10:55 AM']marc... there's one more comment I forgot to post: The scriptures never mentioned about MINISTERIAL PRIESTHOOD! We have the spiritual priesthood and we are given a very specific ministry - The ministry of reconciliation! A PRIEST approaches God and MINISTER to him - Exod 28:1 Ministerial priesthood is, sad to say, invention of the Catholic church to justify the existence of Priests and Peter![/quote] [quote name='Exodus 28:1; KJV']1: And take thou unto thee Aaron thy brother, and his sons with him, from among the children of Israel, that he may minister unto me in the priest's office, even Aaron, Nadab and Abihu, Eleazar and Ithamar, Aaron's sons.[/quote] The Catholic priest is not of a levitical or quasi-levitical priest in any sense, nor has the Catholic Church claimed such. All baptized Christians are given the ability to minister to God spiritually, receiving a higher intimacy and potence in the New Covenant than even the priests of the Old Covenant. This is not what I mean when I speak of Ministerial Priesthood. The Ministerial Priesthood as I have described is not a select cadre of men who are solely allowed to sacrifice to God, as Czarov accuses the Catholic Church. Rather, I am using minister as such: "a person appointed by or under the authority of a sovereign or head of a government to some high office of state." That sovereign is Jesus. Jesus has a kingdom, one prefigured in the Davidic Kingdom. That kingdom is attended to by those He has appointed, the Apostles (1 Kings 4:7, Matt 19:27-28). Not only this, for Peter is named as Christ's prime minister, which this too is prefigured in scripture by Eliakim. [quote name='Matthew 16:17-19; KJV']17And Jesus answered and said unto him, Blessed art thou, Simon Barjona: for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee, but my Father which is in heaven. 18And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. 19[b]And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.[/b][/quote] [quote name='Isaiah 22:20-22; KJV']20And it shall come to pass in that day, that I will call my servant Eliakim the son of Hilkiah: 21And I will clothe him with thy robe, and strengthen him with thy girdle, and I will commit thy government into his hand: and he shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, and to the house of Judah. 22[b]And the key of the house of David will I lay upon his shoulder; so he shall open, and none shall shut; and he shall shut, and none shall open.[/b][/quote] All powers and authorities practiced by the Catholic priesthood are in that order and sense. Czarov refuses to address Catholic doctrine for what it is, and instead attacks the Church by attacking doctrines that do not exist. Should Czarov find any real doctrine that the Catholic Church to discuss, I would be glad to do so, yet I grow tired of refuting that which the Church does not in reality profess. I could continue in far greater length and depth into proof of the Apostolic Succession, far greater than any accusation can endure, yet my time is limited. I admit that my refutation of Czarov's repetitive accusations against the Catholic priesthood is hardly my best work. Even so, I contend that all of his points and verses have been addressed sufficiently and substantially. I will note that Czarov is curiously silent in regards to my refutation of his claims that Jesus is not Divine. I look forward to his counter-argument in this respect, and hope to devote greater time and effort in the future. Even so, I am not a professional apologist, and I work hard and long hours in a factory to earn my daily bread. Please bear with me if my replies are slow.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now